← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5051/2016dismissed

Kimat Singh Etc v. Sukhchain Singh & ORS

2017-02-03Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma8 pages

 

   

  

  

  !! " #$ % & 

'    

  

!    "

(((( )#   *+$  #)!$#*##, "

 ,

#+  !! ((((  

# )#- #    +   !     $ #      . 

 + /0  

#



!-

 - !1+  ! #+ #   +  !  ,0 !!

 +  !-

 - !1+  !

 +   !!( !

  +"   +  #     1$!#    !  1 + 4$ 10  

#   56  7-! # 

 !# 8$ 1 ,90$1#81 +# 3+ # 7-+ # !1+ 4$ 10 

#    7-! # 

 !&"!8$ 1 :  #" ;,90$ 1#81 +#3

(( *# !- ,+  !!( !

+ $

!#   !01  + #   +  + #  + #  +  01# )<   ! $

+  # # 3+ ++ !

)<, + + 7 !!

 #   + ! 7# $1+3++0

+ #"!$7!  1 !

 !" #4 3 !! #-3 !!!" # 

0)<  +  $#   !

 # #$  + #   0  +     =$# $ 

 +  8   $  20!- # 7 $(.- #7 <+$,+ $ # #-, !

+  !, #! #

+  # + #  (

#  

$#7 +1+(7# + #

+  !

+

+ #7# + #

+  !

,0 !-,*!7#1++ - # 7 <3+ $! "1-! 1!+ # $#7 +1+, !

#7# + #

+  !

,3 $  #  3!

<1  #+  # #-

8  $ 0!-3 !!+ 7$ 



+  0!- 7 $- #7 <, $#7 +1+ 

1 7#   +

0

++#  0+ + #

1!-,+ 31" + $ +#  $

+ 8  $ 0!- # #-7-+  + #

+

 + 3  >1!   !

+ # +0 #,+ # !

 3 # ,+$,1"  +  !!( !



+ - $ !" + # 3++ # 0!  +  + #

+

 .- #7 < + #0 + #! 7 $- # 7 < +$,+  !

# #  1+ + ,

+ !- # #  + 0 !"  3 #

+ + $ + #  (

 #+ # + # " # !0 -#1+ " #+ 

(( $ ,    =$   

3 " #,  5  - #  7 <,  +  + # 

 + #  (

     "   + #   #,  +  #  (

 0 +  !!( !

 3 #

+ + $ , =$   $#+ # ! 

+  !+  0!3+

3#  1+  1+7 $#+

+  !

,+ 1 + 0## 3++  #((!3

  + # +"1 "! -  + +  1 + #  (

   !0  +  + $ ,    =$  ,  7 1  + #   #!

#- +0 #,

  "    # !01+ ##1++ +  + -+#     +  !!( !



7!-

!   +  $  # #-   $     0  +  !0 

 +

+$,+ $

#

!#  4$  3            3 #  #

 1  ?  #

$#1#!

    + $ 3#   0 +# $1++ 3 #

 # -,0 !-,!01+,<1 "# $ # !0#-   !$ 1 !0 

0 #!   + $7 17## $ #  &)&

3 " # 0 #, +   ++ $ # #- #! #

+ 8  $

0!- #++  !

# 

+ $ # #-

3 #   ! 

 +  +  !

,    =$  ,  3  $#  7-

$#7 +1+" # 1 # ! 

.5:>?;

 + # #$  " # 0 3  !! 1 + !!+ 7# + #3 # !"1 # 0$ + # # +  $# + 

+ 

(( !

, =$  ,7- $#7 +1+  + $#7 + 1+3$ # 7-1"1- # #0  - $#+ # ! 

+

  $! +- !

+ $ +# $1++ # -!01+,3+ 3   # -   8$!-,    3+! 

     +  !

 

#  %   +$,  +

+"  #1+,!  # # + $ # #- +

#  3 #

+ +  2# 0+  !  1

+  # ,+ #!& $# #0 +

!!

31$ ( 

  

   

  





  

 

 



   







  

 

 



 



 

 

 

   ! "

 # +   !!( !

,  3+  +"  !0  +  $ #- #! # #-, $!

 !  - " "

+  + # 3  " +/ ++01++ !

- #-)<'+  + #+ ,

 + # "

-

! 

>?3+ + ! #!-+ 3++  !

 " #3+ + + $ =$  3 #$ ,3 $# 7- $#7 + 1+  0  +  3    +  ! 

 >?      # 1 #

$0  ##  # $0 

##   +  !

$!

 # 7$+ ! 

7-!  1- "  $!

 7!+ " #+ !   $ ,+ #!& $#,"

4$ 10 

#  , + $

(.( 11# "

 1  +    4$ 10   

# 

,+  !!( !

 # ##  !3+ +3 ! " 4$ 10 

#  563++

!!

31 7 #" ( $

 

%



&

  

 

'





  

(

 )'



   *    

    +   

 

&  *  ,

 



 &'

   '

   

  *  

 

 



     

 

 

 '   &'

&

  * 





%  

  

   

  



 -. % 

  



 



  

 &

 

%  

  & /&

 )'

    ,

 



 -.   '

  



%

      '

 

,

&  '





 

 

&   

 % 

 





 % 

 

  & /&

 )'







 -. 

$

 %

 

'



   



!0    /&

 )'

     



 





   

%



&



    



  &    

 

, 

  %

 

.  $& 3%   &'



  4 )'

 

 

 )

2   5 3

%

.

& 

  



  %

 

'





'







 

  

  



  ,

 



  

& 

 - %

       

 

 

&       



   







  2

)'

 '





 ,



   

  &'









 /&

 )'

% &

 



 '

&  





  

 





  

'











!6

(6(  

,

  4 "  



 

   &  



   +

  

%  

 7

'

 & 



  

  

      '





   

   



 % 

 & '

*  

&

    

 )

 

 

 

   



 %

   

 &

'

  



&    

    





8  %    

 

 &



'  



%  





 '

  





        ' 

'

  &  





   



 

 # + 

#  # $0 ,+  !!+"

+  #  # 1$!#  ! / # $ ! 

#  +   !!  + 

#0$!  +

!!

31$7!=$  

!3( 9:

' 

'

 



 ;0<   &

( $   

='

% > ?'

='  

' 

'

 



 @0   &

( $ 7 ='

9) :

> ?'

='  

&

 &











  6   

 &

  9:

( $ 

7



  

'

    



&

 6 





'

 &



 

 

 







 

  9:

&

  &  

  

  

      

  -.   



 -.  '





 6   9:

& '





 

'



 &

 



   9:

    

 &

 

 

  #

(( / # $ ! 

#  +   !!  +  #1$  +  +

$#7 !

3+"  00 1#"  ## #3+!  01+ $

+  !!( !

+  $#7 !

3+"  ## 

1+ $   @+ + # !!( !

#  3 #  +  $  # #-  #   A   +  #  (

     + ! 

 +  +       $!  +- !   

 +  + $ B$ #-+# $1++ # -(!01+,3+ 3   # -   8$!-,    3+! 

     +  !

 

#  % 

3 " #, #  (

C 33  +" 

+ #3  +  !!# +  $! 3 #

+ $ #

+ !6- #+ 

B#   +   #

+# $1+!01+(+!! 1  ! 3 #

 # -,!! 1

+" 7  ?

$ 3+ # +  #1! ! 3 #

 # -3  !

+  !  +" + # ! # $ !

#+  !! + #   1 # ! 1 ++  # #-, =$  ,  3      #!  # #-,  #+ #  3  $#  7-

  0+ 3#  $#  0!#!-,+  !!(

+" ! !

 7!+++ -3 #  " # + + + $1+

#3 # 0 7-+  !



" + # 7- ?01)@(#7 $!

,)@( !711+, !

(*!1+)@ )@.($#4$#,7$ ?

7!

#! 0 -

+  3  , $ + 1 

! +1 " +7  !

# 3+ +0- 7!++ 

(D(

+  !!( !

 + $ # #-)@

)@ " +"  !

" + 7 #  # 

+ $ =$  +   

+  !!( !

! !7! 

7   " +  3  +"  0 ++  !

 (01+#  1 0 3+ #  !  +$, $7!=$ 

!3# +  #   # 1$!#  ! " 3

$##  1 7-+  $#7 !

3, +& $#

  - $ 

# # #  +  #   # 1$!#  ! + 0 ,

1!-,    "

   4 "

@+ + # <1B#  A 9 B

@+ + ## #7! A 9 B