← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2842/2017dismissed

Surat Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-12-07Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal8 pages

  



!

"

 #"

$%

'

!

& 

( )  * * & + ,,)  * * -"

-

-* **..// 01



'

-* **. !

)

2%3 * $"- !

3 4-

#3  



  

       





 

 

  1, 5671) !

"

  

$ %   ' $%'(    )

 #  &

   *"(  

, . )    1 2(   . ) %

   ' .%'(

 

 

"

   #

  

  *"    #   #  

 -*

*

,/ #,1/    

4 45 34  )

  . )

7

"   ) %  "9

"

(  "  * : $; 30 <

 :  

 4/ 4= 34 <#  .%  < 3=  3, 4= 34 3 =   .% .%   )

"

   $ ,4444449;

 / : $%' = 4 34 -    )

 $ ,,444449;

 !

-) :

  .%   ) 

  



/   

 "

)

  "

    " *"  = 4 34 -

  .%

  

"



 

 > # )

 *

"

< =

 $ 344444449;



8 ? 

"



  .%

 #   )  " 

 

"

;

 

 

 



    



  

 !"## $ 



 

  %            %   

  !"## & 



 

  %          

%  %  !"#'

 ( ) (, .1  .,) > 



@ 

"

;

* (+  *$ ,-  *& .

'  * (/  *0 "#

*12# *3 4+   * (

  * + 3 3 >  



"

      #   

 "  , ,;

56 #* #* 7% 56 # &8

7%9

 % 56 # 8

7%9

7 :  56 #*156 #*3 7%

  

 3 5

 @ 

 



 

"



    #   

 "  , ,;

56 (* 7%9

* - 56 (*$ %9

 6 

 56 (*& 56 (*3 7 %

 56 (* 56 (*$ 7 %

   56 (*& 7 %

   $3  $;

 A@ ;3  "

   #

   "

  $ 3//444449;

#   A@ ;3   64B      " $ ,,444449;



&,1, /9, ,

!1) C



 

"



"

 #   #

% 



) , 3 ? 

 

"



  "

 @  64B   &A@ ;3( #   34B      A@ ;3 , 5 ? 

 

"

  

:

"

"



"

!

"

 *"  

 !"#$

 

 " 

#   , ,  "          #   

#'; 



 ;

-3 && # &"!& %'

3 ;

- -*

* <,5,

* -/ &

* &

/  =1

, * =1 # 

, * 0,//7 ;

55 4 3, 45 34 -  9 /4 )  =344449;

05-44449;

 ;3 ,= 4/ 34 4 -  9 /4 )  4/44449;

304,44449;

 ;5 5,/3 0 45 34 4  9/4 / ) =-44449;

,663,=639;

 ;, 50- 4 4/ 3440  3644449;

344444449;

 -3 && # &"!& %'

$;5 5/,5 3/ 4 34

 8; - 56,5-369;

3/03=669;

 $;, -=/6 34 4 34 8

54444449;

6444449;

 $;6 =, / 3 34  58; 4 -/ / =,9;

3=0=3449;

 $;= -544 3 40 34 /  58;3 34/-/-009;

3,//4= 9;

 $;- =4=- 45 34 68; 5 4-44449;

644//69;

 , 6 A@ ;

A@ ;, 

 



  

 

  

 ? 

 ,/,4 )   /  

   

-46 )     

    54 36 )    A@ ;,

 -4 64 )   A@ ;3

 / 64 )  ? 

"

A@ ;3  



 "

 #

" 

, - 

 

> &A@ $; ( D # 

  



#"

#  

)  A@ $;, #"

< -544  

 "

< 6 

 *  )

>    "

< 6

 )

   #"

< =, / A@ $;5  

 "

< ,5 ,,

 

 "

< ,,

) 





 &3 E(  )

 #"

< =4=- A@ $;6 

 

 "

< 53



 =   

, =

  A@ ;6 

  

"



  *#

   $ 0-5

   4- 4/ 0//  



 0=5 >   

 <

@

 

 

" 

  

 



" 

  

         )

 

, /

 

  A@ !59



  

 "

A@ ;

A@ ;,

 >  

 



 



  )

   

 "





 A@ !,9 

%  )

, 0 >   

    .%  $ ,4444449;

   ) )



" 

)

&,,) > 

   #  = 4 34 -   .%'  

"

 

%)  



#  6 3 

"



          &=5?



3 4-

#3

$"&



%8 <=8/



% > <=8/ -*

* !-

* # - 3- *

-"

-

- 0@-



'

- $D;5-30;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$++< ..

$D;5-5 ;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

+ C>. :A7>

$D;5-53;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

G$+

><

?$

$D;5-55;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

>7 8G$

 $D;5-5,;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$A .+ = $D;5-56;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$

><

?$

/ $D;5-5-;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

7><?:

8G$

I?C $; 55;343

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

>$ ..

?$

$D;5-5=;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$G< 8G$

$D;5-5/;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

>$ ..

?$

$D;5-50;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

7>$A<:A$

><

<:

<$ $D;5-/=;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$ C. <:

<$ $D;5-//;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

 F 8G$ <$ $D;,44,;34 = $G< 8G$

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$D;, ,6;34 =

7><?:

8G$

++A ?D

$F< ?$

= $D;, ,-;34 =

$++< ..

++A ?D

$F< ?$

/ $D;65=5;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

? $8

?$

$D;//;34 /

F ..

$?G

 7><?:

8G$ $!.

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$D;,03;34 / ? $8

?$

++A ?D

$F< ?$

$D;5,0;34 / .>. $ ><%A :A%A A:( $ .$

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$D;5,/;34 / $ % <:A$ <:

?$

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$D;5,=;34 /

 $> ..

<:

?$

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

3, $D; =-6;34 = $

><

<:

?$

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

$D;5-54;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

F ..

$    7><?:

$!.

3- $D;5-,3;34 =

++A ?D

$F< <:

?$

G.+<

><

<:

?$

3 4-

#3 $"&