High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3575/2015dismissed

Baj Singh v. Vijay Kumar Kaura

2015-08-17Mr. Justice K.C. Puri6 pages

!"# $#%&'&( )

!*&(+, --#..!(" /#0'1' 2&*!3415!04!10! #'-($#(" 67894 :,#",#0#-0"#0' 9%!.#;'-!-#0'5!3<#!..;#$" '##",#*1$+5#("= 3#'

<#0# #00#$"",##-0"#0'0("=3#' :,#",#0",#*1$+5#("',1.$<#0#-0"#$&(",#&+#'"=3#' 0#'#("604!1',!.>$/%!"# 0",#!--#..!("

0",#0#!'('5#("&(#$&(",#!--.&%!"&(>$#.!3 $!3'

&( &.&(+",#!--#!.'"!($'%($(#$'"!($'$&'-'#$ !%%0$&(+.3

!*&(+,$# #($!("7!--#..!(",!'$&0#%"#$",#-0#'#("!--#!. !+!&('"",#*1$+5#("!($$#%0##$!"#$

-!''#$<30'!($##- 4!10>$$&"&(!.&'"0&%"1$+#>4!-10",!.!/&$#;,&%,",#!--#!.-0# #00#$ <3$# #($!("@!--#..!("!+!&('"",#*1$+5#("!($$#%0##A

-!''#$ <3 ,0& 5&" ,&($> ",# ",#( .#!0(#$ &/&. 1$+# #(&0 &/&'&( > 4!-10",!.!;!'$&'5&''#$

0&# !%"' ",#-0#'#("%!'#!0#",!"$# #($!("<"!&(#$!

.!(

05",#-.!&("&

@0#'-($#("(

)!($",# !--#..!("@$# #($!(" #B#%1"#$!-0("#!($0#%#&-"&(",#-0#'#(%#

;&"(#''#'>(",#'!5#$!3&( !/10 ",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

&("C#( ",#0# ,#!--#..!("7$# #($!("!+0##$"-!3!(&("#0#'"D E-5(",# .!(!51(",#!--#..!("7$# #($!("!.'!+0##$"0#"10(<!%C",#.!( !51("!.(+;&",!+0##$&("#0#'">($#5!($<3",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

,#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

,!$!.;!3'5!C&(+",#!--#..!("7$# #($!("!;!0# ",# &("#0#'" !%%01#$ ( ",# .!( !51(" 05 "&5# " "&5# ,# 0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

!($0#F1#'"#$ 0",#0#"10( .!(!51("!.(+;&", !+0##$&("#0#'"<1",#,!$!.;!3'<##(.&(+#0&(+(",#5!""#0((# -0#"#B"0",#",#0,#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

&'!.'%.!&5&(+&("#0#'"!"

",#0!"# E>!'",#!--#..!("7$# #($!(",!$;0(+.30#"!&(#$",#!51("

&( F1#'"&(> !' '1%, !' -#0 #+"&!<.# ('"015#(" %"> ",# 0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

!.'+"'#0/#$",#!--#..!("7$# #($!(";&",!.#+!.

("&%#$!"#$

;&",!0#F1#'""0#"10(",#.!(!51("!.(+;&", &("#0#'">;,&%,;!'$1.30#%#&/#$<3,&5><1"&(7'-&"# ",!"",#!--#..!("7 #($!(",!$ !&.#$"0#"10(",#.!(!51(">,#(%#",&''1&" "&%# ",#'1&";!'+&/#("",#$# #($!("7!--#..!(">;, !--#!0#$!($ &.#$;0&""#('"!"#5#(""!C&(+-0#.&5&(!03<*#%"&('",!"",# 0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

,!'(%!1'# !%"&(" &.#",#0&+&(!.'1&"!'",# 0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

,!'("%5#"",#%10";&",%.#!(,!($'!($,#,!' '1--0#''#$",#0#!. !%"' 05",&'%10"( !%"",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

01((&(+!%55&''&(!+#(%3',-1($#0",#(!5#!($'"3.# @2&*!3

415!0 !($ (' !" ',- AG> #; 0!&( !0C#"> 4!-10",!.! ,# !--#..!("7$# #($!("1'#$"'#..,&'!+0&%1."10#-0$1%#!"",#! 0#'!&$ ',- ",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

"",#"&5# 5!C&(+-!35#(" ",# !+0&%1."10!. -0$1%# ",# !--#..!("7$# #($!("> ",# 0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

1'#$"<"!&(",15<&5-0#''&( ",#!--#..!("7$# #($!("(/!0&1'

<.!(C-!-#0'> 05'>'"!5--!-#0'0#+&'"#0#"%(",#-0#"#B" #("0&#'&( ",#&00#%0$,#!--#..!("@$# #($!("&(+$ !&",1'#$"-1",&'",15< &5-0#''&( !" ",#&('"!(%# -.!&("&

70#'-($#(" #'-($#("7-.!&("&

1'#$"&''1#'5#*7 05'!($ '5#4!%,,&!0%,&"",#!--#..!("7 #($!("";!0$'-!0"-!35#(" !+0&%1."10!.-0$1%# ",#!--#..!("7 #($!(";#/#0>&(",#3#!0

A>",#!--#..!("7$# #($!("'.$,&'

!+0&%1."10#-0$1%#"",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

0!(!51(" ' > G> 0 ;,&%, ",# 0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

$1.3 &''1#$ ! 705> <1" ",# -!35#(" ",# '!5# ;!' (" 5!$# " ",# !--#..!("@ $# #($!(" <3 0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

,#!--#..!("@$# #($!(""&5#!($!+!&(0#F1#'"#$",# 0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

"5!C#",#-!35#("><1"",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

C#-"

(.&(+#0&(+((#-0#"#B"0",#",#0><1"$&$("5!C#",#-!35#(" ."&5!"#.3> ",# !--#..!("7$# #($!(" '"--#$ '#..&(+ ,&' %0- " ",# 0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

10&1' 05",&' !%">",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

,!$

!<0&%!"#$",#0&+&(!.-0("#!($0#%#&-"!($ &.#$",#-0#'#("'1&"!+!&('"

",# !--#..!("@$# #($!(" :,#0#!'> ",# !--#..!("@$# #($!(" ,!$ (#/#0 #B#%1"#$!(3-0("#!($0#%#&-"&( !/10 ",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

(0 #/#0<"!&(#$!(3.!( 050#'-($#("7-.!&("&

/&$#'!&$-0("#!($ 0#%#&-">0!",#0",#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

&'.&!<.#"5!C#",#-!35#(" ",#

7 05$!"#$ 7

A"",#!--#..!("7$# #($!("";!0$''!.# ,&'

!+0&%1."10#-0$1%#,#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

,!$-0#-!0#$",#-0("#!($ 0#%#&-" &( %((&/!(%# ;&", '%0&<# !($ 5!0+&(!. ;&"(#''#' ( 5#0&"> 0#5!&(&(+!..!/#05#("',!/#<##($#(&#$!($.!'".3!-0!3#0 0$&'5&''!.

",#0&+&(!.'1&",!'<##(5!$# A #-.&%!"&( ;!' &.#$ 05 ",# -.#!$&(+' ",# -!0"&#'>

..;&(+&''1#';#0# 0!5#$67 :,#",#0",#-.!&("&

&'#("&".#$"0#%/#0",# -0&(%&-!.!51("

05",# #($!("=

:,#",#0",#-.!&("&

&'#("&".#$"&("#0#'" '!" ;,!"0!"#!($";,!"#B"#("= :,#",#0",#'1&"&'("5!&("!&(!<.#&(",# -0#'#(" 05= A :,#",#0",#-.!&("&

,!'+"(.%1''"!($&!($ %!1'# !%"&(" &.#",#-0#'#("'1&"= :,#",#0",#-.!&("&

,!'("%5#"",#10" ;&",%.#!(,!($'= #.&# ,#-!0"&#',!/#.#$",#&00#'-#%"&/##/&$#(%#(",#! 0#'!&$ &''1#',#"0&!.10"!

"#0!--0!&'!. ",##/&$#(%#$&'5&''#$",#'1&"

",#-.!&("&

/&$#*1$+5#("!($$#%0##$!"#$A

##.&(+!++0&#/#$>",#-.!&("&

-0# #00#$&0'"!--#!. 0$#0 ,#.#!0(#$$$&"&(!.&'"0&%"1$+#>!"#,!<!$/&$#*1$+5#("!($$#%0## $!"#$

!.'$&'5&''#$",#!--#!. ",#-.!&("&

"&.. ##.&(+ $&''!"&'

&#$ ;&", ",# !

0#'!&$ *1$+5#("' !($ $#%0##'> ",# -0#'#(" 0#+1.!0 '#%($ !--#!. ,!' <##( $&0#%"#$ <3 ",#

-.!&("&

@!--#..!(" ,#!--#..!("&(-!0!+0!-, ",#+01($' !--#!.>,!'

5#("&(#$",!" ..;&(+'1<'"!("&!.F1#'"&(' .!;,!/#!0&'#(&(",# -0#'#("0#+1.!0'#%($!--#!.67 & :,#",#0",#*1$+5#("!($$#%0##$!"#$

!($A

!0#&..#+!.>!0<&"0!03!($;&",1" *10&'$&%"&(= && :,#",#0",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

&'#("&".#$"0#%/#0 ",#!51(" '>G?>

05",#!--#..!("= &&& :,#",#0",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

&'!1",0&H#$".#($ 5(#3;&",1",!/&(+.&%#('# 0",#'!5#= &/ :,#",#0",#!--#..!(",!'#B#%1"#$-0("#$!"#$

)= / :,#",#0",#9$10"'<#.;,!/# !&.#$"#/!.1!"# ",##/&$#(%#(0#%0$= /& :,#",#0",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

!0#.&!<.#"-!3 !(!51(" ' 7 G"!--#..!("!+!&('"",#7 05 $!"#$

A= /&& :,#",#0",#0#'-($#("@-.!&("&

!($;&"(#''#'!0# <1($'<3",#!$5&''&('5!$#<3",#5= &&& :,#",#0.!; #'"--#.&'!--.&#'"",#0#'-($#("'= &B #.&# G 9#!0(#$%1('#. 0",#!--#..!(",!''1<5&""#$",!"'1&" ",# -.!&("&

&'("5!&("!&(!<.#&(!'51%,!'(5(#3.#($&(+.&%#(%#,!' <##(-0$1%#$<3",#-.!&("&

(",#!<'#(%# ",#5(#3.#($&(+.&%#(%#> ",#'1&" 00#%/#03&'("5!&("!&(!<.# ,!/#%!0# 1..3%('&$#0#$",#'!&$'1<5&''&(<1"$(" &($ !(3 0%#&(",!"'1<5&''&(

(%!'#>55&''&(+#(".#($'5#!51("",&'%1'"5#0> &"$#'("!51(""5(#3.#($&(+<1'&(#''(",#/&..!+#'>&"&'!%1'"5 ".#($5(#3"<#!$*1'"#$!"",#"&5# '!.# %0-( !%"",!"!51("

&'+&/#(&(!$/!(%#&(!("&%&-!"&( '!.# %0-,!""0!('!%"&(%!(("

<#'!&$"<#!(35(#3.#($&(+"0!('!%"&(,#%!'# ",#-.!&("&

<!'#$1-(-0("#!($0#%#&-"$!"#$

),#-.!&("&

,!'-0/#$ ",# $1# #B#%1"&( !($ -!''&(+ "0!('!%"&( ",01+, ",# -0("# !($ 0#%#&-",#'"!($"!C#(<3",#$# #($!("'&'",!"!51("&'-!3!<.#<3",# -.!&("&

" ",# $# #($!("' &( 0#'-#%" '!.# ",# -0$1%# <1" ( $%15#("!03#/&$#(%#&(",&'0#+!0$,!'<##(-0$1%#$>",#%(%100#("

&($&(+ !%" 0#%0$#$ <3 <", ",# 10"' <#.; ",!" -.!&("&

,!'

!$/!(%#$!(!51("

@7 ()

)&'<!'#$1-(%+#("

#/&$#(%#,#0#&'(",&(+(",#0#%0$"',;",!"'!&$ &($&(+&'",# 0#'1." 5&'0#!$&(+!($5&'&("#0-0#"&(+",##/&$#(%#(",# &.# ,# #($!(",!' !&.#$"-0/#",!"-.!&("&

;#!(3!51(""",#$# #($!("

&(0#'-#%" '!.# ,&'-0$1%#>,!/#(,#'&"!"&(&(,.$&(+",!"( F1#'"&( .!; ,!' !0&'#( &( ",# -0#'#(" !--#!. !($ ",# '1<'"!("&!. F1#'"&(' .!;5#("&(#$!</#$("#B&'"!"!.. A ('#F1#(".3>",#-0#'#("!--#!.&';&",1"!(35#0&"!($",# '!5#'"!($'$&'5&''#$ %-3 ",&'*1$+5#("<#'#(""",#"0&!.10" 0'"0&%"

%5-.&!(%#

!" !