High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4921/2016dismissed

Urban Improvement Co Pvt Ltd v. S.V. Babbar & ANR

2017-02-06Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi15 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)

( * + ,+-

!

"

! $ % &&&& ,+- + '

( "

%)*+,%- . #

!/ .#

# ## / / ! "

# " / # # ("

. ("

!

.

( "

+12+,%3 .

"

! " ./. # ##"

" !

"

. #

! + # ( ! 45

/# 5

"

$ 78)!

' .!

' 33209# $ %"

%,2%1*2 #

"

#

# #

#

$ %#

"

0

# $ % "4 / /

0

:

" #

!"!

" :"

/

.0 / # +2+%1**; # #<:

5

=<5> ++!22,?7 1832?7!

! %18%113! /

! $ %#

" " ! / !/

!

" .

. /

+2)+,,+

$ % " 73?38!#( <"

!'

!$ /5 "

"

/

/

$ %.#

! $ %"

" # :"

#

/32,-)09

33209;

8-31

78) $ %

%2-+,,+ #""

"

/

$ %

+-*+,,+

/

@ /

!

/ " 4 /

"

#"

!

%11+,,+ / 4 A" $ 3,*8*

%)1+,,+ # +!+,!,,,?7

$ %

/

"4 . / 4 B # C ;

$ % +)1+,,+

+-*+,,+ #

" +!+,!,,,?7

%%,+,,+ $ % #+!%2!+,+?7 /

. .@ /

! $ %

"

/

+-*+,,+;

+2%,+,,+

0 /

/ / ."

. +)1+,,+

! /

! / " . $ %

)%%+,,+; /

+-+,,3%3-+,,2

. #"

<5 /

$ %

..

/ ""

.!# "./

.( #" /# # # " / "

("

/ # . ("

$ %! /" /

/# . $ %"

."

2*+,,3#

4 /

.""

!

.

" D % %,"

!

#

0 #

! #

$ % "

!

""

#

#

# #

# $ +// ! !

.

/

"

# "#" # "

$ % :

0 @

"

! $ % # /

! . ( $ +

D"

#

! "

# # / %E

## # "

" .

# FD +E

## # "

/ . ("

! .

# FD 8 E

# ##

# FD5 3E

## " #"

# FD5 2E

# 7( 7 ( # . FD5 -E

(

D ) %%FD5 )E

. /

%3 #@5"

FD5 * '

/ / 7#

%,%+,%3

+ E

## # "

# "#" # "

#

/ 78-31

' .!'= $ 78)> $ % .

# FD E /

4 !

/ " .

"

#

"

#

"

! "

" " ###

" ""

.! / . "

( "

+12+,%35 # ! ### # !/"" / ( "

%)*+,%-@ "

"

# . "

##7

. <5

!

/ .""

. 7 . "

#

# "

!/ ( "

!

" #( "

@ .#

( "

!. / D

! ##7 $ %!/

!

."

7

"

#. /"

"

""

#

!

. . " " # ( "

@ # " 4 /

#<5

# 7 !

. " # +!+,!,,,?7 %)%,+,,+! /

. 7"

. @ :

/

."/

.

@

. .

/ . . "!/ ""

!/

.( # ! . /

@ " .

/.

./

.

/.# . .

+!+,!,,,?7@ .# / "

@ "

# / $ %! ! !#

" # # " # "

! "

# ##"

. #

# !

/

. ;

. !

!/" #

$ ! # ""

#

.

/

. #<5.

7 ##5

# !/ "

#

/

"

#. /"

"

##7 !

""

! "

# #

." /"

"

.

. !

# @ ! #

"

. "!

/ ""

!/

.( # " # "

"

.#

"

" /"

" !/ ( "

! / .

. #

!/ / # ## #

"

: ! "

"

#"

"" "

" /

" #/ "

#! (

# . #

%8 %2 # ( !/"

"

!

!" # $

% & '

(#) &(*+, % &' (

,

- ) .

. / 0 $ #

.

. % % & '

.

.

(1

.

(

!)$$ 2

($*

% 34

.

2 .

'5 ! $ )$$

, (

1$$

$1"$$ . (

&

$ .

.

(

. ( $1"$$

!

$ )$$0

(

.

$1"$$6

70

$ 8 $0#092 )!$$,

!!$$

-

.

'5

.

1 . *'

&

3

. .

.

.

" . ) $$

$ .

$1$-

'5 !!- ) .

8$$0$ 92

8!#- 92'

. (

'5 0 .

.

. - !!-0 .

&

/ 0

(

. '5 0

.

,

. .. '5 ,

./:

/ 5 5;

( #)- !! 0

$$ 1

.

/:

/ 5 ( .

8 0--0"#01 92

% ( )

./:

/ 5 5;

( #)- !! < =, ( +9>

5 ? . 2% 8 1 '5 1@.0 !!- .,

.

#* 0 !!- , 2%

& . ,

.

:

.,

. .

,

'5 &

.

5 8 1

.

#* 0 !!-0

)@.0 !!$

.

,

"A

, % B

& .

8 1 0

., (#

,

8 0##01#0 #92C ( .

0

.

.

. 2.

'

5 6'57 .

3/ 0 .

02.

'

5 6'57 .

/ 0 &

'5 / 0 8' D /.> '

* . 0

./:

/ 5 5;

(1$ !!

0

$!"$ #0

./:

/ 5

0

. &

.

.

.

.

'50 0

.

.

4 0. .

, 5

.

<

* 0

.

$, . 2.

'

5 6'57/ 0 . . .

'50& . ( #

'5 !!- )

-'

. .

.

.

/ 0

.

2 .

6'57

.

4 0. .

1, .

(1

. 0

.

. 0

.

3

"

# .

#

"

/ 4 ". . .

" " # ( "

!/

""

/

. ""

#

"

!/" 4 .

! " /

.

"

! "

# #

."

7

"" "

! " # ."

" #

#/!/ ( "

!# / ; /

4 . # # ( @ G / .&#/%!"&"!"#& +"01&2!'0%3!/2!'0"2#/&4

6!'0"2#/&1&.&!/%7'"#/8/%&#& !'0 !'"2#/4

9 2##/! %'32 1&

2!'0%3!/207'!'0"2#/&4

%:%; )

. .@ G

/ # ""

#

:

" "". "

""

#

# " " "

!" / :

"

" # #

. ./

. ##

# ( # "

4 . # . ; " 4 /

+-*+,,+=<:7%%>!

. " / "

%)1+,,+=<:7%+># #+!+,!,,,?7 ; " / 7

%11+,,+!

<:7%3!( / # #

"#"

"

.

"

# ! #

"

<:%% #/4 ## # #

# ! /

"" ( #" #

" =<:7%+>

/

!

!..

" # !

##7 /

. <5!

. #/"!/ # ""

#

/

! # " # /

#"

."

.( # # . #

(

!# '.! 0 #/" 0 /

. "

# ! .

0 #/

#

!

/" 0 #

!/ :

"

("

%,,

# ! "

" "

( @ G !/<!'!'!=#'0/!'!'0 !'"2#/1&+#>&27<!/=%'%!'0"2#/&4

$%:%; 9 !'"&2!?!/%1& @/&2""!7%A!/%4

5 ) $

/ "#"

"" "

"

!"

/ # !

/ / ."

"

! /

. "

;! #$ " #

# "

.! /

! ! /

!/ ,+-

-++,%) *&% ; & 9 E 9( ; < 9(