Harjit Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2023:PHHC:121471-DB



  
  




















 



  !"

 #$%&'%()*)+, -
#.)$)+/0#+'$0%*   122%33#+$*

 $#$%& 4+.#5#+'$0%* 

















 %*2+'%+$*   

   !" $#$%& 4+.#5#+'$0%*   122%33#+$*

 6)2#37#4#+'$0%* 
























 %*2+'%+$*   

  4809)+'%)+/0     122%33#+$

 $#$%& 4+.#5#+'$0%* 

















 %*2+'%+$*  !,  :!

 
 7
    :!

 
 76
 7

%*%+$

!#3.)+'%)+/0;'9(#$%;&$0%#22%33#+$* )+ 



  !  #+'0%;; 4+.#5 +%&$0%#22%33#+$)+ 

   !67#+'0);'9(#$%;&%*2+'%+$*<$  )+ 



 #+' &%*2+'%+$*#+' )+ 

   !6#4+6%%0#40#+;'9(#$%;&%*2+'%+$= )+ 

  * * * * *  7
;
#3"

0%*%$0%%)+$#(4$#22%#3*0#9%5%%+$#8%+42#+'#%5%)+/ '%()'%' $/%$0% #* $0%> #)*% 4$ & # (??+ .4'/?%+$ '#$%'  2#**%'5>#3%#+%')+/3%4'/%&$0)*4$ $0%*#8%&(+9%+)%+(%;



&#($*#%5%)+/$#8%+&? 





  !" #$% #&'!%()"!

!'* # #&'!% 2.

%*2+'%+$* $8+(8%' $0%'* & $0)* 4$@)$0# /)%9#+(% $0#$ $0%> 0#9% +$ 5%%+ #22)+$%' #* 0>*)(#3 #)+)+/
+*$4($* & *0$; 
*" #/#)+*$ <A 2*$* %*%9%' & &%?#3% (#+')'#$%*  0%> (?23#)+%'$0#$*4(0#($)++$0%2#$&$0%$#$%@#*)+9)3#$)+&$0%$%?* & $0% #'9%$)*%?%+$ #/#)+*$ @0)(0 $0%> 0#' #223)%' #+' 0#' 5%%+ *%3%($%' 04/0 .4'/?%+$ '#$%'   # 3%#+%' )+/3% 4'/% & $0)* 4$ #33@%'$0%2%$)$)+#/#)+*$@0)(0$0%2%*%+$)+$#(4$#22%#30#*5%%+&)3%' 3.

04/0 #'9%$)*%?%+$ '#$%'    $0% %+$% & %9%32?%+$&'9#+(%'?24$)+/ &*0$;")+9)$%'#223)(#$)+* &%(4)$?%+$$9#)4*2*$*)+$0%'4(#$)+%2#$?%+$; 4+.#5 4$&$0% #'9%$)*%'2*$* B<2*$*@%%& 
**2%$0%#'9%$)*%?%+$<A&$0% #'9%$)*%' 2*$* @%% %*%9%' $ 5% &)33%' 42 &? &%?#3%*  04/0 ()/%+'4?'#$%'=

 $0%$#$%)+(%#*%'$0%+4?5%&2*$*& 
* &? B< $ =- @)$0 + (0#+/% )+ $0% $0% $%?* #+' (+')$)+* & $0% #'9%$)*%?%+$  %*2+'%+$*  $  #223)%' & (+*)'%#$)+ & $0%) (#+')'#$4%*#* 
*#/#)+*$$0%2*$*%*%9%'&&%?#3%(#+')'#$%*54$$0%> @%% +$ (+*)'%%' %3)/)53% + $0% /4+' $0#$ $0%> 2**%**%' # 0)/0% C4#3)&)(#$)+ $0#+ $0% +% #'9%$)*%'  @%9%;+ $0% *$%+/$0& .4'/?%+$ '#$%'< %+'%%'5># 433%+(0&$0)*4$)+$0%(#*%&*)?)3#3> 23#(%'(#+')'#$%*$04/0@0)(0)$0#'5%%+0%3'$0#$$0%(#+')'#$%*2**%**)+/ #0)/0%C4#3)&)(#$)+)+$0%*#?%3)+%@%%%C4)%'$5%(+*)'%%'%3)/)53%; $0%  )**4%' # 2453)( +$)(% '#$%'  

 (#33)+/ #33 $0% (#+')'#$%* 2**%**)+/ 0)/0% C4#3)&)(#$)+; )+(34')+/ %*2+'%+$*  $ ; & (4+*%3)+/&$%$0%(4+*%3)+/#?%)$3)*$&=-2*$*& 
*@#*423#'%'



0%2*$*& 
*0#'5%%+5)&4(#$%')+$0%#$)&<,<5%$@%%+?#3%#+' &%?#3%(#+')'#$%*)+$0%/%+%#3#+'%*%9%'(#$%/)%*@%9%;)+$%?*& $0%#&%?%)$3)*$+#22)+$?%+$3%$$%*@%%)**4%'#+'$0%?%)$3)*$)$*%3& @#*%'#@+242$%'3>)+$%?*&$0%.4'/?%+$'#$%'=  %+'%%'5> #)9)*)+%+(0&$0)*4$)+D

B<  ,- # ()"!

'* # #&'!%*2%,- # 0(#*% *42#")&$0%@?%+(#+')'#$%* 2**%**%'$0%%C4)*)$%?%)$$0%>(43'+$5%%E(34'%'&?(?2%$)+/& 5%)+/ #22)+$%' #/#)+*$ $0% 2*$* *2%()&)%' $ 5% &)33%' 42 &? $0% ?#3% (#+')'#$%*54$$0%%9%*%@#*0%3'$5%+$2%?)**)53% %*2+'%+$*$ @%%#//)%9%'5>$0%#&%%'#@+?%)$3)*$#*#((')+/$$0%?$0%*#?% ')'+$'%2)($$0%(%($)+$%2%$#$)+&,- # 0(#*% *42#"#*)+$0% %'#@+ ?%)$ 3)*$ $0% &%?#3% (#+')'#$%* @%% 3%** $0#+ <A & $0% $$#3 #'9%$)*%'2*$*#+')&,- # 0(#*%@#*$5%)/0$3>&33@%';$0%#59% *)$4#$)+ @#* +$ 2**)53% 
+ $0%*% ()(4?

*$#+(%*; %*2+'%+$*  $  #22#(0%'$0)*4$$04/0#54+(0&2%$)$)+*@0)(0@%%#33@%'5># 3%#+%' )+/3% 4'/%& $0)* 4$ $04/0 .4'/?%+$'#$%'   0% 2)9#$%%*2+'%+$*)+$0%2%$)$)+*&)3%'5>%*2+'%+$*$#*#3*$0% $#$%& 4+.#5#%)+#22%#3#/#)+*$*4(0.4'/?%+$  %#+%'(4+*%3&$0%2#$)%*0#9%5%%+0%#'#+'@)$0$0%)#53% #**)*$#+(%$0%%('&$0%(#*%0#*#3*5%%+2%4*%' < 0%)**4%#)*%')+,- # 0(#*% *42#"@#*#*$@0%$0% 4+'%$0% 4+.#5$#$%'4(#$)+3#**


 (03#'%"%9)(% 43%*; -B= & *0$; $0% 43%*"; (43' $0%% 5%; $04/0 (%#$)+ & # *%2##$% (#'%; %*%9#$)+ & <A 2*$* & ?#3% (#+')'#$%*  04/0 .4'/?

%+$ '#$%' =   # )9)*)+ %+(0 & $0)* 4$ (+(34'%' $0#$ $0%% (43' 5% + %*%9#$)+ & ?#3% (#+')'#$%* 54$ &4$0% 0%3' $0#$ )+ $%?

 

22%+')E  & $0% 43%*; <A & $0% 2*$* (43' 5% %*%9%' & &%?#3% (#+')'#$%*#+'$0%%?#)+)+/<A@%%%C4)%'$5%&)33%'42+$0%5#*)*& ?%)$)%*2%($)9%&$0%*%E&*4(0(#+')'#$%*
$@#*&4$0%0%3'$0#$$0% .4'/?%+$@43'#223>2*2%($)9%3>

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

#+'$0%%&%;%3>)+/+$0%3#@3#)''@+ )+ ,- . / # 0 (#*% *42#" #33@%' $0% @)$ 2%$)$)+ &)3%' 5> %*2+'%+$* $%*43$)+/)+$0%)**4#+(%&')%($)+*$$0%F$#$%& 4+.#5 $&)3342$0%#'9%$)*%'2*$*)+$0%#59%*%)#$)? =
+$0%?%#+@0)3%;,- # 0(#*% *42#"@#*$%*$%'5%&% $0%42%?

<&

%%'1 #& '!%()"!

!'*# #&'!%4(0#22%#3*@%%')*2*%'&5>$0% 42%?%4$54$+3>#&$%$0%42%?%4$420%3'$0%3#@3#)''@+5> $0)*4$)+,- # 0(#*% *42#" - 04/0 $0% )?24/+%' .4'/?%+$ $0% 3%#+%' )+/3% 4'/% 0#* ?%%3>)**4%'')%($)+*$$0%F$#$%& 4+.#5$% '%$%?)+%$0%?%)$ &$0%*%3%($%'(#+')'#$%*)+$%?*&$0%3#@3#)''@+)+,- # 0(#*%

2

*42#"*+$)(%'%#3)%;,- # 0(#*% *42#"0#*5%%+420%3'5>$0% 42%?%4$$04/0)$*.4'/?%+$'#$%' <2#**%')+%%'1 0 (#*% *42#"


+ 9)%@ & $0% #59%; @% &)+' + % )+ &#($  )+ 3#@ )+ $0% .4'/?%+$4+'%#22%#3

%*43$#+$3>;#33$0%$0%% *#%')*?)**%'

 (*$*  G 7
H





















 

-  G 76
 7

H % .%     D0%$0%*2%#8)+/F%#*+%', %*F D0%$0%%2$#53%, %*F