High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2500/2018disposed of

Fauja Singh & Others v. State Of Haryana & Another

2026-02-04Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja11 pages

!" #"$

!" #"$ %& ' %& ' %& ' %& '

& !

2. 2. 2. 2. & & & & & & & &

&..* &..* &..* &..*

? "$(

"$(

) ) ) )

(

( 66// 66// 66// 66// ' ' ' '( ( ( ( 6 6 6 6 !* !* !* !*

+%,$"(

! -(

+%,$"(

! -(

+%,$"(

! -(

+%,$"(

! -(

"$ (./$.0(12 #3.(.401 5/01 5.(301 2. 5.$.01 (3..$.01 3/(&.//01 66//7/2 8.$.0& 0 9 (56:0(1 2. (.:01 3.-501 6 CCCC "$0$/ "$0$/ "$0$/ "$0$/

-( < ). .33085 E45/.66/0 ./ 2.4.1 1. .:54 4308.4.// 66/1.

.5 33=5...7 2.1/1.4../ =5. /2 > 81.90 8.4> 3

; < %9 29 6 66/0 / //4 8 /. 2 2

@689//& &..$540-/. A !5B 8

;F< % . /9.40.6 0/35.4 E-/ /.5 2..15 1.

.//40 %D0 ./ 0&.. -/038=5.1 1..

.55(.D? ,=5...0 ED A ED B6.1/9 658/. 6563/9 I . 2 . >22 2689,=5.. . !// A ,!B F

0 89 3..4 3 > 1/5GF

7H6 / =5.566 2

33.- -/H

7H68.2

33.- -/H0 //> >. /8.02

// 59 8 8 . ./5.4

K /.5 53 ../ 35 K 636 6.2//59 9. ;D< &.

H. . 2. 2 6 6 89 , =5.. . !//0 66//7/2 .1> 5 (.

ED02. 386/9//289 / !51. . 2

@0 2./ 4.4 3 36 . GDD0 F0EEF F7H6 /2.2 2.5566 2 3 3. -/H FE0 F0EEF7H6 3..4/ 2.2.589 6 2 33 3. -/H 44.1 06 66/26 . / 22//6 <

654.4 .20/ (.5/6 .4 66//7/ 2 583. / !5 2 2 4 1.4>. 514/6. / E

I#J?7%0 ?

I#J?7!

IHD , ( .

5/ 583. . 1.2 / / 20 / I36/ .4 .4 /6 6.2=5.8>. 5,(.5 /

5583. 606 / 6/ 3- ?D77

?7 2 /. 1 1. / I36/ I#J?7% . > 538 1 1

3 6 =5./ , ( . 5/0 5583.

..4 89/ !5 5224

/6/ 3 3.46 /I36/I# #J?7%2/ 29 3 =5./ 50583.3 >1/5..2 2 =5. 8 :54 89 6/.4 /. 5 56 I#J?7% /90 >.414 /.I#J J?7%0I#J?7!IHD , (. 5/ 55 583. I. .

.3 46 .I 3 82 / . I#J?7% .

...5 55(.D ED .6. 3 E

0 50 5.8/ 6 66.. 1 / 6. 6 .1 3 3./. I#J?7%84 . 15 66//7/2 < , (. 5/ / 6. 5 >.4 . 5 446./ / . =5. / 2 . 2 :5 85.4 / 9 1/6 . >02/ -/HH-. / 0. 6/21.45.

3/ ./6./14 0 506..6/ 8/.49328 66/. 50583. 3>1/5

=5./2=5. 8H5.

3 8. 66.. /. E

I#J?7% ;?< 0/(. 5/6.4 > !33.0 0 583. 6. 1 1.4 / 6 /

3.46

/.I#J?7%2 29 3=5./0 / !524/9>. .../ .

656 H3.. 3> 1/5 /583.1 .

./. I#J?7%28> .505.8/52 8.362 3// .1/1 1.,(.5 / /6.5 =5.//:

:/9I..4 . >6 6./ 8.4533 3./../05 26. 66/9.4966.. .34682 / .I#J J?7% .

.. 5(.D ED . ., (.5//583.

..4.1 2 2 .//4/.9. 8/.493689 / !5 ;? , (.5/ 56 .5 6/ I36 6/

IHD 2. / / 15 1.// 4 0 0D-/ / / 2/ ?F0 0

7H2 2. 8 6.

7H 6 2 6 89 , =5...!// /2.52.35 5 /..6. . IHD0 0 532 =5.4. 15 66//7/ 25.365 54:5432/.8/8 .2 2689,!2= =5.8 ;@<

1 / 5/ 6. 4 54 668>2 2//

.58.583..

38/ 66//7/2 ;< %

6.4 50.398 89> / 743 //65898 ..1. ./ 3.85/ 3.I5* H

(/74 (/74 (/74 (/74 3 3 3 3//65896 //65896 //65896 //65896 66//7/2 66//7/2 66//7/2 66//7/2 ( ( ( ( & & & & I.8. I.8. I.8. I.8. ).//4 ).//4 ).//4 ).//4 35 35 35 35

/ F

/ F D

43 // D D

43 // #J?7%

F-/E/

0?0

7H #J?7! E?-/ E/ 0E@0@ 0F F7H #J?7& F -/ / F0?D0

7H #J?7 " F -/ / @0@?0

7H (/65 (/65 (/65 (/65 58966//7/2 58966//7/2 58966//7/2 58966//7/2 I.8. I.8. I.8. I.8.

6 6 6 6 . . . . & & & & (/ (/ (/ (/ !..

!..

( ( ( ( #. 6 #. 6 #. 6 #. 6 ).//4 ).//4 ).//4 ).//4 4 4

H ( / F D

0 0

H?-H

0D H ( /

FF0F

0EE0EEE F HF ( /

F@0

HD-H

D HD ( /

?F0 0

HD-H

; . .0 . 39 8 /1 > / . 65 5 89 6 IH IHD 6 8 1 3. 8/ 0 / 6. 6 . 3 IH IHD 4 82

/> /> 6 . 82 6./

$5 5

5 3. 5/ 0/

IHD2. 83./9/.5689 960 0D- / /

/2/ ?F0 0

7H2.86.

7H 6./ .3 .36. .

..5(.D

ED2. 2.5

. . 210 66//7/ 21/6/ //B6..4 4 9

F0 6 2. 3..35 53 .I 656 693 3 36594.. / / // H-/ /2 .IF

7H6 ..36/. /

IHD2 6 .1/5// 0 0. /6 .13>1/5 / 6...3 30 5 3 2 8 . 8 . 45./ . 656 3.. 3>1/5 =5./ ;E< 5 065/ 53 91.65 89 66//7/ /2 . 3 I#J?7& I#J?7 D

/ /92.53 3/943// / . 2// / 43 // .5 /.8/ 1.

.4 3 3> 1/50 5 8 > . .. .0 21 I#J?7%I#J?7! 4./ E

6.1/908 .4315 1.//4 50 . . 1. 3 6. / 6 /

3.4 6

I#J?7% 6. - ?D77?7 3. FH =5.// /36.6. - ?D77 7 7 %6 / 0 5 55 58/90 .5 . / 6 I.3.9 2. . / / 3 (3 E ,=5...

ED ./896 3/1 2. 6 =5. / 8/4.4 /2766 //

;E <

5.5306 . / 3.46 - ?D77 7 7 =5.03 8/8/ 2 29

3/6 6/ 3.46 /. E

I#J?

?7% 2.1/ /6/36. .- ?D77?7 3.FH

1.2 .0/ !5 52242./.4 /6/

3.46 / . E

I#J?7% 2 2 / 2 9 3 =5. / 1 1 2.0 6 53 1./8/ 0 / . E

I#J?7% . / .4 .4/.. //31 5 1.//4 4 L 5 8 /. 56 656 3.. 3>1/5 /5 =5...06.//92 66. 8 . 89 6 =5 45. 8 8

. / .1/.

.. /.

5 0 . 538/6..

. !50 / !5 1 2 24 1.4 > 14 / 6. / . / ..I#J?7%0I#J?7 7!IHDJ.6 / .

IHD . /9 8 . 6.46 :5433 8845. 8 ./ . 656 3.. 3>1/5 =5./0 ./.. / ..1/2 .I 89 !// 656 693 36 59 4.. /./1 .. /9

F%.. 0. 1.2 /2 /.289 B8/6I !5. 3/)(

3/)(

3/)( ( ( ( ( 9 9 9 906 A DD!!.1./

DD!!.1./

DD!!.1./ @ B @ B @ B @ B0/. .4 .4/6. 8>.5 656 3. .

3> 1/5 =5. / 5 5 2 / . . I#J?7% I#J?7!0 / . E

I#J?

?7%

.4 .

4 / 6. . .4/9 9 . 8.4 8 / I36/ /1 1 646 @ 3 3/B

3/B

3/B 56 I5 *H M @ @

.035 35/.6// 3//6/0 6 8 1./8/ 1 1. .3.4 36.

. (. . /4/ .36.3 ..4 5 / 0 /4.

4./ 64. . 36 . .3. 6 25/ 8 . .

935.8// 3..43>1/5 58 8=5/90 66/9 =5 5 5. 3 /5. . /5I3958 5. 2/-2:.

2/-2:. 2/-2:.

2/-2:.

5 1 ( 1 ( 1 ( 1 ( ( #5:80

(!! ( #5:80

(!! DF DF DF DF 2 . !5 /. 2

// /2* N ./2 1/I36/2. .3.//0..4/ 5/.4 I36/ /0 .

... ...8 ..08. 6J/. .8.4365/./9>29

3 60../ .41/52..3.//. //.9.21 .8 .. .822.//.465 2.//.4//85 .3 =5...N

.1.28..

.( .33(.41( ( .33(.41( ( .33(.41( ( .33(.41( #0 #0 #0 #0

F ?(!!FE

F ?(!!FE 2H:5 548 .!5/. 1.

.56

.3..

.53235/ .6/ / 1./8/ .. 0!5///9.4 1/5 /5I36/5/6. / //2..240.2. / /5/.414 1/5 .3983455O

< 6 / I36/ I#J?7%0 / 35.4 F -/

E / 2 / 53 0?0

7H 8 6. 6 2 2

7H H(.8.34 6 /3 ?382

/ E

I#J?

?7% .5 .

.. 5 (. D ED .

0 5 66..G

K65382 2186.6 .1 3 3L2.53

7H6

4 . . 89 / (. 5 / 6.4 65.8/ 5.=5.866/. /6..1 3I#J?7% E

L3.1. 3 . . 6.0 0:/ 6 0 / / I36/ I#J?7% 6. / 35.4

-/ E /02.89 .34..084 ..1 /1.4 3//6/ /

1.2 . .53 2./ 5=5...35 E-/ / / I36/ I#J J?7% 6. F -/

E /0 5. 2 3// .1/1..2.

< 5 30.=5... .6. 658 8/. 6563/9

I. 2 . >36 6 8/> E- / / /8 =5. .6560 6 . 5

9 / 2 6.353 5./.P. =5. / . .5 I6.5 2 61..4 .. / . 55/ 3.. /.> 6>0 4 8/ 0 335.9 85./. 4 052 1/63 8.36 10 . 39 8 . / =5... . 6. F@0 -/

/3.. 3 3 368/> >//96. 3 .6/I#H 50. 8.65 .12.8/. =5./

6/ . / 3. -/H H-./ /. (

.4292 ./ .429/8 5/9 I..41/6 6 . > 530 66.. 53 9 1.1./8 8/. 3 /

.589 5..6/ !3 33.0 0 -/2. 261 89 #J JH

53(.40 #2.0 />0&. .-/I#J

7 / .

.. E E@? 61 I#J

7 89 #J JH

>-530$ $0!00&..- /0.88/. 3 6. =5. / 3 6 5..6/ /.3. 0 36.. 4/ EE6 03:.9 =5./ // . 4/?

?D EE3./904 4/?D85( .42 29 /.4 3 -/ 2 4/ EE 3 6 5..6/ /.3. 15 1.//4 1.2 . .530 . =5. / . 5.

3 /./ 6 ./ 14 . 50 8/. 4 93 6 89 / !5 8/8:5.

. .4/90/2 /./5 5.

33>1/5 .

=5./ F< .4/90 3> 1/5

/ 5 =5... . G

7H 6 .

..0 /2 // / 8 ./ 2 // 59 8 . . 61. 5 61..

.4 . !36 . 69 . , =5...0 8./../30 0

F /2// / 8./ /.53GF K8.2

.56 ;

D< ! =5/90 . 1.2 .

.5. 3 . 810 66/ 6 . 66// 7/2 89 6 /9

//2. .366/ ./8960 5 .3. J 1 /2 7 1 5 5/9 I6. . 66/7H 8:. ./.4 /4/.18 .36/0 9 9 // 8 /.89 > I 5. 6 .. 89 31.4666 .66/..8 / I5.4!5 ?< // 6.466/..0.

90 ///.6 -( "$ -( "$ -( "$ -( "$ $"& $"& $"& $"& 8 8 8 859 59 59 59

D0000

.> ?

? J J ( 6>.47 ' 68/ ' 7 7 !53 38 ( FEF

FED

F FE?

D FE@

? FD

@ D @

E @

E ED

E !538

F D

? @ E

EDF

E EDD

E ED

E ED?

E ED@

E ED

E EDE

E E

E 859 859 859 859

D0000

.> -( "$ -( "$ -( "$ -( "$ $"& $"& $"& $"& ?