Karan Singh v. Dharam Singh
!"# $#%&'&()
*!+!(&(,- .//#00!(" 1#+'2' -!+!3&(,- .#'/($#(" ) 4 5 55
+#'#(") +-6##(&(,-1#+3!7$8%!"#
+"-#!//#00!(" 999 :-#"-#+ +#/+"#+' 0%!0 /!/#+' 3!; <# !00=#$ " '##"-#>2$,3#("?
<#+# #++#$""-#+#/+"#+'+("? :-#"-#+ "-# >2$,3#(" '-20$ <# +#/+"#$ &( "-# $&,#'"? 999 55 +!0 2&" &0#$<;"-#/0!&("&
=!'$&'3&''#$<;"-#"+&!0 %2+" 8&$# >2$,3#(" !($ $#%+## $!"#$ @ A
' #8#( "-# !//#!0 /+# #++#$ !,!&('" "-# '!&$ $#%+## !&0#$ !($ =!' $&'3&''#$8&$#>2$,3#("$!"#$ B
7/0!&("&
&'<# +# "-&'%2+"8&$#"-&'+#,20!+'#%($!//#!0 !+"&#'""-#0&'7 -#+#&(!
"#+7=20$<#+# #++#$"<;"-#&++&,&(!0/'&"&('&( "-#'2&"
+&# 0;7&(!'2&" &0#$<;"-#/0!&("&
7-#%0!&3#$" <#"-#=(#+&(/''#''&(""-##C"#(" D "-'-!+#&("-# '2&"/+/#+";3#!'2+&(, EA'F2!+#3#"#+'73!+6#$<;0#""#+' !($'-=(&(+#$%02+&("-#'&"#/0!(7!//#($#$ =&"- "-# /0!&(" " =!' 3!&("!&(#$ "-!" /0!&("&
=&"- -&'
<+"-#+'-!$/2+%-!'#$"-#'!&$/+/#+"; +32$-!('( 2/+/!7 ($+!>7 -!0!$7 &'-!( 5!0 '( !3!(7 #"% 8&$# '!0#$##$$!"#$ A @EA 2+'2!(""!32"2!0/!+"&"&(7
," -&' D "- '-!+# &( "-# (+"-#+( '&$# "-# '!&$ /0"7$#/&%"#$<;0#""#+' -#+#=!'!%33(,!0& "-# /!+"&#' '-=( &( "-# /0!( <; 0#""#+' 7 '&"2!"#$ &( <#"=##( "-# /0" "-# /0!&("&
!($ "-# $# #($!(" !+"&#' -!8# <##( 2'&(, "-# '!&$ ,!0& + &(,+#'' !($ #,+#'' " "-#&+ +#'/#%"&8# /+/#+"&#'7 <2" !' $# #($!(" -!$ #(%+!%-#$ 8#+ "-# %33( ,!0&D'"+##" 3!+6#$ <; 0#""#+' 7 "-2'7 "-# '2&" ($# #(%#7&"=!'$#(&#$7&("#+!0&!7"-!""-#-2'# +# #++#$"&(/!+! "-#/0!&("7<#0(,#$"2+!><-!(7 *20$##/ !($ >&"7 '(' !3 -!($ " =!' /0#!$#$ "-!"
-!$ ( %(%#+( "-#+#=&"- 0!&("&
=!' (#&"-#+ "-# =(#+(+&(/''#''&( "-#/0"3!+6#$<;0#""#+' 5&6#=&'#7 -# -!$ ( %(%#+( =&"- "-# /+/#+"; '-=( <; 0#""#+'7!'"-#,!0&'-=(<;'!&$0#""#+'&'"-##C%02'&8# ,!0& "-# $# #($!(" !($ 3#!(" + -&' /+/#+"; !+0&#+7 <+"-#+' "-# /0!&("&
-!$ &("#+ #+#$ &( /''#''&( "-# $# #($!(" 8#+ "-# /+"&(' !($ 7 !' "-#; &("#($#$ " #(%+!%- 2/( ! /!+" "-#+# ' ! +#'20"7 $# #($!(" -!$ &0#$ !( &(>2(%"&( '2&" !,!&('" "-#37 =-&%- =!'$#%+##$8&$#>2$,3#("!($$#%+##$!"#$
B!($ "-##(%+!%-3#("%!2'#$<;"-#3=!'+$#+#$"<#+#38#$
($ (=7/0!&("&
-!$ &0#$ "-#/+#'#(" '2&" !" "-# <#-#'" -&'<+"-#+' ( ! $2# !($ %3/+#-#('&8# %('&$#+!"&( "-# 3!""#+ &( &''2#7!($ "-##8&$#(%# ( +#%+$7<"-"-#%2+"' -!$ %(%2++#("0; %(%02$#$ "-!" &( ! '2&" &0#$ <; "-# $# #($!(" !,!&('" "-# <+"-#+' "-# /0!&("&
7 F2! "-# '2&" 0!($7 ! $#%+## + &(>2(%"&( =!' /!''#$ !,!&('" "-#3 (
B ($7 !' ! +#'20"7 "-#; =#+# +#'"+!&(#$ +3 %!2'&(, !(; &("#+ #+#(%# &( /''#''&( "-# $# #($!(" 8#+ "-# '2&" 0!($ !($ /+"&( !' !0' " +#38# "-# #(%+!%-3#(" %!2'#$ "-#+#&( 0!&("&
-!$ %(%#$#$ &( -&' %+''#C!3&(!"&("-!"7&( !%"7-#-!$%('"+2%"#$!-2'#&(
!&/2+&("-#;#!+ @EA!($=!''#""0#$"-#+#7/'"+#"&+#3#(" +7-#!0'!$3&""#$"-!""-#/+#'#("'2&"=!' &0#$<;-&3( "-# !'6&(, -&' <+"-#+ *20$##/7 "-2'7 "-# /0!&("&
-!$ &(&"&!"#$ ! /+C; 0&"&,!"&( !" "-# <#-#'" -&' <+"-#+'7 "-2,- "-#; "-#3'#08#' -!$ '2
#+#$ ! $#%+## $!"#$
B 8#( "-#+=&'#7 "-# 0!($ /2+%-!'#$ <; "-#
=&"- -&' <+"-#+'7 8&$# '!0# $##$ $!"#$ A @EA7 =!'!>&("/+/#+";!($(%#&(!/+#8&2'0&"&,!"&(7F2!"-# '2&" 0!($7 +&,-"' "-#+ %'-!+#+' -!$ <##( &(!00; $#"#+3&(#$7 /0!&("&
%20$ (" %0!&3 "-# +#0&# /+!;#$ + <; =!; /+#'#("'2&"2+"-#+7/0!&("&
%0!&3#$"-#'2&"0!($!' %33('"+##"("-#<!'&' !'&"#/0!(C 7!//#($#$ =&"-"-#'!0#$##$$!"#$ A @EA7=-#+#&("-#8#($+-!$
G '-=( "-# '"+##" -!8&(, ! $#!$ #($ # #($!(" " -!$ /2+%-!'#$ ! /&#%# 0!($ +3 "-# '!3# 8#($+ ( G @@ ($7!(!(!0;'&' "-#'&"#/0!(C +#8#!0#$ "-!"%33(/!''!,#<# +#"-#/0"' <"-"-#/!+"&#'=!' '-=(&('2"-#+($&+#%"&(!'HI:-#+#!'7"-# '2&"0!($=!'$#/&%"#$"-#+#&(!'H
I 2'"<#%!2'#"-# '&"#/0!(C '-=#$!%33(/!''!,#"=!+$''2"-#+( '&$# "-#/0" "-#/0!&("&
!($"-#$#!$'"+##""=!+$'&"' =#'"#+('&$#7"-#'"+##"=&"-!$#!$#($7("-#=#'"#+('&$#7 %20$ (" <# %0!&3#$ !' ! %33( '"+##"D,!0& ( '-+"7
!&0#$"/+8#-&'%0!&3 5#!+(#$ %2('#0 + "-# !//#00!(" %20$ (" /&(" 2" !' " -= "-# %(%02'&(' "-!" -!$ %(%2++#("0; <##( +#%+$#$ <; <"- "-# %2+"' =#+# #&"-#+ %("+!+; " "-# /'&"&((+#%+$+'2
#+#$ +3!(;3!"#+&!0&00#,!0&"; "-#+!+,23#("=!'!$8!(%#$ ( "-# =!6# "-# /'&"&( !' '#" !<8#7 "-#+# -!+$0; #C&'"' !(; ,+2($7 0#!'" /0!2'&<0# &( 0!=7 " &("#+ #+# =&"-"-#$#%+##<#&(,!''!&0#$F2#'"&( 0!=732%-0#'' !(; '2<'"!("&!0 F2#'"&( 0!=7 !+&'#' + %('&$#+!"&( //#!0<#&(,$#8&$ 3#+&"&'!%%+$&(,0;$&'3&''#$ 8#3<#+ 7
!>!( +2( !00& 2$,#