High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23968/2024dismissed

Union Of India And Others v. Ex Jwo Roshan Lal Yadav And Another

2025-01-20Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages

"#$%&''

#$#($) "#$% ' &

*% +,* --

- .

+,* - -- - *

!" # $%&'&&&( ')& *%

++++ -

- .

/ ,

-%%% &.

% / * &( &!*% &

,0 4 5 /26( & &

! % 7

) - &7 ))

0)1(020)34 #($"

,.& 77

&) ,9:3 & .& )%&

*8 21 3111 &* *31!

&& 1: &!*;&7*!

% 8 *

)%& (

,.&% &<*&&**) 46(.% &(% .&&

*% &<*

,.& 8

% &<*.

1, 1= 3111& .&

& &<77% & * )%& &

*128% -% 888

*;&7*! &

% 7&% &<,18% -% (&

% 5&

7) (

,.&7&.*77!&

*% &<*

(

,*7

(

) - &7 ))

( .% ! % )& & )%&77 % &* & > )

-% & (

,0 31324 5 /26 -%

&*% &

5&)

% &*

! "

#$% !

'( ) * +

( (

! ,

! "

#$%

! ! ,

% -

( !

, '

( . ( ! ,

( !

*8% &* &

& &

% 4 &6( !% 7

) - &7))

/* &%&*7

&&% &.

%@ -(5677#$#819 2 0 $ ")#($ 28# 19 :

1717#$

-% 7

) 7*%

.%7 :0 0'#8

$7#$

4(2017#$8# 19 7 # ) /'';

0 1'< & A' * &#!* ) 2 "01 "'''(%& 8

%&& ' &7B

& &< &'

&<& 7.

% !%8 % 7& 8%*% ;&7*!*

% ( 8* 0 0'#8

$7#$

4(2017#$8# 7 # ) /'';

0 1='<(% )8

&%!8&!) &

)!* & &)7&&< 5)

8% :

,% &<**7 %&,1 8%(.% !% .&&

% 7) *) (%&% 8 * % )%& (.&&)

&&% &<*

-% &*% &

)8&)

*8%)8 % ; 7 %* ;&7*! &&% &<*

# '

(% - &7%%& )

&* & &7!%

&' .*% 7&.7& . !%

@)& 7

& 0$" >0 6-7$49(.%)% #&'&'&'&#8

$) #8197#( 1 ,1

& 7!(

,( '

7!(&% 8 * %

&&%7 &<* *&

7 %& 8%4

8%6 .

% )8

&%! .

.% & ) ) % &

)!&

&% *;&7*! %

*) & ;

8 %&)&77!(.% % ;

*;&7*! *%

% &<*.&

!& 8%(% (' .*%

7&4 &6% &

)!%%.&) & 7

,, .

(% &'7'

&)& %&

&7.% !% 8

) - &74 ) &7$ )%6 . 7% '

) )& ? ; ;7!72< # &@?

#8 297749#( 1< 7

& A 90 01-7$49 .9010$0> $7#$#8$"70 / '& &&& %.% *&

5&)

% &* (

% & '

) % B 7 @'

)8&

31,0)& 7

& $7#$#8$"700$" 19 >A 90 01-7$49.9010$0( .%)%7!72::

02#@@@ '' &

- *

6 -

#$$#$71#

)##7### !

( (

((

& "&

"& ! #$#%### !

)##7### (

8 9

(

, ! (

, "& : (( , , :

;, < :( .

! ,

- *, , (

!" #$% &"

' ( ()%)%*#$%

%% + "%% )*"! %%

)!)

, !) ))-% +$

%))*) . %%(%$ )" (

' ! ,( ( ,

.<- -,

6 /) ))-%

) ))!$ ! ,0*()) !" $ () $

") $ ,0*( ) )

%! %1( )) ! ( )" 2() "* $ ) " 3 ))()"/ !

, (

8 *

$# !

, ! , .

= ! ;

, (

, ( 9#2

, "& :

, !

! $ ,3

-% & '

7&*7&..%)%%&

% !

% B 7

5 @( 8&<

7! )7 &( %& .% % *;&7*! ))

(7 %&,18%

&&&< 7&) (.% (% ) ) &8 )8&8 & 7 )

))

-% ()

&&% &<**& 87 %&,18%(!

8*% 7&*7&.4 &6(%

) &

)!% * ;&7*! *%

# '

% !(' .*% 7)!D))7&4 &6( &

& 7 % '

.8 ;&%8*% ) 4 &6'

&%! &%8% *% * @ )7!.% % &* *&'& 7! . % & ) '/&/' %

,(%)7 &)%

7!.% *&)87& %

(%&87&

'/&/ '% % )7&8& @ ; 7!(%%% !(%%

)7 % )7&8 &! .% % %

)

7(;&.%8% ) .

77 )

.7 &7

)7&8 %& % .& *&7! &

& &7! &

)8&

4 ,=

) & '

8& &7 ) (% !(%

)* % & ) ! % &%!( .% !( %

*) *;&7*!

&&% &<*( )7 '

)8 (% !(% & & 7 *&7% &*% 8!% ( ) & ) '

% . ) & 7&*7&.( 8&< % &8 &

7)& 7 % *&)(&8)%&( &78 % .% .% %

8 7! )

)! *;&7*! &

*,18% &%&%&

&)&

-% (% !(% *&7 ) & ) *&'*

,( *&77 *7(*% & 7&*7&.

) ; ) (%

% *;&7*! (% ;

)

&8 ,?

# '

() & 7&*7&.)*

& 7 %'/&/'

&7 & )& ))& *&)(% !(% 7& *7&.&))% '

)

5@()& 7

& $7#$ #8 $"70 0$" > 0 6 -7$49( .%)% #&'&'&'&#8

(.% !(% & &%&'

)

&(% &

7!% &)&

7$02 "

#8197#( 1 ,0

&* 8&%(*&77% &4 &6(%@* % .

& &8 8

-% 8

(& &

- &7 ))

(8&&

& &**8

*&7.%&77

7)&46(*&!

- .

< ;- - *< ' & <&'

% 9 :

037$4?

0#$ "

% ?# 9 :# 1052

% ?#