Natha Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS.
!
"!#$ %
&
%
!"
'
($)
* #!+
) ,+
") # $
%
& '
$" ( & $%)
& $ *+& $#,- & $
'
./ & $- ' & $0 & $ # & $,-& $,
& $(1#+"& $ +0 , & $#%++ & '
$ ' &
-&!" ) ,+
")- #
*
$./01 012
*
'
"+ " ++ '
*" ( +
)
& 2 1
&45
64 67 '
*"1
(
5
81 (97 '
( 5
8(97 ++ 1
+
"*
*" ++
0 + )
:
1
& 4
3
+ " ' & / $ '
*
+ " ' +
'
2
'21 ( '
' "+/ &&;:
'
) 3
) (
+/ 2&&;:
< 0
" &
'
3
0 != &> - &!
.( " - * ( " ++ *
&!= +
4?@ *
+ &&;: ) (
&
( & $
& #
# & , &!
. '
++ *
+ &
.
)+
&.
+<
1 &) &( " 1 =
"& " ++ *
3 && 3 "
++ )!" '
+ *"1 (
A )( ?+
&
'
:
B
!
"
# $ % * 03 %1405
62' < & '
?+
'
'
:
#C -# &
#C *0
#C
#C 0.
#CA
&( /;!" ,
-+=.& #C2 !*
#C@ , ' 0
#C 0
#C4 .
#C %
( $ &#'
#C $ #0
#C %
+ #CA
1 &
"( / #C2 + , + #C@ ,'
#C < 0.
#C4 >,- & "&1
#C
, + #C +
< + " & "
'
+
:
>?# 1
>?# 1
>?# # "*0 >?#
" >?#A
" >?#2
" >?#@ ( " '2
*"
%& >?#C;.
( " A@ >?#C;.
%+* " : >?#CA;
( " ' @2 >?#C2;.
( " ' 2 >?#C@;( ;
41 ( >?#C@;.
( " ' 2 >?#C@; %+* ": >?#C;.
( "%+* " :
>?#C;( ( " / :
D >?#C; E*0
1 (!
>?#C;> ( " + ;
4 >?#C;F ;
4 >?#4;.
( " /
D >?#4;( ( "0+* " :
>?#4; ( "*0
1 (!= !
>?#4;> ( " ' 2 >?#4;F ( " ;
4 >?# # "
'
>?# # "
+'
+
>?# # " + +
>?# $4AA >?#2 ( "0+* " 2:@ >?#@ ( "0+* " : >?# ( "0+* " :
>?#4 ( " / D >?# ;
4
>?# ;
4
>?# ( "0+* " >?#
/ D ;
4$
>?# ;
4$
>?#A + ;
4 >?#2 -#
/, + >?#@ %+* " : >?# ;
4 >?#4 + ;
4 >?# ( " @4 >?# %+* " : >?# ;
>?# + ;
4 >?# +
*"1 (!
>?#C;. # ( " D + C/"
' " : >?#;( # " D + C/"
' " :A >?#C ( " / D >?#;> ( "0+* " :
>?#;F $ A22 >?#;.
%+* " : >?#C;( ( " / D >?#C; / D
/ >?#C;> -
( *"1 (!
>?#C;F ;
4 >?#C;- + ;
4 >?#A ( "-# ' , +
>?#2 ( "-# /'
>?#@ ( "%+* ": >?#A;
>?#@;
)
>?# ( "$ >?#4 (
>?# ( "+ 4 >?# ( " / D >?# ( " + ;
4 >?# =;
41 ( >?#C2;. $
>?#C2;( ( " + 4 >?#C@;. ( "0+* " : >?#C@;( ( "0+* " : >?#C@; ( " / D >?#C@;> ( " / D >?#C@;F ( " / D >?#C@;- ( "0+* " : >?#C@;! ( "0+* " : >?#C@;< ( "0+* " : >?#C@;% ( " / D >?#C.
( " / D >?#C4;. "&1
>?# ( " 4A@ >?#A ( "0+* " : >?#2 ( " / D >?#@ ( "%+* " : >?# ( "
>?#4 ( " @4 >?# ( " @4 >?#
>?# %+* " : >?# $
>?# $
>?#A %+* " : >?#2
>?#@ ( "
'
>?# ( "
' >?#4 %+* " : >?#A
' >?#4 ( " / D
' .
"
1 (:4:
>?#:& "0+* ":
&>?#: "
)& >?#
" 2 & !" ?+
C& * ( &#'
1 (&
'
+
:
>?4 ;
>? ;
24 >?
' 2 $/
D + $/.
A < * & '
'
+
:
>?#A # " '@ >?#A ( "%+* " : >?#A ( "! 6* +( < >?#A ( " / D
$ ' >?#A ( "%+* " : >? AA ( "%+* " : * /26 :5 ; <0 10
' )( *"
'
*
*" + * " + <'
*
'
' @ 5>?#A7
4 A
3 A
++ :.& &
* /
* 3 ' + +
++ !'&(
'2>?#@
8,; ; ;0 6* + <
05 ;0=
+ +/ 3
'
."
) 4
'
A24 "
>?#@&( G
?
+/ 3 + 2&&;: * 0/14 4 :5 ; 30 13 0>02/ ; >02 !
'
*
*/ '
(' ' 3
& '
" + +/ 3 '
*+
*" '
+ * 3 C
"
>?#&#A
#2&" *&
'
, &'&,
0
'
&& " + # &
!" '
&
>?#@
'
"+
! *+
4
>?#@
3
'
."
' 3
+ + * /< * *+ '
3 ! *+ 0 +
*"(
*"!" *
*"( C
'
( "
>?!(:&
>?:&:2&:'
*"! "
'
*"( 7* %212 :5 ;2 10' A
& "
*"1 #' & "
*" 3 * / >?!(:
>?#&#A'
++
, &'
( "<
!
'"& + !
F+
* "
&
*">?#&#A #2
+ 3 ! &( " " +>?#;.
+
>?#A)
'
'+
>?#;#4 >?#.
4 '
) +/
*
'
! & ' *
"
>?#;#4 #+
+/ 3 A '&
. ?+
*"!" <+"* 0 +
*"( +
"
*" * "
)(' 3 ?+
*"* *
+/ 3 >?
+
@;; C +0 " 3
+
A A * /
"
&
*">?
" + 3 )
" +
+ ) * @&&;: <'
"?+
>?2
2
'
0 '"+ 3
)
'
+ A/
+
4' 3
A < +
&
+
A ?A HA < < &'
"
&
&, ;,
&,
&$
>
+*
+>
+*
'
' )& +* +
) & +
4
0 +
A)>?2
'
*
&&;: A >?#@
'
*"('
+/ 3
."
< & 4
A24 )'
*"(
*0 +
*
( < * *" +(
?
,140 0 6* + <
05
+ 8( *
" "
+ +/ '
+ 3
'
"
0 + "
+
) ? :
* <
&!
(
& &
I& & & ' "& ((
#J!4K&'
)
*
< & ' 0 + ;'
& " &*
* **
'
+
&
!'&
&
& & I& & & ' "& (( E
#J! 4K '
0
* *"!
(
* *
* /
&* + + ''
'
3 * /
*0 +
* '
?+
*
+
+
'
*
' '
&
D
*
* 0 + ;'
* 3 <
+
+
+
'
+ +
* **
* C +
' !
(
*
)+
+
'
&+"** *
"
* 3 ' *
+
"
*
&
<
) +
* +
*" *
"
'
';0 + < *
"
& *" )
" 0
+
' ' '
+
3 ) *" + *
+
* *
+
+
';0 +
3
+*A"
+ *
+
+
* ) ' 0 +
*
*
"&'
' + *
" ** " +
3
" + ) *
'"'"
*
+
+
+
3 +
3
& &
+
& ' /
+
+"
+/+
1 *
'"+" *
* ) ' ;0 +
"
'
+
)
+
" *" 0 + ;'
3 *
/ " + ?+
<
';0 +
* ?+
&'
+
* & ';0 +
* * *
+
* "0 <
+ +
/ *
'
+
&
*
'L
"
"
* ';0 + ' *'
" M A C
+/ 3 &
3 /* E *
* & "
&' +"* &'&
)+/
*"(
* *" < ' &'
+/ 3 &
*" < "+ <
3
" *" '
+"*"'
& "
! &
'"
"
+ +/ *" '
3
E &
+/ 3
=
+
+ *
'
+ &
+ +/ *" '
3
*" AA )
"
+) '
+/
'
+
3 "
+/
+ +
! &
+ +*" *
*
< + &
"
+ &
" '
* ) &
" "
* &
+
A2 <+"*
'
*+ ( ++
" 0 + (>?#A&'
'
*")
( ?+
+ '
>?!(F
&
"
' &* 3
"&
'"+ 3 <'
"?+
"
>?!(&
,
( "'
' + * "
, +
)" 0
* )&
/
> *"
( "&'
!3 &
+ '
+ "*
8* %22' 2 ,
'
&
( ' "
>?#@
+/ 3
"' ?+
3 * &'
" + * *
+ )&'
*" ( 3 "
'
+ +/ 3 (
3 "&
*"!"
''
*"
'
+
"&
*" '
+
2
+
& "&
) ,+
") /
#!%
C
/
; N ; C * N ; SR. No. * "05 4
* *
)!
<-! ;) )>EF!
N E F :2@4: $)#<) $, = ;) )>EF!
N E F :4: $ %<), = E ;) )>EF!
N
E
4.
F :A:4 % <$ 1 $ ;) )>EF!
N E)!> 5.
F :42@: ) )>EF!
N J ;% <$ 1 $J E 6.
F :4: !
!.
%<-! ;) )>EF!
N E 7.
F :: $ $E!
<-!O$<(!
>1.
)!1 ; ) )>EF!
N E 8.
F :A:4 C , =OC , = (!
E)!> ;) )>EF!
N E 9.
F :A: ,>C 1<-! ;)!>) )>EF!
N E 10.
F :A: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;%!
$J E)!> 11.
F :4A: ) )>EF!
N ;!
.
1
E 12.
F :@:4 .
1C<><-! E)!> ;)!>) )> EF!
N 13.
F :AA: ) )>EF!
N ; $<-!JE)!> F :4@4: ) )>EF!
N ; !E,,=$ JE 15.
F :AA: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;,<!
> <JE)!> 16.
F :2: $>!,=$ ;) )>EF !
N E 17.
F :44: <!
<-! ;) )>EF!
N E 18.
F :24: !
.!
% , = ;) )>EF!
N E 19.
F ::4 =$<) <F > >1E#>#< )>1<$<)> ;) )>EF!
N E)!> 20.
F :4: # .!%>>)<-!J ;) )>EF!
N
E 21.
F :2: =1 )<-!5<(>>(> >7)!=1 E ;) )>EF!
N E 22.
F :42: ) )>EF!
N ;.
1)>%<-! E 23.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N ;,< .
1J E)!> 24.
F :422: )!>) )>EF!
N ;(!
< $JE 25.
F ::4 $ %>>)<-! ;) )>EF!
N E)!> 26.
F :@: (!
< $5<(>>(> >7)!=1 ; ) )>EF!
N E 27.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;,<!
<JE)!> 28.
F :22: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;!
)< > <JE)!> 29.
F :A2: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; ) <-!JE)!> 30.
F :A: % ;) )>EF!
N E
31.
F :A@: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;C , =, =OC , = <(! E)!> 32.
F :2A: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;!
!.
% <-!JE)!> 33.
F ::4 <$ 1<-! ;) )>EF!
N E)!> 34.
F :2: ,<!
> < ;) )>EF !
N E 35.
F :A: !
.
1 1 E ;) )>EF!
N
E 36.
F :A4@: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;$ %>>) <-!JE)!> 37.
F :A@: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; <, ) JE)!> 38.
F :22: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;$ %<) , =JE)!> 39.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; %>> <-!JE)!> 40.
F :42A: )!>) )>EF!
N J ; % N<-!
JE 41.
F :A@: )!>) )>EF!
N ;% -.<<-!J E)!> 42.
F :4: ) )>EF!
N ;,>C 1<-! E 43.
F :4A: %E- <-! ;) )>EF!
N E 44.
F :4: ) )>EF!
N ;$ $E!
<-! E 45.
F :A: ) <-! ;) )>EF!
N
E 46.
F :AA: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;<$ <-!J E)!> 47.
F :4@: ) )>EF!
N ;.
1> <-!JE 48.
F :42: % -.<<-! E ;) )>EF!
N
E 49.
F :2@: -<O -<-=< 1<-! E ; ) )>EF!
N )!E=-!(E11>()E E 50.
F :424: ) )>EF!
N J ;!
$# 1J E 51.
F :A: )!>) )>EF!
N ;$=, 1 1J E)!> 52.
F :A42: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;=$<)
< > >1E#>#< )>1<$<)>
E)!> 53.
F :24:4 .<.
1 E ;) )>EF!
N E 54.
F :42: ) )>EF!
N J ;(!
$.!
$J E 55.
F :AA: =>!,=$ E ;) )>EF !
N E
56.
F :@4@: .
1)>%<-! ;) )>EF!
N E 57.
F :A: >> <O >> .
1 ; ) )>EF!
N E 58.
F :4: ) )>EF!
N ;.
1)>%<-! E 59.
F :4: ) )>EF!
N ; %
E 60.
F :4A: )!>) )>EF!
N ;.<.
E 61.
F :4@: ) )>EF!
N ;, C 1%>>) <-! E 62.
F :2A@: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; !
.!
% , =JE)!> 63.
F :4: )!>) )>EF!
N ;=,!C<><-!
E 64.
F :2: =$<) > <5<(>>(> >7)!1
;) )>EF!
N E 65.
F :A:4 >=, ;) )>EF!
N E)!> 66.
F :A: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;>>= - -JE)!> 67.
F :A4A: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; >><-!
JE)!> 68.
F :A2: ) )>EF!
N E)!> ;#EE%
< E)!> 69.
F :@:4 ) )>EF!
N ;) !1 $
5>(> >7)!E=-!1 E 70.
F :@A:4 !
$# 1 E)!> ;) )>EF !
N E)!> 71.
F :A@: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; >> < O >> .
1JE 72.
F :A2: ) )>EF!
N ;%E- <-!JE)!> 73.
F :A2: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; )$ $ O )= $JE)!> 74.
F :A: $<-! ;) )>EF!
N
E 75.
F :A@: , C 1%>>)<-! ;) )>EF !
N E 76.
F :4@: %>!,=$ ;)!>) )>EF !
N E 77.
F :A:4 %,=$ E)!> ;) )>EF !
N E)!> 78.
F :A: )!>) )>EF!
N E)!> ;
!E,,=$ E)!> 79.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;>=, J
E)!> 80.
F :A: >><-! E ;) )>EF !
N E 81.
F :22A: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; # .!%>>)<-!JE)!> 82.
F :2:4 ) )>EF!
N E)!> ; .
1C<><-! E
83.
F :A2: 1%>>)<-! E ;) )>EF !
N E 84.
F :A: ) )>EF!
N J ;#=!# > < E 85.
F :4@: ) )>EF!
N J ;-E#<(!
J E 86.
F :A44: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;$)#<) $ , =JE)!> 87.
F :4A: !E,,=$ JE ;) )>EF!
N
E 88.
F :22: )!>) )>EF!
N ;,<! )<J E 89.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; -<J E)!> 90.
F :A: !
.!
% <-! ;) )>EF!
N E 91.
F :@:4 )!>) )>EF!
N ;-= <1 <-! E 92.
F :2A: )!>) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; %>!
,=$ JE)!> 93.
F :2: % N# 1<-! ;) )>EF!
N E 94.
F :A4: (!
$.
$ E ;) )>EF!
N
E 95.
F :4: ) )>EF!
N ;.
1> <-! E 96.
F :@: >> <O >> .
1 ;) )>EF !
N E)!> 97.
F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; % N# <-!JE)!> 98.
F :A: .
1> <-! ;) )>EF !
N E 99.
F :AA: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;!
.!
% <-!JE)!>
100. F :24: .
1> <-! ;) )>EF!
N
E
101. F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;!
$ (!
J E)!>
102. F :24: -=< 1<-! E ;) )>EF !
N )!E(E11>()E E
103. F :2AA: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; =1 ) <-!JE)!>
104. F :4@: ) )>EF!
N J ;<!
<-!J E
105. F :A2: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; )!
<-!JE)!>
106. F :A4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;
)< -EN 1J E)!>
107. F ::4 ) )>EF!
N ;=$<) > < 5>(> >7)!E=-!!<1 E
108. F :42: !
)<> < ;)!>) )>EF!
N E
109. F :A: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ; %,=$ JE)!>
110. F :4@: ) )>EF!
N J ;.
1> <-!J E
111. F :AA4: ) )>EF!
N J E)!> ;, =!1N
> <JE)!>
112. F :44: ) )>EF!
N ; %=
E
113. F ::4
)<-EN 1 ;) )>EF!
N E)!> PE.%::4 ) >EF!
N E)!> ;>>= - - E A PE.%::4 ) )>EF!
N ;#=!# > <
E)!> 2 F :A:
!C < ;) )>EF!
N E)!>
) ,+
") /
#!%