High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4439/2016disposed of

Om Parkash Since Deceased Through Lrs v. Sukhwinder Sharma & ORS.

2018-04-04Mr. Justice Amit Rawal9 pages

"#$$%&'&()*+&,- .

/ "+0"'1 '&(%$2$%$"'$2!#1+3415 '#1$+'

**$,,"(#'

6$+'3'

3017&(2$+1"+/"#1$+'

$'*(2$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

+$'$(#) +$$*"01"+/"-28%"#$- +#1$"**$,,"(#' + "(0"9"&(-28%"#$- +#1$+$'*(2$(#' ::::: +*,&-( **$,,"(#;2$$(2"(#'"+$&( $43,"+$%(2**$","4"&('##1$ 9324/$(#'"(22$%+$$'2"#$2< "(2

<*"''$2=>#1$#+&", 3+#"(257$+**$,,"#$3+#-71$+$=>&("'3&#&,$2+'$$0&(4 '*$%&&%*$++/"(%$#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,2"#$2 <<-#1$#+&", 3+# +2$+$2 +2$%+$$ --?; &( "83+#1$+$'*(2$(#;

*,"&(#&",(47&#1&(#$+$'#@ A*$+"((3/-&$-#1$23=,$#1$"/3(# #1$$"+($'#/($>71&%11"'=$$(3*1$,2=>#1$57$+**$,,"#$3+#

$'*(2$(#;*,"&(#&' &('#&#3#$2 #1$ '3&# '$$0&(4 '*$%&&% *$++/"(%$#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,2"#$2 <<<&(+$'*$%#,"(2 /$"'3+&(40"(",'/"+,"'-71&%17"'$B$%3#$2=>2$$(2"(# "#$+ 4$##&(4%('$(#+/2$$(2"(#'#@ <,"%'*$+"%+$"#$+

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

"+0"'1;2$$(2"(# 7"' (#'3(22&'*'&(4/&(2(<<< $1"'=$$('3$+&(4+/$*&,$*#&%&#'"(2,''/$/+>1&'"%#7"'

&(#1$0(7,$24$#1$*,"&(#&'-711"2%"*&#",&F$2('3%1"%# /

"+0"'17"'$"2/"'#$+&("%1,"(2=$&(41&41,>$23%"#$2*$+'('-#1$ E3$'#&("**$(2&(4#1$#13/=&/*+$''&((#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,2&2 (#"+&'$1$+"#$#1$,"(27"' <%++$*$+"%+$-#1$+$+$-#1$+$7"'

(%%"'&(+#1$2$$(2"(#'$(#$+&(4&(#"(>"4+$$/$(#@<,"%' *$+"%+$1$"/3(#+$%$&8$27"'("%%3(##1$#+$"#/$(# /

"+0"'1(#1"#+$4"+2-#1$*,"&(#&'=#"&($2#1$#13/=&/*+$''&(' /

"+0"'1 1$ $(2+'$/$(# "# #1$ ="%0 #1$ "4+$$/$(# '17&(4 *"+# *">/$(#&#'$,'17'#1"##1$,&($'1"2=$$("22$2,"#$+"#$+#"0&(4#13/= &/*+$''&(' / "+0"'1('$8$+",*"*$+' &(%$#1$*"+#&$'7$+$"#8"+&"(%$-#1$#+&",3+#+"/$2#1$ ,,7&(4&''3$');

! "

# $

! %

$'*(2$(#;*,"&(#&'$B"/&($2"'/"(>"'3+7&#($''$'-"(2 ",'=+341#(+$%+22%3/$(#'B

-&$-"4+$$/$(##'$,, B

-+$%$&*#'B #B -2$"#1%$+#&&%"#$ / "+0"'1B <-,$4", (#&%$B

-9"/"="(2&$'+#1$>$"+ ;B D#B -'",$2$$2 2"#$2 ..<B

-'",$2$$22"#$2 . .B

-"4+$$/$(## '$,,2"#$2 D<B

"(2'#"#$/$(#'"%%3(#'B

(#1$#1$+1"(2-2$$(2"(# "9&8H3/"+1&/'$,"**$"+$2"'

"(2 ",' $B"/&($2 +"4=&+ &(41 C; 1$ 2$$(2"(#' ",' =+341#(+$%+22%3/$(#'B #B -&$-#+$"#/$(#+$%+2 /

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

#%(#$(2#1"##1$ +$%$&*# 2"#$2 < 7"' 1"8&(4 '#"/* *"*$+ =$"+&(4 +

D<- 71$+$"'#1$+$%$&*#2"#$2 <7"'1"8&(4#1$'#"/**"*$+

D< 1$,"'#*"*$+#1$"4+$$/$(#1"'#1$'#"/**"*$+=$"+&(4

D<"(2 #1$+2*"4$&'1"8&(4#1$(3/=$+

D<<-71$+$"'#1$&+'#*"4$&'1"8&(4 '#"/**"*$+

D< #2+"7#1$&($+$(%$#1"##1$2%3/$(#'1"2=$$(

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

7$+$"**&(#$2"'43"+2&"(-71&%17"'(#2($&(#1$*+$'$(#%"'$("%#- #1$+$ &' "/*,$ $8&2$(%$ ( +$%+2- 71&%1 '3+"%$2 23+&(4 #1$ %+''; $B"/&("#&(#1$*,"&(#&#1"#&#7"'+4$27&#1"%#&8$%((&8"(%$7&#1 1"4&(41-=3##1$3+#=$,7$++($3',>=$,&$8$21"4&(41-#1$ /"+4&(",7&#($''#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,(#1$+7+2'-*,"&(#&'"&,$2# *+8$#1"##1$>1"2*"&2#1$",,$4$2"/3(#,"%'# / "+0"'1 1$+$7"'(%%"'&(+#1$3+#'=$,7++2$+&(4#1$+$3(2 ,"%'+2$(>&(42&'%+$#&("+>+$,&$"(2-#13'-3+4$2#1&'3+#+ '$##&(4;"'&2$#1$&(2&(4'3(2$+%1",,$(4$

$+%(#+"- + "(0"9"&(-,$"+($2%3('$,"**$"+&(4(=$1", #1$+$'*(2$(#;*,"&(#&''3=/&##$2#1"##1$"**$,,"(#;2$$(2"(#'"&,$2# =$,&$#1$#13/=;&/*+$''&(' / "+0"'1 "(2 "' 7$,, "' 1"47"(# 1"+/""(2 "9&8H3/"+'(' / "+0"'11$'#"#$/$(#1"4&(41 1"'=$$('*$%&&%"(2%1$+$(# $%$&*#'1"8&(42&$+$(#'#"/**"*$+'

73,2(#=$"#",##1$2$%&'&(#1$%"'$"''/$#&/$'-#1$'#"/*

*"*$+'"+$(#0$*#&(+2$++"+$(##>*$2&('$+&"#&/"#",,-#1$ 2$$(2"(#'7$+$8$+>'3+$#1"##1$'"/$1"2=$$(+4$2-(#1&(4*+$8$(#$2 #1$/#=$,&$#1$'&4("#3+$'?#13/=&/*+$''&('#1$"+$/$(#&($2#7 *$+'('&(%,32&(42$%$"'$2 / "+0"'11$+$%$&*#B <,"%'

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

/ #1$*+$/&'$#1"#23=,$#1$"/3(##1$%/*$('"#&(=$&(4($#1$ %(2&#&(#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,7"'#($+3' + "(0"9"&(-,$"+($2%3('$,+#1$+$'*(2$(#;*,"&(#&' 2&2(#"4+$$##1$"+$/$(#&($2*+*'",-=3#,$#&###1$2&'%+$#&( #1&'3+# 1"8$1$"+2#1$,$"+($2%3('$,+#1$*"+#&$'-"**+"&'$2#1$ *"*$+ =0 "(2 #1$ 8&$7 #1"# #1$+$ &' ( +%$ "(2 /$+&# &( #1$ '3=/&''&(' #1$,$"+($2%3('$,+#1$"**$,,"(#;2$$(2"(#'"(2#1$ +$"'(&'(##1$($=3#/"(>);

1$'#"/**"*$+'=$"+&(4$(2+'$/$(#E3"+$%$&*# 3+#1$+*">/$(#-8$+"(2"=8$$"+($'#/($>(#&('$+&"#&/ 73,2(#,$"2#1$"4+$$/$(#3($B$%3#"=,$"'"%##1$/"##$+ &' #1"##1$#13/=&/*+$''&(' / "+0"'11"2(#=$$( 2$(&$2I =!

$%$&*# 2"#$2 < B =+$ #1$ '#"/* *"*$+

D<-71$+$"'+$%$&*#2"#$2 <1"8&(4#1$(3/=$+ #1$'#"/**"*$+"'

D<8$(#1"#73,2(#",'/"0$&# 3(=$,&$8"=,$+&("2/&''&=,$&($8&2$(%$-+-&#1$2$$(2"(#' 7$+$'3+$-#1$>%3,21"8$'3//($2#1$+$%+2#1$'#"/* 8$(2+ # $'#"=,&'1 71$#1$+ #1$> 7$+$ ="%0 2"#$ + #1$+7&'$I %!

#1#1$+$%$&*#'=+$#1$#13/=&/*+$''&(' "9&8 H3/"+- "9($$'1H3/"+"(21"47"(#1"+/"",(47&#1#1$ #13/=&/*+$''&( / "+0"'1"%0(7,$24&(4#1$+$%$&*# ,"%'"(2 <,"%'8$+"(2"=8$"'3/ < ,"%'+$%$&8$2"'$"+($'#/($>"##1$#&/$$B$%3#&(#1$

0 "4+$$/$(##'$,,8$(#1$"4+$$/$(##'$,,7"'",'(#(,> #13/=/"+0$2=> / "+0"'1-=3#"%0(7,$24$2=>1"47"(# 1"+/""(2 "9&8H3/"+ '('! 2!

''&'#"(%$#1$"(27+&#&(4B*$+#1"'(#=$$(#"0$( #=$,&$#1$"+$/$(#&($2'&4("#3+$'"(2#13/=&/*+$''&('I $!

C;+"4=&+&(41&(1&''#"#$/$(#'#"#$2#1"# /

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

1"4 &(41- #1$ /"+4&(", 7&#($'' 7"' ",' %+''; $B"/&($2 #1+$"2="+$ "(2 1$ '*$%&&%",,> 2$*'$2 #1"# /

"+0"'17"'&('3(2"(22&'*'&(4/&(2#&'(##1$%"'$ #1$'('#1"##1$>7$+$(#(42#$+/'"/(4'#$"%1#1$+ / "+0"'12&$223+&(4#1$*$(2$(%>#1$'3&#"(2#1$'(' 7$+$ %(#$'#&(4 #1$ '3&#- 71 "+$ ",' '&4("#+> # #1$ "4+$$/$(##'$,,"(2#1$+$%$&*#1$3+#'=$,73(2#1"# #1$"4+$$/$(#1"2=$$(*+8$2#=$4$(3&($2%3/$(#-/3%1

,$''+$"2&($''"(27&,,&(4($''("%%3(##1$"%##1"##1$ 2$$(2"(#'1"8$,'##1$+&41#"(2#1$#&#,$&(#1$*+*$+#>"'#1$ ,"(2 7"' "%E3&+$2 => "(2 < %++$' 1"2 =$$( +$%$&8$2"'%/*$('"#&(#&'&(#1'$%&+%3/'#"(%$-#1$#+&", 3+# +2$+$2 + +$3(2 #1$ 23=,$ #1$ "/3(# "' #1$ 2$$(2"(#'"&,$2#*$++/#1$&+*"+##1$"4+$$/$(#1$ +$"'(&(4"''&4($2-&(/>8&$7-&'(#"=,$#%3#&%$#+/" 2&$+$(#*&(&(#1"(#1$($"++&8$2"# 4!

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

234 ()56'

,474381 93

:39

,474 7;"

:39