High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3127/2015dismissed

Pseb Now Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ORS v. Rakesh Kumar Trehan

2016-02-15Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain3 pages

!"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- !"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- !"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- !"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- .

/ .

,(0!*"!"#1#%"+&%&"- !+$!($"2#+'

33#11!("'

4#+','

!5#'26,7!++#2!( #'3($#("

) ) ) ) 8 9 8 9 8 9 8 9

+#'#(")

+#'#(") +'2!(9!12!+7!.$:%!"#

+"2#!33#11!("' ;;;;;

;;;;;

. #'3($#("2!$ &1#$',&" +$#%1!+!"&("2!"2# <!'#("&"1#$"+#%#&:#"2#3+7"&(!1'%!1#(%731#"&( -#!+' '#+:&%# 2#%!'# "2#+#'3($#(".&(*+&# .<!'"2!"2# 2!' 0&(#$ "2# '#+:&%# "2# 3#"&"&(#+= !+$ ( ?

/ #"&"&(#+ <!' #("&"1#$ + "< 3+7"&(!1 '%!1# &(%+#7#("' ( %731#"&( -#!+' '#+:&%# # #($!(" 2!$ 3!''#$ !( +$#+ $!"#$

<2#+#*-."<3+7"&(!1&(%+#7#("'<#+#@+!("#$""2# 3#"&"&(#+<#:#+.$#'3&"#"2#3!''&(@ "2#'!&$+$#+.

&" "< 3+7"&(!1 &(%+#7#("' 2!$ (" *##( +#1#!'#$""2#+#'3($#(" 33#11!("'=$# #($!("'&("2#&+<+&""#('"!"#7#("

!$7&""#$"2#3!''&(@ "2#+$#+$!"#$

"<!'

,+"2#+!:#++#$"2!""2#!%%,("'

&%#+2!$&("&7!"#$"2!"

+#'3($#(" $&$ (" ,1 &11 "2# %($&"&(' 7#("&(#$ &( &+%,1!+

!'2#$&$("2!:#!:#(,# "2+## 3+7"&(' ("2#31#!$&(@' "2#3!+"&#'. 11<&(@&'',#'

<#+# +!7#$*-"2#"+&!1,+")= B C2#"2#+ "2# 31!&("&

&' #("&"1#$ " 3+7"&(!1 '%!1# !($ "2# &(%+#7#("' !' %1!&7#$D

C2#"2#+ "2# ',&" &' !1'# !($ +&:1,' !'

!11#@#$D

C2#"2#+ "2# 31!&("&

2!' ',33+#''#$ "2# 7!"#+&!1 !%"' +7"2#%,+"!'!11#@#$D

C2#"2#+"2#31!&("&

&'#'"33#$*-2&'<( !%"!($%($,%" +7 &1&(@"2#',&"D

#1&# E

!+"&#' 1#$ "2#&+ #:&$#(%# &( ',33+" "2#&+ +#'3#%"&:#31#!' +&!1 ,+" :&$# 0,$@7#("A$#%+## $!"#$

>$&'7&''#$"2#',&" "2#31!&("&

=+#'3($#("( !(!33#!1 &1#$*-"2#+#'3($#("."2#&+'"33#11!"#,+" :&$#0,$@7#("A$#%+##$!"#$

$#%+##$"2#',&"

"2#31!&("&

=+#'3($#("#(%#."2#3+#'#("!33#!1*-"2# !33#11!("'=$# #($!("' 9#!+(#$%,('#1 +"2#!33#11!("'2!'',*7&""#$ "2!".!1"2,@2."2#+#'3($#("<!'#("&"1#$"+#%#&:#"2# &" "<3+7"&(!1&(%+#7#("'(%731#"&( -#!+' '#+:&%#. *," "2# !++#!+' %,1$ (" *# !11<#$ *#-($"2#3#+&$ "2+##-#!+'

( "2# 3+#'#(" %!'#. !$7&""#$1-. "2# *#(# &"

%1!&7#$ *- "2# +#'3($#(" <!' @+!("#$ " 2&7 *- "2# !33#11!("'=$# #($!("' :&$# +$#+ $!"#$

<#:#+."2#7!""#+<!'+# #++#$""2#!%%,("'

&%#+ :&$# G2&*&" !($ "2# !%%,("'

&%#+ *'#+:#$ "2!"

+#'3($#("2!$("3!''#$"2#$#3!+"7#("!1#G!7&(!"&( !($ <!' (" 2!:&(@ "2# !:#(,# "2+## 3+7"&(' #'3($#(" <!'. 2<#:#+. (" &( +7#$ H,! "2# 1#""#+ G2&*&" ,+&(@"2#3#($#(%- "2#',&".!33#11!("'= $# #($!("'3!''#$"2#+$#+$!"#$

$#%1&(&(@"2# &" "< &(%+#7#("' " "2# +#'3($#(" ( 2&' %731#"&( -#!+' '#+:&%# &(%#"2#+$#+$!"#$

2!$*##(3!''#$*-"2#!33#11!("'=$# #($!("'

$,+&(@"2#3#($#(%- "2#',&"."2#1#!+(#$&+'"33#11!"# ,+" +&@2"1- 2#1$ "2!" "2# !++#!+' !$7&''&*1# " "2# +#'3($#("%,1$("*#+#'"+&%"#$""2+##-#!+'!'"2# +#'3($#("2!$*##($&1&@#("1-3,+',&(@"2#%!'# ',*'"!("&!1H,#'"&( 1!<!+&'#'&("2&'%!'# <!++!("&(@&("#+ #+#(%#*-"2&',+" &'7&''#$ #*+,!+- .

/ #*+,!+- .

/ 7!2!:&+