← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3861/2015dismissed

Rajinder Kumar And ORS v. Jaswant Rai Etc

2017-02-15Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi13 pages

   !  

"#$  $%&'&()  * 

          



           ) +, -,.

     



   -,. ,     !

 

  "     "!    

    







    "

    !

  

 #  

  $

     "!



% &  '()*

+*, -



!!   !

 

  !

 !

 

 "$ "

  

 "  "$ 

!!

      

  $  "



  $  .

  "$ 

/

     

  

    "$ $

 "$ 

!!    0



 "! 1  %  &  *2)(3+(,+44)  

 "$  

   +

   !       .

  

!! "$ %

$ 

 

1    

!! "$ %  

  *44 $ " 5 "

  " "

   $ !!

!!!

     "

  " "

    



     

    5

  $ *6,)7,2    

    $ +44+74'         

1 

!!   

    "

 0 "

  

   !   

 

              $    &  0     !       '42*668  "

     /

  ! 9  ***+*626 

1  

    



& *  $ &    +6,*668 #   /

  ! 9  *6***664 

    $ 1  

7

& *     ***6(4   /

  9  *46*626 



 & ,  (    0     +4'*66) # /

 9  +42*6(, 

    

 & ,  ( 1 

&    *+++44,     "  !  

 & +  8 :  $  

 "  



   $ 

 ! 

!!   

     

       !   

 

!!

 %

$      

$  

 

!!   

 

 



 &   

    

    

!!        !

   "$ 

 

  "$            

!!   

 

  

 

  

  *44 $ " 5 "

  " "

        $ *64'7*648    : ;     .

  

   " $ / &   

  "

  

    "$ 

/

 

$   .

        

  

    "

   

  /      $    !

      

     



     !        !  

    :

   

     !   

 

 

 "     $     "

  $    

 

  

     .

  

  /  $  $    !

      

     

 

 #        " $  "   

 < 7

!!  ! "     

/   "$ 

!!       

!

   !

    $ "  

7

!!    $    =



!

  

   

 !   7 * 9  

       $

>= + 9  

  

      $

> = ' 9       !$ ">=< 8 9       "  "  > =< ,  ?

%

 

    "$ $

  

 "$

!!     &   7)883+(2+44) 0





  

 "$  

   ,

   !    ! '+

  "

5   

 

7      

$  "       "$  

   

!!        .

  

!!     "$ %

$ 

  

1     

       

 !!

!! "

   

!!  ! :   

!!    .

  

$

!! 

      

 

       

  ! 

%

$  !

!!

      ! 

  @ !

!!A 

1  :   "!  !    .

  

!!



  *44 $ " 5 "

  " "

  



"

 .

         .

   !  $ 

!!

$ "

     $ "   !    /     

 !    .

      !     $        $  !  ! :    

   !

$

  

  "     $   

 

   "

   

  

 $

!     $ 

 

  .



 

 *8)+44)        $  "    

$     < 7

!!    <  &  *  ,          "

   &  + '8  2      $  

 ! /     8(+446 #     $         

!

   

! 

 =



!

   

   

 !   7 * 9  

  

    "$ $

  ! * "! *) "

$     

 "

>= + 9  

 

      $

> = ' 9  

 

 "

7    

 $ >=< 8 9  

 

   "> =<

, 9  

    "$    



!    > ) 9  

 

   ">=< 2  ?

 "

  "

    !       $    "

          

 !$ 

   

         

   "$ "

    "  



    



"

    :   

     5 "

         

$      ! 



    !

! 

!     "

!  

  

  

  

!!7

  7

     &  *2)(

+(,+44)    

     

!!  

  1   &  )88

+(2+44)    $ 

   

!$   &  *2)(        &  )88

    "$ $

       

   !      *,+4*+ <  

  7

!!

      "! 1 **6  **67 0       "$   

 

 !       +4*+4*, #   !

 

    

!!7

   # 



   < ! 



!  $   $

      

 

!!  $

*

!! 

!!

$

!!      !

    

/  

 !! 

 

!!        !$    "!  "  

 # !    1

     

  

 "

  

  !    !             "  B 

    $    %

$

!!     

  

1  :  

 

$

!! 7      

!

!!7  

1       

!!7%

$  !!

  6 0

    "$

!!7  "$ $

   &  *2)(3+(,+44)   $  "



    "$ 

/

 "  $    

  '4 $ 

!!         !         "  

   =    "

    "$

!! "$ $

   &  )88       

$

!! 

  



!!  

/    " -  

    "  $

  

 "               "$ 

!!   

    "$

!!  !$        !        " 

       "

  5 "$  1

 

   

 !  

 # C" %   1

    

7 #" % = 5   +44) : @%1A )() @%1A 3 ;     D<1 ;   +4** : @%1A +4)4 @%1A %   $ $  @ A "$  ; *66+ @*A  *'(@E#A 

    %    +44( @*A 1 @ A ''8 @E#A ;   %!  & %! 

! #

%! @B0A : *684 ;  84* 0

  !    

    

 7

      ! 

  

    D    $       

   /  

        ! ! 

 "$    

   *6  +*

   !        "      7 F 

                                       !"#$  %  &

   

  !" #!    '!()  *+ (!"   ,     ,  -   .!.!(. *+ /  %  0123!4!5!60

23!     (

7  &%%  7.7        

8   

 & 

         % 

          

  -  9  512!4!:,)0 2 !  .;

7  &%% 

(             <

, #%   

 

, !=,  >            

                                  ) <

, #% 0 )# %  >   /             

       1  ?=    >    

 *+ /"  >        

   @    1          1  

   

   %     !"       != "      )   % !

<  '!

;

 )  *+

;!A      

 &  ("!0!       

!!    

 



        !  B  

  

   & 

         !     

       

@   !A  >  

!

3 

  1 0 ) # #%  

 

 1 #  0#%  ,  C 9  "!  !C!  C    !  & 1 C  

 +

!

&    )  

   <

,    #$ #% C:$  &        #$ &  % 01$  &   

    @ 11 

   

   %     !#  <

, #$ # 

0#% , C$  &  1       

        !

#  #$ & % &C$  &      

              #$ #  0   #$ 0 )2# #%    ) #$ )  2  #   #  %     C  :$

  ! D   

 

  ++   ++ 

!"  C!8+     @!  0               !

 

            !                    ;+;7!           

 @     &C$  &  #$ & %   

   !C   %     !  #   %  &   '!C"+ 77           8                    )    !"

  % & '!C"+ .       

   

@      !!               !"  %  

 8 % &  '!C"+ 77        

  % & '!C"+ .

   !"                     

    %  +     !

 # C" %   1

  #"C  @ A   

!!

$

!!  !  !       /$

*44 $  

 !      "$  # C" %   1

  #"C  @ A  # C" B  0 



  

C  @ A  

!!   5    $   "

 "  

$

!!  " !

   "$ 

!!  $    # C"  0   

C  @ A 

       "$ # C" B  0 

;  #! 1

 & %!C  @ A : 

  " 

 "

     

  "

  

!!7

  

     

!   

     $   "



    "$ 

/

$ " 

!!7  

   !         '4 $ =    

!!    "! !

$

!!   $

   

5  $       *44 $   "$ # C" %   1

 #"C  @ A     !$   "$ 

 "  :  

 



 "

  

 ! 

 "$ 

 "     !         " 

      B$  .





   " .



  "  

 "$ 



     $ " .



  "

 

  "

  

    .

 

 !  !

 

    

 1

  / !      %  *44

 1

1  

  :  !   "      

 # C" %   1

  "12"("("3$(41"("(4 "(#5$16',$7'582"13&(&"(4#5$1'9 0 %&:&;

 "(#'5"<"1&6' =1'5##"8&>"1&9   *0 &

 !

   !  

   

 

  "



     

    1

 

   "

    

  "

  

 $  "    

  &



    " 

  $   "

 "    "

  !

 

         

  

 -,.

  *,++4*2 1&  A18F8'  A * F8'