← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1946/2018dismissed

State Of Haryana And ORS v. Dharmbir Singh And ORS

2018-05-09Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia6 pages



    

     !""#!$#%!&'#'

  &$##!('(")  * 

  



  !""#  )  +,  ---., $% & "'

('( ))))) --.,/

, *

" 

 + 

,  - ,". .* ,.!/

 

 01 " ","%  "," 1 "   "#,"

",

# 3 4

-( !2,

2 1," 5&"   ","%  "," ,"   + "

"#  .! 6 ."- .  "  ","(

 !

"." 

"," ( 

-  "

"# ", 5&"  &",% *"  "##".#"

-3 4! (722 " "  #-  (, "-! 8,9 """5

,(."- +  ! ,  3 ((:;,++( 3( :;,!

"1"# /", ," 8,9 """,(  "

"," 3  

"#"."

#722 -",-,9 "   , ," -<  *!" , " 01$$3($

  $  -  /  "  ,""       #"."#   =  

",.#-/  ( (4 :;* :3, -  ",,  .  (-""#", / .

- "1",!.> -    --"#    4(

( +:;,", ,", -",-,9 "."01$

3+     

(    -  #".    ! "     = ,     :3  ,"  -    "     #  "# , " *,  #    ""# 

" 01$-",- /

  01$3  /    *"# "",  "!

!2,* ","  "# / .

"-!

"-"

"#-"" 

!

1    "9 "*,

 -",! ,! -. /.

-

#-.

 "  " , %

-0  12(3($ 4&0%5-& 6#  %##% " &$#   0#7('$0&$( "5&4&0% 0#& -&6# !"'(%#0&$("

'

#0  &!0# 8&69#

' :  ("!0#;#"$  <#0 =#&0 $&6  8&69# <#0  &!0#  &'

"    

' 1  ?*

@A

 /*/

5A /

/

5A /?/ >5A 0;

?*

$   /// >A 2&BB &0  > 1 *> A* **/

/

5A * / /*>5A

'?/>/ 5A 0;

*> $ 

>/

/?5A A%A  1 ?

*> @A /* /

5A */*/*5A

'?/>/ 5A 0;

*> $ 

/>/>*5A A%A ?



1  > *  @ /

/

5A /

/

5A AAA AAAA A%A  > 1 * *

>

-C&0%'

/

/

5A /*/ /

'>/*/*>5A 0;

*

$  //>/*>5A A%A *

1 ?  > A>@A> /?*/

/

5A >/ /?5A

'>//>>5A 0;

? >$  */ /

5A A%A  1 > 

*'C=&0%' ?//

5A /*/ /

'>*/*/5A 0;



$  / />/5A A%A > ?* 1

>>>

5 ?5 > >A@A?

/*/*/

5A ?/* / **5A

'/??/ >5A 0;

? >$

 *?/ ?/ >5A A%A 1  ?



'C=&0%'

/

/

5A / / /

'*/ /*5A 0;

??

$  /?/

/*5A A%A  >?

1 

 ?'C=%'  /*/

5A // 5A

'?/

/ *5A 0;

 $ 

//*?5A A%A 

?

1  

'C=&0%' /?

/

5A /*//

'?//>5A 0;

 $  // />5A A%A      -

#-.# !/  #, / -", ,+   ?01$ @( ,4/ 4  ?01$ @" "

 01$" 4 , / 3  *!." -

#-     .

    ,  -  +( (+4:;(   4(( 3:;   3 (+(++:;,". >"   ="  ", !# /.

!/"#.#  ( "#.  ,  :3*"#   "  ","  "- "#  /.

(-", %  



   

    

       

   

  

  

 

     

  

            

!

#$ %



&'  (

 ) #  **+,-'%',%

-+.

,/%-01 2

#

&/  3 #

 *4,-'*4,)#3-0/  3 #

 & $  /   #

  *.  ,- 5 3   6.* ,)#3-   7    

    

5 5          8             

     

 ! 

5   



 

    

 5         

  

    97      

  5     

     :;)!:;)!:;)6!:;)4:;)+   

 

;

     !      

      

           :;)             &    :;)   



         :;)6   <  /  !

   :;)4  5 .<.  !5    :;)+      . !4 <6           5 **4**+3

!   :;)5       **=   

+<!  :;)=5        **+ 

   

.**  !  :;).

   =   !  :;)>

   ***  !  :;)*

   >6     :;)

   **  !  

       

+ 8        

  

   

    

    ! 

 

     

      

   

         :;)    :;)6    :;)4    :;)+    7     5 

'+!+!.?@  !<  

5            !  

 ?6                    

   ?6        5 

   8       5  '==!6!+?@  A 

("5 " "" 2"  -",.! , /.

,!

" * -.!#"." -", ".  /,.! #,

",".",-.

 !!." 1  -",!  "!.(

 ,,!

 ""  #- * ", (01 +! -     -  !    8  ,9 """  5

,  #"#   +(+(:;3( ( :; 3 8/, ",!.!-!8,9 """5

,*  ,9 """ ,!   "#" ,""

, ," -< 722*  

-"  ,9 ""2""#" "#- 4;A,-""5"722"", 9 " ", B&  ,9 " 

-""  B&   "!*" ", "   ,!

-

!",  , !" -", .!! #,

"," " -."

!

!   /.

 

(# "  " "-

- " " 6" , "#""-"



,"#  -""  ,!/ ",""!"5 -"

" ""#

! C" " ."#!" "( 9 "!" ","  --.,  +  . C/"#: D: C!

D: