Bhagwan Singh v. Ludhiana Improvement Trust Ludhiana And ANR
!"#$
#" %%&& '() *)"
+,%(-, .() "( %
/)(, &
#"
%%&& '() *)"
+,%(-, .() "( %
0( (&(1- ("%%&& (/( $&1- ("(%
!3"
4)#, 1
"&& %1 )$"
" (,
,, #(53" &( &("%( ." %&
%%&&
" #)&( %%& #
"
)((
# (( -535""6)(5&$ ."%&
%%&& 7
#&&, "%&) ( " #(38* & %& 0( 9!""6)("-) "" %%&
& 53 " %%&& $ ( %(
3( %%(:
,&3
5"" 1"((1 ,5(()&;"
0) 45.$ +,%(-, < & = * &&, 0& )&1
>"(
(5(((8?
>)&?91() (
!
"
#
$!
%
$
% &'() *
% '+ ,
- .
/
0
%
0 % % 1
2
% 3 $
/
%
# %
/
$!
5 5
% 6 %
%
$
1
>
%
6 %
$
#
3 7 # $
0
0
6 8 9 /
'+ , :
%
"
% :
6 %
0 1
1
7
9
#
3 7 #
(" 9
"
2
% /
; 3
/
% 0
# %
/
$!
55 0
0 ! $!
;
% 7
9 .
/
.
/
9
3
/
# 4 %
/
!
. 4 -7 7 <
= * 0 .
2
# 1 4 $
/
!
!
"
"
# $
% & & "
'
#
( ! ) * 9 + + >& + >& 9 + !
&+ !
?
9 + !
(+ ,
!
9 + !
)+ ,
!
9 + !
'+ ,
?
%
7
7
+ 6 (0
7
&
6 ) 0
7
(
&69 !""6)(5&$"-"&"%()&; 1 $ 5& #(3(8* & %& 0( 9%%&3("%&
@(, $ "
%( >3((,"7
#-("% " & A) (53".()+ "%( 1 %)"" % " & $ 7 -( 53 " +,%(-, .()
; ."
6)(""("&( &("%( & #" $ "" (5&
# "()#""4)#, %53 "6)(5&$ -( )4)#,
53&( &(" %( + ,3 5 "
" %( 1 " A)
%(
#$(
53 )
#
) ( >" 0) 45.$ +,%(-, .()
."* A)
6&& (
" $( ;
" ,1 " /-( , " (, " )& ,&3 < & = * &&, 0&53+,%(-, .())&1
"(
(5 (((8?
)&?9%()&
?
)&?18* & %& 0( 9,35&&%&)%" = A)(3( ("&5 B$-(1%( )((%%&
$ & $ ?
)&?$()5 )53"/-( , 53(,
#" ?
>)&? %()& ?
>)&?1?
)&?$((%& )& ?
>)&? :( ) ( +
#0 @ : - .
% 9
0 4 AB'
6;
)&;?
>)&?"&(35 :( 5-." ,
(&&, %&$(#)&53)&
?
>)&?1 $"
" :( ) ( 8 ,
$ 0
&$
7
0 / C3C
/ C#C
6 (8 &
7 0
7
"
'+ 46 )+ 46D (+ 46E &'+ 46' &+ 46) '+ 46( + 46 %
7
+
6 ) $
0
+
/ C3C
"
%
0
0 '.
0
0
)
6 E9
!
!
'
# 0
$ ;6 B.
0
1
69 4
(
#)&;1
?
>)&?1
&("?
)&? :
, ?
>)&?$"
"
$( $ " (,
>B
1 %%&
) ( ?
)&? )&5 &(" ( , ?
>)&?
5-1)&; ?
>)&?%(- "" %%&
(&&, 5,$ "
>3((," 7
#-("% "& A) (53".() &&)("(1 )&
"?
>)&?, "-(3%( $"%%&
(&&, %
#) ("&)&"&&&5(A) (%%&3 ("(&&, ) ("?
>)&?, &31
"%( 1 " %&
%%&3 ) ( " ?
> )&? $ "
" , %( ( 5 *( & ( " %%&& $"
& (&3
# )% " 4)#, %53B C5&")%(,6)(
-
.+/
0
# 3 1
) 1" " &3 &31"%&
%%&& )& 5
"&&, B"(((%( "4)#, %53 B C5&")%(,6)( ()&(
#"( 4)#, 1 %%( "
"(" "6)( ($ "?
>)&?"
" B C5&)%(,6)( -("
&$ "", && )("(1
" ( 1 " %%&& $ % &3
B
1"( 4)#, $)&"- %%&
*( &")("((& )% "4)#, %53 " - !
""
6)(
" 4 5
3 2
6 7!
-86 9:
;;;/
<... ()&:,
"( 4)#, 1
#
%%( "" "6)($ ($ "?
> )&? *( &")("(($ " "6)( "4)#, %53" - !
""
6)(
-86 ;.
..9/
7 5 3 2
6 7!
/
=.9..: + "
1" - !
""
""% ( "%%& ("%&
"3(
$"+,%(-, .() $"
""&%-("&&, + " 1(& $#( " % (
"( *( &("%%&& ")("((& )% " 4)#, %53"
6)(
-86 +.=
./
,
3 2
6 7!
/
.:..+ "
&1" "6)($ ($ "?
>)&?." 6)()("(
""%%&
"% "( , 3
"3(
""(" 1&( &("+,%(-, .() "($ " "6)(" - !
"4)#, "
6)(
" >7
5 4"
3 2
6 7!
-86 =
..;/
=..<1 $"(
( (
#&&")&(,53"/-( , (, , ,1 " 6)( "& " " A) $ ) %( ( %(,)&# ?
)&?5)"% (%%& (,("
3( A) "& - (%(,)&# ?
> )&?1"& $ ( &3#( #"( ( "3"- -( #"("&&, "%& &3("( "" (& A) (."(&- ) (%() ) ( 9 8
(E .
FAB' 4 F
&
+
FAD( 4 F60 +
60
+ 6;
&&)("(1 $&&&" &&, 5, $ ") )
#-( ,
-
#"%%&
(&&, " %&(,&&%( $"(& # 5&+ 5
3-( , 1" %%&&
7"&&, "%&$ ")# -
#%%()
3
, &(&3 )%( ,% *( & ( " %%&& " )5, " " A) "& $ "&& # *0 &53"%%&& $ , 1"((1"%%&& $$&&$ "
"
( #",-
%%&
"(( +,35 "") $( &
"3( %( ")(3)& ,&3?
>)&?1%%&
$(A) (5 &$ "
%( "(3((,"1"% $7
-(53"+,%(-, .()+ "%( 1"% $ 7
;1"((1",1"%%&
)&5 & $ "
%( "(3("( )%"3(
@(, ()&(
#")&1 "&& #" A)
%(
# %
3"& # "
1 : "& , ( &
#%%&
(&&, ) (")& + - $"( ) 1"( #()
(( $ ""
)((
# (( -535""6)(5&$ !""#)&( %%&( , &&"%
#, && )%%&
1 31(& %1
- $"5- 4)#,
!
"
% #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0