High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3847/2015dismissed

Mahender And ORS v. Jai Chand Th His Lrs Dharamwati And ORS.

2016-05-09Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh5 pages

!"!

!"! #$ %

&' &'"

## ('")"

*!& " &' )+&&!",+,&!'"

! $ % # -'" # '.-'/"&&'.%0 % ' & '

() -'$'! &!"11,! ! !" ' ! ,$ $"

!,!+ &11, 2 ' &'" ". ! ! &11,! ! %3&! &!"),$ ")11 '

4$ &!0!

& ,'/ & )",% 11,! ! !",, 3 ,$ $"!'

!,!+ &11,"

&,,+! &!"11,!" &5)+. '1"" 4$ &!0!,*)+*)! ' !0!"! 2'!4 %3&'4$

'1'. !5) ! '"

'!!+ "' .

''!+! &1 ),1 """"! !"! ")!

$%". ! ! 1,.'/3!

'"6 72 "& 3!' , )'"!

) &8!')./!8&!'!4!'

(!,,+&!/&1)'%9&"!,6,,4+'&% !"

2'!4%" !,! ")!

&'' .'!"!+$ "

') ! 0' $%!$ .'%&"4 '%11,+!"

3&! &1'''4$ "&"4!".!""4$ &!

! , !"

*)+%2'!4 :

!" & ! &,' )", ' "

" 4, 3&0 1' 1',$ 11' ! &1,!+" 0! 4' )+& ' ' ; ""'

" & '!+!, 3'" ! 1 """"! $3'</&5<$/.%3&! &3"

'.!+1'

,4'!+=&3 >>%3&! &&4 1)' &"4$ &.! 1) ! 0!", '

!! "4'!+

),$!"")4$&4!,!

. %8)'+ </&5<$/.? ) +',1 3'

'$!0 )' !"

9& !4!+ &+',1 3'

'$& ,'? ) ", 4'!+

.")'!+ ',"!0 )' ;'1, "

%",

,.")'!+@ .'," ! 0 )' -'. !+&% 1' "" ' 11,,

11,,

%",

',.")'!+@',"!0 )' +,

9&1 """"! 3"," & 0'% &)"%

"4 . &4" ,) 3'"!1 """"! &!'

'"1 !0"&'" 0' $: &,!+& &"","%!

11' 1'

! ),''3"" , &.4$),$) & '!A1'" ; " 1,%"!,4$ !"%!"B)!

!' ' . $"!

!"?!"

!+ &"1 4 )"

&4 )'!" $ ,,$9&'!" ). '$ 0! 1' ) ' '4$$ &1'

!""& 3!+1 """"! 0'

$%3&! &%.!

,$%!"0 ,9&!!+"% &)"% ' '4$ "4, 3 ")"

!"'0 4"

!""'0" 4!".!"" :&0 "!' &")4.!""! ".4$ &,' )", ' "3!

&&!"""!"

%&0+ &' )+& &!.1)+ 5)+.

!" !!"1) & 3'"!1 """"! , & ,% 3&! & 3" " , & '"1 " 4$ !"4$3$ &'!' ","%''' 4 0% 3'</&5<$/. &4"!" 3 ", '

!! "!"")4$

&&4!,!

! 1'

. %8)'+ %&0!+41)' &"4$ &.! 1) ! :

!"," !!"1) ',!'!"1) &"'!" 3<$/.</&5 "! &1' "" '"

" & &'"!%.,$%-'.

!+&%&'!+&%+,!+&%

%51,;'1,<$/ . ,!.&!.", 4 & 3'

1 """"! 1, .")'!+ C?

C&"& 34 )'!" &1' 1'

$%" !,!7?- 9& "! .1' .!"%3&! &&"41, ' '"7?-

&!'"

. "'7?- &'")!

3"!,4$</&5

")!

3" ' &4"!" .1' .!"%5)+. '

&' '7?"- - &"

. &1'

!"!"7?-

% 3&' & "3' &"."! &',!'")!

%.,$%-'.% &'% +,%

% 51, ;'1, 9&$ & .!

"" 1,7?-D > &$' !

&!'"

7? -

</& 5 3" 3' 1, .")'!+ C?C "3' 3'" 1, .")'!+C?C :

3"," 1' 0!

&'3" 1""+4)

!+ &1, *!& !%3&! & 3". '*!&%</&5 & "9&"!

1,7? -D >!" ' '%3&! &&"4.!

3&! &&"! .1' .!"! "!

1,% ,1,

*!& '"1

!!""& 3 & '

&"!: ")!

," % '"1

!!" ,!.!+&!.", 4 & 3'!1 """"!

0'$1, "!"11' ' . &',!',!"%

" '

&!'1' "" '"

%3& 3'1'

!" &',!',!

!+ ! %3'

3'"!1 """"! &!'1' 1'

$%3&! &3".")'!+C?C%3&! & 1' 1'

$ &$'"

!,,!1 """"! &)"% ,!.$'!+& 0'

,%3&! &!" &' & $9&!!+"%"' '4$

"4, 3% &)"% 4), 3!

9&!!+"% &)"%' '4$ "4, 3'4" )1 1' 1'11' ! ! &1,!+" &0! 4' )+& ' '4$ &1'

!"3&! & ,, '$! '' &'1 ! &"4'!" ''+)4$ & )", ' 9&'4!+ )'' !!+"' '4$ "4, 3 & " & "%3&! &&04 ) 44" 1' 1'

11' ! ! &1,!+" &0! 1' ) 4$ &1'

!"%

&'!" !,,+,!

$! &!.1)+5)+. "1""4$ "4, 3

9&'!" ")4"

!,B)"

! ,3! 11,% 3&! &'B)!'" "!' ! &!" )'

:0!3 &4 0%!!+ .'!

! 11,% "."

"!".!"" *+'& (