← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2923/2015allowed

Varinder Pal v. Nagar Panchayat Mahilpur And ANR

2018-05-18Mr. Justice Arun Monga7 pages

 

    

 

!"##$%&%'(!)*+* ,!-%'.#- !/ 00#//!'"

,#-&1& 2#!3!- !'$2!)!"!2%/01- !'"2#-  #&0'.#'"&  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

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

%'"2##'"%-#!2%/01-"2#-#!-#- 4#-2!'3%'3&A7%'%'3"2#21&#& #%"2#-&%.#&"2#&"-##"&!-/%#-+"2#-#:!&!"2-#!"!""2#2!'.& .##'.!'"!'."2#0/!%'"%%'&"%"1"#.%4%/1%"**B -

 0#-8!'#'"%'71'$"%'&##<%'3%.#'"%$!/-#/%#+:2%$2:!&.#$-##.9)"2#"-%!/ $1-"4%.#71.38#'"!'..#$-##.!"#.@%'"2#//:%'38!''#-(; = 

        



     ! "# "      $     

 %& '     ( )

*  

 



 

  '

       

 & 

 

 +,  +  ,

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

2!&'"9##'$/!-%%#.%'"2#'"%$#!&":2#"2#-&%8%/!-!$"%'2!.9##' "!<#'!3!%'&""2#!//#3#.4%/!"-&-#-#."2#$80#'&!"%'+:2%$2%& 8!'.!"-%/)-#E1%-#."9#//:#.+"2#-#-#+"2#'"%$#&9#&#";!&%.#



#-  $'"-!+  &!&4%-  5!1-+  /#!-'#.  $1'&#/  -#0-#&#'"%'3 -#&0'.#'"&198%""#."2!""2#-#%&'.#%!'$#""2#71.38#'"!'. .#$-##.!"#.@2#&1%"2!.!/-#!.)9##'.%&8%&&#.+-+"2#!3!-

!'$2!)!"2!."!<#'"2#8#!&1-#!&0#-"2#$"2#$'&"-1$"%':!& -!%&#.  :%"21"  !')  &!'$"%'  !'.+  "2#-#-#+  "2#  1-"&  9#/:  -%32"/) .#$/%'#."2#%'71'$"%'!'.+"21&+0-!)#.-!%-8%'3"2#%'.%'3&1'.#- $2!//#'3# 2!4#2#!-."2#/#!-'#.$1'&#/-"2#0!-"%#&+!00-!%&#."2# 0!0#-9<!'.!/&&##'"2#71.38#'"!'..#$-##.!"#.@'

!-!3-!02"2#!-#8#'"%'#.71.38#'"+%"2!&9##'$!"#3-%$!//)2#/. "2!"  "2#  !00#//!'";0/!%'"%  2!.  -!%&#.  "2#  $'&"-1$"%'  !"#-  "!<%'3 0#-8%&&%'-8"2#!3!- !'$2!)!" !-!-#!.&!&1'.#-(;

=).

* 

     

 ,  ,    

  

  &   )./)0 ,   1 2+

3)  

  

           

    

*     ).

 & +    ,     4 

  5

'

 &   '     

 *   

 6 

  & 

 & 2+7

 

 '

,  

    &   ,   

      

%  

  ,  +2+7

,  , +      &  *             

           ,    

- '

,  

*   & 





   

  

  

 8  * 

 9   9   , 6 

6 

 

  '

 



 &   3

       +

           

 

   : 6 

 '    

   ,,    , *   6  1 , &   1   6 

  *   ,,  &   )      ,     1

  &      6  

       ,       6 

 1  *    , 

 &

  &     

                ,4 %   

  

      '

   ,        

    

     ,

  ,

  '  

   &       ,  ,     &           :   '

  &        

     ' ,



 & )/) '

   1     6 

'      1  );;<  

,

,   

           4 

  

 +      ,   & +

,   



  

 +   

   

 4 %     

5   

 

      1       6 

 *   , ,     &                       

  &     ,  ,     ,                



 

   

   - #$"%'D "2#$"#'4%&!3#&"2#0-4%&%'-%'%"%!"%'3 !$"%'--#84!/"2#$'&"-1$"%'!""2#%'&"!'$#"2#1'%$%0!/ 88%""##  '/)  !"#-  #-%'3  $80#'&!"%'  -  "2#  &!<#    9-#4%")+ #$"%'D "2#$"-#!.&"21&(;



 

    

                    => 

    &                9 ,     

,        +,'                          &   ,  

 



 &

     

      , 9

?

'$#.#./)+"2#'"%$#1'.#-$2!//#'3#.%.'".%&$/&#"2# $80/%!'$#"2#0-4%&%'&'&1$2$%-$18&"!'$#&+"2#1-"&132"" 2!4#3-!'"#."2#%'71'$"%':%"2"2#-%.#-!&'"%$#.!94# .19"+"2%&1-"+'#!-/%#-$$!&%'&2!.9##'-!8%'3"2# &19&"!'"%!/E1#&"%'&/!::2%/#.#$%.%'3"2#!00#!/&91"%'4%#:"2#-!"% .#$%.#'.%$1//#.1"9)%4#/#!-'#.1.3#&"2#'F9/#10-#8#1-"%'



 ! !" #$ ! %& !

 ! '(

. )*+,&)- :2#-#%'"2#0-0&%"%'!-&#!&":2#"2#-%'4%#:"2# 0-4%&%'&#$"%'D   +0-4%&%'&#$"%'@"2# 1'7!91-"& $"+*:1/.!00/)-"2#!00#!/%# :1/.9#%/#.1'.#-#$"%' .#%4%/ -$#.1-#!'..#$%&%'"2#-#$1/.9#:%"21"-!8%'3"2# &19&"!'"%!/E1#&"%'&/!:2#'&"%"1"%'!/#'$2'F9/#10-#8# 1-"2#/."2!""2#.#$%&%'%'. / .

 ! %0!

,#  ! !"$ ! )** 2",&&)+)'!00/%$!9%/%")#$"%' D   %&'"!$--#$"/!:+%'#&&#'$#+"2#0-4%&%'&#$"%'@ "2# 1'7!91-"&$"+*2!.9##'-#&"-#.9!$< -"2#&!<#9-#4%")+ "2#-#/#4!'"0-"%'"2#71.38#'"%4#/#!-'#.1.3#&"2#'F9/# 10-#8#1-"%' !'<!7!<&2%F&$!&# &10-! -#!.&"21&(;

=  0)  &+ 

,  

,8  ) ,      ,    ,:%  #  

 0  3'(45 67-5* $ 89":



    @>A3;?- =A 2    =0

 ,     

 0)   &  );)<  7         ,        4           

      *, 

  4   < 1 

 * );)=,,, 

, 

%  *   

       

     1 

 );.= ;

  

       .;=1 

 );.=  &

, 

,    * 

 

 



 .A)"

 



=0

 , 

/    ,   

, 4   +

,   .A

  .A)" ,  , ,          4       5            ;A)"      

   ");AB   

0)  & ,    ,  - 2#-#-#+.'"%'"#'."-!8#"2#&19&"!'"%!/E1#&"%'& /!::2%/#.#$%.%'3"2#!00#!/+!-#8#'"%'#.

-"2#-#!&'&&"!"#.!94#+"2#71.38#'"&!'..#$-##&"2# 1-"&9#/:!-#&#";!&%.#2#&1%""2#!00#//!'";0/!%'"%%&.#$-##. :%"2"2#-%.#-"2!"%":%//'"0-#4#'""2#!3!- !'$2!)!""%'%"%!"#"2# 0-$##.%'3&!&#'4%&!3#.1'.#-#$"%'D "2#$"!'.!&:#//!& $80/):%"2"2#0-#4%1&71.38#'"!'..#$-##.!"#.@ 00#!/&"!'.&!//:#.

01,1    *)+%

234 '(56& +474389 :3

 ;3:

+474 7<!

;3: