High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4822/2016dismissed

Rajinder Pal Singh @ Pappu v. Sukhjeet Kaur And ORS.

2018-05-01Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan6 pages

!"#$#%&'&()*

!-&(./!-&!' !001 00#--!("

2#,'1'

13/+##"4!1,!($"/#,'

#'0($#("'

) 56 4 6

,#'#(")7 ,2&3!'!/-8#(&,$9%!"#8:&"/8 '!0(##"4!1,8$9%!"#8 ,!00#--!(" ,6&$/18$9%!"#8 ,,#'0($#("' ;/#"/#,"/# #0,"#,'-%!-(#:'0!0#,<!=>#!--:#$" '##"/#+1$.<#("?

>#,##,,#$""/# #0,"#,,(" @ ;/#"/#,"/#+1$.<#("'/1-$>#,#0,"#$&("/#$&.#'"? 77 77 6 <01.(#$&(,#.1-!,'#%($!00#!-&'+1$.<#("$!"#$A 0!''#$>=-#!,(#$$$&"&(!-#''&('1$.#8 !"&!-!8!&,<&(.+1$.<#("

!($$#%,##$!"#$ @80!''#$>=-#!,(#$$$&"&(!-&9&-1$.#

#(&,&9&'&( 8 !"&!-!89&$#:/&%/'1&"0-!&("&':!'$#%,##$!.!&('" $##($!(" !-&(./!-&!' !001 -!&("&':#,#/#-$#("&"-#$" ,#%9#,= 7,<$##($!(" !-&(./!-&!' !001 (!%%1("$!<!.#'$1#"<1,$#,1,+&"&(./!-(.:&"/&("#,#'"!" "/#,!"# 0#,%#("0#,!((1<,<"/#$!"#&('"&"1"&('1&""&--$!"# $#%,## -!&("&':#,#!-'/#-$#("&"-#$,1"1,#&("#,#'"!""/#,!"#

0#,%#("0#,!((1<("/#'!&$!<1(" 7,< !-

77 &(./!-&!' !001 $##($!(" ,&#!%"'"/#%!'#:/&%/!,#,#B1&,#$">#("&%#$, 01,0'#$&'0'!-"/&'!00#!-!,#"/!"(*@*8!"!>1")@ 1,+&"&(./ '&(%#$#%#!'#$ !-.(:&"/#+!&(./'(!,!"!&(./

!-'$#%#!'#$ :!' !>1"" .&(!"!&#,!>#!,&(.,#.&'",!"&(

777 80!,3#$&(,("6!<>!!3#,=!($:!'".":!,$' ,!/< 41<!,& '/,!<8 >!%3'&$# $& --#.#8 !"&!-!8 $##($!("

!+&($#, !- &(./ !-&!' !001 %!<# &( ! :/&"# !,1"& %!, >#!,&(. ,#.&'",!"&( 77 7*,<>#/&($#:!'!,<#$:&"/>,# .1(#'"00#$/&'%!,&(,("9#/&%-#1,+&"&(./!($&,#$": '/"'10(1,+&"&(./:/&%//&"/&<(#!,"/#,&./"'&$#(#%3!($"/##!, #+!&(./%!<#1"%!,!($,!(":!,$'>!%3'&$###($!(""/#(&,#$ !'/"(#+!&(./:/&%//&"/&<(/&'>!%3!($/##--$:( /# %%1,,#(%#:!':&"(#''#$>= !(>&,&(./84!,!<+&"&(./!($!,&($#, &(./:/,!&'#$!-!,< !-&(./-#$!:!=,< "/#'0" 1,+&" &(./ :!' "!3#( " !+&($#,! '0&"!-8 !"&!-!8 :/#,# /# :!'

$#%-!,#$>,1./"$#!$#+!&(./:!'!-'"!3#("'!&$/'0&"!-8>1"/# '1%%1<>#$"&(+1,&#' -!&("&'%-!&<"/!"$#%#!'#$1,+&"&(./:!' /1'>!($0-!&("&!($!"/#,<&(,0-!&("&'!($@!($'( $##($!(" 1,+&"&(./:!'@*=#!,'!.#!($:!'/!9&(.! -1,&'/&(.!,<&(.!':#--!'>1'&(#''%<<&''&(!.#("1($#,"/#(!<# !($'"=-# '1,+&"&(.//!($&(./>#&(.0!,"(#,#:!',#.1-!, &(%<#"!C!''#''##!($#!,(&(. '*8 70#,<("/#:!''0#($&(.

'@8 70#,<("/(0-!&("&' (!%%1("<1,$#,1,+&"&(./8 0-!&("&''1#,#$-''""/#"1(# '*88 7,:/&%/"/#=%-!&< $!<!.#'

7@7 ("/#:,&""#('"!"#<#("8$##($!("$#(&#$"/!9#<1,$#,#$ 1,+&"&(./!($#+!&(./ /#&(%<#!($+>$#%#!'#$:!'!-' $#(&#$ !,"&#':#("(",&!-(--:&(.&''1#')7 ;/#"/#,"/#0-!&("&'!,##("&"-#$"$!<!.#'(!%%1(""/# $#!"/1,+&"&(./%!1'#$>="/#$##($!("8&'8":/!"!<1("?

;/#"/#,'1&"&(0,#'#(",<&'("<!&("!&(!>-#? @ ;/#"/#,"/#'1&"&'>!$,<&'+&($#,%!1'#!%"&(? ;/#"/#,"/#'1&"&':&"/&("&<#?

#-&# ,&!-1,"/#-$"/!"$#%#!'#$1,+&"&(./:!'<1,$#,#$>=

!-&(./!-&!' !001 $##($!(" "%('&$#,#$"/#&(%<#"!C ,#"1,('$#%#!'#$!($!:!,$#$%<0#('!"&(""/#"1(# '88 7 ("/# !00#!-8-:#,!00#--!"#1,"/#-$"/!"$#%#!'#$:!' /!9&(.>1'&(#''&(%<# ' 70#,!((1<!($ 70#, !((1<!'!.,&%1-"1,#&(%<#/#,#,#8&":!'/#-$"/!"$#%#!'#$<1'"># #!,(&(. ' 8 7 0#, <("/ &' !((1!- &(%<# :!' %!-%1-!"#$ !" '88 71-"&0-&#,*:!'!00-&#$3##0&(.&(9&#:"/#!.# $#%#!'#$:/&''"!"#$">#@*=#!,' /#,#,#8:/&-#!00-=&(."/# !1"/,&"=

8 D D8 &" :!' /#-$ "/!" :&# &' #("&"-#$ "

'88 7(!%%1("-''%(',"&1<!($%/&-$,#(!,##("&"-#$"

'88 7 ( !%%1(" -'' -9# !($ !#%"&( %%,$&(.-=8 %<0#('!"&(:!'%!-%1-!"#$!" 7 /!9#/#!,$"/#-#!,(#$%1('#-',0!,"&#'!($/!9#!-' %!,#1--=.(#"/,1./"/#&-# #,#"/&'1,"8&"/!'>##(9#/#<#("-=!,.1#$(>#/!-

77 !00#--!(""/!"1,"'>#-:/!9#.,!9#-=#,,#$&(&(%-1$&(.!.,&%1-"1,# &(%<#$#%#!'#$&(""!-&(%<#/#,#,#8&($&(.'!,#0#,9#,'#!($ %!(>#&("#,#,#$&(,#.1-!,'#%($!00#!-"/!'>##(1,"/#,!,.1#$"/!"!' /#-$ ,#%#("-= &(

8 &9&- *"/!"&("/#<!""#, ,#.1-!,'#%($!00#!-8"/&'1,"&'.9#,(#$>=#%"&( 1(+!>1,"'

%"8D8:/&%/&'<,#:&$#,"/!(#%"&( 8D/#,#,#8&"

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

%#$(&-#:#9#,80#,1'!-&-#'/:'"/!" 0-!&("&13/+##"4!1,/!$!00#!,#$!-(.:&"/,&.&(!-&(%<#"!C,#"1,(' !($ 0,$1%#$ 0/"%0&#' "/#,# :/&%/ :#,# #C/&>&"#$ :&"/1" !(= >+#%"&(/#,#,#8-:#,!00#--!"#1,":!'+1'"&&#$&(,#-=&(.10( &(%<#"!C,#"1,('$#%#!'#$/#<1,$#,:!'%<<&""#$(*@* /#,#,#8 &(%<#"!

7 ,"/#=#!,@7&',#-#9!("

:/#,#&( >1'&(#'' &(%<# $#%#!'#$ &' '/:( !' ' 7 !($ !.,&%1-"1,#&(%<#&''/:(!' 7/#-#!,(#$'#(&,%1('#-/!'

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

' 7:#,#!$$#$>="/#-:#,!00#--!"#1,"!<"/#9&#:"/!" "/#,#&'!"#($#(%="'/:-:#,&(%<#&(&(%<#"!C,#"1,(8"/#>1'&(#'' &(%<#!<1("&(." ' 7&'>'#,9#$">#&(%,,#%":/&%/!'0#, !''#''<#(""/&'1,"'/1-$>#!,1($ 'D 8 70!&# '8 0< :8(#"/&,$"/#>1'&(#''&(%<#&# '@8 7&'"># $#$1%"#$ !' 0#,'(!- #C0#('#',%!-%1-!"&(."/#%<0#('!"&( /# >1'&(#''&(%<#,%<0#('!"&(%<#'" ' 8 70! &(:/&%/

'@8 7(!%%1("-''<!(!.#<#("!.,&%1-"1,#-!($&'"># !$$#$/#,#,#8"/#-''"0-!&("&'%<#'" 'D8 70#,!((1< 00-=&(.<1-"&0-&#,*8&"%<#'" '88 7 '88 7( !%%1("-''%(',"&1<":&#!($ '88 7(!%%1("-''

-9#!($!#%"&("%/&-$,#(!,#!-'">#!--:#$"!-!<1("

%<0#('!"&(%<#'" ' 88 7 (9&#: &($&(.',#%,$#$ !>9#8&"&'/#-$"/!"&(0-!%# 780-!&("&'!,##("&"-#$" %<0#('!"&( ' 88 7!-(.:&"/&("#,#'"!'!--:#$>=",&!-1," (9&#:<!""#,8:&"/!>9#("#$<$&&%!"&(&(B1!("1< %<0#('!"&(8,#.1-!,'#%($!00#!-!&-'!($&'$&'<&''#$&(%#,#.1-!, '#%($!00#!-&'$&'<&''#$80#($&(.!00-&%!"&(8&!(=8!-''"!($'$&'0'#$

6 * '+3' ;/#"/#,'0#!3&(. ,#!'(#$ ) #' ;/#"/#, #0,"!>-# ) #'