← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5182/2016dismissed

Surinder Singh v. Amar Singh & ORS

2018-12-05Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

 

     

 

!"##$%&%'(#$#)*#+, -+%'.#+%'/0 11#22!'"

3#+&-& )!+%'/0 "0#+&  #&1'.#'"&  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

+#&#'"( +!"%'.#+%'/2!,.4$!"#, +"0#!11#22!'" 55555  *)+%,' 0#1+#&#'" #/-2!+#$'.11#!2%&.%+#$"#.!""0#%'&"!'$# !11#22!'"6.##'.!'"7,800!&'"*##'&-$$#&&-2%'.##'.%'/"0# !11#!2*#+#"0#98#+11#22!"#-+"1+##++#.*:"0#12!%'"%&!/!%'&" "0#;-./)#'"!'..#$+##"0#"+%!2$-+".%&)%&&%'/"0#&-%"

#&1'.#'"612!%'"%&%'&"%"-"#."0#&-%"*:&"!"%'/"0!"'"0# *!&%&"0#1#+)%&&%'/+!'"#.*:"0#98#+11#22!"#-+"4%.#+.#+ .!"#.<<!&"0#1+#4%-&&-%"$2!%)%'/8'#+&0%1'"0#*!&%& "0#!.4#+&#1&&#&&%'0#2."*#'")!%'"!%'!*2#,+#&0&-%"8!&%2#.8%"0 !11+1+%!"#1+!:#+'"0#&!)#$!-&#!$"%' 0%!)=!-+,1+#.#$#&&+6%'6%'"#+#&""0#12!%'"%&,8!&8'#+ %'1&&#&&%'2!'.)#!&-+%'/*%/0!&*%&8!&$)1+%&%'/=0!&+!  

6 ,  7 

6  !2'/  8%"0  "0#+  2!'.  &%"-!"#.  !"  3%22!/#

!2!&-+0#+!22:#>$0!'/#.2!'.)#!&-+%'/*%/0!&8%"0'#!+.!) %'/0&' !+"!1%'/0,&-$$#&&+&6%'6%'"#+#&".##'.!'"&<!'.

 !'..#2%4#+#."0#1&&#&&%'%'$#"0#'!+.!)%'/08!&%'1&&#&&%' "0#&!%.2!'.!&8'#+!+.!)%'/0+!22:#>$0!'/#.2!'.)#!&-+%'/

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

+": :#!+&!'.%'"0%&*!$B/+-'."0#)!""#+,.#$2!+!"%'8!&&-/0" ##'.!'"  &  !'.    11&#.  "0#  &-%"  !'.  +!%&#.  "0# *;#$"%'$'$#!2)#'"!$"-!2!$"&,)-$02#&&''6;%'.#+!'.)%&6 ;%'.#+   "0#  1!+"%#&  "  8!&  $'"#'.#.  "0!"  "0#  1!+"%"%'  1+$##.%'/&

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

&#1!+!"#8+%""#'&"!"#)#'"& "0"0#1!+"%#&2#.#>"#'&%4##4%.#'$# +!"%'.#+%'/2!,2#!+'#.$-'&#2+#1+#&#'"%'/"0#!11#22!'"6 .##'.!'"&-*)%""#."0!""0#98#+11#22!"#-+"$))%""#.%22#/!2%": !'.  1#+4#+&%":  %'  .#$+##%'/  "0#  &-%"  '  "0#  1+#)%&#  "0!"  "0#  "+%1!+"%"# !/+##)#'"*#"8##'"0#1!+"%#&0!&*##'1+4#.'!$","0##'"%+#!11+!$0 "0#98#+11#22!"#-+"8!&*!&#.-1'&-+)%&#&!'.$';#$"-+#& !)!*!'.%#&> ?"> &08#.0%!)=!-+8!&'""0##>$2-&%4# 8'#+%'1&&#&&%'2!'.)#!&-+%'/*%/0!&*%&8!&$)1+%&#.%' =0!&+! 

6 !'.7

6 ,%#,"0#!22#/#.2!'.#>$0!'/#.8%"0 !+.!)%'/0*-"8!&$6&0!+#+-1""0##>"#'"C&0!+#,"0#+#+#, #>$0!'/#*%/0!&*:0%!)=!-+.%.'"!+%&#!)!*!'.%#&> ?" > &08#.=0!&+!@!'.@!/!%'&"=0!&+!& !'.

7,"0-&,%'&-$0$%+$-)&"!'$#&,%"$-2.'"*#1+#&-)#."0!""0#2!'. =0!&+!&@!'.@8!&#>$0!'/#.8%"02!'.=0!&+!& , 7!'.?!'.?8'#.!'.1&&#&&#.*:.%#+#'"8'#+&

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

+#)#'"%'#.+#4#'-#+#$+.,!& 1#+1+4%&%'&#$"%'??"0# -';!*9!' #4#'-#$",$!++%#.!

1+#&-)1"%'"+-"0!&"0#:+#)!%'#.-'+#*-""#.##'.!'"&0!4#'"*##'

 !*2#"*#2%#"0#&"!'."0#12!%'"%&"0+-/0!':.$-)#'"!+:#4%.#'$#

+"0#+#!&'&&"!"#.!*4#,.'"%'.!':%22#/!2%":+ 1#+4#+&%":%'"0#%'.%'/&+#'.#+#.*:"0#98#+11#22!"#-+",80%$0!+# *!&#.'!11+#$%!"%'.$-)#'"!+:#4%.#'$#/+-'.+%'"#+#+#'$# %&)!.#-",)-$02#&&%'424#)#'"!':&-*&"!'"%!2D-#&"%'2!8

#&-2"!'"2:,"0#!11#!2%&.%&)%&&#. / 01,    *)+%

023 '(/4& +353267 82

 928

+353 51!

928