High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3450/2015dismissed

Harinderjit Singh And ANR v. Iqbal Singh ANR

2015-10-20Mr. Justice Rajan Gupta11 pages

" #

$%!

! "# # &' ( )# *" +,,--

$$$$ .++, --,, /0--1* +2#*3/ 4 *+, 4 5.+++2#*3/ +#-*,* + 3 4 #

+ 3#- *,,-+ ,*0*

*5- 3*

2#*3/ ****&06 ,

*0 #*3% - / 32#*3/ ** **#3# 5,

*0-*** -) " -#*37 "

8 % -1+0 # +,- , ,/ *-

*,/ 2# 1 **1 + +9 :;

+ /- #- */ # 36( - 6/- #--0* -*

+* +,-

+ 3 "

3 +

- +* 1+1 1 ,

+- *+9 :; + /- #+- */ # 36( - 6/- 9#* 3/

-- /5< "#,- 6;=, 1 * "*<;= / 0 +, 1

- **1 3*9#*#,&05 "#,- 0 "

3 -

1 - 3**- "*+ /1 - 3*+ - 9# *33 * -** *#* ,- +-- -* 3 + / 9#* * 3 3 * +#3+# * -# +,,- +/# / 0 +--*/* *3/ 1 *

/, ,, 5;= 1+ + 1 * 0 #/ -

3+ &+ *

3+ * *

3+ 2

3+-- % - *51- 1#+ *3/ # +0- *,#+ + # - */*

+,- -10 / **0 *1 -- 3,/+ ,+ * --*0 *1 -- 3

&01+ ,- / + # - * + * * 5 - /* + +0 +* ,#+ *+ # - */ *,-

3+=* + ,- /* ># 0 &0+ *+ *,0 2/ * * -**?@9#*0* "# * 5 * / ( 1 + " 3/ ># * +* -*+ # - **

*51+ +* 1 +"

3 0 3+ * #+ *5

" 1 +* ** + 3+ +,- *1 +#+

+,- --3--0 39#*+ -**?@ *3+ /3 *, +

* 9*9# -** "#+,-

1 ++" *3/ --&"+- *1+ ++*

/33*0* 1 + 3#) -)=, "% ( ! / * +% - *+*3*3+ /*/* 9# -** "#+,- + +* 3 */*0* +* / * + -** 1+ +- +1 +* + +* #++

-** ># " #-- *" * *+ + 3+ +,- + #+ ,-**+ +

* -** 1* *5 #, 3+/#

* + "# *#+- + # - * "#

/+,

*+ 3+ #+ /1+ + --0 --3- * +0 #* * 3 +1#-*# /#- ,- 0 - 3 1 +, +,- ># ** */ +3/ --3* 3+ # - * **+ -** ?@ 3 #-- *" * *#+># ** 9# + - ** 0 "

3 - -

* *- " ,

# - *+,- # " ,- -* # , ,/ *- *,/ 2#

A, # 1

*0* 0 - 1 /

3,- / 02

+3#

+,- + -# * *# -+, # *++ # / - +, / --3*+ 3/ 3* * **#/ *,- + -*+ , # *# +

/ +,-0 3* *

#++,-0 3* -*3 , - /+,-

/ 1 #/ *+* 1 1 ,

"+ # - *+9 :; +1 * *+

5<* +*9#* 03/ --+* ,#*- B6;=, 1+* "*<;= / 01

- * *+ -**1 3*9#*#,5

+1 - 3 1 * *3* 3+ # - **# 3+, 0+ # * +*--03* -- +- ** 1+ +*2

+- ** 1

*+ -** 3* * **#/ 1 #+

#/ *+ -- 3+ # - * 1 / #/ .+ -* 3--+"/ - -0,0** /

-+ # 1 /* < *5 -* ,1 /

,- / 02

+ # / - / 3"3#

, # * ** # * +" / * +

+--3*3/ +,- C+ # + ,,-0 "-#*+,#, #

/ + * * + * 3/ -- 1 + ,-

5< */ *+

1 3* +",#+ *+ # ,,0 / *

;= " * 3 * -****? *1 ,

# ,,0& -"/ /

3, +" "* ,0** /

- #

/ --0* <+ -* ,1 / 0 #/ 3+,- + -*+

" 1 + 52# *+ 3+ +* <+

,- * + # ,,0 1 -*0 # * /33 1 + +

1 3* * +*># -0/33*+ / 1 +* < < @ 1"*# 3+, 0 # /* < 1 *-*/+0* " 1+ / 3 **0#

-+,- ?

D/+,-* +, " #

# 1#--* #0-* -# *++, 1**/,-,,#

**# * -#*+ " * +,- ** -*- 1-- *#/ 0 " * , + ,-*

# ># -0- *+ " * -0E 3" * " -- -**#*0,

- *#/ 0 *+ 3- *#

-, # ,- 1 **+9 :; + /- * -*

+* +,- "#+,- ,/ *

3/ --**5< :

33 "*3

2#*3/ ****#3# 5 ,

*0-* -#* *5,* ,,-#+ 1 - * /

* 0 -* #*3 % - &0 6 5 / 3;#,+-* 32#*3/ ****#3# 5,

*0 -* -#

+ *1 +* /

-,,-0 ,,--# *5,*

,,- :

.+ -

- 3+ /,#3 *2#*3/ **,

*0 + -* - # * /* 0 -1 ,,-- # +

#-- -0 3#* 0 - * #

- + ,,-- + +0

# ># ,#+ *++# -1+"/

#* / *+" * " -- - *+ * -1

0 * 3 + # + ,- = , , ,/ +3/ --**/5<9#*0 "#,- = , + -** 9#*0* "#,,-- =* *5

-3- *"- * * + +,- = , - + + + 1 -0 -* +# * /# 0 * - #-*+" 3 *0+# -1 3

+,,-- 1+* *5 + # >#

,#-0,,-- =* *5 ,

+ ,,0 # * 3 *,#+ #-*+" " * + - ** #-* +" * -0 , # *- + # , ,/ -3--0/ - &"+ -# -1,,--#+"#+*

-11+ ---0 3 3++,,-- =* *5 +" *#-0># *0+ -# + / - 3 * 3

+/ + + - (

0+ # -1 +3/ - - 3 *

! *#

-,,-- =* *5#+ **+++# -1+"- -*,, + + .= #

, >-

3+=,- &",- #-* ,- *," *3 * "

3" * - ++ -****&0< 3* * * *#/ + 3** + 3* -#-0 *#,

2# +# + /,#3 *2#*3/ ** # -

+0 -1 *- - *010,

,,-

+ )# + 3 " 9 # +#3+ + *

/*0- *#

-+,,-- #+ )#

3/ 1 ++ /+

**-1 *,"+3/ --**5<>-

3+=,- + / - ,,* +1

9 .=5 * +

*+ ,- ,/+ / 0++ - 9/ * #/ -

3+ .= * *

3+ .= 1

#/ -

3+ .=+ 3 --0*, * ++ * -

3+=* + * 3/ -- **5< ,+- */ # 3/- 1 * ,

*0+ /B 6, 11+ +1 2**1 / 0, + , +, *

3+ "* #/ <;=1* / 0#+- -

+ #+ *++ +3/ -- 1*" *9,- * * -

3+1+,, **+

# (

-0+ + - *, *

-1* ++ *

3+ *+ /

/3 -1

,+/ * *

+3/ -- **5<9 =+ -**1 9#* *3 *

&05 ,0/ - -

.= *

3+ + 31

+3/ --+ - #--0 *+" >-

3+=,- .=5 +

#/ -

3+ .=>-

3+ .=5+ - *, *++ *0 *1 -- 3,/+ ,+3/ * 1 * 1+" -*+/ * *

** * ,/+ , D#++ **+ 3+ ,- = , + 9#* - ** ?@ ** < "# *5 +#3+++1

/-0 #/ -

3+ .= * *

3+ .= +" 9/ * 0 ,- = , * - #2* - 3+0

=9/ #

+ 3# #-+* #-*1 +*#+/ 5 +*

*1 --

+,,- = , *+ ,"*/+++ ,- = , ,,* * / * + #= 3 - 31 ++- -

*+9,

#*3 3+ -**3 * + ,#-** &05#+ /* * * # #, *" 79 =8>-

3+=,- + ,-* *,"* * 1+ + + 3

3+ *F + F#/ < 1#-*- #,-/ + + # 2 + -*+ " *+,19# "&3

1-- + #=3 +/++ + *" 9 =+ /*09# "&3 * / + +1 , + #3 +1 - +*#0 + #=3 3 +*#/ * 0 *" * -10 * +, 0 9# "&3 %# + / *

* , *" 9 =

3 * ** - "* +#3+ *2

3+.=

* -

3+.=+",,* +1

=9 *+" * ++- 31 +* 5=2

3+,#+ *+,,0 #/;=/* " * -**9=#+

# " "

3" * ,"++ -

;=1 ,

*+ /9# *3 - **0* "#* *5+ +

/3* + / ++1

.= *.=+

/ 01 ", *0* *5* + #=3 " ,# - -**9=

, ++

1 ,

*/++ * *5 +, #3 , --0 " 1+ ++ -+ -**++ -

1 3 "

0* *5 +, +1

++# + # , 1 +3*+,

1+ +#-* /"*0,,-- ;* *5

+ +

+ 3 + + *+ , *53

+- * #2/+ -**

9=* + " -* / -

/+ ( *#+++- # 33

* 1

, *0,,-- ;* *5 - #+ -

@ %#+# #, /,-0+ (+

9/ *,"+ ,*+ /- 3

* 1+ ++ , *0,,-- =* *5+ #-*+" -0,"*09/

3+ (/,-0%#

#+ + 3*1 /* / --0 + 3+ - #3+

* 0 ,,-- ;* * 5 + + 1 - 3/ -- 1 * *,,-- =*

* 5 , + 3/ - ,,# ** 0 ,- = , &",- = , *

/-- 0 *+ # ,,0 - ,"*2 1 +,*

= = +,- ,*

= * /1+ + / -+*

*511#+9# -**9=; =%# , ++0,*+ -**9#* *3 *

+ "# ?

+- 3+" * ** #

+ )#

**" 1++-*-1#+ 3+-0 -#**++

-** +/

1 +#

* + 3 9#*0,,-- =* *51 +" 1*+ 3+ , =,- +-*-1,,--#+ - 3+-0 #*1 ++ **0+-* -# +

)#+ - * * 0 / 0 --3- 0 + /,#3 *

2#*3/ ** + / -#-0

1 ++ " * " -- - * -*

-1 6 #, ++ ** #

,,-

1 +# 0/ #++ / * /

*#1 + *

(