High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2891/2015dismissed

Rajender Prashad v. Bajrang Lal

2019-11-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

! "

##$$ % & ' ()$

# !

* +, "##$$

-".&#+, " #

////

1 " 2"##$+"2 $$3$44$("##$

# $% ' $4+" "#$' ( )$+ 0 "5 &("&( ! "+ " 6$3$6" ,$$(7&2" 4+8"$ 1"5 -( # 2 & ( " 2 ( " &$,(

# " #$ , " $ 2# -" * 99: 2

+ ;

+ :

+ ;9 +

+ 99 9 ;+ + 9 ;+ + 9 ;+ 999 +9

+<9 +:9 2& ( -$;2 $&,$$(7&2" 4+8"$ 1"5#("2" 25 ,( ( 2 4& (","" #$ &-" * 99:2 :& ,$$(7&2" 4+8"$ 1"5

# " , " #$+ " 3 #"&$" &"="= 1 2 0&" >"3 ("="=$(3"" 2$4225 >"""## $5 " " #$>"#$+" " 5 " " !3 7&2 52 "3#$2 7 "3 "$(3"&$7&2 3 5- 2& #&5"5 > " $2 " 2 7 "5&$7&2 3 ?&54@& + 1"5+ 3" #$+ !3 7&2 3 ,>"#$!37&2 3 $5$54 "0("@& 5&"3( "> " 2" &(&+ + " #$+ !3 7&2 3 ?&54"0("@& > $ 2"$

< "2" &(&+ + " " ?& " #$""3 >"#$" "" 0 +"="=3$4(,+ " "#$# 2" " ="="2"&(& >""5 ( " $, >&5?&$4#& 53 "# "" &$,( #"#$, "&$> ($4"#$ ,-"$"-("2", " , # ="= "2 5& + " " " # " #$ 2 " & $ $"#-" &25 +(,( & "#$5 ("&

+ " ## $ 3 2 ( "& (, &$($5+ 2 (""- )$" "# 33 " $&3"" " " 9< " " $ 2# -"3* -"&* < :-:2& ( ;-$2 $# 25 "4 ; ,& " 2 ! " ' ( )$ #$?&$" ,,$@& < " 53""2&* 3,& " 5

>"- )$ ,"$

: 5($ & #$&"&(" 2$,& " 2" &(,+" "-" ! "A +3"3$-(2 "" " $,& &(,>"- )$' ()$" # 22#"$ >-54&" # 2+"3 ( "9<" "$ 2& (;-$2 $,& &(,3* )$+2" "- )$,,$@&

# @,$ & * ;< $ =2 &( % & ! " =>"- )$"$ "9;" " $,& &(,+ 2(9;" "$3 54"- )$,& ,,# @,$@& "53""2&* ;

3 + &$$4" ,& +&(,52 3 B" +,9;" +' ()$523 9<" "$$2& (;-$2 $> # , 2& * ;

<+ &( , 52 " 3 $ 2# 7"3 * :

-"& * <; 2& ( < -$ 2 $> , 52"3 $ 2# -"3* -"& * <;2& (:<-$ 2 $' ()$A#$" 523 $2# -"3* ;-"&* ;< 5 (-" * 99:2 +

+ ;9 +

+ 99 9 ; + + 9 ;+ 999 +9

+<9 +:9 2& ( -$ 2 $ & ,$$( 7&2" 4+ 8"$ 1"5# 25 "4 :

C " 3 2+ " " & " #$""4 :!"42# ( $, " # "- )$+' ()$A#$ ! "+;<-$2 $$( "2' ()$3(, ! "A 2#"2# " # 2"4 : ! "$(3""2$4 (" ="= ( 24 2+ -"+ , " $ 2 ("2&$ ! "> , ",( " 2# 7$$* 99: 2($&;<-$ 2 $& &$,#"" 2$4"4 :3 #$&$ 2& ( -$2 $ 54", @,$@&

& 54"2,& &( ,""" "- )$5 " ' ( )$ C"+"# 4 2$"&

"#$("# +$$3(&3 2

; D"" "#$$ # 2 & (" 2 (" &$,(#"#$$ 2 4 & ( " , " " #$E !!

D"" "&"#$25$" # 2E !

< D"" "#$"$&$"# &E !

C # ," +"#$"( "2!D5 ( &2

"" "+""## D "$ 2&2

" ("$ &$ "# +" $ @& &* ,& "#$(" +&* <(",& "#$ &$$4+" $@& ,&(2 ;

< "&"3 2 ("#&$#"#$, " &$& " ", ",# "&# # 4 "F( -" * 9:2 : 3"32" 2"#(&(2

1$((( ,54"&(2 +" " $ ##$ 5 6&(+ 1"5+ 3""3($ 6&(+1"5+3" ,&(2

:2"##$ &#"$"2#&(&(2 #54" $@&

$$$(3""&(2 #54"@& 5$3+""$"# (&$ ##$5 "@& +3""3& " ##$"## " &("&$

C"," $ &$ "# 5(( " &("" C42 "##$

8" $ @& $4 " &$ $($ #"2"$&"" ,& $ "3 "##"#$, "&$ 8" "55$# ,", 545 ((&(" ( ,( , 8" $$( 2$4 $2 ,53"225 $$(0&2$4, 3"" $ 2& ( ;< -$ 2 $ " $4 5 " $" ,&

8"@,$@& < "5

@2("## +"2$3", 4# # ## # 2 54" $@& # * " &(2+3"" 4 # &&

!"#

% &

(

)

(

)

(

+ &

+ #

, + '

' #

)

@2("&(2#54$ 6&(+1"5 8"$3 ##$$@& ""$"" $ 24"3" ( $$(2$4$2 &## 544&25$"";< -$2 $$3(," " 25 "4 GF !"5(,3" " #$ "3 5 &$,( # , " $ 2& (-$2 $$&(;<-$2 $$+ 3""&52 "# $( C"& " 5 5 ,""@,$@& &(2 ,& " #$' ()$3, "$$(54" ! "" ""2$ $ "3"""5 # " & # # 4 $ 3 "

2#$2 # ,&

(

GF ;#$ 54 "+"#$"#$

GF !"3("25#"&# # 4 8" 5( $ 53

# # 54 " C (# 2& "@$ ("

# # 54",&# 2& " !&5),&+"

# # 54" ,&# 25(,# ,3&(2 -54$3 ##$$@&

( "25$4+"1 ##$$@& "5 ,# * &

. /

, &

!""#$%& '!&

'1 2,3 '' 4

, &

(

) $*

+% ,-. &

, 8"& ("& 54" @& 5$3& 24 (&$ 4 $$($4 8" ( 2 *&$&3""&(2 #54"@& 5$3 8" &#"$ *&5$?&$3 "##$

C 5( ,3 " & ( & 54"@& 5$33"3""C4 ( +C$&""##$3"&2 2 ($4

#% ' &'()'(**(+,-.(/0,1(+23.4 (,0- &'()'(**(1-*)+56( (,0-