Babli Devi v. Rakesh And Others
!
"# !$!%&!'
() ) !
"# %"*"+*,!-!* '
) ) ./" 0!0 "*'
) ) Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?
Yes '
12
3) 3 3
3
!" # $ "
!% &
''''
3
3 ) C.M. No. 23470"CII"2019 (
"
) * +%
,-.# & ,-/& 0
+ "
2" &
#
!"
#
2
/
3 %
& 194 days 0
&
*
(
0&
")
,
(
0 2 1, ,1 14,5 &
!%("
2
% "
) ,..
,-556
7("
89
% % 0 % "
** 444: 02 ;-<
"%
"
) "
" ,.
14,=
" %
>" "% % 2& ("
>" "
& 3
3 2 32 3 #
( "
%
%"
& ("
2
( &
2
%
2
/
"
# $ "
!% &
2 % &0"20& %"
%
& ("
0& 0 ( & %
* $ "
"2
32 24 3 .
? 8 )"
% !" Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 5
3+.%!-!
"+% $!$ 6
(
2 2 % % % "
@30
!"#$
%# !"&$
&' !"($
31)
* (+,
-
$ . /
*
32
(+,
(+,
* * * * * * 42. )
&$ 0
1 $ !2 !(%+ %!
%(
$
3 !4 %'#+
3 !'#!#(
3 !(#'&+
3 !&&!&(
3 !#&'(+
3 !!(!((
3 5 (''+
3 4'!'(
3 (''4+
=
? 8)"
%!" National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 5
7
3 6 2"
) ,..
,.# ,.5
,-55 2 "
0 A % %" B
8
69 ) %" 0 0 B 6!9
0
& 0%" B 69 0" %& "% "
A 2 6C9 3"" 0 02 % B % & A& ( "0% "
"
@52. 6 conventional heads
7/
8*
7 %(+++
7 !+++++
7 !+++++
7/
0 9
:
6
;
*
!(+++ 7 &++++ 7 !(+++
<
)
!+,
)
= = = = = 59.3)
(+,
/
&+
#+,
&+ (+
*
(+'+
!(,6
59.4*
$
&+,
7
&+
6 %(,
&+(+
!+,
(+'+
59.5.
#+#%0> ?
59.6.
0> @ &%/
59.7
59.87
7
!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++
!+,
A ? 8)"
%!" 9- !*!% /
*$+% *,!
"-. *:
2;-; !0 <$) *+ - /; $ =+=%+ - =!%$
3 ( 0 3 %/ <!%- $+.% % * :
3! =;
3+.%
20 0 "% % "
"
B216 <
C 0 8
;
*
D D
D D D
D D D
)
%!! Spousal consortium
D
/ D %!% Parental consortium
D
D %!# Filial consortium
6
22
3 /
E
3 /
23 3>
6
*
C
6 6
24
D
D C 0 8*
7 &++++
-
" % "0 2 ) 2% 0%&,,& %6CA9 %
( ("
2 0
%%0"% ,*444:
"%
,4 $& 22 &
2 % & % %
>"2 0 " "
% " 0 % ( " & " 0
00 0 "% &% &0 0D @ E2" & "2" & " % "
,-55
,, $ "
" % % "
@
%E & % %"% 20 2 )
% ( ? 8)"
%!" 0 % 2
Kajal v. Jagdish Chand & Ors. [(2020) 4 SCC 413] Baby Sakshi Greola v.
Manzoor Ahmad Simon & Anr. [2024 SCC OnLine SC 3692] 2 2 % ""
"& %: & % %"%20 2 "
%
,1
(% 22 & Hitesh Nagjibhai Patel Vs.
Bababhai Nagjibhai Rabari & Anr, 2025 INSC 1070, % "
"
B5 ;
/
*
*
*
0
Kajal v. Jagdish Chand and Ors., (2020) 4 SCC 413 Baby Sakshi Greola v. Manzoor Ahmad Simon and Anr., 2024 SCC Online SC 3692 !+6 2
*
%+!% F/ 7 %%42(
/
7 '2#((
7 '2#'" A ,#
& 0 % &
% % )
0&
$) >
? .!% -"* = 0% %"%20 2 ) ?&
,/
$ ("
& 0 %" 8 (
& 22 &? 8)"
%!" $ "0% Baby Sakshi Greolavs. Manzoor Ahmad Simon and another, Law Finder Doc Id # 2672826
%" ,5 0 & 0 % ( % "
"
B&2
G/ $ 3 6 $
0 9
7 &#(2"
E
!26
&#(2!%!2H7 5&!#%2" 5&%+++" A ,*
(2 >"&
( 00 % "0% %" "
(
,.
" " 2 ("
2 0 &%"
2 ""
% ( 2 % @ ""
,=
" " 2 ("
"
0 & 0 A " ! 0 2 "
% F " "
2 A " 2
,5
" " 2 %0%"
0 & ("
"
G "
A
3"% %"
2 "% ( 2>" "0
!"
RELIEF ,-
$ 2
allowed 2 1, ,1 14,5%
0&
2 2 &? 8)"
%!"%
%
%"
% "2 Sr.
No.
Heads Compensation Awarded , &$
% ,4444: 3"" ;/4< /444: 6/4< ,44449 # "
2 A ",:1 =444: 6,/444H,:19 /
($
% =444: 6,/444 =4449 / " ,5 *
"
& ,* ,1 444: 6=444H,1H,59 .
+ C ,* 444:
= 3"
CA ,* 444:
+ ! "% /4 444:
3 /4 444: A, " / "-.!*$ ;"* $)8> >
? !0+, ;"*
%"
2&("
$) >88>
? *= *,!0 -"+* $)(> 7>
?
8
88
)
&? 8)"
% !" Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 2019 ACJ 3176 R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107
%"
" & ;-<
"% !A,/+0;*9 =!
.!%;"0 "# 0!/ :
"# 0 :$ ;* #;/;*9 =!
..! /
% 0 %
D
1,
# $ "
!% &
%"
02 2("
2 2 % % & "0% (("
"
%"
% 02
%
$ 2 ,5 4= 141/ 3 I ,.51 144= $ "
!% & " " " !" "
00&!"
1#
0
69 &
) )
3
3
J"
K 0:
0) K :