High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1257/2014dismissed

Gurcharan Singh & ANR v. Shingara Singh & ORS

2015-10-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'( $")#*+ ",- .*$,!*!'%'/, ",#*& 00#11!'"& 2#*&.& ,%'/!*!%'/, ",#*& #&0'3#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 4,#",#* #0*"#*&1$!10!0#*&5!6)#!117#3"&##",#8.3/5#'"9 )#*##**#3"",# #0*"#*&*'"9 : 4,#",#*",#8.3/5#'"&,.13)#*#0*"#3%'",#%/#&"9

*#&#'"( *),%'!; )#*%-3;$!"#* **#7!1-3;$!"#- *",#!00#11!'"& <<<<< *)+%,' ,#!00#11!'"=01!%'"%&!*#%' #/.1!*#$'300#!1!/!%'&"

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

3$50*%&#3%'C,!&*!:DDD@=- D@=-+DD=+-D@=!"2%11!/#C!&%!'7!&/%;#'".*3%!

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

%1%'/",#&.%"",",#.*"&)#17,!;#*#'3#*#3%'3%'/&!$" 3'"%'"#'3"3%#*7%",",#%'3%'/&*#'3#*#3)6)",",# .*"&)#17-7,%$,!*#)!&#3'!00*#$%!"%'*!1!'33$.5#'"!*6 #;%3#'$#-5.$,1#&&'&.)&"!'"%!1A.#&"%'1!7!*%&#&*3#"#*5%'!"%' )6",%&.*" ,#!00#!1%&!$$*3%'/163%&5%&&#3 1203, *)+%

453 '(-.&