Makhan Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others






    
     

  !"# $%&%!'()       

     ! ( *+  ,
,

,- .

" #!#$%#!&#'(!)*# +%  %#)#  #(  ('#, + ! #%-#(!)*# + !. //// ,

,- .

 /0 +1    %0%  %  #    +$!  !  *  12. 33(% #40%5#%0+

6+ 626..62  78  
9(  &%*%  &#  0!  #0#  %- # $* # #!#( * #0(*0%(++* ! *1:.(;.;(;1+% 3(#!(#$+#$$%,5 *!0(  #(  #  %+-(    %  ,#  +  *- - 78
;9 . <%  %  #    *#-    +  %#0   16.6=(%3
!#*%+%3-#!!* ( % $$#5##0#**!(-#4# &% *% )#*>+%*- -%$#! $$#5##0#&##$

.
!*!!*$% (&%%%#>%  )$)!%***(&%# #>%  ( #!(&%*+%*- -&$!,5!+5#%0 +%

(#!(+%#>%*-#$*# !0#0#% %#+!-#4# #%#% %#! ! !!( (#*- -?$-(#)!#( *+%

 7 #9 &%  % @  + *- $##
 !    .  7* !*#!9 ; %#+-#!!16.6=,>%3
!# *%+%3(%#,*- $!&%,>%$#! $$#5# #0#  **!(  #!(  %  $*!     %#  ,  $#*!   *! #$+% (#-!%3(,>%$#! #0#**!()#$%#%$-?*- -(#)! # 
  %  ( #!( ! . 7* !*#!( %0%%@9(#5$+,%(,0 
 

(,!% *- -?$-,0#5$+ **( ,08*! #*%%%+(%$#!#0#%#  !  %#  %  $-  ?*- -(  ! !!     ,>  % (  +  40  %   5#%0  +  % 

 7 #9(    ,% )$#>(#!(0 1

%-(%$#! #3$(*( -!%-(,>% )0#0 ++*7

9**!(,-%# %0%%*%#$$#%#,+$!,(%*%#0#>,+#-! : &)(%$#!*$# #0+% #(%# ,-!%#!$0*% *#,0#!%

;
# (#+%*
#**!(#-$>@#*%-## 0#>    %  !!  +  *- -(  *#!    8  
; %+(%*!%# *+ *#> #$++*(  *-#$!+5#%0(%,#+*- -!!( *#!8
;(#%*#,-#!,>%3&)( %#,),-,*-%0!(%&#4+%@+% $#$>  #00)!
*- $##
'!(  #$  -#40  #  *#$    8
;(%#) *+%#,)@#*%-#(%>%$!  5##!+5#%0,0-#!( (%8# ( %* ,>%  3&)( % $#! # 3$  %0#+$+(% (%0!(%#+ %++**!#0#%#**!

(#-*%% ! *1:.+% 3(
*- !#,$)&%% $#)+%3 A &)(+%#,#0!%#+(% #+ #>(#-#!,>%$#! #*$(*#,#** ! ,>%3%+% 
-#+! $$0%)0 +#+-#!#0-(!( %+#*-+#$##-( ,0-#!,+%3(,>%$#!*$+% ( %##+*- $+)0#(%0%# ! * B;33(%#, !(,*%#0%#>,!#& #0#%#**!
&% *% ++* B %++*+%#+#-(#-#!&%8- )%-*,>%$#!*$+% (#!(#$% ++*+%#--#!,>%$#!

1
#(%#%$)# ##-#*# $#!#)!*+% C,$ 83(!!*#$!#( 


  

 

   (#-*% ## $#?**0%(%#%% &! * 12.33(#)!%0%3(+5#%0+*-#$ *!0(#?+

*- $#(%0%*,0-#! % )+ *12.33(#%,0!*#!!++ +-% &0)#*-#$3(%*+*- !0% $)#++*(,0'!,*-!)D
#
)D%+#* %#!(+# # $*#%&)(%##$,%$! %(%#+ &)!%0%3(+%&! $!(&%#>$-#(,0 $#*!%(>%# ,8*!*%!+'*(#!( )%#, + *+#>3%0%#0%'#*4+-$#(%#, *- $#!  %(  +  *  ,0  -#!    %  -#!#  + *  12.  33(  %*  +  5#%0  +  # 

(    *-#$ *!0*- $#(>%#$,*)D
#
)D)#$! 8*0(*- !% * $(%#+%#**!#!% *- $###%#)#$!  
 $-(#!(&% % %*)*+%#**!,*--#!,$#4 35$>(%#,-#!#!(%#$%++*0% ,5#%!(%0%%8*0+% &)!! * 12.33(##!%(#-*%#%#+(! -,!>++*# #0-!(# (!#*>*(#!( &%%++*#$# *#$#$4)+

:
3   *    ++*  *--!  ,>  ,$*  )#(  &%$ &40%#*# #*>(% *#, -,$>8*! &)( )!8*+-,#07 #9( $% )!*  7 #9(  % (  %  0%  3  #  ,#!(  %0% *0%-#!#+ *12.33(%*(5#%%

   5#%  %  *-#$  *!0  # #0    ?% ++*7 #9 2

# 8#*%$)# ##0# %+%)!* -#!,>%C,$ 83
C*#7 #9



  
 
 


  
 



 


 

 


 

 





 
  


   
   !
"#$ % 


  
 &


 

 
 


 
 
'()
*    
)

* &  % 




  
 % %  &
   

 

      


 &
 % +
 +
 

     
&
%
    
         
&      
,

 ++ 
&+%

&

    



- 
&      
 %!



    
  
    
&%  !

&+  &   
  

  



 
 
,.
 
/ 

 & 

,

 
&(
&





 


 %0 

 

&  

&

  

 


+
 &    

  


+ 

+  
+ 

+  
       
,  
       

  
&
 &+%
&
 

&

   
 


 % 
 &+
  &






A




+  
   

+


&


  , 
 
    

                
    
      
 
        
&




 
      



%   +
 



   
   &     
    
    
   
   



 



       
     
      

          
+


 


   



)*


 
+
 


 







%1 = *%++*(! *1:.+% 3!( 

(# #,0#)(#!(%(# ##*%0+%-,#07 #9+! %0%3 )!*  7 #9  %+(  %  $-?*- -(  #  )#$!$> !(',0)!35$>()+%#+ ++**- !#,$(%3!!-+#**  %*79+%$#! #*$(%#%3(-#> %0%*0%-#!#+ *12.33(5#%%

(  *#$$>&%%*%#0#>,+#-! #+-#%&% #%% (%*%#*+% ,0*)*!# -#&$$#,$#4 5$(%!0+%#$+% #**!(&$!$%##-#!%-$#(,0*#! %#**!(,!&$!!+#%!+'* 6

%-(#-- %#+-#!)&( #$!)!+-%'!0-!!,>%3*#$! # !"#



 $ %

&'

''

  &(&%#$(%#,))&%#,

B
#!  %-% (#!(%#-#$$&! 35$>(  #+  #** 0  %     +  %  $#!  #0# **!(%3 *!5#%%

7 #9 . **!0$>(  % 

  7 #9(  #!(  #$  #$$  % *5#$ *!0(%*#0%+-(#5#%!5# %  0,

,- .

)   4#)0%