← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4796/2016allowed

Dilbagh Singh And ORS v. Joginder Kaur And ORS

2018-11-12Mr. Justice Amit Rawal10 pages

    !   "#$ %$&'(')*  + 

',-"./')./")%#/$0( 11$,,")#( 2$0(3(

.')%$04"30")%#/$0( $(1)%$)#(



  

.')%$04"30")%")#/$0 11$,,")#( 2$0(3(

"(5")#4"30")%#/$0( $(1)%$)#( 67 +

"(5")#4"30(')&$%$&$"($%#/03./8(

.')%$04"30")%#/$0( 11$,,")#( 2$0(3(

".#"0')./")%#/$0( $(1)%$)#( *98 :8 ;;;

 

    



 !

"#$!%  &'  

 $ !# "#$ ) *+"

"#$!%



 !

"#$!% ;;;

:8< 8 (

==  

7==  ')=

=

- & 

 

   . 

$$ . 

 /  &

  &



0 . 

$$ . 

  (7 == 7 +== ')=7 + =

1 2 $*$!

"#$!

 3 & 3 4 .

 /  

  &



.

   1 2 $*$!+ "#$!

   "!

. 

 /  

  &

 0 "!

. 

  (

= <

=  7 + =

2 &  &'      14



2 $ !# "#$

*+"

"#$!%

 

  2

 !

"#$!

 &

  4

   2

 !

"#$!



0-

  5





2 $ !# "#$ 5

 





  1

4 2 *# "#$$ 

5

  

 

.

  6# #* "#$$ 74    % 4 4-84   

2

 !

"#$!

.

 -.

  & 



 &   

,

  -   

& &

2 *+"

"#$!



 4  % 4 9 5

  



 1

4 2 $!$ "## 

 4  % 4 9 5

  

 & 

& 9 

 && 84 

&4 

& 



 

-  && 

   



:4   

7 4    

1

4 2 *# "#$$ -

4

 & 74

  # $$ $ !!

-.



 6"# 

7& .

 ;-84  $#* 

 4  & &&

 

 . $ !

  4-'  < & 4 $#* 

  ;&4 4   &4 2 $#!

#$ $$ $ !+

,  "#$$  4

4

 .

   #  $"

    6# #* "#$$ 4

2

 !

"#$!

 4& 

1



4 2 *# "#$$ 



& 

 &   #* #! "##

.

74

 4



84 4  -

, 14



- .

 

 

     &   ,

  

  1

4 2 *# "#$$

 4-84  

.

4  > &

=  4& 



-  





 4  

 &  

& - 14 4-  84



'4  ?    < -    4.

 74

4

 & @

  .

<

7

74 A7 0 $%





?

=





-4 * .  ; 5

; B4

 C 

4,   0 &

=

74  .

. 4  

4 ,   =

 



  .



  &

 = 

&.



.

4 4

   &.

 4 4

.

 .

   4 & 3

=

&.

 4 4

.



 & =

.

.



  &.



 =  .



 6 ! %

#6+ #%

# + #%

"6+ #%

"

+ #%

"$+ #% "! + #%

"!+ #%

"+ #%

"++ #% "* + #%

*#+ #%

+ #%  & 4 $#*(  

 &.

4 

4 = 74 <

- 4 &.

 

-

&.



2-.



.

 

-

= 

.-.



4 &  3  &.

< .

 

-

<

74 4 &.

  

 &

 =   =



$$ $ !!

;

4

,   2 +6*   ";

;

A74

<

;

& '

;



 A7

 

4 <

;

 

; 4

24

;



 @

1.

6"#   

#



7& .

.

$#* 

 -84  4  

     4

 



4-&

-

 4



 4 - 

4& &-  <    

 4  

 $ !+   &  

 

 - 84 44 4 



 .

-&

-4

 

$%

4

4  $ *!



.

&



&

 .

&4 4 4  



&

 D& =  



4

313%> "0%/""0"#/>2( $)#"1"#'"?"40'(/)"")%#/$0( "#$!$% 11%

'4& /")%$0 "0@"(/")% ")#/$02303"/"0"A)")%130(/0"?03(#")%#/$0(<   

8

7 

 

 .

 1

4 2 $!$ "##    3  

4-84   1

4 2 *# "#$$    &'   4

 

  -  4

4-&

&    

 4

. 4  

 74

 &   #* #! "##

  6# #* "#$$

     

& 

 &  1

4 2 *# "#$$

 < &

   4-

"

$ *!



.

:

 &-    4



 .

  74 4 4 &   &4 #$ $$ $ !+

4

&    1

4 2 *# "#$$



 



   1

4 2 $!$ "## =

  4 

   -3





& 4-& 

     4

 & 

.

  6# #* "#$$

 

.

&   

   &  A& 4   &  4

<

 

 4 

$%

4

4  $ *!



?

$%

.



&

4 

84 - 

&&& 



4 

& A7  E= 4-  ?.@ 4 - & -

&& -

84

&

4     

  4   

      &

.

 

    -



  

 3  7  4

   

.







.

4





&& .

- &&&  @  544.



.F 4 %

4



""

 54 >   >

4

:  

'34& ) :  = $ !"

6   

$%  -

?$!

>.

$%  4 4  

4 & 4



4

 

&  

-4 

A7  7 ?.@   7 4

84

4 &     

  4   

      &

.

 

    -



  

 3  7  4

   

.



 >.

$% .

   

4 &

 

+ 4

 4



4 

-4   &4  44-.





4 

 

4

& .

  ' &.



4   &  

 -4

4  4 '4&

.

 &

4

4  

.  &



 44

4  

4   4

4 &  4   



  & 

 

  4

4





4   

 3   

&



4

4



4 



4   -

 

  4  

  &  >4 9 4  

4 <&G  .

 $ 6 

  4

-  H 

4  & 

4-

&



   - &  .

 4-' 4  

4 4 7  

4   

4&

   &

 

4

4   4 &.

  4 4 .

14  &4= 

 

    @ "+ & 84

  -

4-

  4 %

   

  4-' 



 

  84



 4

$%  - & 1

  14  9 



4

$%  

7 4

   & 

-4  "

= 

:   '

:  $ !%

6*   ,4 && G 



4

?

 

&- 4-  $%

"%

4-' 

4&-  14

& &  ,4 &&





.

 4 



4&-   -4

   &   4-  "%  

84

&

4  &

 

.

 7 4

  4&   

 & -

 





84

4 & 4   

  4

 7

4

84  

&- 4-  "%   4&   





-

  .   &4



 

& B4

4

 



&

4 

&     

& .

 I        4 0



4



  4-  $%

  

 7.

 .

&  4

 J  4-  $%

.



&

4 4

  - &&&

4

4  4 -&

-4 4 &

4 &&&   KG

< 

 

&

4  

 

&&&  -&

-4  &&   4 4

 .

%   & 

   4&  

 4 

  &  4-  $% 

  ?.



&

4 L

&&& 



4

&  @ =  4 4&  

    

&  

  

 -    & 

-4   4 

&

4 4  







7 KG   

4-'       .

 4  @

&   '4&  4

 4 . 4 '4& 

F-

4&

B3,("??"2B$(/"$%%>< 6

 :  < - - .

& 

       &. 4& 

4 4  & - .

&&  

& 74

74  4& 3 

 4 4 

 4 -4  4-  4 



  84  44.

   4 

"%

$ *!

 

.

4

4&  

-.

'

& 

3    .



4-  84 4

 4

  

4 &.



 '4&



    1

4 2 *# "#$$

-.





4 .

&

'4&

  1

4 2 $!$ "## 4 

4 .

&

2

 !

"#$!



2 $ !# "#$

*+"

"#$!

& :8     + (3)'#"

<   3;  M;2 <   -

M;2