← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3952/2015dismissed

Maru Ram Through His Lrs. Sadhu Ram And ORS v. Banwari Lal Through His Lrs. Munna Lal And ORS

2019-05-20Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

  

     

     !

"!!#!

$$%% &  '( #%!

"!!#!

$      ) 



*!+'!, -(!



!! ,-  !$$%%



 #  , -(!

 .  ,-  ! $

////  '

%+,! !$%!



  $ !

"!!# !

! !

0 !

1  (%%!

.  2 ! !

  ,%%  !%% !

,0 % ,! " !!2 "!  % "!

'( #%, !

"!!#!

#%!

#%3,  #%-

   )-3"! ,  '!"(3((%%   0 %-3"! $    '!!+  ( $!45!   2(!! % $ *!(0 66*!0 *! 0 66788

 $ 9 2 !+  : 0 % ( $!4;%! !%  "

2"! 72( $ *!(0 <:*!0

:*!  0  88  ,

88  887*$ 9 2 ! +    ( $;%! !  "< ;

+ 2+- =%%2 "0 7

::

  !     !       !

>!!   2 "

0

7  ! 0 6  ( ",  %%"%,  %%    -    %2%    2        

$% 9( $  $ !2+>!!  2+- 2%%0 <:

!2=%% ?! !$%% - $ 9  "!     ",%"  "!! "- ! +;

$ !- !$%!

>!! ((

$!%  " 2( 2"! 72( %!$%!!(("$" !  "< ;

+ :;

2+- % 0 7

6@!!(%("  @! 0

3!

'( #%!

>!! ( "$ %+ !- %* !! @!!

>!! !

"!

 

"  '- ! 0 !  ! !2 "!    %! @!>!! ( "

(!!$%,(!( %*" ! @!$%(!!

 ->!! 4=%%

::- ! $%-(!!!2;!!$ +!$% ;%! @!>!! <

@! !!! %%(! -%"!      !     >!!      !  2     %  , %"!4=%%- !$%,! ,!  %%"%%2%2@!!$%!

;! ! % 2!+ , "-" !$%%!

!$$ %! (     "  !       !  $%  "  -  %  +29@!%%""! 2%+!,% !$%2 "! +!-"

 ! %!    ,!+!!$ + ;!9.A %+$  +$ +@!>!! ( " +!%(%%" %*@!>!! %"(!!!

( *"!%22@!!+ ( %-"9%+@!!%  " 2"!%72( $  *!(0 <:*!0

:*! 0  88  ,

88  8%7*($ !  ! 9$% B!

 "%(%$ !  !  $%@! ! $ !"!  ,%!  , 8(

< *  !)   +C$ --%$ '*,0 %@! >!! (!* ! %+,! ,- +!"( !! ,!(- ,! (2+%%! %+  2 >!! @!>!! ( "(!! %+ ! %!!!$ !!2+- % 0 7  

6@2;%+,  (! (      "    !  ( "  ,  !+  (     %-"

$ %+  >!! @!>!! - 4!=%% - !$%@!>!! (!-"": +  (2%(%! ! "!  ($ @!!=%%(( ","%( %    $ @!1  !(!=%%-

(! ,!(- ,!%(! " !! $(  +@!!=%%( - 2 "  @!  %!%- " "4=%% (!!(%!(!!(  8 % @!! ;(4!$ $%  , (!! %$$ 2 ! -%,! % 2(!! @!!$  ( $;% ! !$ +%2+>!! B!!   % $ !  !(   ?! ,!+$ +  %!$! 

%

$%(%2+!$% - "! !!(  (!   "! 

 !$% A  !$%"!$ ,%%("(   

 =!! !$% 4%-( $! +,$%!$%D ))

=!!    >!!    4  !  -%  =%%   

::- !$%,,(!D ))



 =!! !$% %  %% !D

)

<

=!! !=%% "2 $%!(   D )

=!! !$%!-%!D )

=!! !$%!-%%!D )

%

?  $ -! ,!$%!4 )=% !*1  ,)=.  ,)=!#%,)=<E$%1!, )= C! , 1$ ,)=69"!," +C% *, )=792 "!

" C% *,)=:F ,)=1  , )= E2 )=

! ! "!%*,G4$  2  "  

  !  !  !,  !    !  4   =

!#%,=!2 ) !,=B C!,=<0!%,= !  "!,  =6  !*  1!+$    =7    #%  2  "     ! "% % !$ ,! %C 

6   0

 < " ! $%    -  ! ,0 6"!$%- !   %%+,      !  $%  (     (!   % !(%%(% "! (  $    !  $ +    ;    -(    !     ! !!!$ +>!! (%-%- $!%"%! >!!  (!%((!!

! ,(!!!2 $ 0

!$%! +(!!!2 $ 0

 !!% 4 !(!!(  8 % B!( -9"  



 A%"  ""

-  2+  !    9"      ,  ! $%!%$$%!C  >",0 %,(! -9"  6   ! 

%%%"2+!9"  $ 2+!C 2%(,!$%!-**! !C  2+(+%" "% $$%$ +"!! 2$, ! $"9"  $2+!C 2%(2  

"" "% $$%,! $ !-$$ 2 !C !

"!%

?!-! % % !$ 2""

!

"!!  

B!    " -2+% 

% !$$%%(!!4!=%%(%+

7 -!  2" "  ,$  $ 4(!,!(- ,!=%%(( "%+ 2+ !C 2%("  2+!C 2%( $ -  2$$$ -  ! !%$ -!!$ +!>!! ( % +

=!   %     %  $$ "    !

$!-! %+!"  2+!C  2%("!%2(!!9" $2+!  %C A $$%%C @!!=%%$2+!$% ( "!%+ 9!  $!9" $ 2+C 2%(2+(+$!$$%

 ! "!%  % !$  ""!

"!!  ,?+ "

(!! -   "-  2+ ! C   2%(  9"  !  =%%    $  2+ ! $%  %+ ! !!=%%!$$2 "   , !%"%-% ,!"!   " ,$  $ 4  2 (

.(- ,!$  $ 22% 6:!G- %(!$ 4  ; 2+%(2

 =%% (!! ; 2 %(

B!$ -!  ; 2+%(2 ,!%%2-%"( %!2%% !$ $$ -"4,! 2"(%-,29!$ !C 

:   $2%    "-"  -  B! ,  !  $%  (

; 4 "(!=%% )=1   '  !$2*!>!! (!%$$" !4!=%% - !$% !!!"8! 2  *! =%%$ !"(!"( !"8! 2  *!=%%!$ !!

!  ; 2+%(, ! !!!!*( (!!  >!!    !  4  !  ! 2   $     !   .! ! 4 ! $(  +(4- .  

 , $ $ !=%%( $ !  4!=%%!>!! (! ! " (2%+!"

?!(+,! >!!  ( B!=%%22$ -!2 !+$$"( =! "  "(!=%%!

1 !,# 2  ,!! !$%!4 !E$%1 !)=<,2 ! +!" !!

)=!#%,  2!=%%! ! 4 !!  *( >!!  $ %%+ 1  ( %  *(! $ %%+,! !$!%$! $% !$ -"4!=%% B!$%

 ! 4 )=792 "!," +C% *2! $2*$ (!!!"(  $ % %+(!!! ! 4 ! !  4    "  (  (     *(    ! $ %%+ B!  - %$  

"

!=%%,(!!!-22+!C 2%(@ 2"

!  -(!

>!! ,!!

'( #% "

"!   0 %( %-2!   !=%%2!  !%"-"+  $ -"!   "-"+! !$ +2+! @!   -!!=%%G4 ) 

! 2 $ !8>!!  ,!$%!4 )=

!

! ! "!%*,  G4$ ,!(- ,!!$!!! $  !! 2 $  " =%%!

>!!  

::(!!  %0  <

6   (! !!*(! 2 $ !

>!!  * ,!(- ,!%G4 )<( 

+%+! 2 $ !

>!! ,(! ! ! (!!

!-,(!!  !$

$     2  2%  B!     4$   4   2+  !  =6!

!*1!+$!"-!$!  $ ! 2 $ %2 ! 2  $ $ $ 2!>!! !=%%(%%

   G4 )( 2%

 B! $ 2* !$%!

  ($ ! "

 ,(!!(  !2  %    2  !      +  +!"  (!  "    !

>!! !-"4+=%%- !$% *"    "        !  2    !  =%%

B! ,*$"-(!%+!  ,!=%% $2+!$%( "!%+ 92+! %C  !"(  2+%  >",0 %

#  >",0 %"-"$  "

! !%!!$ +;!2 !2+!

>!!   !9. %+, ,! 9. %+$ +,(!!% !-22;!2+- =%%

#  % ! $$%% 

  ! ,     2"    

            

          

   !"!#  $ , (! (2 -!=%% ; 2$ -2+ 4 ""(% ;  6:

  !  G-    .(- ,    7  $ -  !    ! "(  %%!4!  ,4 +2$ -2+! - B! ! +!%$!!$$%% !!



 !"(!=%%!

 3)=!  !" !=%%!"!!!! *(  !

  1 !,  #      !      *(  (!!

!

>!! !4!! 2 $ =%%G4 ) 

! 2 $ ( % +! !

>!! ($ ! B! , !  ! !$%%!-$2%+*  7 

!$ $$ -"4!=%%

# % !$$%%!%$   -!  %!&     % !'

  %!&  

(

   !"!#  )   !# 

    %  $$)



2!$$%!    !4 (!!!2 -!2 

# % ! $! 

! + ! #   #*!+!!,-

$)./!" 0!#

.,(! (2 -!!"! 4!=%%($ -$ "

C% ! $2+ 

"!9" 2 !! (C 2%(-(!-2+!$ !-

 

"!!4!=%%($ - !"2  (!2+!C (!%! "

"% $$%$;%  .!



    ! + #!  1!##  /2     /&

  1 !34 ,-

$%2  5$ (! 



"- $  ,(2 -!(!  % " 2 $  ,!4=%% ($ - A  ,% ! $$   -  !  / ! 6    %7       ,- $.$%2 .8,(!!%(!$   $$% ?(2 -! !!$ -

 %  2" B! 9   $$%!"



",!(- "

!



+ 2 0 !!!"! $$%% C 2$   +- *+!% " >"!."!C ,!! ,9    $$%(!!""-2+!  $$%%C 2$$$ ! %-- ?  !!690 !   /6!!690 !   

$$.

(%2    

(!%%"(!$ $ 4=%%,(2 -!(!( !$!!%%"=%%("2+!!  !!!! ,!4=%% -

#   %    !  $  %  

   !     2  %!&          %    %!&

%2    (58, :, !    %%   ! #&#2 !"    ,- $8 %2 

8$  1&!

 % 

    :!%!& %!!   & &#2 !"    

.

5%2    ( .$$ !

02%;%( !$$%

 " ! % !,(!!! 2%%(2+!A $$%%C !!2!%%"2+ !$$%%$%2+(+%"$ $$% 0- !% !( "!%+%%(  B! ,?+  !$ $$%    +    2! %"%,-%  (%%   9" $2+!C 2%(

B!$$%  "%+

  '

9  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#