High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4820/2016dismissed

Ludhiana Guru Arjan Dev Co-Operative House Building Society Ltd v. Ludhiana Improvement Trust Ludhiana And ANR

2017-05-09Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul14 pages

!"!#

$ !%

&%! $'$ (( )) % *# !

* $$ %$ ( !

" !#

""""

#+ *+,%-,. /

+, (( )) """"

$ #+0 +, (() 1 +% #

2 0+ "

)-, (( ) +, + , (() .4 ))

2 0+ "

)-, (( )

$, (( ))"()

, , (+ -1)+%

(( )-, 61 -4

+ 78( 90 ) +

)+ - .1 ,.5, + 90, (( )

90, + ( "

"$+1-, 61 -4

7( 90) + /) - :

1 +/ ;.

1 ,.5

( :4 -, + 90, 1

4 ;

&+ )0 ., ()

( +/ %

0+ - +

1 +, #169

( +/ %

.8:, + + ++ <()

0<;, 1

+( +4 61 .+ +- , + ( "

=$+1:, + + ++ <

"$+1<;

4)) -.) -. ))-.+ ++- 4, - / + , (

27 +

1 *

)$ 5 >.#+"

.1 ,.

+4-(+

7 + , 4

)$ 5 >.

#+". 1 ,. 0 , + ( + +

0. , + , , ()

0#+0 +,) 9 4

+4 +061

+ -,

"$+1 )) , + 4-() ( +"

0 ( + 82 , + ( +, ()., ()

(1+ , ) 4 1+- ? @1+ 0+ 1 ))-

.$ ,) + 1 , 88 + .,

)

05 @1+ 90,

"$+1

, / ) (4

, 4 A 5<*

)$ 5 >.#+" % , 4 < $, ()

0 , ,)) - , @1

+ , -, 1+9050

5+( ., 5 / +. 1+-, ( 0

, 5+( ., 4 +5 4(+ 4 90,

"$+1. 1) ((+ /)

, % / +4

#169.5, + 90,

"$+1, -+ > 4(, )

0 , >

7B B

05+ @1 5, +5, 5+(

-)0.

, ()

05, + 5, 5+( ,

"?"

/ +4

#169 1 82 > 4(-, )

0 , >

7B B ( +, + ( 90,

"$+1.)), 9

4 49 +

0 ?149 +.5 + 9

90 )) - () 5,)

- . , ) )) , ()

0 >

, )4

> 4( ., .+ +/ (+ ,))9 ,+- 4, ()

0, 0 +2?.,

"$+1 , )) + ) ()

4 *

)$ 5 >.#+"% , 4 1

, > 4(

) , + 4-4 49 +5 + 9

) + - $, ()

0 4 / +) + (+

+ , + 4-)) 4

() .91,

"$+1 ))0"

))

, 4 + 1 ,, ()

0, +/ 1 % 2

, #169$ 54(+ / 4 . 72.

91 ( . )) 4 54 .

-, ()

)

/)1&1 + )-

, 1.,

"$+1)) 7 ()

05,(+ 4 )) + 4-() ) +- $, + +. ,1+

"$+1.

, ()

05, + 5, 1&1,

"$+1

1) )), (+ 4

)) 4

() . ( / +) + (+ . 5, , , + , ()

0 , +5+( 9

+ ,-, 1+$, -, 1+ +

"$+1

, + (+

5, 5 4 ,.91,

"$+1

"7"

()

0 ) , +5+( C# ?7

8 $, 5+ ( 5 (

8 5,

9 +/ ,, 196 4 +

, 5+ 9

+4 90, -, 1+

/ @1 )0.

, ()

05 + A+ 4 09

+ , /) 1+ $, + +. , ()

0 +/ ) -) 1( ,

"$+11 +% 2

, $ 54(+ / 4 $+1 .

+)) 4

+ 4-()

+ 5+ )) 4 4 49 + ( +,

82 , + &1 ( + (

"$+1 ) )) , + 4-() ()

0 ., 15 ! .,

"$+1(( + 5+ 4 A-(+ )4+0

+1 .

)

1 . 1

.()

, / + , () ( + )5. /) 1 + % 2

, #169 $ 5 4(+ / 4 $+1 .,9 +/ , 19++ 90 )4 $, ()

0 , + 5, , ) @1 4 1+- 27 + . 5, , , +5 5

( 901 ,4(+ / 4 $+1 , ,9 A (+ +/

+(+4+0 ,

)*9)0

, 1, 9 + )0, + +., , 9 )5,

4 +% , 15 49) ., 4 5)9)

9 4 $, ()

0, ))0 )

,5 5 +

4 1+-?8D)2=*+) :??@1+ 0+ ;))- 5

:1 ,;. )

5 +

, +) 4 1+-&"&"7&:28?7@1+ 0+ ; ))- $+ &1++ 1

D,+ 787:&"8&"&; D,+ =7 :&"&"&; + , (-

8+ -+ -, ) @1 ., 41

4 1+-&"&"& 1

D,+ =71 ))- &1+ 5 )) 4, 4

5 +,(

,) 5+ ++ , 4

6%-,

+6%-,%4)+)0.41

, +) 4 1+-&"8&"

& 1

D,+ 787

))- &1++ :1 ,; 5 )

)) 4 , 4

()

0 , 4 5 + ++ , 4

&,-5 D1+ , 50. , ()

0+ 4 5 +

4 1+-??@1+ 0+

4 1+-?88@1+ 0+ )) - , 1( + > 4( ., ()

05 ) > 4(

, >

7B 1

4 1+-??@1+ 0+ 1

4 1+-?88@1+ 0+ &15,) 4A- 4+ (+ . , ()

0 / 5, 4 $+1

),)+ 0- )) +

8@1+ 0+ 4,

"+1)) -)4 +5, , > , ( +49) +

7B.5, ,5 9 A 90, ()

0/ 5

, > 4( 82 + , + (

144

, (+ ., + + -+ -,

"8"

) @1 5 , , 4 ,

, $+1 ,, 9 / + ++ 6%-,) - )) () ?" E

??8" E#

4(+ D,+ 787

))- &1++ :1 ,; , 50. , ()

0. 90 4+ (+ .,)+ 0- )) > + 4,

"$+1.5, + +/ +-, )49 A, (

, > + 4, ()

0 )9) , "

/ +, > +

"$+1!4 +.

5 194 , (0

+ 5 1(() ,

"$+1.1 ,, ++

, 4 , 0 + 2?. ,

"$+1 / 4 4 ?82?

)) = > 4( 2() / 4 4 27. , +?7 ()

05 + > 4( $, +) 1+/ 61 -4

+ 7 ,, ) ,, ()

05 +-))0 5 +

?8@1+ 0+ . 1

5, ,.28?7@1+ 0+

55+ -)0+ ++ , 4

6%-, &,-5D1+ -5, 4, ()

, 1.5, ,5

/ 1+

0$, (( )(+ ++ 906%-,5)

4 $,1., ()

05, ) 5 +

?8@1+ 0+ 5, ) ) 5+ -)0 + ++ , 4

6%-, &,-5D1+( + ., ()

05 ) ?@1+ 0+

) 91, 0,/ 9 )) () .4 1+-2@1+

$, ()

0, +) + 15, ,5

4 5, +5 90 , ()

, 1+ 90 ,

"$+1,, 05)) ) +, 9) )4

-)0.

1+4 + () 5 + 1 , 4$,1.

)08() 5 + ))

0-?4 49 + ))() 5 + 0 9 ))

-)0., +) 1+.

/ 61 -4

+ 7.

, 1

()

0 --+ / -,

+ 61 -4

7.,

"$+1 (( )9

+ , 5 + (( )) 1+$, (( )5

( 90, 5 +(( ))

1+/ 61 -4

+ 78 , 61 -4

+ 7( 90, +) 1+5+ / + C,) + / +-, 61 -4

, +) 1+., 5 + (( )) 1+ , , ) , 4 )0. , ()

5 +

4 1+-?@1+ 0+ 1 ))-

, 4 5 @1+ 90 ,

"$+1

/ ) (4 , 4 A 5<*

)$ 5 >.#+"< 5

1+, +, ) ,,

"$+1,/ 9+ )09 , + , 9

># + >#?$, + ) / ( +

># #?+ 1 +"

F > +

( 5 + ++ 9019"

% 8

, #169$ 54(+ / 4 )) , + ( 5 + 9)-,4,9 ,) , / +4

"2"

#169() -+ > 4( 1+1+6 /

( +/ 1-&1) -%

0 4, *

) $ 5 > % , 4 #+"

, 4(+ / 4 $+1 1 ,. ,

)) 5- +4G ;

$,, )0 1

, (+ ( "

( +/ 1- ) 05))

+4(+

/ +)))0 1

, , 4 5 / +.5,) +4-, / +)))0

+ 5 1) 9 4 + , + @1+ 4

( +/

0 + ( 9) 9;

$, / ) (4 ,+- 5))9 ( 90,

0 , +1 , 9

+ > 90, +1 ++ 190, 4(+ / 4 $+1

;

$,1)H , + > 4( / 1+

( +/

05))9 , > , ) 1)H , / +)) , 4 3 + .

, ) )

+ + . (+A , + (1+( 5 1) 9 , 4 > ) / +)) , 4 @1 )0., + 1 +() 5 1) 9 9 17B B

, + + > 4(

;

$, > 4( 5))9 + (

1-%

, / 1)4 49 +5))9 -/ 1 +A-,, 05)) + +.)

+ , +5 ) ()

+( +

0 + 4 + , () 5))9 -/ / 1) 4 49 +I %"

& F%,+%1+6%-,.% + +0.1+1+6 / "

( +/ 1 &1) -%

0,+ @1 ,,

0, 5, +5 , <9) -, 1+ 1 ,.

, 0 9 ) -/ > 4( )A , +

4(+ / 4 $+1.1 ,.,+ / +5, ,+ +

4 5, +5%

0,+

? @1+ 0+ , ? 4 49 + + -+ 78 (+

+ , 4 -

$+1( + +

, #+

"" ;

+ 44

, / +4 ,,

09 ) -/ > 4( )A , +

$+1( , +,,

5, + )+ 0 > 4( . , 0 9 )) = 1() ( + , + 0 , +

+ , , (+

+ +

, () 9 + / + I $, 5 +(( )) 1+.5,)

(-, (( )

"$+1./ 61 -4

+ 78.

- , 61 -4

+ 7( 90, +) 1+. 9 +/ 1 +"

F ( + , 4

C /+ %-,.

+ + D1- ., " >4 ., ) )

05?@1+ 0+ ) 1)

J7B

05 ) @1+ 0+ ) 1)

05 )

?@1+ 0+ 4 )0.

0))

) 2@1+ 0+ 5, ,, )) 9 5 7B B +, @1

90, 1 , 4(+ / 4 $+1. , + ( "

()

0, + + 5, , (+ ( +0$, + ( "()

1+, + ) , 50) + + , )

4 1+- 27 + 1 *

) $ 5

> #+"C, , (( )),/ @1+

, ) ., 0,/ / +0+-, 1 , (+ ( +0 +

(

, (+ ( +0 ( + +1)

61 9 -+ + +, (( ))

14 ,9 (+

+(+ / , ,, + ( "()

05 )

)+ ,9 1-,90 , + ( "()

0+ -+ -,

14 +1 +A-,9 (+

(+ / , ) 90 , + ( "()

+ (

,, (( ))5 )) , () ,4 49 +

0$, +

1 +A-,+ -+ 4 9 1

, (( ))

+ )) - , () ( ))0 5, , + ,- , "

%""2=7? 82 + + 8 I --+ / -,

+ 61 -4

78., ()

0:(( )), + ;, , (+

-1)+% (( ) + 1 )

+ , (( )) , +-1 , , -4

+ ( 90, 5 +(( )) 1++ / +- , + 61 -4

+ ( 90, +) 1+- )5 $, 5 +(( )) 1+,- , +) +, /)1 90, (( ))"

055, +5 , 1+

, + ( "

=$+1,, 9)

1) 9 ) + .91, 4 5

.5, ,) )-

(+ 1 , 1+, ++-1 ,, ()

5 +

?@1+ 0+ .91, (( ))"()

05 )) )02? 1

?@1+ 0+ B > 4(

. , + 4-+

@1+ 0+ -/ , (( ))"

0. )45,+ ( , +9 4 49 + 1) ) 9 $, + --/ 90, 5 +(( ))

1+,, (( ))"

0, (+

14 , 5 ) B

5, ))0 ++ 31+, +.)

5+ -)0, ) 90 , 5 + (( )) 1+ ,

14 1 +A-,(+ / , ) , 5,, $+15 )) () , 4 49 +

(( ))"

0 %1 , + - 9 )1 )0-, )5 1+-, ( 0

,(( ).) + 1 )

+, (( )), (() *"82" ".1 +!+ 7

1) + 5, % # . () + , + ) += + ?27

?: >1+ #" #"7;9050

) / ,+ ++ ) +: >1+ #"7;/ 5, ,, "

( +/ 1 &1) - %

0 (( ))"

0 5 A + -+ - )) 4

() , 9

) + ?.5, + , $+1, 4 -/ B+

)) +

, ,(

()

( +/ 1 &1) - %

/ 72 ,+-1

14 + +0

+(+ ( +

14 5 + (

, + ( "$+1.

, +

+ ., (( ))"

0 9 , 41 + $ , 0 +8 )0

,/ , + ) + 1 )

+, (( )) $, (+ )4 (+ 90 , (( ))"

()

0, 1.+ ) ,,

(1+ , 4 1+-?@1+ 0+ 88 $, ) 5 @1+ 90 , + ( "

=$+1

+ ,

/ ) (4 , 4 A 5F*

)$ 5 >.#+"% , 4 I $, @1 5 ,)) - 90, (( ))"

+ , -, 1+,+ 1-,5+( 1+-, ( 0

, 5+ ( ., 4 +5 4(+ 4 9 5 , (( ))"

0 + ( "

.5, + 90,

-+ > 4( , ) , (( ))"

0 , >

7B B

-)0., 5+( 55, +590, (( ))"

0 51 90, % / +4

#169 82 > 4(-, )

, (( ))"

0 , >

7B B $, +-14 + 90) + 1 )

+, (( )) ,, ()

0 ) - , > 4(

) )) ,

4 1+-?@1+ 0+ 7B.5, + ,

$+1,/ 5

, :

>#; + :

>#?;.

, + 1 +() 5 1) 9 9 17B B

, + + > 4( 90$+1 )1 :

;

>#;+ (+

1 +"

;

$,1)H , + > 4( / 1+

( +/

05))9 , > ,

"?"

) 1)H , / +)) , 4 3 + .

, ) )

+ + . (+A , + (1+( 5 1) 9 , 4 > ) / +)) , 4 @1 )0., + 1 +() 5 1) 9 9 17B B

, + + > 4( I $,1. , ( +1)

+ >+

># ) +)0 (+ / ,, + 1 +() 5 1) 9 9 17B B

+ + > 4( $, +

+ ., () + 90, (( ))"

0, )0B+ 9 > 4( . 9

( C"/+ %-,. + + D1- . , " >4 , ,, ))

05?@1+ 0+ ) 1)

J7B

0 )

@1+ 0+ ) 1)

0 ) ?@1+ 0+ 4 )0.,

0 ,)+ 09 )) 2@1+ 0+

5, ,+-- 9 5 7B B + , @1

, ) 90 ,

"$+1., ()

0, + + 5,, (+ ( +0$, ()

0, 1+, + ) , 0) + + , ) 4 1+-27 + 1 *

) $ 5 > #+"C, ,

"$+1, @1+ ) ., 0,/ / +0+-, 1 , (+ ( +0 61 9 -+ + +,

"$+1 + -+ , (+0 +

, (( ))"

04 ,+ 1-, *"82" "

+ () - + >1+ #" #"7

+ .5, + / >1+ #"7.,

"$+1,

"7"

4 -/ B+

)) +

., 4 9

( . 1 , / , 1) ,/ 9 9+ 1-,9

+ , 1+9 ) 5 ( , ,, ) +

?.(1+( + 9 (+

9050

) / .

5)+ 0 > .91 1 ,

+5 + 4 9+- ,) + 9+- ,

1+9 ) 5

-)0., (() *"82" " 4 , +( +-1 19)@1

)5+ , (+ + -1)+ (( ) /-A 1(( + 4,

14 :

>#;5, + ,9 9), ,, (( ))"

0,)+ 09 )) 9 17B B., 1+

0)) -)0 , 61 -4

+ 78( 90, 5 + (( )) 1+

-)0., (( ) 90, (( ))"

0 4 !#

6 / C, , +( A-=+ K ' =

C, , ++ ( +9) K ' =