High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5314/2016dismissed

Bhajan Kaur v. Buta Singh And ORS

2018-08-20Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill4 pages

"#$ %$&'(')* + + ,"-")."/0 11$22")# 3$0(/( /#"')4,")%#,$0( $(1)%$)#(

0$($)#* 0"/0"5,"06"7%5&"#$ 0#,$"11$22")# 88888

11$22")#912"')#'

'("440'$5$% -/%46$)#(")%%$&0$$(%"#$%

+ 1"(($%:;'5'2 /%4$ /)'0 '5'(')7"0)"2"")%

1"(($%:; '(#0'&# /%4$7"0)"2" ,$ "11$22")#912"')#'

'2$% " (/'# 0 1$06")$)# ')-/)&#') 0$(#0"')')4#,$%$ $)%")#( 06$)&0"&,')4/1)#,$2")% #,$12"')#'

0 0"'(')4:/)%"0;<"220&)(#0/&#')5$0#,$2")%')=/$(#')0($22')4#,$ (1$&'

'&>,"(0")/6:$0<'#,/#1"0#'#') #,$(/'#101$0#;#<"(12$"%$% #,"##,$12"')#'

")%%$ $)%")#(<$0$-')#<)$0( #,$101$0#;6$"(/0')4 ?.")"2 "02"")%#,$12"')#'

<"(')$@&2/('5$1(($((') #,$101$0#; ')=/$(#')6$"(/0')4 .")"2A"02"(#'( /0#,$012$"%$%#,"##,$"0$"') =/$(#')'(<'#,')#,$0$('%$)#'"2B)$")%'(&(#2'$0#,")#,$"40'&/2#/0$2")% ,$%$ $)%")#(90$(1)%$)#(7'#<"((#"#$%7<$0$#0;')4#$)&0"&,/1)#,$ (/'#101$0#;7<,'&,<"(')1(($((') #,$12"')#'

7"##$61#')4#%'4#,$ :/)%"0'$( #,$ (/'# 101$0#; ")% 0"'($ :/)%"0; <"22 ")% &)(#0/&#') #,$0$)#<"(12$"%$%#,"##,$%$ $)%")#(<$0$#0;')4#($22(1$&'

'&>,"(0"

)/6:$0( /# #,$ (/'# 101$0#; <'#,/# ($$>')4 1"0#'#') #,$ 2")% ') =/$(#') /'# <"( 0$('(#$% :; #,$ %$ $)%")#( ) #,$ <0'##$) (#"#$6$)#7 "5$06$)#( ) 6$0'#(7 <$0$ %$)'$% #,"# #,$ 12"')#'

9"11$22")# <"( ') 1(($((') #,$(/'#101$0#;#<"((#"#$%:;#,$%$ $)%")#(#,"##,$;,"% 1/0&,"($% #,$ (/'# 101$0#; ) 06 ,"))" ')4,7 /0&,"0") ')4, ")% "0')%$0 ."/07 <, <$0$ ') $@&2/('5$ 1(($((') #,$ (/'# 101$0#; # <"( /0#,$0 (#"#$% #,"# #,$; ,"% "20$"%; &)(#0/&#$% :/)%"0; <"22')#,$(/'#101$0#;")%<$0$0"'(')4&)(#0/&#'))#,$2")%')=/$(#') $12'&"#')<"( '2$% 06#,$12$"%')4( #,$1"0#'$(7 22<')4 '((/$(<$0$ 0"6$%:;#,$2$"0)$%#0'"2/0#*C E,$#,$0 #,$ 12"')#'

( ")% %$ $)%")#( "0$ -')# <)$0( #,$ 101$0#;')%'(1/#$F

E,$#,$0 #,$ 12"')#'

'( ') $@&2/('5$ 1(($((') 5$0 #,$ (/'# 101$0#;')%'(1/#$F

E,$#,$0 #,$ 12"')#'

'( $)#'#2$% # #,$ 0$2'$ 1$06")$)# ')-/)&#')"4"')(#"(10";$% 0F

E,$#,$0 #,$ (/'# 12"')#'

'( )# 6"')#"')":2$ ') #,$ 10$($)#

06F E,$#,$0 #,$ %$ $)%")#( "0$ ') $@&2/('5$ 1(($((') #,$ 101$0#;')%'(1/#$F E,$#,$0 #,$ (/'# '( :"% 0 6'(C-')%$0 ")% ))C-')%$0 )$&$(("0;1"0#'$(F A $2'$ G H$"0)$% #0'"2 /0# <,'2$ ,2%')4 #,"# ))$ #,$ 1"0#'$( <"( ":2$#105$#,$'0$@&2/('5$1(($((')5$0");1"0# #,$(/'#101$0#;7 %'(6'(($%#,$(/'# '2$%:;#,$12"')#'

11$"2 '2$%:;#,$10$($)#12"')#'

<"("2(%'(6'(($%:;#,$2$"0)$% '(#0'&# /%4$7"0)"2"75'%$0%$0%"#$%

440'$5$%#,$0$ 06710$($)#"11$"2,"(:$$) '2$% H$"0)$%&/)($2 0#,$"11$22")#"04/$(#,"#)&$'#'($5'%$)#

06 #,$ 0$&0% #,"# %$ $)%")#(90$(1)%$)#( <$0$ #0;')4 # &,")4$ #,$ )"#/0$ #,$(/'#101$0#;7(/'# '2$%:;#,$12"')#'

(,/2%,"5$:$$)%$&0$$% ")%')-/)&#')40")#$%'),$0 "5/0$12"&$%0$2'")&$/1)#,$-/%46$)#( 1"(($% :; #,'( /0# ')

! " #$! %&'( )%* + ,' " -

.! %&&& )/* ) *(& ,"5$ ,$"0% 2$"0)$% &/)($2 0 #,$ "11$22")# ")% ,"5$ 4)$ #,0/4, #,$ '2$ "( <$22 "( " &1; #,$ 12$"%')4( :$ 0$ #,$ 2$"0)$% #0'"2 /0#7<,'&,<"( /0)'(,$%')&/0##%"; # '( )# ') %'(1/#$ #,"# :#, #,$ 12"')#'

"( <$22 "( %$ $)%")#( 1/0&,"($%(,"0$(')#,$(/'#101$0#; 06#,$'00$(1$&#'5$5$)%0(<,<$0$ "2(&C(,"0$0(,$"11$22")#912"')#'

1/0&,"($%,$0(,"0$ 06"0/')4, ")% "2<')%$0 ')4, 5'%$ ("2$ %$$% %"#$%

,$ %$ $)%")#( 1/0&,"($% #,$'0 (,"0$ 06 ,"))" ')4,7 /0&,"0") ')4, ")% "0')%$0 ."/05'%$("2$%$$%%"#$% #'()#')%'(1/#$#,"##,$5$)%0( :#,#,$1"0#'$(<$0$-')#<)$0( #,$101$0#;')=/$(#'),$'0(,"0$( <$0$ )# %$ ')$% $5$)/$ 0$&0% @

# @

0$5$"2( #,"# #,$ (/'# 101$0#; '( ') 1(($((') " )/6:$0 &C(,"0$0( ")% ))$ #,$6 '( 0$ 2$&#$% # :$ ') $@&2/('5$ 1(($((') "); 1"0# #,$ (/'# 101$0#; H$"0)$% :#, #,$ /0#( :$2< ,"5$7 #,/(7 0'4,#2; ,$2% #,"# #,$ 12"')#'

9"11$22")#'()#$)#'#2$%#')-/)&#')"(10";$% 0"4"')(#&C(,"0$0( 04/6$)#( "%5")&$% :; 2$"0)$% &/)($2 0 #,$ "11$22")# '( #,"# #,$ %$ $)%")#("0$#0;')4#&,")4$#,$)"#/0$ #,$(/'#101$0#;<$5$07" 1$0/("2 #,$&1; #,$12"')# /0)'(,$%')/0##%";0$5$"2(#,"#'#'(#,$

&"($ #,$ 12"')#'

,$0($2 #,"# #,$ 101$0#; ') =/$(#') <"( " &(#2; 0$('%$)#'"2 101$0#; ,$0$ 0$7 '# %$( )# 2'$ <'#, #,$ 12"')#'

9"11$22")# # /04$#,"##,$%$ $)%")#("0$#0;')4#&,")4$#,$"40'&/2#/0"2)"#/0$ #,$ 101$0#;')=/$(#') #,$0"04/6$)#,"(:$$)0"'($% H$"0)$%&/)($2 0#,$"11$22")#C12"')#'

'(/)":2$#1')#/# "); =/$(#') 2"< 6/&, 2$(( (/:(#")#'"2 =/$(#') 2"< <,'&, 6"; :$ ')525$% 0&)('%$0"#')')#,'(0$4/2"0($&)%"11$"2#,#,$'61/4)$% -/%4$6$)#("0$<$220$"()$%-/%4$6$)#(0$)%$0$%" #$0101$0"110$&'"#') ")%&)('%$0"#') #,$$5'%$)&$)0$&0% .$$1')4 ') 5'$< #,$ "&#( ")% &'0&/6(#")&$( "( %'(&/(($% ":5$7 % )# ')% "); ') '06'#;7 '22$4"2'#; 0 1$05$0('#; ') #,$ '61/4)$% -/%46$)#( ")% %$&0$$( %"#$% + ")%

1"(($% :; #,$ 2$"0)$% '5'2 /%4$ /)'0 '5'(') ")% 2$"0)$% '(#0'&# /%4$7 "0)"2"7 0$(1$&#'5$2;7<,'&,<"00")#");')#$0 $0$)&$:;#,'(/0# ,$0$'("%$2"; + %";(') '2')4 #,'("11$"2.$$1')4') 5'$< #,$ "&# #,"# #,$ 6"##$0 ,"( :$$) "%-/%'&"#$% ) 6$0'#(7 =/$(#') %$2";') '2')4#,'("11$"2,"(:$$)0$)%$0$%"&"%$6'&

0$($)#"11$"2:$')4%$5'% ");6$0'#('(%'(6'(($%<'#,) 0%$0"(#&(#( )

* 1 22 #%&%&'3 (,<"0 4$#$! 5$6 7!$ $"89$ 7 4$#$!!$5!# $89$ 7