High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3447/2015dismissed

Seth Malhotra v. Raj Pal & ORS

2017-01-20Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi9 pages

!

"#$ $%&'&()

) *+ ,+-

,+- + ..//

! "

"

# $ "

"

"

%% % ## % # & '

%

( "& !

# # &

"

)*& )+

(,-. &

")- )/&

"0 1 $

&

&%

- /! & ( /(/ )/ - + % (( )+ - +2% -( 34

5 6 ,() # " &% # # " # 7 &

1 " - / & " &

"

"

&

")- )/& # #%1

&8 '"#$ 2 -,* '"# $ 2

&

# && $ $1

&

" &0$ 2 -,-. 1 -,-. &

& $ " "

(* -- ())-& 9-(# &

&

-,-. &

")-& )/ -* )* ())( & -,-. )- )/ & :..))),! "

-* )* ())( && ;%&

<

' <" = & $

> # %& # (,-. # " #

#

# 1

&#

-,* # -,*

# #%

&; ,() (- + - + "

(+ )+ - 34

? &$

1 &

# # "& 5 ( // (/ )/ - + % # " # 34

" & & " 1" 2%34

& " # " $ '"#$ 5 - .# "

& &

'"#$ ) -/# "

0 " '"#$

5 - (9# "

& $ '"# $ 5 (. (/# "

& 1

& "& 5 ( *( "

8 8 5 ** .6 "

? "% "!

#

& "& & %

& "

& # "

!

- 3 (( + - +& 5 ( /(/ / - +2% -( 34

5

" @A ( 3

@A

* 3 &

@A

3 #

@A$ .

3 & # @A$ 3

@A$ + 3 % !

@A$ / 3 5 6 % " 7

@A$

3 # # "

"

@A$ -) 3 # &@A

-- 3

@A$

-( #

%

# & A#

"

7 5 -(*# # &

? #

" % &

$

"

%

" "

" "

" " % "

&

" # & & " "& 6 * ()-( B """

# & % & %

& ""& () - ()-.

?

?

&% " % & ""& # # % #

" "# % %

# % 7 % C&

> & & ! (( + - + % & 5 ( / (/ / - +# !34

(( + - + !

# # &# # & 2 (* -- ())- CD !( >

# % # % & % & !

# & # !

#" " " ? #

1 7# % #

? !

% "

& & (* -- ())-C2 ( # > & # # " 7 % # & 2 1 #

%% % # 1 %

2

%

#

1& # !

%

% " # " " % &%

-) -9 "&# % !

!

" #$%&$

#&&'(

#%$) ! " ! " #

! "

* "

#$'$) +

"

#,'

-

#,. ,) / "

#,%$0

1

,1' $'$)

+ 23( 230

,&&$..$ ''...14

1 (

$

5

) 26" 23"&

23$260 23( 26,

23""& "' 1

-

7 8

* +

1

9 8(+

/

1

! 1

: ; 3

!"#$%$& $ '("

43

: ;3

)

*+++!

#$%$& $ '+*

3

43

7 8(+

/

* -4

8

* +

8,.+

/

1

1

3

1

7

- 1

-

7

1

7 8' *

/

1

$ %

( 1

3 $

( (

0,

1

9 1

$%%) $)),%%5 $$5,%%5

1

< $

"

" #

# # " " # "

" & " #

" % "& E %

& & " "& %

" & " # & #

# 2 "

-)) 5 % 7 ## 7 "

%

& ""& % # %& "& ? F% & "01"("( "2$(30"( "(3 "(#4$0 5' +$6'471"02&(&"(3#4$0'8

9 %&:&; .<

5 "&#

"

& % # & #

& % &

# % 1 & 5 %&

# % % & "

& # #

,+-

() - ()-+ -+

8 -

1 =1# 8 > =1#