High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3995/2015dismissed

Chanan Singh v. Goldy Multani

2016-12-13Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

* +!(!(&(,+ --#..!("

/#0'1'

.$21."!(& #'-($#("

) 3 4 4

0#'#(") 01(&'+1-"!5$/%!"#5

0"+#!--#..!("

45 +&'&'"+#'#%($!--#!. &.#$62"+#$# #($!("&(!'1&" &.#$62 "+#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

5'##8&(,!$#%0## 9&("-''#''&( "+#'1&"

-0-#0"2562:!2 '-#%& &%-#0 0;!(%# !(!,0##;#(" '!.#$!"#$

* +#'1&"-0-#0"2&'$#'%0&6#$&("+#&;-1,(#$91$,;#(" .#!0(#$&/&. 1$,# 1(&0 &/&'&(518#0&!(5!' =8!(!.'!($*;!0.!'

.!($56#&(,!>0$ '+!0# "+#""!..!($%;-0&'#$&(/!0&1'8+!'0!

(1;6#0',&/#(&("+#-.!&("5'&"1!"#$&(/&..!,#!"#+-105 5 #+'&. !'12!5 &'"0&%"'+&!0-10

(!."#0(!"&/#-0!2#0 00#%/#02 '?5<<5

>7:&"+&("#0#'"

"+#0#1-(5:!'!.';!$#62"+#0#'-($#("+#0#&(+#0#&(! "#00# #00#$" "+#-.!&("&

5!.(,:&"+&("#0#'""+#0#1-( +# !%"'5!'"!8#( 0;"+#91$,;#(" "+#.#!0(#$%10"'

6#.:5!0#"+!""+#!--#..!("7$# #($!("+#0#&(!

"#00# #00#$""+#!--#..!("

:!''"!"#$"6#0#%0$#$!'"+#9&(":(#0&(-''#''&( "+#'1&".!($ :+&%+ +# +!$ !,0##$ " '#.. " "+# -.!&("&

5 /&$# "+# !

0#;#("&(#$ !,0##;#(" $!"#$

*5 :&"+ "+# '!.# %('&$#0!"&( '#"".#$ !" ' =5

>7-#0!%0# "+#!

0#'!&$'1;5"+#!--#..!(":!''"!"#$"+!/# 0#%#&/#$'5?

>7!'#!0(#'";(#2 0;"+#-.!&("&

!""+#"&;#:+#( "+#!,0##;#(":!'#("#0#$&("!($"+#$!"#62:+&%+"+#'!.#$##$:!' #@#%1"#$!($0#,&'"#0#$:!''"!"#$!'<

?5&#(#2#!0.!"#0 ":!' 10"+#0%("#($#$&("+#-.!&(""+!""+#!--#..!("+!$!.' !,0##$"-!2$16.#"+#!;1(" "+##!0(#'";(#2""+#-.!&("&

& +# "+#!--#..!("7$# #($!("$&$("#@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$!($&":!'!,0##$"+!" "+#0:&'#"+#!,0##;#("$!"#$

*:1.$6##( 0%#!6.#&(!%10"

.!: +#-.!&("&

+!$ 10"+#0%("#($#$"+!"+#0#;!&(#$-0#'#("&( "+#

&%# "+#167#,&'"0!0("+#.!'"$!"# &@#$5"-#0 0;+&'-!0"

"+#%("0!%"61""+#-0#'#("!--#..!("$&$(""10(1-!($"+#0#! "#0!.'5 $#'-&"#;!(20#A1#'"';!$#"+&;"#@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$5"+#!--#..!(" :!'!..#,#$.2$#.!2&(,"+#;!""#0((#-0#"#@"0"+#"+#0 ('#A1#(".25"+#-.!&("&

5"+01,++&'%1('#.5&''"!"#$"+!/# '#0/#$!.#,!.("&%#1-("+#!--#..!("( *

?5&(:+&%++#&( 0;#$ "+#!--#..!(""+!""+#'!.#$##$'+1.$6##@#%1"#$( *

":!'2#" 10"+#0%("#($#$"+!"("+!"$!"#5"+#-.!&("&

!,!&( 0#;!&(#$-0#'#("&("+#

&%# 167#,&'"0!05 !'12!561""+#!--#..!("

'"&..$&$(""10(1-5!

"#0:+&%+"+#-.!&("&

B;!08#$+&'-0#'#(%#C5/&$#!( !

&$!/&" "+#'!;#$!"#5&# *

'-#0"+#-.!&("&

5+#2#"!,!&(0#A1#'"#$"+#!--#..!(""

#@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$61"1-(+&'("+!/#$(#'5"+#'1&":!'&('"&"1"#$(

"&%# "+#'1&"+!/&(,6##(&''1#$""+#!--#..!("7$# #($!("5 +#!--#!0#$!($ &.#$+&':0&""#('"!"#;#("0!&'&(,-0#.&;&(!0269#%"&(' :&"+0#,!0$";!&("!&(!6&.&"25

#"%!($(;#0&"'%("#($&(,"+!""+# -.!&("&

&'!"0!/#.!,#(":++!$!--0!%+#$"+#!--#..!("!($!''10#$+&; "+!"+#%!('#($+&''(10(!;&(,+""!.2:&"+&( ;("+'!($"+!""+# !--#..!("'+1.$-!2+&;'=5

>7 0"+#'!;#+#!--#..!("!,0##$" $'!($(

*5+#!00!(,#$ 0'5?

>7!($,!/#&"""+# -.!&("&

&("+#-0#'#(%# !,&0&(,+5'( +#"&(,+!($&'+!(&(,+ '( 10!(&(,+56"+0#'&$#("' /&..!,#&;!!(,!"5:&"+&"6#&(, !,0##$"+!""+#0#;!&(&(,!;1(":1.$6#,&/#(""+#-.!&("&

:+#("+# !--#..!("'3'(:1.$0#!%+"!.2 '-#0"+#!--#..!("5"'#%10#"+#0#;!&(&(,!;1("!,0##$ 1-("6#-!&$5!:0&"&(,:!';!$#("+!"$!"#&"'#. (

*!($ "+#0# 0#5:+!":!'%("#($#$"6##!0(#'";(#2&("+#'1&":!'!%"1!..2 "+#;(#2-!&$62"+#!--#..!("""+#-.!&("&

5&(/&#: "+#.!""#0'#($&(, +&''(""!.2

":!' 10"+#0%("#($#$62"+#!--#..!("&(+&':0&""#('"!"#;#(" "+!""+#'(("+!/&(,6##('#("5+#+!$0#A1#'"#$"+#-.!&("&

;!(2!"&;# "0#"10("+#!;1("-!&$5!.(,:&"+"+#-!''-0" "+#!--#..!("'3'(!($ "+1,+"+#-!''-0":!'0#"10(#$&("+#;("+ !(1!02

?5"+#!;1("

-!&$5&#'5?

>75:!'("0#"10(#$61""+#-.!&("&

!,0##$"+!"+# :1.$0#"10(&"&(#!'2&('"!..;#("' :#/#05 &('"#!$ $&(, '5 +# &.#$ "+# '1&" !,!&('" "+#

< !--#..!(" * +1'5&":!'%("#($#$&("+#:0&""#('"!"#;#("562"+#-0#'#(" !--#..!("5"+!""+#0#:!'(#/#0!(2&("#("&( "+#!--#..!(""'#..+&'.!($ !($"+#:0&"&(,$!"#$<

*:!'#@#%1"#$(.2"'#%10#"+#!;1("

0#;!&(&(,"6#-!&$51" '=5

>7!,0##$"6#-!&$ 0;"+#!

0#'!&$-.#!$&(,'5"+# ..:&(,&''1#':#0# 0!;#$ 62"+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#)7

!""

$%&

'() # !"" * !""

!"" + # !"" !"" % ,

!"" -

) !". / $ 0 = +#-.!&("&

#@!;&(#$+&;'#.

!($(#!09&($#0 !.&(,+!($ !("+#05 !.8!0 &(,+5 !' :&"(#''#'5 :+#0#!' "+# !--#..!("7$# #($!("

#@!;&(#$+&;'#.

!($"+#!

0#;#("&(#$ !,&0&(,+!($&'+!(&(,+!'

+&':&"(#''#' -(!--0!&'&(,"+#-.#!$&(,'5!0,1;#("'!($"+##/&$#(%#.#$5 "+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,# 1($"+!""+#0"+!("+# !%""+!""+#"#'"&;(2

:&"(#''#'#@!;&(#$62"+#-.!&("&

5&(%.1$&(,+&;'#.

5%1.$("6#3$#("#$3 #/#(&(%0''7#@!;&(!"&(5"+#!--#..!("7$# #($!("'3:(:&"(#''#'5&# !,&0 &(,+!($&'+!(&(,+5+!$!.'!$;&""#$""+#!--#..!("'3!'!.'"+#&0 :('&,(!"10#'("+#!,0##;#("5@ 7!($&( !%"5 D7 !,&0&(,+5 #/#(!$;&""#$"+!""+#!,0##;#("+!$6##(!%"1!..2#@#%1"#$ 0'#..&(,.!($ ;#!'10&(, =8!(!.'!($*;!0.!' ":!' 10"+#0 1($62"+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#"+!""+#!--#..!("

%1.$("-0/#&(!(2;!((#05"+#'"!($"!8#(62+&;5"+!""+#!,0##;#(" :!'!%"1!..2#@#%1"#$"'#%10#"+#0#;!&(&(,!;1(" '=5

>75 '#($&(,+&''(""!.2 #(%#5"+#!,0##;#("@ 7+!/&(,6##(#@#%1"#$:!'+#.$" +!/#6##( -0/#$561"$#'-&"#"+!"5&":!' 10"+#0+#.$"+!""+#-.!&("&

!%"1!..2$&$("-0/#"+!"+#+!$%;#-0#'#("6# 0#"+#167#,&'"0!0( "+#$!"#!%"1!..2 &@#$ 0#@#%1"&( "+#'!.#$##$""+#.!'"'"!,# 91$,;#("5"+#$!"#+!':0(,.26##('+:(!'

?62"+#&/&.

1$,#5:+#0#!'#!0.&#0&"+!'6##('+:("6#<

?5!'+!'!.' '-#%& &%!..26##('"!"#$62"+#.#!0(#$ &0'"!--#..!"#10" #(%#5#/#("+1,+"+#.#,!.("&%#$!"#$

?:!'!.' '+:("+!/#6##('#("620#,&'"#0#$-'"!($"+#0#! "#05"+#-.!&("&

-0/#$ +&'-0#'#(%#6# 0#"+#167#,&'"0!0( *

?5&#"+#$!"#,&/#(62 +&;&("+#!

0#'!&$.#,!.("&%#5+:#/#05&":!'+#.$"+!"&"$&$("-0/#+&' :&..&(,(#''!($0#!$&(#''"#@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$("+#$!"# &@#$&("+# !,0##;#("@ 7 +#0# 0#5+.$&(,"+!""+#0#.&# '-#%& &%-#0 0;!(%#&'!

$&'%0#"&(!020#.&# "6##@#0%&'#$$#-#($#("1-("+# !%"' #!%+%!'#5"+#

* '1&" "+# -.!&("&

:!' (.2 $#%0##$ " "+# #@"#(" 0#%/#02 ' ?5<<5

>7!'-0!2#$ 062"+#-.!&("&

562:!2 !(!."#0(!"&/#0#.&# +#-0#'#("!--#..!(" &.#$!(!--#!.6# 0#"+#.#!0(#$ &0'"

!--#..!"#10"5&(:+&%+"+!"10"$1.2("&%#$"+#-.#!$&(,'5"+#&''1#'

0!;#$!($"+##/&$#(%#.#$6# 0#"+#.:#010"!($"+#0#!

"#05.&8#"+# .#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#5%!;#""+#%(%.1'&("+!""+#!,0##;#(" '!.#5@ 5#@#%1"#$62"+#-!0"&#'""+# 5+!$6##($1.2-0/#$"+!/#6##(' #@#%1"#$5:&"+(#/&$#(%#.#$62"+#-0#'#("!--#..!("5"+!"&":!'!%"1!..2 (.262:!2 '#%10&"2 0"+#0#;!&(&(,!;1(" '=5

>7"6#-!&$ 1-(+&''(6#&(,'#("""!.262"+#-.!&("&

+1'5"+#!;1(" '5?

>7'"!"#$"+!/#6##(-!&$!'

#!0(#'";(#2""+#!--#..!("62"+#-.!&("&

:!'!%%#-"#$!''1%+62"+#

&0'"!--#..!"#10"!.' ("+#(#@" !'-#%"5 "+#0#!$&(#'' !($:&..&(,(#'' -.!&("&

"!%"1!..2#@#%1"#'!.#$##$&(+&' !/105!,!&("+!"10"!.'

1($"+!""+#-.!&("&

+!$("-0/#$+&'-0#'#(%#6# 0#"+#167#,&'"0!0 ("+#'"&-1.!"#$$!"#5&#<

('#A1#(".25&":!'+#.$"+!""+#-.!&("&

:!'!.'("#("&".#$ "-!2;#(" '?5<<5

>75:+&%+6/&1'.2&(%.1$#$!-#(!."2!;1(" #A1!.""+#!;1(" #!0(#'";(#2 .$&(,!'!6/#5"+#91$,;#(" "+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#:!'

;$& &#$""+##@"#(""+!"&('"#!$ '?5<<5

>75"+#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

:!' +#.$ #("&".#$ " 0#%/#0 (.2 "+# !;1(" ;(#2 -!&$ 62 +&;5 !.(,:&"+&("#0#'"E*F-#0!((1;501((&(, 0;"+#$!"# "+#$#%0##

"+#.:#0%10""&.."+#0#!.&G!"&( "+#!;1("

? < +#!--#..!("7$# #($!("&'"+1'5&('#%($!--#!.6# 0#"+&'

10"5!,!&('"#/#("+!"91$,;#("!($$#%0##562:+&%++#+!'6##($&0#%"#$ "0# 1($"+##!0(#'";(#2-0/#$"+!/#6##(-!&$"+&;5!.(,:&"+ &("#0#'"!'!

0#'!&$ ""+&''"!,#&"'#.

5&"(##$'"6#("&%#$"+!""+#0#'-($#("7 -.!&("&

&'("'##("+!/#%+!..#(,#$#/#("+#$#%0## "+#.#!0(#$&/&.

1$,#62:+&%++#:!',0!("#$(.2"+#!."#0(!"&/#0#.&# -0!2#$ 0!($("

"+#0#.&# '-#%& &%-#0 0;!(%# "+#%("0!%" &;&.!0.25 "+# -.!&("&

&' !.' (" &( !--#!. !,!&('" "+# ;$& &%!"&( "+#91$,;#("!($$#%0## "+#.:#0%10"562"+# &0'"

!--#..!"#10"5#("&".&(,+&;"!0# 1($ (.2'5?

>7&('"#!$ ' ?5<<5

>7 4#!0(#$%1('#. 0"+#!--#..!("+!'%&"#$!91$,;#(" 1-0#;#10"&(!"&'+ !"0!/'1$+&0!:!.5

< 5"'16;&"

"+!"(%#"+#-.!&("&

%1.$ (" -0/#+&'0#!$&(#''!($:&..&(,(#''" #@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$-10'1!(""!(!,0##;#("#("#0#$&("6#":##("+# -!0"&#'5"+#!--#..!("7$# #($!("5&#"+#/#($05:!'#("&".#$" #&""+# #!0(#'";(#2-!&$ D+#0#!' ( -0&(%&-!. "+!" -0-'&"&( %!((" 6# $16"#$5 +:#/#05& "+#0#+!'"6#! #&"10# "+##!0(#'";(#2-!&$5&("+# -&(&( "+&'10"!.'5"+#(&"6#%;#'&(%1;6#("1-("+#$# #($!("" !.'-0/#+&'0#!$&(#''!($:&..&(,(#''"#@#%1"#"+#%("0!%"5#/#(:&"+ "+#-.!&("&

5&#"+#-0'-#%"&/#/#($##5(" 1($:&..&(,!($0#!$2 ( %!'# '1-0!5 1($16"#$.2 "+# 0&,+" !

'#..#0>/#($0" #&""+##!0(#'";(#2-!&$"+&;51-(((7-#0 0;!(%#

= "+#%("0!%"62"+#-0'-#%"&/#/#($##5:!'1-+#.$:#/#05&"&''##( "+!"&("+!"%!'#5 &0'".2&"'##;'6/&1' 0;!-#01'!. -!0!,0!-+ "+#0# 5"+!""+#'1&" &.#$62"+#-0'-#%"&/#/#($##5:!'(.2(#'##8&(, 0#%/#02 "+##!0(#'";(#2:+&%++!$!.0#!$26##( #&"#$62"+# /#($0+#.:#0%10"+!/&(,$&';&''#$"+#'1&" "+#-.!&("&

5&(!--#!.5 "+# #.+&&,+10"+#.$"+#'#..#0#("&".#$" #&"(.2!(;&(!.!;1("

>7!($(""+##("&0##!0(#'";(#2 '?5

>7+!"

91$,;#(" "+#&,+10":!'0#/#0'#$62"+#+(36.#1-0#;#10"&( "+#!--#!. &.#$62"+#/#($051-+.$&(,+&'0&,+"" #&""+##("&0##!0(#'"

;(#25:&"+"+#-.!&("&

("+!/&(,6##(!6.#" 1.

&..+&'-!0" %("0!%"5 -!2;#(" "+#0#;!&(&(,!;1(" '*5

>7&(0$#0" ,#""+#'!.#$##$#@#%1"#$ :#/#05"+#&040$'+&-'!.'+#.$!' ..:'6# 0#!..:&(, "+#!--#!. "+#/#($0)7

= ("+#-0#'#("%!'#5"+1,+"+#0#&'!0#%&"!.&("+#'!.#$##$"+!" & B-!0"2( C5&#"+#-0'-#%"&/#/#($##-.!&("&

0# 1'#'" 1.

&..+&'

-!0" "+# %("0!%"5 "+#( +&' #!0(#'" ;(#2 '+!.. 6# %('&$#0#$ " 6#

#&"#$5!($:+!"+!'6##(+#.$62"+#.#!0(#$%10"'6#.:5&'"+!""+# -.!&("&

:!'(" 1($"6#-0#'#("&("+#

&%# "+#167#,&'"0!0" #@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$("+#.!'"$!"# &@#$ 0$&(,'5!'%("#($#$&("+# !,0##;#("5 &# <

? +#0# 0#5 !( &( #0#(%# :!' $0!:( "+!" "+# -.!&("&

%1.$("-0/#+&'0#!$&(#''"-#0 0;+&'-!0" "+#%("0!%"( "+!"$!"#'!.0#!$2("&%#$5"+#-.!&("&

+!'("%+!..#(,#$"+#91$,;#("'

"+#%10"'6#.: :#/#05&":!'!.'-0/#$"+!"":!($+!.

;("+'"+#0#!

"#05 &#( *

?5"+#-.!&("&

+!$'#("!.#,!.("&%#""+#!--#..!("7 $# #($!("/#($0"%;#!($#@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$'&@$!2'.!"#0(

?5(:+&%+$!"#"+#-.!&("&

-0/#$+&'-0#'#(%#6# 0#"+#167 #,&'"0!0 +#!--#..!("("+#"+#0+!($5%1.$("-0/#"+#'"!($"+!" +# "8 &( +&' :0&""#( '"!"#;#("5 " "+# #

#%" "+!" "+# !;1(" ' 5?

>7:!'("-!&$62"+#-.!&("&

"+&;61"&( !%"62+&;""+# -.!&("&

5 0"+#-10-'# '#($&(,+&'!--#..!("7$# #($!("'3'(""!.2 !($"+!""+#!,0##;#("#@#%1"#$:!'(.2"'#%10#"+#-!2;#(" !;1("0#;!&(&(,"6#-!&$!..#,#$.262"+#!--#..!("""+#-.!&("&

51"

"+#""!.%('&$#0!"&( '=5

>7!..#,#$.2'#"".#$6#":##("+#-!0"&#'

0"+#-10-'# '#($&(,"+#!--#..!("'3'(!60!$

#(%#5"+#!--#..!("&( !%""0&#$"-1""+#'+#("+#"+#0 "

62'!2&(,"+!""+#;(#2:!'-!&$62+&;!($(""+&;#"5(#&"+#0%1.$

+#-0/#"+!"5(0&( !%"$&$+##/#(0!&'#!%1("#0%.!&; 00#%/#02 !(2 '1%+;(#2 0;"+#-.!&("&

#(%#5 0+&;"0#.21-("+#!,0##;#("

'!.#&"'#.

5:+&%++#!%"1!..2$#(&#$:!''1%+!(!,0##;#("5"'"!"#"+!""+# ;(#2'+:("+!/#6##(-!&$"+&;62"+#-.!&("&

!'#!0(#'";(#25 '+1.$'"!($ #&"#$&(+&' !/105&'!-.#!("!/!&.!6.#:&"++&;

"+#0"+!("+#!6/#0#!'(&(,5#/#(,&(,:+..262"+#"#0;' "+#!,0##;#("5"+#-.!&("&

!".#!'"!61"":!($+!.

;("+'!

"#0"+#.!'"

$!"# &@#$ 0#@#%1"&( "+#'!.#$##$5'#("!.#,!.("&%#""+#!--#..!("

0#@#%1"&( "+#'!.#$##$561""+#!--#..!("!"('"!,#:+!"'#/#05 :+#"+#06# 0#0!

"#0"+#.#,!.("&%#&''1#$62"+#-.!&("&

5#/#0&''1#$ !(2("&%#"+&;50#/#(0#-.&#$""+#("&%#$!"#$ *

?5"#/#( '"!"#"+!"'&(%#"+#-.!&("&

$&$("%;#-0#'#("!"!(2'"!,#"#@#%1"#"+# '!.#$##$5"+##!0(#'";(#2'"$ #&"#$('"#!$5+&''"!($:!'"+!""+# ;(#2:!'("-!2!6.#62+&;6#%!1'#"+#!,0##;#(":!'!%"1!..2("!( !,0##;#(" '!.# #(%#5&('+0"5"+1,+"+#-.!&("&

!".#!'"":!($+!.

;("+'

.!"#0#@-0#''#$!$#'&0#"#@#%1"#"+#'!.#62-!2;#(" "+#0#;!&(&(, %('&$#0!"&('#"".#$5"+#!--#..!("!"('"!,##@-0#''#$+&'$#'&0#"#&"+#0 #@#%1"#"+#'!.#$##$50#/#(" #&""+##!0(#'";(#2-!&$5$1#""+# -.!&("&

(""10(&(,1-("+#0&,&(!.$!"# &@#$5&#<

+#0# 0#5&("+#!

0#'!&$%&0%1;'"!(%#'5 &($(#000:+!"'#/#0 &("+#&;-1,(#$91$,;#(" "+# .#!0(#$.:#0!--#..!"#%10"562:+&%+5 "+1,+"+#'1&" 0'-#%& &%-#0 0;!(%# &.#$62"+#0#'-($#("7-.!&("&

:!'

("'$#%0##$5&(/&#: "+# !%""+!""+#-.!&("&

+&;'#.

%1.$("-0/# +&'-0#'#(%#(<

?!($"+#0#62+&'0#!$&(#''"#@#%1"#"+#'!.#

$##$52#"5:&"+"+#!--#..!(" &0'".2+!/&(,#/#($#(&#$"+#!,0##;#("&"'#.

!($"+#0#!

"#05(" +!/&(,'+:(&(!(2;!((#0"+!"+#:!':&..&(," #@#%1"#+&'-!0" "+#%("0!%"5+#%!(("6#!..:#$" #&""+##!0(#'"

;(#2-!&$ ('#A1#(".25 &($&(,(;#0&"&("+#!--#!.5&"&'$&';&''#$&( 61":&"+(0$#0!'"%'"'

-8>(&"&( D+#"+#0'-#!8&(,>0#!'(#$ #'

D+#"+#0#-0"!6.# #'