M/S Cimplex Machine Tools Corporation v. Punjab Financial Corporation Ltd And ORS












 

 



 

!"#

#$%&%'(
#)"#*+#,
-.
  /&
%*)0#1
!$2%'#
0&
,),!"%'.
*,%"&!, ))#00!'"

3#,&4&

4'5!+
%'!'$%!0
,),!"%'
6"7.
2!'7%8!,2

"2#,&  #&)'7#'"& 
 !

"#$%&
'( )* & *)
+%,'(-.&

 92#"2#,
#),"#,&

0$!0
)!)#,&
*!:
+#
!00;#7
"
&##
"2#
5478*#'"<  
+#
,##,,#7
"
"2#
#),"#,&
,
'"<  92#"2#,
"2#
5478*#'"
&2407
+#
,#),"#7
%'
"2#
%8#&"<

,#&#'"( ,= #>2%.
7?$!"#.

,
"2#
!))#00!'" @@@@@







































 *)
+%,'


AB

 

,
"2#
,#!&'&
&"!"#7
%'
"2#
!))0%$!"%'.
;2%$2
%&
&4)),"#7
+: !'
!%7!?%".
7#0!:
%'
*!>%'8
7#%$%#'$:

$4,"
##&
!&
87
%&
$'7'#7 

&"!'7&
7%&)&#7
 
A-B

  1#*)"%'
8,!'"#7
,*
%0%'8
$#,"%%#7
$)%#&

5478*#'"
!'7 7#$,##
7!"#7
- 

!'7
''#14,#&
B
"
B 
&"!'7&
7%&)&#7
 
ACB

 

,
"2#
,#!&'&
&"!"#7
%'
"2#
!))0%$!"%'.
;2%$2
%&
&4)),"#7
+:

 !'
!%7!?%".
7#0!:


-
7!:&
%'
%0%'8
"2#
!))#!0
%&
$'7'#7 
&"!'7&
7%&)&#7





 

2#
!))#00!'"B)0!%'"%
%0#7
!
&4%"
,
7#$0!,!"%'
!'7 *!'7!",:
%'54'$"%'
&##>%'8
%'7408#'$#

"2#
4,"
"2!"
"2#
4'5!+

%'!'$%!0
,),!"%'
,
&2,"
D

E
;!&
'"
;%"2%'
%"&
,%82"
"
$2!,8# "2#
%'"#,#&"
!&
)#,
"2#
;2%*&
!'7
!'$%#&.
"2482
"2#
)0!%'"%B!))#00!'"
2!& '"
7%&)4"#7
"2#
!$"
"2!"
%"
2!7
+"!%'#7
"2#
0!'
,*
"2#


!'7 #1#$4"#7
!
*,"8!8#
7##7
7!"#7
A  CC 
1$#)"
"2#
%'7%'8&
,#'7#,#7 '
%&&4#
.
,#&"

"2#
%&&4#&
;#,#
4'7
!8!%'&"
"2#
!))#00!'"B)0!%'"% !'7
"2#
&4%"
;!&
!$$,7%'80:
7%&*%&&#7
,= #>2%.
0#!,'#7
$4'&#0
!))#!,%'8
'
+#2!0


"2# !))#00!'"B)0!%'"%
&4+*%"&
"2!"
+"2
"2#
4,"&
+#0;
2!?#
$**%""#7
!' %00#8!0%":
!'7
)#,?#,&%":
%'
'"
,#'7#,%'8
"2#
%'7%'8&
!&
)#,
"2#
,!0
!'7 7$4*#'"!,:
#?%7#'$#.
;2%$2.



),?#7
"2!"
"2#


2!7
$2!,8#7 "2#
#1,+%"!'"
%'"#,#&".
%#.
+#:'7
"2#
"#,*&
!'7
$'7%"%'&

"2#
*,"8!8# 7##7
"
%&
%'
"2%&
$'"#1"
"2#
&4%"
;!&
%0#7 
2!?#
2#!,7
"2#
0#!,'#7
$4'&#0
,
"2#
!))#00!'"B)0!%'"%
!'7 !)),!%&#7
"2#
)!)#,
+> "
%&
!
*!""#,

,#$,7
"2!"
'#
%*#
#""0#*#'"

;!& #'"#,#7
%'"
+#";##'
"2#
!))#00!'"B)0!%'"%
!'7
"2#
7##'7!'"B,),!"%' 74,%'8
"2#
)#'7#'$:

"2#
&4%"
!'7
"2#
!$"4*

"2#
&!*#
;!&
%'"#'7#7
" +#
+,482"
'
,#$,7
+:
"2#

"2,482
!'
!))0%$!"%'.
+4"
"2#
&!*#
;!& 7%&*%&&#7
?%7#
,7#,
7!"#7
F-

'$#
"2#
!))#00!'"B)0!%'"%
2!& #'"#,#7
%'"

$2#*#.
'
$!4&#

!$"%'
&4,?%?#&
%'
"2#
&4%"
"
!8%"!"#

 "2#
8,4'7&
"!>#'
"2#,#%'

7
'"
%'7
!':
%00#8!0%":
!'7
)#,?#,&%":
%'
"2# %'7%'8&
,#'7#,#7
+:
+"2
"2#
4,"&
+#0;
!&
"2#
&!*#
!,#
+!&#7
' !)),#$%!"%'

,!0
!'7
7$4*#'"!,:
#?%7#'$# $$,7%'80:.
"2#
!))#!0
%&
7%&*%&&#7
/012,  *)
+%

034 '(-.&