Satnam Singh v. Ram Parkash

 
 
  
 

 ! !"#$#%&'


 

  



  
((


 

  



   
)& *+)
)+

 

    

  ,-
 %#%./0   

 

  

 

   !

 

      

!

"

  !


  #$%
  $$$%




 $&'($) *"'+   



  !    

,

   -

  

 

)''$')  

!

 

!    '. '$ )''$ !

 ,

/!  -

     !



   

 

  0 *   !



 !

 +   

*  !

+

 






*   +

 

     1  2    

   !

   

 

!

  

  

 !

) 

   !

   

 

 

 !

 

   * 

  

 

   

 (

!  +

  

!

 

  

  !

2    

 

!

   3

   

  



    



   





 

 

 



!



*

 +






"#'''( 

   $" $$ $.." 



  )$ '$ )'''



  

  

  3   

   

 

  !

 

 

!     '& '. $..4

!



 

    2

 

!

"



!



  $&'($*"'+   



  !        -

     



    '# ') )'$' 

    

5 

    '# '& )'$$ 6

  

   ! !

  



  7

 8$         





:

;

)        2  

 

 



 :

;

    *

+  

  

 

 :

;
< &      

    

 :

;
< #        

 

 

  :

;
< / =

   

     !    "#  #  #

! 

$  "#!



 

 &!  "  #"  "


'



 # %" # "

"(  " #  ""

) *      " + %

,

 - %. -
/%0# )0# 

  % "     ( #  

  1

2 -3

4(  0 "( (  (" " #% ! "     !  -!   0  

   

#  #!      !     %               " #    

        5  -6,0    

   (    (  % 

- 0 78
 -640  !  ##9(#

   5  

#!  "(  %

(  +   7     

    #! 

 % 

(  
(  

  

#!



 " #!

  (+64

!  

   #: # !  % (+6,#  5#

#
(  (   !  

+#  !  "  (+       62# 

(    #" ! # % 

 + !       #! 6&(    !   %  "  " "

! (  " " +%

" (+

#! "   ; ;6&*#  %   !

 !

 % 3

6& %! (+ (   !( (+!+ +  (+ 3 +   % #

!(+ ( +

" 

  &

"  %(

 !   +   -% 

0   #

  "#!(+ 

6:#* 
 #5#  : &: (

 "  "#  

 (

 #(+! " ! "   (   " -
0

 "!  + !#6&#<

 #!     



"

(  7!

#      +       "       "  : &:-! 

 !( +"    (  



"  :

(8 " (

 (+" 

  "  !(  

%
"$ 

""   "14$ " ! " (+ #      !     (

 (+  %  # !     %  " (  !  "(  

  # "   %
"$ #!+ !  ! (

  " "

 

  

( " ( %#   "   (

 

!+

" %

(+

# " "! "   #!    

(   "   -   1

2 0#              

  "

"!$+ #!  " " %(

 +  

2 ,#!( + "(

  " ,: 
"

  = "#



(  %!  "   "  -> ( "

   +" #

! %

" 

  0

  %  (+

 #

   8            ( !       

  

 /6#98
 - 
'
 
 #

%" 0# %     (+  -3

/0



""

"



  24 ,2 ,

?>( "

     8   

  !(  

:

11&#

 2$    !24 , 2 , 7!

# ! (%++  " #! "  +!   #!( 

# "   (  %+ 

   1

2 #! " !( % (+ ( !@



 ( 5
 /62# % "

 " +A>   , , 2  

      "   (  
"

2  4, 4: &2 *> /6$

 (+

 ! <
 #! 

% " + "

  2

2 ! "  (

"

!  "   (+ # 8  % 

 # <
 ( !  "



/6,! * 
 #  3 "B"

#)# !    % " + % ;%      

)''.

  





 

 



  

!  

 !  >  <9% ?

 ,!



7    ,  ,  ,!

    

   

  % 
%5# , 2 #! /6&(  78 
 #  !   

   !              

 %  

/" + % 

! "  !     #

#!

  (+ #! "

!

#"  "" 

 # ( ! "     " #+

%

 "  !

%

#!   $C,(+ "" " "  %% ! 

   

" 

!(   !  ""+ " %   D +#      !   "

      %  %   8  "

  , 2 2

  !

(   >

 #  "

 %     " "

   /". #A E

# ( 

  +  # ( %  (+      

#!   "  " "



  ( " ( !    #!"+  +" (  #   " ( (     (+% 

 %# 

 ! ! "  "( 

7!

#    D "

#      "    !  (+"  #! (+ !



   "

#  #! D ( 

(+ #  %   "

    %  -! "  "

  0  ! "+ "  % 

 F !

#

 

 

 ( "

   

#!  

# "

 (+ ! (+

 "  "-!    !   !    8  "

 (+ !

0

 D +#( 

!

 #  " "% +

 :, 

 # "

(   $

*     #  <  9   <8#     " 



#(   ! "+ (  + 

 (!

 +           # !  

       " #! " "  %(

 # (+"   (" 

!    ((   >!(     " "

#!      % 

""

"



 (

   

:

11&#!    , 2  

 8 
 (    !

'

   ( +           "  ,:     
"

     = "#( " !(  ! 

$+   

"

  1

2   (+   %#!

! 

2 ,#

 (   +     

 (   !

"+   " "

!  



(      % 

"  

   ( ! %   " 6,#  5# #  "    #: # ! (+ (     

 !    ! %

 + 

,



(   !
(/% B"

 8(
 3 ""+* ! D  

 

  "  +%( 

+# ! "    # + " (+6, (   #" + !

 ! "( (+ !

<  <8  

  (             % "     " D    " %# +

"  "#!    #!(

=+# (  !     

#

"

( (+  %(

  #!   %(

(  +"





"(    #! "  +      % + # "% +

"

 :,  

" 

 "

 ;#   :, 

"

 (+   " "# ( "  +( &

7%  "         #        D  "% #   !   (

  1

2 #>

   #  "

# "" " " (+(  ( !# " 

"  

+ % (+!+

 !   

 ! !    #! " "

  %+  !   + 

  %  
  $4::

    + (      !      "     

   #            "+       + # !

#+#!( (    ! "  %    # %(

 (+ " (    !  % #
(/%B"

 8(
 3 ""+*

 + (+# ! "+ +6,#+ % (

 (  +  "  ( (  #

"+  

" 

  (+ - 6,  50#! ! % (

 F !

# #+ #

"

 (  % (

% #(+

 #(   ("  #% !  "( ! "

 ! (  
(   !



!

"  #: # !  % (+!+  " 

"#     % (+  ! # 

 D "( ( %+ % 

#>"

!  "   #% ! " !



 + % (

 % (

%

-    8  (

  

""+(+ " 

(  #    % (

+

( (  ( !0#   % 

%+

"     1

2 #  !    %%  !      %  +  %#  "

 !  %   ;    " #+  #! 

(    #"   % (+ !  "


( #   "(

 %  ;%;

B "+# %  (+

+    

"

#  

;!  +  "

#                  " #  !   8   ( !



:

 

  " 

#    "                !     ( +

 # %(

   $+  



2 !

" #  ( " % ! "       

     "

    "      (   #  !

  - (+!+ %  0#  2+ 

 " 4, 
"

  = "# 14$#      %(

     

+#%    #

2+  

#!   %    %(

  +  "  (+    

 #  +   "E         # ; "!        

+- %  0#(  (    

+#"  %  (+%

  1

2 # D  ! "  G( +# " "

 !  (+ " -   0#    

 %(

  

2 #!  " " (+ ( !

( +$+    #   % (+    # " 

 ! "

+ % !    " #! 

;"  "+(     " ! " ( (+# 

 " + " ! +  !  

# !

 "   %(

( 

 "  

#

 "+ " #!"   "  #

 1

2 #  " ,4 
"

  = "

 D +#   "

 

 < <8#  "  +" ! (   " 

"  (+  

 # "    ( " 2  F +# " "  !(  (    ( ! "(    (   "

  +# +( "  +"    #: # !  % (+ 

#  !          "# 

"+  !    +( '%   +

#!  !

  "#!(   #  ! !   !( +"   +

7!

# # (+#  %   " %   %"

#      

""+ !(  (  ( !#!     " %(

 (+ " #  !(   (  (+ 

 ""

 ! "

! +

    #!   " " + 8 #(   (" %   + %  " "#  "(  

(+ %   +# +# +" " 

( 7!

#"   "+ ! % (

 ( (+ #    #+ "  %  %(

   "#>

          #  ! "    " D +  "  H #   " +     8  (     ""

 8(
 3 ""+*#

   8(
 !

  = #  + ( "   (+ #  %   %"

#" " "

"  "   

+#!   +" #!  # " "   # !

 

  (+ " 

# "       

+ %(

 " D    "   !   #

  "#(+ #   "  !    



+ (   

" "      "      (# !    " D        # 

 8" 

  "(+     #!  %      -!  0# (+ 

>     ;   #         

     " ! 

    

+# 

    #  "  (   "

      %#  !

#  !    % +    %(

 #!  ( !

(%+ %"  ""  !"+



  # "   %
"$

""   "#14$#" +  +#!   %     %(

  "

 " %# !( (  "  "

# "  "

 

  (+< <8#  "

(  "% ( 

#  >

!    "

 !( 

(+

 

(  # "

 % # !

#  "% + : (+!+ "



"

 (+  "  "#>

! 

  "+

 : !(

(+   !

  #  %  %     #!  +     #( "   %(

 -      !  +  ""

0#    +  

"     (+    

  B & # +  % "    "

!  #

 " "+"   " 

  % (



(+ " D +#!   "

! "#!!( "% ( 

8  (

7!

#     "     " "    

     

  %     " "#

 + %   #" D +" "



1

   %(

 % "

  #

! D  "

    

  " "

# "% +   :  (

(+  !



 #  "#8 + 

#   8   

 # " "% + : "



"

    (+    

        "   "#   

 "

! +( (+ +



"( " "-!    0#

   #+

 % (

(+  "( " 

#+ !( "% ( - 

  " "0 2$

6   ( %#

  #% 

  8  !



  

" "% + "

+( (+

#

 % (%

3%  % 

# !

#

 !  (

( % (+      

"(+ " 

#!  

( '%   % % 



 "! 

#



D     1

2 #  !     +  "   !         #" + 8 (    #8(
 !

     =  - "

       8( 
 3 ""+*0#    !

" 

 "" % (

 (+ !

! +  (+! "(  %   %"

 #+"

 + ! D (  (+  "

 +  

 "( 

""+% % ! "    % (

 (" %  !

 "!  " D +#+    ("

"

   +  +" ""

 (    %   %"

# +"  ( +  "

" #  "

+(+ "# (      8(
 !

  +(+!+( "#!    %+  "   #! "        (      ! +      !     (+     

7!

#

 (  (+    # 

A     # "  (  $

2 :

!2 !,3!40

5)+


   



  I 9 6 

( I 9