← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3222/2015dismissed

Bhagwan Singh v. Punjab State Electricity Board And ORS

2017-09-29Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik10 pages

  

!"# $#%&'&() * *

+ ,!-.!(&(-,!($,/ 00#11!("

2' /(3!4"!"#1#%"5&%&"6!5$!($",#5'

#'0($#("'

) 7898:  

 





 98:; 8



  

     





! !

    

"  

 

 "   #$ $# %$##    

  &   ' 

 "   %$ $( %$#)  " 

 *    

 



 %

 "    

 + ( , -   .   

 &   

    

 + /#0% 

 1 2  3 

  & + ( 3  

  

 



 !

 + /(40     

  

 1 " & + (        

    

   

     2  5   6 7  

 &   .6 &

 2       2   

 - 8 * - 2

    !

  !

  !  

 

 

 2 

 !  

-  

  + /#99 *   !



7    2     

  + (

   

    & + # %     :   

    6!

      %0 #$ %$$;

  2     !

   3 





  + (  

 + #<9%  %0 #$ %$$;



 2 

"   + # %   !  

  + (   

 & !   & + # %

  " !       

   "  ,  



 /*    /*

 , * -

 6!

  + (    & + (

   !         

  + /(40 =

 1 "    !  

  + /#0% ,  

 + (     

 + &/#4;

=

 &  

>      

  

!

 / # ?

  

   

!

  

  + / (40 ! 







 

 1 " @ > %

?   + #<9%  %0 #$ %$$;

  

 @ > (

?

  

 

"  @ > )

?    

     + /(40





 

    

   "

-  *@ >&

<

.



?

!

       6

  

  

    !

  

 

      

 

   

 

   /*

   /*

 

   

"



 



  !

   

:          !

  "

-  *

 

:     

 "   #$ $# %$##

1

 

     !  

 

 

  !  



        

:  !   

 "   %$ $( %$#) 2      2

 

 1   

2A

-

,!(-!1=!5!6!!&$/ $#!$ 468'2'!-!((!", $#!$ 468';

**<

  !  



!

 : "

 !5>!',&(-,!($",#5'2'&("#=#10?#("??&''&(#5; /(3!4!($",#5';

<  &=&1 + /11#(%, ;,!/5!!-$/

!5!1>!52'"!"# !,!5!',"5!;

+ @

;2!0!66!!'"56 !($",#5'2'=" !($",#5';

+ <  ;5##"0!1!($ ",#5'2'"!"# !56!(!;



*  &=&1 A  ,/5/!?2' ,!5!?0!1!($",#5';

 &=&1 +@A >  /

 

     



   

  

 





!

    

 ,



   /





     

    / 

 /

 !  3   

  2!   

  

/

   

    /   3     

   7  

     : 

 



 !

   

    

!    

!

!

2       



!

! !

 "      

 "   





    



   /*  

:           

     !  

 

 



  &   '

 



  /*

@ !

6   

 -     

"



 



/* 





"  !   

 



!

 /

            ,  

     

!

     





 



!

  

! !

   

 "   

   * 

"    

 

  

3         !

  



   7     

  &   '

 #( #9

 " !  

    /   

          

     



          

        

 

   

    



    

!  

    

       " # $  %

 

    

 

   

        " # $ 

%         

%

+ 

     

  



       

      &

'(%$  )*+       

%

   

   & 



 

    

   + , %)  

)

   

  

  

- .)  )



  "  

      

)



        



    

- .    

 



       

   

     

- #/!.01     ,1 (2 ,223     

        

 

 

 

45 

   

     

 

$                            

                

       4     



     

         

   

 

   



   

 

     6)#+&)   21 2( ,2((    % 

 (007)(001),22, ,2(( %

    

          ,22, 

    # $   

A %

     ,22,    

                   

 - .   

 

- (03   8     ,2((  %    

        

      9

       

   

   #+& 

     





!  

       

 

    

    

       

    

   



    &              

   #+&

     

  

  4 

    

  : 

 

         

   

 

  

        

 

     

    -)          



 

     4   

   

     

      

  

  &)  9       

    

       

 

  

    &       

  :     )   9     

    

 :  

             4          

*

      &              

 

      $

  

 



)   

     "



 

 

     

    

          



  '

   

   

 

 

;

&   

 

    



 

 "  



!

2 

   :

! 

   :

! ! 

 :        !

3



 "    - #$$ 

 ,  

 



!

!

2B

-

!5!6!(!(  !3#($5!(  !($  !(",#5  2' 8#>',?6!53&(&!($",#5';

*

 @< +       

         

  !







 



 "  



!  

     

  !

  

      

+ 

 

  

-   

    



3 

 

  ();



  

   

    

  

.       

       !    B98:C %4 $4 %$#0   ? 6 C DC+ ? 

DC+