High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3953/2015dismissed

State Of Haryana Through Collector, Narnaul And ORS v. Bharat Singh

2016-01-06Mrs Justice Sabina4 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* ")+",- ./

")+",- ./

#"#$ ",-")"")%#0$,( 11$22")#( 3$,(+( 0","#')40 $(1)%$)# * * * * 56 56 56 56

,$($)#*

,$($)#* ,"+,"700+)#"/ ",-")" 88888 88888 88888 88888 /

/ $(1)%$)# 0"% '2$% (+'# , %$&2","#') &0"22$)4')4#0$,%$,%"#$%

/90$,$7-/0$9"( ,%$,$% # 7$ ,$4+2",'($%:"7(,7$% "4"')(# #0$ 1(#

6"7+,$, ')(#$"% ,"&#, %,';$, ")% #0$ ,%$, %"#$%

./90$,$7-/"11$"2 '2$%7-#0$,$(1)%$)#/9"( %'(<'(($% 0$&"($

/')7,'$ /9"( #0"#0$9"("11')#$%"(,"&#,%,';$,) >")% 0'( ($,;'&$( 9$,$ #$,<')"#$% 9$ . $(1)%$)# ,"'($% ") ')%+(#,'"2 %'(1+#$ ")% #0$ 6"7+, +,# ;'%$ '#( "9",% %"#$% ? ,%$,$% #0$ ,$')(#"#$<$)# #0$,$(1)%$)#9'#0&)#')+'#- ($,;'&$ )&<12'")&$ #0$("'%"9",%/,$(1)%$)#9"(,$')(#"#$% ')($,;'&$")%0$@')$%0'(%+#'$(0$,$"

#$,/,$(1)%$)# <"%$",$1,$($)#"#') ,,$4+2",'("#') 0'(($,;'&$("("

%,';$,,+1559$;$,/;'%$,%$,%"#$%

/ ,$(1)%$)# 9"( ,$4+2",'($% "( " 6"7+,$, ,+1 5 5 44,'$;$%"4"')(##0$("'%,%$,/,$(1)%$)#1,$ $,,$%") "11$"2/ 7+# #0$ ("'% "11$"2 9"( %'(<'(($% 7- 0'$

)($,;"#, ,$(#(;'%$,%$,%"#$% .

.0$ &"($

+,#0$,/9"(#0"#0$0"% 7$$)1$, ,<')4#0$%+#'$( "%,';$,")%9"(#0$,$ ,$/ 2'"72$#7$,$4+2",'($%"("%,';$,')(#$"% "6"7+,$, $)&$/#0$(+'#9"( '2$%7-#0$,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

11$22")#(=%$ $)%")#(')#0$',9,'##$)(#"#$<$)# ";$,,$% #0"# ,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

9"( "11')#$% ) #$<1,",-7"('(")%9"(1"'%9"4$() ,"#$( 0$

9"( 2'"72$ # 7$ ,$4+2",'($% "( " 6"7+,$, #9"( +,#0$,";$,,$%#0"#1(# %,';$,9"( 2-')4;"&")#')#0$

'&$")%')1+72'&')#$,$(#/,$(1)%$)# 0"% 9,A$% "( " %,';$, ( () "( (<$ %,';$, 9"( "11')#$%#0,+40$,;'&$$2$&#')",%,)#,")( $,/ #0$)#0$("'%1$,()9+2%9,A"(",$4+2",%,';$, )#0$12$"%')4( #0$1",#'$(/ 229')4'((+$( 9$,$ ,"<$%7-#0$#,'"2+,#*= B C0$#0$,#0$,%$,%"#$%

1"(($% 7- %$ $)%")# > 90'&0 0"( <$,4$% ') ,%$, %"#$% .

1"(($%7-#0$%$ $)%")#'( 9,)4/'22$4"2/)+22")%;'%D

C0$#0$, #0$ 12"')#'

'( $)#'#2$% # 7$ ,$4+2",'($%:"7(,7$% "4"')(# #0$ 1(# ,';$, 9$

9'#0"22#0$&)($E+$)#'"27$)$ '#

"2)49'#0')#$,$(#/'

(/"#90"#,"#$D

C0$#0$,#0$(+'#'()#<"')#"')"72$')'#( 1,$($)# ,<D > C0$#0$,#0$12"')#'

0"()&"+($ "&#') ,2&+((#")%'# '2$")%<"')#"')#0$(+'#D

$2'$ F ,'"2 +,# ;'%$ @+%4<$)#:%$&,$$ %"#$% .

"229$%#0$(+'#

0$ ("'%@+%4<$)#:%$&,$$1"(($%7-#0$#,'"2+,#9$,$+10$2% 7- #0$ ',(# 11$22"#$ +,# ;'%$ @+%4<$)#:%$&,$$ %"#$%

')")"11$"2 '2$%7-#0$"11$22")#(=%$ $)%")#( $)&$/#0$1,$($)#"11$"27-#0$"11$22")#(=%$ $)%")#( 0";$0$",%2$",)$%&+)($2 ,#0$"11$22")#( ")% 0";$ 4)$ #0,+40 #0$ ,$&,% ";"'2"72$ ) #0$ '2$ &",$ +22-

",#'$( 2$% #0$', $;'%$)&$ ') (+11,# #0$', ,$(1$&#';$12$"( 0$+,#(7$29"

#$,"11,$&'"#')4#0$ $;'%$)&$2$%7-#0$1",#'$(),$&,%/0";$4';$)" ')%')4 "&# #0"# #0$ ,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

9"( "11')#$% "( "

%,';$,;'%$G0'7'# ) ,"#$(%<'##$%2-/($,;'&$(

9$,$#$,<')"#$%")%0$9"(,%$,$%# 7$ ,$')(#"#$% 7- #0$ 6"7+, +,# ;'%$ "9",% %"#$%

? "( #0$ ,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

0"% ,"'($% ") ')%+(#,'"2%'(1+#$&0"22$)4')40'(#$,<')"#'))&<12'")&$ # #0$ "9",% 1"(($% 7- #0$ 6"7+, +,#/ ,$(1)%$)#= 12"')#'

9"(,$')(#"#$%')($,;'&$%<'##$%2-/,$(1)%$)#= 12"')#'

9"( 9,A')4 "( " %,';$, 9'#0 #0$ "11$22")#(=

> %$ $)%")#( 0$,$"

#$,/ ,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

,$1,$($)#$% #0"#0'(($,;'&$(7$,$4+2",'($%3'%$G0'7'# /#0$&"($

9"( ,9",%$% ,,$4+2",'("#') 0'(($,;'&$"("%,';$, 9$;$,/;'%$'<1+4)$%,%$, %"#$%

/#0$($,;'&$(

9$,$ ,$4+2",'($% "( " 6"7+,$, ')&$ #0$ ,$(1)%$)#= 12"')#'

0"%7$$)1$, ,<')4#0$%+#'$( "%,';$,9'#0#0$ "11$22")#(=%$ $)%")#(/#0$+,#(7$29,'40#2-%$&,$$%#0$ (+'# #0$ ,$(1)%$)#=12"')#'

")% ,%$,$% #0"# #0$

7$ "7(,7$%:,$4+2",'($% "( " %,';$, 9$

(+7(#")#'"2E+$(#') 2"9",'($(')#0'(&"($ 9",,")#')4')#$, $,$)&$7-#0'(+,# '(<'(($%

")+",- ./

. <"0";',