← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2937/2015dismissed

Malkiat Singh v. Dayal Singh & ORS

2015-09-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

     



  !

"#$$%&'&()$*#$+,$-.

"/0&"#&(12 **$//"(# 3$-'4'

"5"/&(12"(6#2$-'

 $'*(6$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&-()./'

 72$#2$- $*-#$-'/%"/*"*$-'+"5,$"//8$6#'$$#2$9461+$(#:  ,$-$$--$6##2$ $*-#$-'-(#:

 72$#2$-#2$9461+$(#'24/6,$-$*-#$6&(#2$&1$'#:

-$'$(#) -2"-+".6;%"#$.

-#2$"**$//"(# <<<<<  +*,&-(  =>

-  #2$  -$"'('  +$(#&($6  &(  #2$  "**/&%"#&(.  82&%2  &' '4**-#$6,5"("&6";&#.6$/"5 6"5'&(-$>&/&(1#2$"**$"/&'

%(6($6  '#"(6'6&'*'$6



  !

2$  "**$//"(#>*/"&(#&  2"'  &+*41($6  #2$  9461+$(#'  "(6 6$%-$$',#2#2$4-#',$/8.82$-$,5#2$'4&#&/$6"#2&'&('#"(%$- 6$%/"-"#&(  #  #2$  $$%#  #2"#  #2$  1&#  6$$6'    "(6    6"#$6

?-$1&'#$-$68&#24, $1&'#-"-."/"(62"-,$&(1-$'4/#-"46.

 +&'-$*-$'$(#"#&(.&//$1"/"(6;&6"(68&#24#"(5/$1"/($%$''&#58$-$(# ,&(6&(1  4*(  #2$  */"&(#&  &(  -$'*$%#    #2$   '4&#  *-*$-#5.  8&#2  " %('$@4$(#&"/-$/&$*$-+"($(#&(94(%#&(.2"',$$(6&'+&''$6 -2"-+"./$"-($6%4('$/"**$"-&(1(,$2"/#2$ "**$//"(#>*/"&(#& '4,+&#' #2"#  #2$'4&# *-*$-#5-&1&("//5 ,$/(1$6 # "-("+&(12"(6"#$-2&'6$"#2.2&''("(#"&(12,$%"+$#2$8($- ("%%4(#6$"#2"(#"&(12."5"/&(12"(6462&(12,$%"+$ #2$8($-'#2$*-*$-#52$'4&#*-*$-#58"'"(%$'#-"/"(6*/"&(#&"(6 6$$(6"(#' ..?#

8$-$%*"-%$($-'"5"/&(12."#2$-#2$ */"&(#&"(6462&(12.2&'4(%/$.&//$1"//5"(68&#24#"(5($%$''&#5 1&#$6"8"5#2$*-*$-#5&(@4$'#&(&(";4-4028&(6$-A"4-8&68  "-0"'2&(12"(6"2"64-&(12.,58"5"-$+$(#&($61&#6$$6' &(%$#2$*-*$-#58"'"(%$'#-"/.#2$-$-$.#2$"**$//"(#>*/"&(#&2"6" -&12#,5,&-#2('4**-##2$"-$+$(#&($6'4,+&''&('.2$'4,+&#'#2"# 9"+","(6&$'B #B 8$-$,-412#(-$%-6#'28#2"#"(#"

&(12'("-("+&(128"'-$%-6$6"'8($-#2$*-*$-#5"(6. #2$-$-$.#2$*-*$-#5&(#2$2"(6'"5"/&(12"(6462&(128"' "(%$'#-"/"(6.#24'.#2$5%4/62";$*"-#$6"8"58&#2#2$#&#/$"(6&(#$-$'#&( #2$*-*$-#5,58"51&#6$$6('4**-#2&''4,+&''&(.2$2"'-$/&$6 4*(#2$9461+$(#-$(6$-$6,5#2$(C,/$4*-$+$4-#&(  01.2

344,44  2 5

 154- +6 !

678 #%(#$(6#2"# 82$(#2$-$&'('4-;&;&(1+$+,$-&(9&(#"+&/5.*-$$-$(%$'24/6,$ 1&;$(##2$%//"#$-"/';$-'&'#$-$4-#2$-'4,+&#'#2"#&(#2$8-&##$( '#"#$+$(#.-$'*(6$(#>6$$(6"(#' #?6&6(#6$(5#2$'#"#4'"(6 ("#4-$#2$*-*$-#5"''$/>"%@4&-$6('4**-#2&'%(#$(#&(.2$2"'

 6-"8(#2$"##$(#&(#2$4-##*-$/&+&("-5,9$%#&( .82&%2-$"6'

#24')> D  



                            

          

         

   

   

      !   





  

"                  

        

#     

      !$    

               

 %

" & 

' ( ' 

     

    !'

)      

                !     

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

$

 &

( .+4%2/$''.*$6&1-$$#",/$8$-$-$@4&-$6#,$ *-;$6 (%$#2$"-$+$(#&($66%4+$(#'2";$(#,$$(*-;$6.&(+5

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

#2$(4'2$";&/5-$/&$64*(#2$"**$//"(#>*/"&(#& #*-;$#2"##2$("#4-$"(6%2"-"%#$-#2$*-*$-#58"'"(%$'#-"/";&(1 "&/$6#6'.&(+5;&$8.#2$1&#6$$6'."''412##,$%2"//$(1$6.%4/6 (#2";$,$$(-1$6"'#2$*/"&(#&"&/$6#*-;$#2$("#4-$#2$ *-*$-#5,$&(1"(%$'#-"/ (  ;&$8    82"#  2"'  ,$$(  ,'$-;$6  ",;$.

045 ()./'