High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2693/2018disposed of

Partap Singh v. Land Acquisition Collector-Cum-Sdm And ORS

2026-05-01Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

B7)*)*'& B7)*)*'& B7)*)*'& B7)*)*'&

+)'

2?"4 2?"4 2?"4 2?"4 &8(('8)'-8+' &8(('8)'-8+' &8(('8)'-8+' &8(('8)'-8+'

'877(#

'877(# < !

99'33+()2 99'33+()2 99'33+()2 99'33+()24

"F% % % % .

. '9(-'() '9(-'() '9(-'() '9(-'()24 "# "# "# "# &''()# "&

"& $ " % $ " % $ " % $ " % " " " " %+&+(07) 7(:*.-@8+)' )*'+99'33+() )*+&*,'-. ./(0+1 GGGG .2&+34 .2&+34 .2&+34 .2&+34 % " % " % " % " 56 7- -')*78,,(&-'&.)*'9&''

'()+99'+31'+&7(:

2?"4+&'1'

'7(: -'87-'-++33) )*''+99'+3*+@'+&7'(/)

8,,(+8A/77)7(+(-7(@ 3@' 7-'()78+3 +8)+ +(-A/')7( 3+B&)*'+H H' 1&'@7)C. +8)+&'1'7(:)+H H'(

5 6 C B+C 9&''() +99'+324. 8*+3 33'(:' *+ 1''( 3+7- ) )*' B B+&- -+)'- ; 9+'- 1C )*' 3'+&('- --3 7)&78) /-:'. +&( + +&+( /&) /&) /&) /&)I4 2*'&'7(+ )'&)1 1'&'

'&&'-+)*'D'

'&'(8'/ '

'&'(8'/ 6 & 7'

3C )+)7(:. 7( )*' 9&''() 8+ +'24. 8'&)+7( 3+(- B('- 1C -B('&24 7)/+)'- B7)*7( )*' & &'@'(/' ')+)' @733+:' %*+- -&

+*71. 7)&78) +&( +&+(. 8+,' ) 1' + 8A/7&'- @7-' )7 78+)7( -+ +)'- ; +(- 7/'-/(-'& '8)7 (;? )*' +(-8A/77) )7( 8). ;2 & *&))*'D ;8)I D ;8)I D ;8)I D ;8)I4&'9'8)7@'

'3C &)*'9/13789/&9'.(+,'

'3C.

J & ')+137*,'

,'()E8()&/8)7(

78' +(- &'7-'(8'

". '*73. + +71F '*73-+&+(-)* *'7&',93C''7(@733+:'%*+- +*71N(B+&-/(-'& '8) )7( ; 8)B+9+'-1C)*' +(- 8A/77)7(33'8)&2 &*&) D)*' I I I I4( .B*'&'1C,+&H')@+3/'

)*'+8A/7&'-3+(-B++''- -K ..EF 9'& +8&' +3(: B7)* +33 )*'

& )+)/)&C 1'('

7) +(- 7()'&'

') 9&@7-'-/(-'&) )*' ;8) 5;6

7 F+)7 7'- B7)* +B+&- 9+'- 1C . -B('&24 9&'

'&&'- )*'7& 10'8 8)7( 7( )'&, '8)7( & '+- B7)* '8)7(

)*' ; 8) B*78* B'&' &'

'&&'- ) )*' 3'+&('- '

'&'( (8' /&). B*78* B B'&' 9+&)3C +88'9)'- @7-' 7) + +B+&- -+)'- ; . B*73' &'F +'7(: )*' , ,+&H') @+3/' )*' +8A/7&'- 3+(- K

..EF 9'& + +8&' 7&&'9'8)7@' 7) (+)/&' 1'7-' :&+()7(: +33 )*'& )+)/)&C 1'('

7) /(-'& ;8) 5<6 ::

:&7'@'-)*'&' .)*'9&''()+99 9'+3B'&'9&'

'&&'-+))*'7()+ (8' )*'+99'33+()2 24E3+(-B('&24+B'33+&'9 (-'()E )+)' 2 4# 2 4# 2 4# 2 4#

F L # L # L # L #F 6 ,9 9/:(7(:)*'+ &'+7-+B+&-.3'

'+&('-8/('3+99'+&7(:(1'* *+3 )*' +99'33+() )24E3+(-B('&24 /1,7) )*+) ) )*' 3'+&('- '

'&'(8' /&) '& &&'- *+@7(: +73'-) &'3C/9()*''@'(+3'-''-2 2M F)MF 49&-/8'-1C -B('&24 B*78* 9'&)+7('- ) )* *' +,' &'@'(/' ')+)' 733 +:' %*+-& +*71 +(-)*',+&H')@+3/'B+)1 '&'F+''-+88&-7(:3C'+ +3 97()/))*+)B B*73'+'7(:)*',+&H').@+3/ /')*'3'+&('-'

'&'(8'/&)+ +3

+73'- ) )+H' 7( () +88/() )*' +8) )*+) )*' , ,+)'&7+3 +@+73+13' ( &'8&- 83'+ +&3C

')+137*'- )*+ +) )*' +8A/7&'- 3+(- 9' '- 8(7-'&+13' 38+)7(+3 + +(- 8,,'&87+3 9) )'()7+3 B7(: ) 7) 9&M7,7)C ) ) )*' ')+137*'- 8,,'&87+3 + +(- 7()7)/)7(+3/(7) )')*/.9&+C)*+)+B+&-9+ '-1C)*'3'+&('-'

'&'(8' /&) B+37+13')1' ,-7 7'-+(-)*',+&H')@+3/'B B+)1''(*+(8'-7( +@/& -B('&24 )*'& +&:/,'() *+ 1''( &+7'- ( 1'*+3 -B('&24 F #

#F 5>6 '& & 8()&+. 3'+&('- )+)' 8/('3 3 97() /) )*+) )*' +3' 7()+( (8' 2MF )M F>?MF 49&-/8'-1C)*'+ +99'33+()24E3+(-B('&249'&)+7( ('- ))*'9'&7-9 )()7 78+)7(/(-'& '8)7(;

; ;8)7()*'8+'24 47( *+(-.)*/B'&' 37+13')1'-78+&-'- '+&('-

)+)'8/('3 /&)*'&97()/)) )*+) )*' +3' 7()+(8 8' -+)'- < 2MF4 9'&)+7('- ) ,+33 9+&8'3 3+ +(- ,'+/&7(: A '')+(-+/8*.)*'+,'B ++3&'A/7&'-)1'7:(&'- & &, )*'O(' 8( 7-'&+)7( 5>6 '+ +&('- )+)' 8/('3 /&)*'& /1 1,7) )*+) )*' &'

'&'(8' 9')7)7( (24 9&'

'&&'-+))*' 7()+(8' )*'+99'33+()24E3+(- -B('&24B'&'1+&&'-1C37,7)+) )7( +/8*.)*'7,9 9/:('-+B+&-9+'-1C)*'3'+& &('-'

'&'(8'/&)B+37+13'

') )*'')+7-'+( (-)*'B+&-9+'-1C)*' B+&'A/7&'-)1'&')&'- )*'&+&:/,'()* *+1''(&+7'-(1'*+3 )*' &'9(-'()E )+)' # # # #F

56 * *+@' *'+&- 3'+&('- 8/('3 )*' 9+&)7' +(- :(' )*&/:* 9+9'&1H+B B'33+&'8&- )*'8+'24 7(-/1)+(8'7()*'/1,77 ( ,+-'(1'*+3 )*'+99'33+()24E3+(-B('&24

6 () )*'9&''()8+'24.)*'-')+73 )*'+3'7()+(8'7()*' &, , M )MF

9&-/8'-+(-9&@'-(&'8 &-1C)*'+99'33+()24E3+(-B('

&24 7(/99&) )*'

'7&83+7,+&''M)&+8)'-*'&'/(-'& &#F Area Name of village Sr.

No.

Sale Exhibits Da sa ate of le deed To co (R otal Sale onsideration Rs.) Value per acre (Rs.)

1. Ex.A-3 .05.2012 17 Marlas Khadoor Sahib 8, ,16,000/- 76,80,000/-

2. Ex.A-4 .05.2012 15 Marlas Khadoor Sahib 7, ,20,000/- 76,80,000/-

3. Ex.A-5 .07.2012 2 Marlas 3 sarsai Khadoor Sahib 2,50,000/- 1,71,42,857/-

4. Ex.A-6 .08.2012 4 Kanals 7 Marlas Khadoor Sahib 2, ,00,000/- 3,67,816/-

5. Ex.A-7 .09.2012 8 Marlas Khadoor Sahib 4, ,00,000/- 80,00,000/-

6. Ex.A-8 .05.2010 300 sq. feet Khadoor Sahib 2, ,50,000/- 3,63,00,000/-

7. Ex.A-9 .09.2012 8 Marlas Khadoor Sahib 1, ,07,000/- 21,40,000/- 56 & ,)*'+1@'.7)7+99+&'())*+ +))*'+3'-''-MF )M F> +(-MF 9'&) )+7('-))*'9'&7-9)()7 8+)7(/(-'& '8)7(; ; 8)7()*'8+'2 247(*+(-.)*/(''-()1'&'

'37'-/9( &+'7(:)*',+& &H') @+3/'7()*'9&'

''()8+'24*'+3'-''--+)'

'- < 2MF47)*' (3C +3'7()+(8'B* *78*9'&)+7('-))*'9'&7-9&7& &))*'()7 78+)7(/(-'& '8)7 (; ;8) 7()*'8+'247(*+(-.&'3+)7(:) )*'+,'&'@'(/'')+)' @733 +:' %*+-& +*71 @7-' B*78* A '') 3+(- 8,9&7'- 7( '8)+( (:3' < EEE B+ 3- &++3'8(7-'&+)7( .<.EFB7)*1+'9&78' 9'& +8&' +99&M7, ,+)'3C .

..EF 56 &, )*' &'8&-. 7) 8+( 1 1' -78'&('- )*+) )*' 3+(- /( (-'& +8A/77)7( &, ,9+&) )*''8)+(:3'< +(-< +(-)*'3+(-9+&8'3 +3'7()+(8'-+ +)'- < 2MF49'&)+7( ()'8)+(:3'< )*'+ +,'

&'@'(/' ')+)' @733+:' %*+-& +*71. +- -1+) . 7)&78) +&( +& &+( */.'@7-'()3C )*'3+(-/(-'&+8A/77)7(+B B'33+)*'3+(-9+&8'3 &,7(:9 9+&) )*'+3'7()+ +(8'-+)'- < 2MF4 4B'&'38+)'-7()*'+,'@787( (7)C +(- 83' 9& M7,7)C. +88&-7(:3C. 8+&&7'- 7,73+& 38+)7(+3 +(- 9)'( ()7+3 +-@+()+:' ( / /8* 87&8/,)+(8'. )*' 3+(- 9+ +&8'3 &,7(: 9+&) +3' 7()+( (8' -+)'- < 2MF4 9'&)+7(7(: ) )*' 9'&7- 9&7& ) ()7 78+)7( /( (-'&

'8)7(; )*'

' ;8)8/93'-B7)*)*' +8) ))*+)7)738+)'-7()*'7,,'-7 7+)' @787(7)C )*'+ +8A/7&'-3+(-=1'7(:)*'1')/ /7)+13''M',93+&.(''-)1'&'3 37'- /9( &)*'9/& &9' +'7(:,+&H')@+3/'7 7()*'8+'247(*+(- 56 " &'@'&. &,)*',+)'&7+3+@+73+ +13'(&'8&-7()*' &, 8& F 'M+,7(+)7(

LF ,) '',+ 7(:*. '*73-+&. %*+-& +*71. 7) B B+ ')+137*'-(& &'8&-)*+))*'+8A/7&'-3+(-B B+38+)'-7(83'@787(7)C +3&'+-C-'@'39 '-9/13787()7)/)7(37H' '(7& & '8(-+&C 8*3+(-') /'

8' + B'33 + 3- '*73 , ,93'M ( )*7 &':+&-. )*' 8& F 'M+,7(+)7( LF1'7(:&'3'@+()7'M)&+8)'- -*'&'/(-'&#F JL LF

'',+ 7(:*'*73-+&. 8&F'M+,7(+)7( %*+-& +*71&'8+33'- )78&&'8))*+))B+&- )*'+)'&(7-' +8A/7&'3+(-)* *'&' 7 /&/-B+&+97+(+ +*71. '(7&

'8(-+&C 8*3+(-')/'

78')78&&'8))*+))B+&- -)*'/)*'&(7-')*'&'73-'

'*73 , ,93'M)7B&(:)/::'))*+)) )*'+8A/7&'3+(-78,,'&87+33+(- -) 7B B&(:)/::'))*+),+&H')3+(- - ('+&)*'+8A/7&'3+(-7 +8 9'& ,+& +&3+8+(())'33&+33CB*+)7)*' ' 9&''()833'8)&&+)'+)9&''()7( ( )*' +&'+ + @733+:'%*+-& +*71)7B B&(:)/::'))*+)*+@'-'9 '-

+3 '3CN

5 6 *+ +))*/:*)*'+3''M',93+&-+)'

'- < 2MF49'&)+7( ) )*' ,+33 9+&8'

'3 3+(- ,'+/&7(: A

'') 3+(- 2+99+&'()3C 1'7(:

8,,'&87+3)&+( (+8)7(4+(-)*'+8A/7&'-3+(-+ +3&'+-C1'7(:7(-'@'39'-@787( (7)C. + -'-/8)7( K <P @'& )*' 1+' 9&78' .

..EF 9'& +8&' -'&7@ @'- )*'&'

&, B/3 3- /

78' )B+&- ,+33(' 7) +&'+. B*78* )*/ 8,' ) <;.;<.EF9 9'&+8&' 5 6 /& &)*'&.7()*':7@'( +8)7(8')* '+8A/77)7(7()*'8+'247(*+ +(- B+ 8+&&7'- /) ) & )*' 9/1378 9/&9'. (+,'

'3C. J')+137*,'()E8()&/8)7( (

78' +(- &'7 7-'(8'

". '*73. +71F F'*73-+& +(- )*'7& ',93C'' 7( @733+:' %*+-& +*71N + /8*. )*' &'9(-'

'()E )+)' ('7)*'& /

'&'- +(C 3 3 )B+&- 9)7,/ /, /)737O+)7( )*' +&'+ +8A/ /7&'- (& -7- 7) 7(8/& 'M9'(-7) )/&' )B+&- 9&@7-7 7(: +--7)7(+3 7( &+)&/8)/&+ +3 +,'(7)7' )*/. ( 8/) )B+ +&- -'@'39,'()8 )(''-)1'7,9'- 5;6 88 8&-7(:3C. )*' ,+&H') @+3/'

& )*' 3+(- /(-'& +8A/77)7( ( 7 +''-K <;.;<.E <;.;<.E <;.;<.E <;.;<.EF9'&+8&'

9'&+8&'

9'&+8&'+()*'- -+)' ()7 78+)7(/(-'& '8)7 (; ;8) )(+--7)7(.)*'3+(-B('&* *+33+31''()7)3'- &+B+&-

+33 )+)/)&C 1'('

) +(- 7()'&')+9&@7-'- /(- -'&)*' 9&@77( )*' ; 8) 2+,'(-'-/9) -+)'4*'3+(-B('&*+33+3 1''()7)3'- &3+)7/,1'7 7-' +B+&- 7()'&' ))*'&'/9( 5<6 ' 7-'7).(,'&7)8+(1' /(-B B7)*)*'/1,77(,+-'(1'* *+3 )*'&'9(-'( ()E )+)')*+))*'&'

'&'(8'9')7)7 7(9&'

'&&'-+))*'7()+(8' -B('&24 B'&' 1+&&'- 1C 37, ,7)+)7( ( )*' 9&''() 8+'

'24. ()7 78+)7(/(- -'& '8)7(; ;8)B B+7/'-( ; .B*'& &'+ )*' B+&- /(- '& '8)7( )*' ; 8 8) B+ 9+'- ( *'

8'&)7 7'- 89C )*' B+&- B+ +9937'- 1C C )*' +99'33+()24E3+(-B('&24 ( ; +(- )*'+,'B+9&'9+&'-+(--'37@ @'&'-(> +(-)*'&'+

)'&. )*'9')7)7(/(- -'& '8)7( ;8)B B+ 73'-7(/:/) */ .7) B++99+&'())* *+))*'&'

'&'(8'9')7)7(/(-'& & '8)7( ;8)B B'&' 9&'

'&&'-+))*' 7()+(8' )*'+99'33+()24E3+( (-B('&24B7)*7(7MB''H H(B3'-:' )* *'8()'() )*'+B+&-"&'@ @'&.)*'&'B+(,+)'&7+39&-/ 8'- (&'8&-1C)*'

'&'9(-'()E )+)')*+)+(C()78 8'/(-'& '8)7( 2 4 ; 8) B+ '@'& '&@'- /9( )*' +99'33+()24E3+ +(-B('&24 & '@'( +(C )* *'7& &'9&''()+)7@'B B+9&''()+))*')7,' 9+7( (: )*'B+&--+)'- (/8*87&8/, )+(8'.)*'&'B+(733':+37)C& &9'&@'&7)CB7)*)*' 7(-7(:

+8) &'8&-'-1C)*'

'3'+&('-'

'&'(8'/&)))*'

'8))*+))*'&'

'&'(8'9')7)7 (

73'-+))*'7()+ +(8' )*'+99'33+()24E3+(-B('

'&24B'&' 73'-B7)*7(37,7)+)7( ( 5 6 ( ('A/'()3C. 7( @7'B )*' - -78/7( ,+-' *'&'7(+1@'. +99'+3249&'

'& &&'-+))*'7()+(8' +99'33+() )24E3+(-B('&24+&'*'&'1C9+& &)3C +33B'-7()*'+ + &'+7-)'&,+(-)*'+99'+32 4 73'-1C)*'&'9(-'()E )+)' +&' *'&'1C-7,7'

'- 5>6 L* *'&'@'& )*' 3+(-B('&24 *+E* *+@' /( &)/(+)'3C 'M97&'- 7( +99'+324E8&F 10'8)7(24+ )'& 737(:)*'&' +(-)*'3':+3*'7&*+@'()1 ''( 7,93'+-'-. )*'C C *+33 1' +) 371'&)C ) ''H 'M'

'8/)7( )*' 9&''() -'877( 1C ,@7(:+99&9& &7+)'+99378+)7(241'

&')*'3'+ +&('-M'8/)7(:/&) 56 33 9'(-7(:+99378+)7(24.7 +(C. *+33+3)+(--79'- % "4 % "4 % "4 % "4 "+C "+C "+C "+C ....

)7H 2 2 2 2 L* L* *')*'&9'+H7(:E&'+('-

*')*'&&'9&)+13'

E E