High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3006/2015dismissed

Jarnail Singh v. Hukam Singh And ORS

2018-03-19Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh6 pages

!"#$%&'() %%*!)(($

!" #$$%% +++++ %*!)(($,& &# $ $$% " "#%%' ' "

' " () # +#()

() #

- ./ "% $/

" $" %" "/ (+%%"" ( '0

1 % 20

%% .# 1,, 3 $ /(

# ) 40 3 !

%%' #/#$ &# % 5 " 2'#( " ()# %* # %%+ '

"0 67# $%

"0# " /, (+%% "" ## '# #/

' # # .# % / #

' # %" / # $$ % / # %" " (+%%,/ ()#$%

&#$$%$ (): '#$$%%#

+ ##5 ":

'2'+## "" '%)

'" ()# %* +

/ #$$%%#

'/ #* +" &#

/ ()" #$$% # $ ,$%

# ("/ "0# " / (+%%"" % 4 ;;

$ $ ( <"

() + '# # /% ) = ! '#2% $ '## '# :+ > $" % / .%( # % #($! () #$ ,$%

"" "+ #%+# </ ) ' + # % +# + '# + %) </ 0 0"# #$$%% '#$$ )"0 </ # / &# " / () " # #

$$ # + (< $!# " = '# ?0 </ ) # $ ,$%

#! $% .+% ' # / % " $% () #

- #

' # * $$% $"

()+ #$$%% #( +# #"" + #/ $$%% $ () 5%

% / #

" @2#A#

#('

#= '#?0 # "</ # / #+ '#'!

/ / # : '#B/ &#

+$ " ( #* ()5%

'#5?0

"$)# +/. @<5 ,# (! #* $$%#

+( '#( # "" &# % / () " #

! %

/ ).

'$ # %

% ()$ ,$%

# ()#$!

" 1 # # $"

" % " ;

# C# "B A $$ # " # # % $

'/ # * !"#$%&'%( ')*(%+, - ./"#$$0'#( ')*(1,+ A#!# " #$$%%$ #$$0(. "$ " $$% ()" '#" # ' + % / ! #

" # %) +

@<?

, %' + # "$) % @< ( % # " </ " % ("/$% #$ +)= '# )

"# %)+

@<?

, # /) D "$) %

4 ;;

+/. @<+ # )( " ()#" $) % " </ = '# + % /. !

## "</ = '#+ #' $ "# % / .%()- '# #!

% 4 ;;

()+ # /% +%% ) = ! '# 2% $ '# # '# :+ > &# % % + % $ " ( # * () + '#?0 +##"$)# +/. @<&# $ + '# # "0# +# <"

# %

- ./ '# # #! <"

"" #% %)# :+ + '#+%</ +# !

@<?,

# ' # #@< $ E # "

/" " # $$%% # % - ./ '# # # ( $! "" "+ #%+ ! / % (%( " #$$%%# %)"" #$# % @<+ '# #% # "" 8 %' + # +# $ '# 8 % / .% @<-#

# / #"

# % @< + # ' # %" " "" %#/ #% @<5<"

'#()+ '#"+ +# /#"" +" # #

- '# #

%""$" # $$%%#/%)(" # "" #( / $$%% # (

$ $ ( <"

() + '###"0+ # .#+ %

# %" 8 ' ' # % # $ +# "#" (/ ..# $ #"0+ ( $ $ $"% % # $ $ "

% ! A+ % # # #((% # " # # # %" # % <"$ # "" %% .#1,, 3 ( "/ % @<

+%%

&# '#= '#)

# / # " /#+ '#'!

#/ : /( "

/+$ #+

$! # = '# # / "" #

"$) +# + $ " () 5%

'# 5?0 </ "# % % /) 5%

'# + % !% # # + # $ ( #!

'( '## // " ' %" " / 20

# / : '# + '#-#% $ #+ '##'

" "" #/ '#- # !

" "$) #

@<5 , () '#"$)

+# "##( ()# /$ #* +# "# ""$ % @<5 ,-+!

!)"%

# % "

/+! %(%+ ##+ # /"$)

+ ()# / '##+ # ( '##

#* #$$%%* + "" (! #

#(( '# ( #* ( !##$$%%""% /<"% ! '# #""

+ '#+# # % ) # #"" - #$% @<"- '# ##! ("/ "0# # ( % <"

() + '# +# % + # "" - ./ '# #"( $ ! # '# #%" "/

#' #/#( #/ : '#()# #

&# ( '#* #% + #' #

( '/ (% + %

! %

/ ) $ % A # " #

" ' # "0#

$" $ % )###

/ )

% $$% " $ # % # ")#$ ,$%

#$ # '# ( ' %

#%" """ '#'

!# /

#% @<&#

'/% $()" # $$%% % + # %)

"!) # # $$%%" !) !'# " #

% ()

( " 1 # #"&# $ #$$%% #

"% + # "8 % %

" # $!

" 1 # # " + % ( " #'

/" F# ' '#$$% % "" '%)

/ % " 2 %,"#$%0 -23( C5= % B ?##$.

', ), ?##$(% ),