High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3086/2015dismissed

Sudershan Dogra v. Dav College Trust And Management Society And Another

2019-12-17Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh10 pages

! !

% &

)

* #

# $%&'()*+"'',#+**&

!"#$$ %& '((!! "')*' + %&,+' -'. %& ' ( ----- ',#+**&.( /'+ ,+!! +(

++&!01+!,& +%!% 21+&+ 3 &+!+) & & " .

-'!!$ + ' ( ((! ' 4 + & $+ &&1

++$ 4) ' -1 ,'

4) 1+ . ) +21&++ &+$'((!!501+%&.( ) , ' . "+&' . ' +!!$!!) & &' +1 + 67 + & ) &'! 8'

-9 :1&+!

& 9- -'+$ ''% (+.

(5(!++ &% ).$,( !)& 4)'

-+%+!#1$#1+ 6+%++

-'+$ ''

;' +!-1 ;

%+21$.& '!!,+$ & 9 <=%+,.)++$+&1++' .+ +1 ' 1+ ' (!++ + ( !) & 6& ( + %1 (!++ . ) +21&+ + &+$'%&'( ( )'% '.'(!++/'+1+ &% ).$ ( ) + 4+.+/'

'!!4 &> /'((!(

4)11&&1!((!!5, +.+4)'++!6+ +&#1$ -'+$ ','

4)++$

4)' +!-1 , + .,+'1% +& /' (5(!++ +! 1+ ,+' ' % . ' ((!! , ((+ + ? + . ?!

67 + & )&'!

& 9- -'+$ '

( ((+.! @ @?,4( %+)&&..++''! ..( )& 1&+, ++? +.?!4 1 "(+$&. 41+!+$. +! ( 01+(. " 1 +1

! !& +&! ((!+& & /' ((!! . '

.(!) , !!, !+% + ' .( ) .( )4++!!')&1!

$ ! +%&&..+ /'.( ) ,+!!$!+,&+4)': +& -'+$ ' /' 1 ' ((!! ,+' (& ' +(1 ( + , !) ' !+& /' 6 = &'!

A/ -'+$ '-'+$ '.++ +'4 +$'!!'

&'!'1!4+&.(!+& ++&7+!+- ++& !

, &+% . ' 6+ +& :1&+ +&

A/-'+$ ''',+B1.

''+: +&

A/-'+$ '( !!)%++&'!( .+

+ 1&'&'!1' ++ .%'+!!$! +!+$ ,'+&' ' &'! ! 41+!+$ , !+4! 4 1. ', &1 +& , ! &+%

+ &+$ ' &'!

.% ' +!!$! 1 !$! +& , +1 ' ((!! 1&' '

.(!) %& ' +!!$! 4)

/' ((!! '

+! 1+ +21&+ ,'

+ +21&+((!+&+,+.+/'((!!' +$' + ' 4%9+ ( .+ ' ( '% (+ 41 .!+'+!!$! ( % 1.(+ /'((!!5+!', +. + !+.+ )42&++ !+!&1+ (+!'1+ (!+4+$( ( !)% ++?+'', ( %+,+')&&..+=+14.+'

+&+(! &'! + ! &&1()+$ &&..+ + ' &'! ( .+ /' , !

) 41+! , +$ , ()+$ ?1 9&1.9 !+&& ' &'! 1' ++ . +. +. !! . +!% .'(!+, +,+'( ) +.+! 1++&

+4!4!,'+&', 1!) (!+%+ (!)

= ' (!+&+ ' % . + + ' (!+ ,

+ ( !+.+ )42&+1+', +., +

/' +!-1 .!!,+$+1 .++ 9 C''

'(!++++! !+. ) +21&+( ) D

C''

'(!++++! & &% ) ( ) D

C''

'1++.++4!D 6 C''

'(!++'%!&1++!' 1+D 6 C''

'( 1+'4( ( !)% ++ ( !,D 6

!+ /' ( + 1& %+& & ,'

' 4 .+( '21$. +!-1 ?%+$' &1! '( ++'!+$'. +! ' +!-1 ( !)& '1+21$.' +!-1 ,+ .+((! -1! ' ((!! ' +! &&1

++$ +. +!),&1/'+ 14.++.4)&1!+'+ ')

.(!)67+ & )&'!

& 9- -'+$ '4&. +!'1 '((!!,!!, &&..++'&'!( .+ ',4+$(+)'1

'& ) ',."+$()., '1 E&1.9 !+&& 1&'( %++$ &&..+4&. ' &++ %+&'((!!=+%'.!) $1'+'

(,&'$'&++ %+&((!! + + +1 +! +(1 '

' . !+ ,+'+ .+ =1 +!/ +41!5841 -1 &+1&''-+%+!-1 '

@ 21 ++&+ + )'( 1+=+1 '

$1' ((!! + (! ' ' 1+ + .++4! +! -1 . +1 + '+ $ , $!) &+ 4) ' -1 ++$'+1 !+4!4 % =1(( '+&+ ' ' !+ 1( 21$. '+ -1

!"# $ % & '&()*(+ &, *- .//01.2 '

034, &56, '&()*( & 75 -899.1:2-;.9( &'!4.21$. ?;4!'1( .-1 & , *<*)*(5

+& &! 5 !&, -./=/1:2'

8.:( '

14.++ . 4) &1! + ' + ( ( 4) ' : +& -'+$ '

+ & +&&1(+'((!!'

.(!)=+ $1 ' &&..+ ( %+

+&+(! ' &'! , ! &+ 4) .++ + A/ -'+$ ' /' &'! ' 14.+41+!+$(!,'

+&&..+( %+'

+&+(! ' 4 +&!1 $+$ & ) &+ : +&

A/ -'+$ ' = + $1 ' ' ((!! +.+! !) +1 .(!)'%4 + !)4)+&!1+$&&..+ +'+ (+ 4++$& )&+ '

&+'

(5(!++ & ' 21+&+! & 1+) ,' F.+'1&'1.! +$'01!+) -1! +$ ' (5(!++ ' & ) '1(( &+++$ 4)'-1 ,+'' 14.++''.1 .

.1&'!( % +) ,

+$+ %++&((!=+ $1'1&'+1

, +4)'((!!'( %++$&&..++' &++ %+& ! +'

++1 +!+(1' !+,+'+.+=1 +!/ +41!&+=+1 '

$1' %'

,+ ."+$( %++ ().'1 !$ '((!!,((+ +') @,1!+! ' ((!! & ' !!,+$ '+. + + ' .( ) +01+.1'&++'+ %+& $+$+%&,1!.1&'$+&++ %+&

++$+1 +!+(1?'! 1&+'((!! '+&' ('%+&!1.( ) !!, 4 1 4) &! =7 .(!) &'! + +'

.1 +& +.++ ' ((!! '

,+ & &'!!$ &+ ' 1' +++'+ $ = '% ' &1! ' ( + ( 1 ' (( 4"

1! ' , + . +! ,1! %! ' ' ((!! +.)1 ( !+.+ )42&+/'((!!+ ++1%,+' $ 9.++4+!+)'1+,' !" ++$42&+,+' $ 21 ++&+'-+%+!-1 + &+ ' 1+ ' & ) + ( ' !+.+ ) 42&+ ' '

+ ' &+ '

(5(!++'%!&1++!'1+-1! ' ((!!'+!(+1+)1&'(!,+' $ -+%+!-1 !&"+$21 ++&+ + )'( 1+, ++' $ 1((!4 '+ ((!!-1 1&'&+, + %+& 1 +$ ' &1 ' +$ ' ((! /'

01+,+' $ &++ %+&'((!!++(1 &1!& % )'.&4!!,4 + ' + +.+&((!='+%+,'.

&+ +4) &1! '((!!,+' $ 21 ++&+'-+%+!-1 + .+&&+%!+4!4 2& /'+ ( ++(14!) ' ((!! , ((+

+? +.?!67+ & )&'!

& 9- -'+$ ' %+ ((+. ! @ @ -1! ' ((!!'+!(+1). +! ''+. '+((+. +,'&++'+ %+&'',1! 4 ( %+ ) &&..+ + ' '! ,+'+ &.(1 ' &'!=')

( %++,. ().'1 4+.(!)'&'!/'

+&++"4)'

(5(!++,+' ,'1 ='$+%&+ &1.& ++++&1!&&(&+'((!!'"+$ %&+ &&..+.1&'$+&++ %+&' 4 .+4)'=1 +!/ +41! /' ((!! ' ( 1& ) ! !!. &&..++'+%1 :%'

,+ +.(!)'4 !!&&..+ ',1!.

!)4!+&'.(!) /'((!!'+! ) 1! ( &1 ,'+&'' &" '+ &!+. . +$'' %+ '&&..+ %+'+.+11' +G

'.'1!4$!$!+G ,' %+(!,14.+4)' (/'4+$ ' ((!!& +%)%$'+&+ .'&' &&..+( %+

+&+(!'&'!'4+&!1+

' + (! 14.+ -'+$ ' .++ + ,'+! !!,414)'((!!+.+! !)+1.(!)'% 4+&!1/'4+$ &+ +4)'((!!4) +%"+$ +&!'-+1+=++(!).+&&+% && +$!) 2&='+%+,'.

'((!!& " ) + '+&+ . '

1' ++ + %+,(&1!+ &&+ &1.&+%!%'

+ =%+,,''4+&1'

++$ .

+ '((!+! && +$!)+.+!%+$'( + 4 '+ ,& # .4-89./ 7#'2 H6I1!+J C''

("+$5 )5 C''

( 4! )5