High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4797/2016dismissed

Gopal Chaudhary v. Inder Kumar And ORS

2018-11-19Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

!"#$%!& !'

(')*"*$%!+, -./ 012342 5 '''0011 6 3 4 73 -2 '''

04 $'

('89"%$%!+, -./ 2 01-2 '''0011 6 3 4 73 -2 '''

04 ! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

. '6: (;2#4 - . '2 (4#4 # 20011 (')*"*$%!+'

. ' 4 (;2#4 . ' < (;2#4 # 20011 ('89"%$%!+'

===== +*,&-(

2 4 211 40 > ;31 (4 001 ;')*"*489"%$%!+

?31>4 1 4'

( ')*"* $%!+ 2 20011@ 44'!@012342 52;> 4 #>2

('89"%$%!+2144'$49'

1(3'!$$%!!24 73 4 .(;2#01#>14;2;>,44/ ; 0 45012342 5 5;2 14 21(;2 44'$49,0011 ('89"%$%!+/1 ;

00 2; 1144%&'%+'$%%* 0 14 ; '4:11'!%AA$8 3 ;*:1* 1# 72> '$$8#72'9)%#34>22 3 611;;12342 541 1 349+'%%1# ; 414B+'%%10 :1;205 !'%%1 5' >420 2 2; #2 > 403 014 3 ;8:1!& 1>;2 0 31;242144314C34 >5 24 1D '8$""$%%$4 04;23 '> #1441 #''#!:1*

1>C34 3 (3 !8'%8'$%%"'E # 2 #''#$+'%9'$%!!#%*'%*'$%!!4!8'%)'$%!!#44 '!42 48'%%#)'%%4$'%%13 222>314 : ;2> 0444#3 44 '! 2;> 4 2 ; 44 $%'%$'$%!94#23#3 34123!$'%9'$%!9' 2;> 1;2> 444 012342 5@44'!00423 3; 34' >11;422; 4!8'%8'$%%">22 01;2144!:1* 1'23C4$%%"

442;2> 0>1104;'2 0

. !#!&#8%%A@42 3!!'%%1>144'

1 300 2 4 # C 4 D@! 273 # D@$ 4(2 # D@9F E1#

D@)E:2 4 4 # D@8(2:373 ; 1 :# D@+ 244 # D@* >73 # D@& 2 # D@"(2 2 (;2.1:#4> ;C0 # D@!% (;2401'! 4>C D@!!4 3;2 443 C'

!C'

&#C'

D"A#C'

D"A@!C'

D"A@"'

22 24#44C 4D@!(5 #D@ ! 2E1#D@$.24 73 ; 1 :#D@9 2 E1#D@)(5 #D@87 1<441'21 4#D@+EC # D@*2 01#D@"(54 F1344012342 52 1 00 4D@&41 3;2 443 C'!C')# C'D+A#C'D"A#C'D"A!C'D"A!8' 31#01 3;2 443 C'

" C'

!+'

20 04 2 4#2 13 44 ; 200 2; 11#3 4 4 34 !$#!&#8%%A@1;>2 B!$G0 3 41 4 444'! 34!%'%%144'$49' 0011452 0 0 244 44# 2 #2>001'

. '6: (;2#1 431 20011@44 '! (')*"*$%!+3 422 13 2314 2 31442 1511; 2; 44$%'%$'$%!9 4544'!2;>,44/>244

'$494253 1 4 4 4 34 3 !%'%%1 4132; ' 1

151405205 8'%%#)'%%4$'%%1# 4 '2 ; 4#1 4314 >22 3 2 ; 4 :>14;

' 0 C'D"A

C0 2 315 3244>22>34 ;4#3402 0 2012 14'2011442 ;23>2 ; 4205 !'%%1>;@413 23 2 4 3'32 3 #24 23142 4 5 !'%%1#>22>042 C3 ;1; 44%&'%+'$%%*'

>C442 2 44 ; 44%&'%+'$%%*24 4 2C32 14444!8'%8'$%%" 014 3 ;!:1* 1'

2 2 421 431 20 #00 42 00 : 4 2 > 2 2 4 2 3 21 431 20011@44' ;20 >214 3 ;8:1!&

1 > 34 ?3 2 4 2 ; >2 44'$49'205 !!'%%1# 44 4#4 #20 42 3;22 52 ;>'

0 22C0 21 20 >2;;2 'D@"(54 F134 @C 4 4 434 @ H

2 3 #23 1>4 442 4 2C0 C 45201'2 1 3 242 0341>223?3; >22 > 443 ;232; 44%&'%+'$%%*'2 3 1>5 3142 13<541 5' 20 32 3 >2 ?3523 4 4 44'! (')*"*$%!+ 34 3!%'%%1 4 42 4132; 44$%'%$'$%!9'

2 4 #3134>22 3 4;# 321511;15 0 5'; 34 43# 321 1 531?3 1>' 31152001 4 4'

012-3 +*,&

145 ()67'

,58549:

<4;

,585 82"

<4;