← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2942/2015dismissed

Dharambir And ORS v. Raj Bala And ORS

2018-04-27Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

   

       

"#$ %$&'(')*+ ,"-"./'-")%")#,$- 00$11")#( 2$-(3( .#"4/"1"")%#,$-( $(0)%$)#(

 *  56    7 6  -$($)#*8 -7319'-"-:"1;%9&"#$; -"00$11")#(  <,$#,$-#,$$0-#$-( 1&"1)$:(0"0$-."=/$"11:$%# ($$#,$43%>.$)#?

 /$-$ $--$%##,$$0-#$--)# @ <,$#,$-#,$43%>.$)#(,31%/$-$0-#$%')#,$%'>$(#? 88 88 6 

6!

.03>)$%')0-$($)#-$>31"-($&)%"00$"1'(43%>.$)#%"#$% +;0"(($%/=1$"-)$%'(#-'&#3%>$;,"44"-;"

'-.')>43%>.$)# ")%  %$&-$$  %"#$%  ;  0"(($%  /=  1$"-)$%  %%'#')"1  '9'1  3%>$

$)'-  '9'(')!;  ","%3->"-,;  9'%$  :,'&,  (3'#    #,$  01"')#'

(  - %$&1"-"#')")%0$-.")$)#')43)&#'):"(%$&-$$% )#,'(&"($;#,$$(#"#$ (,:"-')>,() ,")6"1'(') %'(03#$ 1"')#'

"4 "1"&1"'.(#,"#"

#$-%$"#, ,'( '-(#:'

$ "- ="-';(,:"-')>,."--'$%,$--.#,$."--'">$;#:&,'1%-$);)".$1=; "-%$$0")%'#3:$-$/-)"-%$$0:"(>'9$)')"%0#')#"(($9'; 9'%$"%0#')%$$%%"#% "(($9',"00$)(#/$('(#$- "4 "1",$&1"'.(#,"#%$ $)%")#(,"9$0-&3-$%"/>3(<'11A%"#$% @A(,:"-')>,)$9$-$B$&3#$%("'%<'11

)#,$#,$-,")%;%$ $)%")#(#@;:,,"00$)#/$ ()(")%%"3>,#$- (,:"-')>, -. '-(#."--'">$:'#,"-="-'&1"'.

#,"#(,:"-')>,,"%)$9$-."--'$%"4"1" ,$=,"9$"1(%$)'$% -$1"#')(,'0 "-%$$0")%'#3:'#,%$&$"($%

88 -.#,$01$"%')>(; 11:')>'((3$(:$-$ -".$%*8  <,$#,$-#,$01"')#'

("-$:)$-(')4')#0(($((')  #, (,"-$ #,$"&,!')0-0$-#=.$)#')$%')0"-") #,$01"')#?   <,$#,$-#,$:'11)A%"#$%@A'('11$>"1)311")%9'% ")%)#/')%')>30)#,$-'>,#( #,$01"')#'

(?  @ <,$#,$-#,$01"')#'

("-$$)#'#1$%##,$%$&-$$ -0$-.")$)# ')43)&#')"(0-"=$% -)#,$>-3)%(.$)#')$%')#,$01"')#?   <,$#,$-#,$(3'#'()#."')#"')"/1$')#,$0-$($)# -.? 

 <,$#,$-#,$01"')#'

(,"9$)1&3((#")%'")%&"3($ "&#') # '1$#,$0-$($)#(3'#?  A <,$#,$-#,$01"')#'

(,"9$(300-$(($%#,$."#$-'"1 "&#( -.

#,$ 3-#")%)#$)#'#1$%##,$%'(&9$-=-$1'$ -')43)&#')?  + $1'$  -'"1 3-##C30'((3$(;")%@#>$#,$-")%,$1%#,"# -$>'(#$-$%<'11A%"#$%@A'("(3(0'&'3(%&3.$)#".$:"( "&&-%')>1=%'(&"-%$% -'"1 3-#/$1'$9$%#,"#"4"1","%."--'$% (,:"-')>,")% -.("'%."--'">$;#:&,'1%-$);)".$1=;"-%$$0")% '#3;:$-$/-);3# :,'&,"-%$$0:"(>'9$)')"%0#') :$9$-; '#3;.')-%"3>,#$-'((#'111'9')>:'#,,$-/-#,$-((3&,;%$&1"-"#') ")%  ')43)&#')  :"(  >-")#$%  #  #,$  $

$&#  #,"#  01"')#'

(  "-$  :)$-  ') 0(($((')##,$$B#$)#  #, '$#, (,"-$$"&,')#,$0-0$-#=') %'(03#$")%#,"#<'11%"#$%@A'()#/')%')>)#,$-'>,#( 01"')#'

( /$')>)311")%9'%%$&-$$ -0$-.")$)#')43)&#'):"("1(0"(($%')

"93- 01"')#'

(-$(#-"')')>%$ $)%")#( -.3(#')>01"')#'

( -.4')# 0(($((') 0-0$-#=")% -."1'$)"#')>#,$0-0$-#=)#,$/"('( ("'% <'11%"#$%@A,$ ')%')>("-$30,$1%')"00$"1

8@8 ,"9$,$"-%#,$1$"-)$%&3)($1 -"00$11")#(")%&"11$% - 1:$- 3-#-$&-%")%$B".')$%'#  #$->')>#,-3>,#,$%'(03#$%<'11;". #,$9'$:#,"# (".$,"(/$$)-'>,#1=%'(&"-%$%/=/#,#,$ 3-#(/$1:#&.$(3##,"# <'11:"($B$&3#$%/=(,:"-')>,)@A)#,$>-3)%#,"#,$'()# $)4=')>>%,$"1#,$%'$% '9$%"=(1"#$-)@@A##,$#'.$

$B$&3#') <'11;,"-"./'-;)$ /$)$ '&'"-=:"(0-$($)##,3>,;')#,$ (3'#,$,"(%$)'$%#,$(".$")%(#"#$%#,"#<'11:"( 3)%"

#$-%$"#,

(,:"-')>,)#,$<'11;#,$-$'().$)#')"/3#,'(:' $"4"1"")% .')-%"3>,#$-'#3)#,$)-."1&'-&3.(#")&$(;:,$)"0$-()$B$&3#$( "<'11;,$ #"C$(&"-$#,"#"

#$-,'(%$"#,;,'( :'

$")%.')-&,'1%-$);

0"-#'&31"-1=;%"3>,#$-'(1C$%"

#$-:$11).$)#'')> 1$>"1,$'-("1( '()$ (3(0'&'3(&'-&3.(#")&$(<'11:"($B$&3#$% '9$%"=(/$ -$#,$ %$"#, (,:"-')>,")%)$ #,$/$)$ '&'"-=:"(0-$($)#,$-$ -$;

#-'"1 3-#-'>,#1=&)&13%$%#,"#<'11A%"#$%@A'(1'"/1$#/$ %'(&"-%$%$>"-%')>-$1"#')(,'0 "4"1";'#&.$(3##,"# '-(#:'

$ "-="-' (,:"-')>,,"%"%.'##$%1=%'$% ,$1$ #/$,')%#,-$$ &,'1%-$);,"-"./'-;,-$$"-C"(,")%%"3>,#$-7"."1:,'(."--'$%# "1(&.$(3##,"#')#,$."#-'&31"#')&$-#' '&"#$ '#3;,$-%"#$ /'-#, ")%0"-$)#">$'(.$)#')$%:,'&,(,:(#,"#(,$:"(/-))@A ,$."#-'&31"#')&$-#'

'&"#$ "-%$$0 B+!"1((,:((,:"-')>,"( ,'( "#,$- -$9$-;"%0#')%$$% "-%$$0(,:(#,"#(,:"-')>,")% "4"1"/$')> "#,$-")%.#,$->"9$"-%$$0')"%0#')#"(($9' %0#')%$$%/$"-(0,#>-"0, (,:"-')>, ,$-$ -$;#-'"1 3-# -'>,#1=&)&13%$%#,"#"4"1":"(."--'$%:'#,(,:"-')>,")%#: &,'1%-$):$-$/-) -.("'%."--'">$')&$"-%$$0:"(>'9$)')

88 "%0#');'#3"1)>:'#,,$-.#,$-"4"1""-$&1"((8,$'-(,$ ')%')>  "&#(,"9$/$$)-$&-%$%/=#: 3-#(/$1: ,$1$"-)$%&3)($1 -"00$11")#(,"(-$1'$%30)$&#')A

,$3)4"/ 3(#. :$-# )#$(#!&#; ". #,$9'$:#,"#("'%($&#')%$()#/"-01"')#'

( -.

&1"'.')>%$&1"-"#')#,"##,$="-$"1(&1"((8,$'-(")%$)#'#1$%#(3&&$$% #,$$(#"#$ (,:"-')>, ,$1$"-)$%&3)($1 -"00$11")#(,"("1(-$1'$%30)"3#,-'#=   #,'( 3-#') 



     ; ! 

'9'1!;#0-$((#,"#.$-$0-$($)&$ )$ #,$/$)$ '&'"-='()#"

>-3)%#%'(&"-%<'11 ". #,$9'$:#,"##,'('()$ #,$&'-&3.(#")&$")%:,$) #,$-&'-&3.(#")&$("-$"1(#"C$)')#&)('%$-"#');<'11:"(-'>,#1=,$1% #/$ (3(0'&'3(%&3.$)#")%-'>,#1=%'(&"-%$% ,$-$"-$&)&3--$)#

')%')> "&#(-$&-%$%/=#: 3-#(/$1:,$-$'()'11$>"1'#=")% 0$-9$-('#=')#,$ ')%')>(-$&-%$%/=#: 3-#(/$1:$)&$;-$>31"- ($&)%"00$"1'(%'(.'(($%')&$."')&"($,"(/$$)%'(.'(($%;#,$-$ -$;

0$)%')>"001'&"#');'

")=;"1((#")%(%'(0($% 

6 !

 

+ (4C( <,$#,$-(0$"C')>-$"()$% * $( <,$#,$-$0-#"/1$ * $(