← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1828/2018allowed

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Mohindergarh And Others v. Hoshiyar Singh And ORS

2022-12-07Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal10 pages

  



  ! "# $ % 

$ 

& ' ()) $ * ++' ,)) -

 % $ -) ))..// 01

- % -

$ -) )).

 '

2#3

) " - 3 4-

!3  



   

    



  

 

  1+  5671'

 





 

%  &# '

    ( %&() #

#



 





$

 '  





#!

)

, -

. *#  '

    1 2)   . *# & '

    ( .&()  %& 

 #     

$

    

#!

   #

$



$   #

 -) ) !+1/ /& $ 



4 45 34 

" /

 .

! 

#

&#

 !

 8 9 '



#:

  ;

<

- 

# 9 4; 34 - 8# $ 

.&   8 5;

 35 4 343  #  .& .&

 

# " /

 

% 5444444=:

  / <

%&(  ; 3 34-  #  



% ;//4444=:

  -'

< 



#

 .&  



/

   



 

.&

! ## 

$ 



 



  % ;4444444=:

  

!      =

 



 



   

 

.&

 $

 *#

(

&+ .1 58  .+& .+'

?    @



 :



 

 

          3 3 ? #    #

  

#

  



 $#   

!



 , 3

#!

:

!

 " #

$ !

 % "&'"

()"

% 3 5  



  

 @

 % :

A 

%

#$:<  B!

 % :3

"

A# 

# B!

  < 7C% 

!

3 , ? #   

 #

 #  



 $#  

!



 , 3

#!

:

!

 *+" *  ,"&"

$ !

 *-" !

 *  !

 *.

"&"

" !

 *  ,"&'"

/ !

 *0 1  ,"&'  "

 ,"$$,"2  !

 * 1& "","&'"

3 " ," ,"# !

 *) 1& ""&'"

4   "+ "),

9 /8+ *    58  ' %& 

 ! # #



#

# :

 ( 46$"

,7$"

"

&/$,""

" ," ,"#"

01,7"1, 89#:;   &"$"' , ,"&" "( :;        &"    $  "   ,"&"",,""

&,, :

; # $

5 3  # 

#!   %&

 

 9 #  #  B@ :

B@ :9  







 



 B@ :

!# 



&#

      % --44444=:

  &#



4E

 

! $  



  &#   4E # #

 

F



 #!

B@ :,  

!#

% -;5,444=:

    &#   4E # #

  

#



#  

$+1+  /8+ *  71: *  / 1/ .+7  .+'

7

  #    !

 $   # $"

  &# 

 *# 

; , 3 

!

      

  #  #    

$#

:

-3 $

$- ! $ $ #% 

3$ < - -) )

=+5+ ) -/ $ ) $ /  :1 + ) :1 !  + ) 0+//7 :

549, 3; 43 34 ;44 *  504444=:

599;344=:



:3 ,5,;

4, 43 344/

 ;;444=:

//44444=:

 :5 59/ 49 4/ 3440 ,3 *  ,4444=:

,-40;3,=:

 :, 49 4 3440

" /3;444=:

--44444=:

 -3 $

$- ! $ $ #% 

-

% =7 ;;

4; 4- 3440 3A:3 3-4444=:

/44444=:



% =& 45  344 " 33;444=:

044444=:



% =< 5 3 344 A:9 33;444=:

093095=:



% =B //,, 9 4 343 9A:; /93444=:

04430=:



, 5 

  #  

  

 # #  

    

#

# 



*# $

, ,  

  # 

 

! "

 B@ % =7 B@ % =B !



3;

 #

  $#  

 #

 -

#! #!

 #





#

" G# B@ :

'$ 8 549,) #

  *#  #

    





 B@ :3 '$ 8 ,5,;) B@ :, '$ 8 099) 

 



> !

  $#  

 

! 

, ;

 " #  B@ %,=8 #

 ?

    #  B@  5=7

 

*# @



#  # ?

    B@ :, '$ 8 099)

!



$

#

 # 

 



  #

 .&



"

 #



, -

 # B@ : 



   

# ;44 * 



! 

 B@ :3 B@ :, 

 



!

 B@ :

    

# ;44 *  

! ## ?

 



#  B@ %,=8    

! 





   B@ :

'$ 8 549,)





 # #

 B@ % =7 '$ 8 ;;)

  4; 4- 3440



 



# "

 $#  

$ 

$  

% /44444=:

 



  

! 8 0 "

 8 5 3=3  # #







 



,  "

 # $

$   #  





, 9

  

!



3;



 

$  

"

 #       #

 .&

3;

 $ &#





  # 

 .&

#

 ! 



#!

 

# &#



 !"#$ , /     B@ % =7

  "

 # $

 $   B@ % =& '$ 8 054)  45  344



# "

$ 

% 33;444=:

     % 044444=:

 

  

! 8 33 "

 8 4=  # #

B@ %,=8 # 

 



  $#   # #

     

% 044444=:

  #

#

 



# B  B@ % =B '$ 8 //,,)  &# # 

#

  

! @   



 8



9 4 343

$  

% 044444=:

  , 0 

#!   #







#   ?   

&#



 $   $     

 .&

   35 4 343 

*#  

 B@ :, '$ 8 099)



  



 ! $#

            #

 

;

$++'

;

? 

 #  #

 $   ; 3 34-

 

  



 



? #$  #  



/

 

 ; 3  

#  

   

, $:5? 

3 4-

!3 1'

" $

 &4*" <=*)"

 &"/$ <=*)"

-) )  ) ..//') .') )

++B >H %I8 8< >%

> ?I%

?8 8< >%

%H:/30:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

78 ?

8< >%

%H:/54:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

> ?I%

?8 8< >%

%H:/5:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

<?8B  AJ% 8< >%

@ ;

%H:/53:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%.

?8 8< >%

- %H:/55:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

8+> 

%H:/5,:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

B8<B%

?8 8< >%

/ %H:/5;:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%B  AJ%

%H:/5-:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

> ?I%

?8 8< >%

%H:/59:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

% &8<B% 8< >%

%H:/50:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

J%> 8< >%

%H:/,4:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

% &8<B% 8< >%

%H:/,:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%>+  8< >%

%H:/,5:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

J8<B%

?8 8< >%

;

%H:/,;:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

+ .A - %H:/,-:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

 I AJ%

%H:/,/:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

<BBA AJ% 8< >%

/ %H:/9;:34/

++B >H %I8 8< >%

J8B  <B6?

%H:00:34/ 78 ?

'8> <B&B B< +% .%) >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:5-:349 %B  AJ%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:5-3:349 > ?I%

?8 >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:5-5:349 > ?I%

?8 >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:5-;:349

J8<B%

?8 >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

3, %H:,00:34/

+ .A

++B >H %I8 8< >%

3;

%H:3-/:343 %>+  8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

3- %H:395:343 > ?I%

?8 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:39,:343 % &8<B% 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

 3/ %H:39;:343 %.

?8 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:3/3:343 <?8B  AJ% 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:305:343

8+> 

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:3--3:343 J%> 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

%H:3--;:343 B8<B%

?8 8< >%

++B >H %I8 8< >%

3 4-

!3 " $