High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/29916/2019dismissed

Sanjay Garg And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2019-11-19Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary,Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal7 pages

!"#"$%&%'( !" " # #" $%&' "( !" &")" ) $#*! !" " # #" $%&' "( !" &")" ) * $# +,- !" " # #" $%&' "( !" &")" ( +,

- - +,

-- , "" . /,0# "#/12 "3# ! 4 56# /12 "

!")" # #" & "!+!" /6/ ( #

/4,# 6 /6/

( #

& "!+!" /12 "(778#

/4,# 6 /12 "(778#

99999 - ,.

:!# ,-" !66#)""-" #"3# )" # # 2--;," #2 63"#161" !""#:!"2 " *"#"< 2 "-

# 6" !"$ "( !" &")" =( " 7, #6 7 ,2 ," 8"1"6)-" ) #! >(778?#,"1" #"-" "@

#1# #))6#2 #- !"""6),*6#2,2 # )6 # ,-*" 7, #6 % " # !" " ( 7, #6 % "

+,6# 3 6 ) !" 1" #"-" :!" )" # #"))6#")6 # !"##, #6" " !"6 " "2"#) ))6#2 #3

:!"6 "3"< "" A

1#",*";," 1" #"-" %=,2 #32,2 " @

:!")" # #"?*# ;- )6 3!#2! !"""1")#2"& B=)";- :!"

-" !"!#!" *#&C B=)";- &

B=)";- ")"2 #1"6 :!"*# 3 22") " (778 #," 6" " "

#-# !" )" # #" *, !" "

"2 # !"# *# 7 !" # 6" " # 3-" #" ! !#!" *#66#D"#, #6)6 # 7, #6% "

+,6# !*"""

"2 " ! !"-"3,6*" ""66 -" !,!"!1" #"-" E"""#2,"6 !")" # #"!,*-# " ! )6 # - 7, #6 % " 3"" !" ,* "2 - " 1" #"-" " @

/,2 # !"6 # 66 !" !" #, #6 " " !1" *"" 2#-" *, !" ))6#2 )6 # 7, #6 % "

+,6# !1"*""#2#-# "# :!"(778*"#

# ,-" 6# "

2,6 !1" #6" , !" ))6#2 7, #6% "

+,6# #"" " -" /) - ! # # ,*-# " ! !" *# ,*-# " * !" )" # #" 3"" 6- &

B=)";- !#!" ! !"""1")#2" !"" "2 # !"*#))" *"-6#"(" !, ) ! !""

"2 # !" !#!" *# !")" # #"*";,!"(778*"#"2 " #," 6" " 66 -" !" )" # #" ! *"" " # !" 2" ))6#2 !" #, #6 " " (" 6 )62" "6#2" ,) 8#1##5"2! ,-" "

)"#

@ # 6"/!#!0#$(778 !" / ! 3# " "-" ! *"" #6" *"!6 !" (778 *" !"",) 6"" 2,"6 ")" ,*-# ! 6 !,!

#6" 1" #"-" 3 #," # ")"2 )6 # 1#, #, #6 " " ") " ,2 # 3 2,2 " # ")"2 "2! #, #6 " " !"2" # # 2 ,66 #2"2 ,*-# ! 66,2 # 4)62" !"-" ! !"))6#2 7, #6% "

+,6# !1"*""#2#-# "# / *6"! *""#1"### !"! 3# " "-" ##2 # !" "3!#2!,2 #3""!"6# !"#"" #, #6" "7 # , !" " ! !" ,2 # 7, #6 % " +,6# 3 2#-"*"2," !")#2"" 2!"# !"%=,2 #3""-,2!63" ! !" " 2!" # -,6 ,2 # 2,2 " "6#" / 2! ! *"""<"/"<,"&=3# ! !"! 3# " "-" !3# !" #""2" *" 3"" !" )"" *# !" *# "2"#1" # !" -,6 ,2 # 22# 3!#2!

!" #""2" # !" *# "

C -))<#- "6 &AAB=)";- & B=)";- 7 !" *# ! *"" 22") " !" (778 3,6 !1" ,"" ,* #6 6 !, #6"),*6#2# "" # 3"2#" "

"2 !"*# "2"#1" # 7, #6 % "

+,6# 7 # , !" ," ! -"" ,*-## !"!#!" *#" 26 !")"3# ! #! !"*#- *"22"66""

"2 " "3! "1"&"6#2" # )62" ,) ( '* 8"1"6)-" /, !# !" $ 2!#7 ,2 ,"8"1"6)"E AC C :!" -# " 2 " ! !" %=,2 # 3 !"6 @

! !")" # #"3"" !"!#!" *#" :!"" " 1#" 2--,#2 # "

!" )" # #" 3"" #-" ! !"#*#!*"""

"2 " ! !")6 3,6*"), ,2 # 6 " " :!" 1"-" *"!6 (778 ! !" -,6 ,2 # !"6 "6#" ! " 2!" !#!" )#2" ! *"" 2 1" "* !")" # #"'" !"2#2,- 2" 2# *"# ! !"2 #(778#"

"2 # !"!#!" *# !")" # #" 3#66"6*"#*# -6#"F /22# , !"3"## !"" #1"7 #*"

21#6 ! !"!#!" *#"" " 26 !"3# !#! #,2" 66 -" :!# # *"2," *# # " 3!#2!# ,* "2 22") 2" "

"2 # * !" , !# #1# # !" *# 5"" 22") 2"*# !""#226,"2 2 *" 3"" !") #" *#"# " # 6" ""4#,2"6" "66 -" - "#! 7 !"2"2!#7 ,2 ,"8"1"6)",) !",)"-", !"6 ! ,# # # , "* !"!#!" *#"

"26 # ! !"!,6*"#,"6" "66 -" 3!"6 *" -# #*6"*" !""# ! 226,"2 2 ! 2-"# *"# !"-4# !"!#!" *#:!"*"1 # !",)"-", ""),2"*"63.= > C7 #" 6"63 ! !"!#!" *#"!1" " #! !1" !",2 #226,"#!#1,:!" 1"-" # , !# 2,6 16#6 " # )3" 22") "

"2 !" !#!" *# # !" # "" ),*6#2 "1"," " " !" 2#"")## ! !""3#! 2;,#"1" " #! 22," # 1, !" )6# # -""6 *"2," !# *# -, 3!#!" !")# " G !"*#-, / )"&",6 # !"&",6 #

A@ 66 -" 6" "! *"#,"22") 2" !"*#* !"!#"/-## 3# !# !"" !",22",6*#"! ")# !"

G !"*#-, 7 !"# 2"66 -" 6" "!"1" *""#," !")" # #")"&",6 # #1#"3= 22") 2" !" *# :!, !"" 3 226," 2 2 &",6 # !"&",6 #

A@#"< 2 "!"",". 6"6""6*,#6#* ,2 #= 7 !" 2" 6" 6"" * ,2 # !" )#2"B)"-#,- *" 2!" !66 *" ,2! ""1" )#2"B)"-#,- - *" " "-#" 4# # 2#" # !"1#,2 ##2 "#,*=",6 # &",6 #C !#!"-, " "-#"",6 *###)",2 # )"2" !"!#!" *#!66*")# !") * !" !#!" *#" # 2! * -" "- # !" -" )"2##" # ,*=",6 # &",6 # :!" ,22",6 *#" !66 *" #," 66 -" 6" " # I- >? >=77?* "# "") !" )"2" !"*#22") " !66*") *6"* !",22",6*#" # !"-"##2 " 3# !# !# !" " 66 -" 6" " 21" # 22") 2" !"*#* !"!#"/-## J#6#3!#2! !"

)" 2" -, 6" ")# " !66 "# " !"

/, !# !",22",6*#"!66!1"26#- !"6 *,#6#,2 #" :!" ) -" *62" !" )#2"B)"-#,- " # "" 2!"*6" !""21" # "" !66*"# !"-" -")1#"#,*=",6 # A&",6 # C:!"""6 "-2# # !",2 #!66*" ,2! - *" -" * !" !#" /-## - #-" -",2" !"),*6#2*"",2 # !") K 7 1#"3 !" *1" " 6" )1## 63 3" !1" !"# # # !6# ! !" ,-" # /!#! 0# ,) # ))6#2*6"# !")"" 2":!##-"*"2," !"2 " # 6""2,"6 !"(778 ! !")" # !""-" #"

,-" !*"" "* !",)"-", #E#6"* !" (778 ! *"" 2 1" " * 6"" "# 2,"6 !" )" # #" :!" "

"2 # !" *# 7, #6 % " +,6# ! *"" #2 #6 "<)6#"* (778* ,*-# # ! !"-,6 ,2 # !"6 "6#" ! " 2!" -,2! !#!" )#2" / ,2 # # 2,2 """ #"1","# !"2-)" " , !# ! 2-" 226,# ! 22") 2" !"!#!" *#3,62," 6"1","

# #16#""

"2 # !"!#!" *#,6" # 2 *" !3 ! !" "2## # -6 #" # - #1 " * !" "< ", 2#" # ,2! 66" # ! *"" -" * !" )" # #" '" !" 2#2,- 2" !" ,*-## 6"" "# 2,"6 !")" # #" ! !"(778!2 "#!#!!"

A *# -" !"))6#2 7, #6% " +,6#" 22"" -"# "

"2 # :!"3# )" # #"22#6

#-#" - , &-"")#! !" !")"4#B"" L"B !" !"&") *6" L"B