High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/43614/2025allowed

Virender Singh Alias Mp v. State Of Haryana

2025-08-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

''/A) /A) /A) /A)'.6 .6 .6 .6 ! "#1&"% ! "#1&"% ! "#1&"% ! "#1&"%, ,& )> , ,& )> , ,& )> , ,& )>-.6 .6 .6 .6 6 6

B* " 5&,& $!! ! "#!$ B* &0"

% & % & % & % & %'

8( * 8( * 8( * 8( * ( ( ( ( * ",!5!-5"1! #"

0 "* *0!+9,7! :!3- !$!!* ;;;;;

;;;;;

(

(-*<

(4 -*<

)* & 0 " !&2#3, 1 ">/"# !! $!

!+,!

!+& !! !-./<#"& " = 84#" ! "# ,3!2!3 "

0 " 1!&2! "*>>! )*./*.6- & #" "##1& 0, & !23 , 1 " )6 <

4 "# !1" 1 , & ! &$1 " "01 ,2& !1&1 -)?>6<#"& " =1 84<1 "C'"# 1 !

! 3! "4- ! "31 ! "

$ ! !2:!3- & 1 &!* * !5!7"# ! "& !& 0 "& & !11,&"#2 5"35! 0 !

"1 5"35 >693"

" /6 !7& "# # "! 0"& !33 3$ 1"5 #"7 1"'!11,& "# 0 "-!7 73$-!@ !7!9! !! !7

9! !* 0 " !&2 "7! & 1!&- " 2!&& "# &1 13"&, & ! 7 "# !"

1"'

!11,&-!7 73$,& "-:

":!&'

,7031! &1!&"

&13"&,"# # !#"&!1"'!11,&-!73 3$-!@ !7!9! !! !7

9! !* /* (!1",&3#" 0 " !& ! 0 "& 1,& "$ & &1 )>*.A*.6* (! 1", &3 !& #, ! , 0 " !& &2#!3&3$7031! " D,& "*(!1",&3

!& ! ,

7!! "$ 0"5&"& & "# 1 !5 "

&1,0,3",&3$ 21"703: -! ,&-

0"&1, "1!&&,##&#"7 7 # 1 &*(!1",&3 !&#, ! ! !&&,7 ! ,"-

0"&1, "

"5&"& !+ "21"1 070"&1, "51 !5!3!23!

!& 0 "&&13"&,& & ! 7 "#1"'!11,&-!73$- ,& "-:

":!&' ,7031! &1!&-" &13"&,"# 1"'!11,&- !73$-!@ !7!9! !! !7 7 9! !*(!1",&3 !& #, !

0 " !& &,## 1!1! " #" !2", . 7" &* ,& &- ,3!2!3&0!$#"* * (! ! 1",&3 !&"00"& 0& 0 "2$! ,

! "&!&!

!& 0 " !&",&! ,!- ,&-

"&" &5 1"1&&""#

,3!2!3*(! ! 1",&3

!&#, &, ,27 & ! 2!303! &2!2$ "&"#1 " /C"# 1 -! ,&- &!7",

"2&7&&*(! ! 1",&3&+& & "03!1"1"1,& "$1 #1! ! )A*.>*.6-:

& !+"1"

"* 6* !5 !1",&3#" 5!

!30! &! !5 " ",

!5!3!23 1"&"# 1!&*

A* 0 ":!&!& ")> >*.A*.6-:

-5& ! " :!& 1! ", ! 1 !33! :!& 0& " )/*.C*.6* " !3 6 6 0"&1, ":

: &&& !521 -2, "

" !&2E!7 33! * * 0 " !&27031! !&!!11, ,& D,& "&"33$ " 2!&& "# &13"&, & ! 7 "# 1"'!1 11,&- !73$- , & "- ":!&5 "35" 2!&&"#&13"&, "#"

1"'!11,&-!73$!@ @

!7!9! !! !7 9! !#"7:

"&0 0"&&&&" 1" !2! :!& 1"5 * & 0 0"&1, " 5& &"- & " "

7! !3 !5!3!23 " 1"1 0 " : 1" !2! E10 #" &! &13"&,& !

! 7 * &0 ""

! &,1 &13"&,& ! 7 &-

!2&1 "# 1""2"! 5 51 "3 37 5 !$ 5!3, ! 1!" 2 &"

"3 2!&& #" 7031! 0 0 "* 3!1 " & ,&,2& ! !

& ! 7 !&& &",& ",2 & !2", #!&& ! "2@1 5 $"# 5& ! "* &" &0, 0 ":!&"

0& ! &0" * 5!1 $!:

D, "2! !1 " &13"&,& !

! 7 7!2$ 1"'!11,&:

:332#,33$ & ! 7"# !3* 5 5!31" "&!&! ! 5 & "2! !23&&,&-:

& !332! "

1! ,0", 1",&"

# !3* & ", "&" 7 7 !00"0! "350 " &5!31" "&-! && !

-3& 7!$ 0@,1 !3*"

! 23 !&2 2",

#":! "1! 3+3 """#

0 "!2&1" #"7

0"1&&"#@,& 1" #

: 0"& 1, "51* A*)* &@,1 ,- :",32!00"

"& "# "!@, 7 0!&& 2$ & & ,3!!!5&,& ! & ,3!!!5&,& ! & ,3!!!5&,& ! & ,3!!!5&,& ! "#,@!2 "#,@!2 "#,@!2 "#,@!2-0!&&

A6.? A6.? A6.? A6.?'. . . . <.6% %..)?>4- :

- !# 3$ ,0" ! "

" 1 "#

@, 7 & "# "823 ,07 ", "#!

5&,& ! "

"#!73!,- ..,07 7 ", 66?F7 *!@7,& !- 2,3 !7

!7$! (!"" !0, 5 5&,& ! "# ,@! - !1" 1&

" "3 , !,- . ?.F ! 2$ < < 4 !3,, 5&* !33,3!2 7!7 7, !G*8-.<)4

< 7!34CAF!@!$

5&* * ! "

"# !$!!- 2! 01!3 ( (!5 " 00!3 < 3*4 "*<&4 4 )AAH./- 1")C*.6*./- !& 3

,&% IA*/ & ! :33 & !23& 0103 "# 3!: ! ! 1"#&&" 7!2$!1"'!11,&,1 " AC"# 1 & 3$!

5$:!+01"#51*,1

& ! 7 <&4-2$ 7&35&-1!"

#"7 &"3 2!&& #" 1"51 1 " "# ! 5,!3 ! 7,& 2 &1, J : , 7"& 1!, " 1"@,1 " : "

&,2& ! 5 51*""5-"1"5$ !& &2##1 #"7 0"&&&&""#

0 "-:

" !&2&,2&D, , 3$7031! !&!!11,&&"33$ " 2!&& "# &13"&, & ! 7 "# 1"'!11,&* ":5- !& ,3!2!30 !& "3#!32 $"#5,!3- ", &!"23 ! "& +!2!3!12 :&!# ,! 0&"!332 $!&, ##1 5 !7& ! " "# @,& 1 !& !3&" 5& ! "* #!3 5 !$5!3,!!7&&23 $"

&13"&,& ! 7 7!2$!

1"'!11,& #!33 : "7! "# !3 ", ! ! " 2 !@,1! , 1",&"# !3!11"!1: & !23& 0103&"#3!:*":5-:

3!@ @,1! !03!#" ,3!2!3- &

", 1!" 7! "235",& "

11,7& !1& , :

0 " !& 2 !! " 70 7031! - 13, ! , "# !33 ! "&- 513+ 0 0 " " "##1!&:33!& &01#1"3! 2, " 0 " " 1"77&&""# "##1*07!#!1E!7! ""

&#!1 "&&&& !3 "&, -!2,&"7&1 *K

0"1&&"#3!:&" 7&,&

A** , - & ", 1!& "# !&:

!3!& 9!3!

!&:

!3!& 9!3!

!&:

!3!& 9!3!

!&:

!3!& 9!3!

!!!! 5&,& 5&,& 5&,& 5&,& ! ,@!2 ! ,@!2 ! ,@!2 ! ,@!2 0!&&

''//C?

//C?

//C?'.6 .6 .6 .6 6 <.6%

%.>?)A)4 !& 3 ,&% I)* & ! &D, , " !2 0"& ,3! &7 % <4 <4 2!303!"7 &F "# )?>6 5"35 "##1<&4 1 " C' "# ! #"

D,! $F & && !33$ D, 1 "/C"#1 * <4 ",<&4"#1 "

2!303!<&4"71!3 ", E 1$13, !&" 1* <4 ",<&4"#1 "

2!3&&",

#""!11 13)"# "& , "

!& &,## 3" ,' !3 !#"33$ "#&" ! 2, * : 1" "& 1" ! ! ! " " 1

** *H"!$"

!0 * : 1" "& 1" ! !1,7,3! 5! ,! !D, "2&! &##" * " 1"&! " 2$ 2!3

1 "/C<)4<24<4"# #"235 &" , <4 2!3 7! !3- 13, 1!

0,0"&"#!@,1!

<4 ,1 1"&!

,3 " "11- &

&1, $D,#"!

!@,1! "G1,37 <4 3!<&4 "# # 13, 7! !3H"1 3""+ "2$ 2! 03!* * "1"&! ""# 1" **= &" 3+3$ "1"77 2"5'&! ,7! "- #"33":

&01 "#! ,1 4 , 1 " )? " 1 " " #" "##1<&4 5"35 1"771!3 , " 7 : ",<&4 "# "/C"#1 "" !003$ "!

<&4- 72!3"!11", "#!$ "#7&"#!13"&#!73$3! 5 "/C"#1 0!3 ""235" 1", "#3" 1!1! "5:"# "#!**:

2!3'!0031!

3 1,& "$- !3 & 0"1!& !

, !23 "&,1 2!3'!0031! * 1 " /C<)4<24 "# 1 1" "&H0!!7 & 1" ! 0031!23E ! 3!:* 1 " /C<)4<24 "# 1 " !3 ! 5**2"

1" "& !2!3'03! "2&,11&&#,3*

", "# 1" " & 0,3! 1 **I !!&"!23 ",& 3 $"#&,1 "##1K% ",

" &# ",

!33 35! !&'!$- E13,&53$ #" 37 &,1 2!303!* ! "- 1"1 !&&&&7 "#

",3 " 7" &!7 "# !!1D, !3"# !11,&! #!3 ! ""# !3* #1 2$ !0031! '!11,&- # !$- 3 1,7 & &,00" "#- 7!$ 2 !3'

", :

3!@,1! &,1 2!3 "& 0,3! 1 "/C<)4<24<4 4 !$"##1:

3"2!38%

<4 :" =3 D, !7"& !

"## 2$ 2

" 1!3"-!&"

2!3'!0031! * <4 #!1

! 1 &"# ! ! , "# "## ":5- 5"35 H"

"##1 1"13,&""# &0"0 #, ,* <4 2!3'

70"& ,0" !00 :",3&,27 -! &,1

& 0,3! 2$ ", 1"1 01!3 <,&1 "!34 , ! "- " ##1 1"77&&""#!$"##

#!1 &"#! 51!

21"& "2&, ,7! 1 " * &" !&!$

"# 0": 2$ ! ", F :

1" "& & 0,3! 1 ,0" @,1!3 &1 " !11,7& !1&"#! 5 0"&&23$23!":!& ":

&! &#!1 ""#D,7 ,

!& &":,D,#!1 &H11, "

2, !, "0!!5"

@,1!3 :&"7 ! &1 7! *K +3$8 ",

" 2 0 !& !23!&,2& ! !30"2!23 $"#'

2!3'!0031! - !

! ! 7 "

", 1!01 #, ,1",1 "# '

,!37! E"#! 51!&13,

2!3'!0031! -"3!&12 " 7- #1 ! D, " 2 35 "* 57 "# 2!3'!0031! !"

* 1!" 0&" #!1 " &,3 0& $#"1"77 "##1 7!$- ! 7 "# ! 2!33- 031! '!11,& ! 1" "

,3! 70"H 5!3!&7!$ , ! 2!3- ! !##!5 2#" ,

", H33!D!

1!3 & ! H1"1 "31 !& " 2 5"35 ##1!# 2 3!&"2!3* !&-70"& ""#&,1 1" "7!$ &,##1 #"&! &#!1 ""#1" " /C<)4<24<4*

! ,-7"!E "#E1&

3 &! &#$ &3# ! " /C "# 1 F & !33 0 E1& 2$ &,1 ", #!1 & 1!&*"E !,& 5 ,3&1! ! :",31"& , 0!!7 &#" ,1 "/C<24!&5$1!& ,7& !1&*!+ &,1 !! 70 &

",* "- &&&,&2& 3# " " "# ", !3 : &,1

A*/* &5:"# 7! -

"70"&,1 "/C"#

1 1 & !&3, * C* &01,& "$1 #1! ! )A*.>*.6#32$ 3! ! 1",&3 3- 0 " !&!3!$&,## 1!1! "#"!0""# .)7" ! 6!$&-G&" & ": "2 5"35!$"

1!&H * ,##1 "&!$-#, ""

0 "!&!, !3& " :!! #!1 &!11,7& !1&"# 1!&*

>* 5: "# !2"5- 0& 0 0 " & !33":* " & " "2 3!&" ,3!2!3" &#, ,& 2!3H&, $2"& " &! &#!1 " "

(* 1"1 !3 H, $ !

& ! * ":5- ! " "1"

" "& ! 7!$270"&2 2$ 1"1 !3 ", H, $ & ! -

0 "& !337!2",2 2$ #"33": 1" "&% <4 0 "& !33" 7 <4 0 "& !33" !

"1,7 !$-, <4 0 "& !33" !2 &',& 32 $ ! * !70: !$51-"!3" !3* 2& 7&3#"!$! 2#"

!3* <54 0 "& !33" 1"7 <54 0 " & !33 0"& !3 ", * <54 0 " & !33 5 5& ! ##1H

& !33 " 1 ! & 1 07&&""# !3 ", <54 0 "& !33" <54 0 " & !33 &,27 77 !$"##1:

3"2!3* & & 0!&&0" - # !$- : & 1330 " ,72 "

"#1"1"31 ! "! 33'0 " ,72 : ", 0" , H33!D!!

& ! * !$7! $ "3!$ !3* 7 - " #& :"+ !$ "# 5$7" -!!##!5 - " ##1 !&"

!$ "##1 !# 2 0 "&#", "2 2 3! "2!3

&!##!5 ""

:&- #" : - #" 1!133! " 1",&-& !332! "1! 2#" 1"1 !3 ", - 25"351"77&&""# 3!& " 2!3* 1!& 5"35!$"##1!# &

0& -" 2!&&"# ! &7!! "7"5- "# & 2!3 :

03!- 2, "# ,0"7 & "#* ?* 1!& "# 2!1 "# !$ "# !#"&! 1" "& ! "& 7!$2 270"&2$1"1 !3

", H, $!

& ! !&1

!2"5"

",0"& ": !$"

&,##1 1 1!,&- ! H1"703!! & !332! 32 2 $ "7"51!133! ""#2!3"

0 "* ).*

!11" 3$* ))* "

&! !2"5& !332 21"& ,!&!E0&&""# "0""

7 &"# 1!&*

)* 1 7! 1!& !& 2 1- 0 7&133!",& !0031! "-# #!$-& !33!3&"& !&&0"&"

"##* , ,& )> , ,& )> , ,& )> , ,& )>-.

!5 L &0!+ L 0" .6 .6 .6 .6 < ( ( ( (4 H!&"% &H" !23% &H"