High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/544/2016dismissed

Ranjodh Singh v. Karnail Kaur & ORS.

2016-10-25Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh8 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

!(*$+&(,+ --#..!(" /#0'1'

2!0(!&.2!10!($"+#0'

#'-($#("'

0#'#(") 0+&($#0213!04$/%!"#4

0"+#!--#..!("

+&'&'"+#'#%($!--#!.

"#0+&''1&"'##5&(,!

$#%0## -#03!(#("&(*1(%"&(!,!&('""+#0#'-($#("'6!'$&'3&''#$!($ "+# &0'"!--#!. &.#$78"+#-0#'#("!--#..!("6!'!.'$&'3&''#$78"+# .#!0(#$.6#0!--#..!"#10"

0&# .8'"!"#$4"+# !%"'4!'"!5#( 03"+#*1$,3#(" .#!0(#$&/&. 1$,# 1(&0 &/&'&(4!7+!4!0#"+!""+#'1&".!($6!' !$3&""#$&("+#-.!&(""7#%3-0&'#$&(!*&("5+#6!"+#.$78"+#-!0"&#'4 6&"+ "+# !--#..!("9-.!&("&

+#0#&(!

"#0 0# #00#$ " !' ! !--#..!(" &( #:%.1'&/#-''#''&( /!0&1'5+!'0!(137#0'!'6#0#$#"!&.#$&("+# -.!&("#6!'!.''"!"#$"+!/#%('"01%"#$!+1'#((#-!0" 5+#6!"$3#'"&%#.#%"0&%&"8%((#%"&(!($!;3"0%((#%"&(<6#0# !.''"!"#$"+!/#&('"!..#$&((# "+#5+!'0!(137#0'&(+&'-''#''&( " 6!' 10"+#0%("#($#$ &( "+#-.!&(" "+!""+#0#'-($#("9 #($!("+#0#&(!

"#00# #00#$"!'!$# #($!("6!'"+0#!"#(&(,"!.&#(!"# "+#'1&".!($786!8 '-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#0'!($"+!"'1%+.!($6!'

7#""#0=1!.&"8!($30#/!.1!7.#46+&%+61.$-0#*1$&%#"+#0&,+"' !--#..!(" #" 10"+#04 &" 6!' !.' !..#,#$ "+!" "+# $# #($!("' 6#0# "+0#!"#(&(,"%+!(,#"+#(!"10# "+#.!($6&"+1",#""&(,&"-!0"&"&(#$ !($6#0#!.'"+0#!"#(&(,"&("#0 #0#&("+#-#!%# 1.-''#''&( "+#.!($ -''#''#$78"+#!--#..!("

-(("&%#&''1#$&("+#'1&"4"+#$# #($!("'!--#!0#$!($

&.#$"+#60&""#('"!"#3#("4"!5&(,-0#.&3&(!087*#%"&('(3!&("!&(!7&.&"84 %!1'# !%"&(4.%1'#"%!($ 10"+#0%("#($&(,"+!""+#'1&".!($6!'("

%3-0&'#$&(!*&("5+#6!"(06!'&"!*&("+.$&(,7#"6##("+#-!0"&#'4 !($"+#-.!&("&

6!'!.'("&(#:%.1'&/#-''#''&( !(8.!($4!'!..#,#$ 78+&3('"01%"&( !+1'#/#0"+#.!($78+&36!'!.'$#(&#$4

10"+#0'"!"&(,"+!""+#'"!($

6!''#.

%("0!$&%"084""+# #

#%""+!"("+#(#+!($+#6!'%("#($&(,"+!"+#+!$%('"01%"#$! +1'#(&"6+&.#("+#"+#0+#6!''##5&(,0#.&# !,!&('"%+!(,# (!"10# "+#.!($ 17'#=1#(".8 +6#/#04 !' 0#%0$#$ &( "+# *1$,3#(" "+# .#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#4"+#$# #($!("''"!"#$"+!""+#8!0#%9'+!0#0'&("+# 5+#6!"46&"+$# #($!("'( &(*&("-''#''&(6&"+"+#-.!&("&

&( 5+#6!"( >45+!"(&( 471"6&"+"+#.!($%3-0&'#$&(5+!"(&( ?

"+#'!3#5+#6!"47#&(,&("+##:%.1'&/#6(#0'+&-!($-''#''&(

#($!("'( "6!' 10"+#0!/#00#$"+!""+#'#"6$# #($!("'+!$"0!('

#00#$ ! @A

"+'+!0#4&# 5!(!.!($@3!0.!'4&( !/10 $# #($!("'(B !($("+#7!'&' "+#'!&$'!.#!31"!"&(+!$!.'7##($1.8#("#0#$&("+# 0#/#(1#0#%0$+1'&"6!'%("#($#$"+!""+#-.!&("&

+!'(0&,+"4"&".#0

B %(%#0(6&"+5+!"(&( ?&(!(83!((#0 +#!..#,!"&(' "+#!--#..!("7#&(,"+0#!"#(#$#"%6#0#!.' $#(&#$4 10"+#0%("#($&(,"+!"&( !%"4"+#%($1%"

6!'%.#!0 ""+##

#%""+!"+#6!("#$",0!7"+#.!($ "+#$# #($!("'78 &.&(,"+# '1&" B 0#-.&%!"&( +!/&(, 7##( &.#$ " "+# !

0#'!&$ 60&""#( '"!"#3#("4"+# ..6&(,&''1#'6#0# 0!3#$78"+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#)9

! !"

+#-.!&("&

#:!3&(#$+&3'#.

4(#$0!

"'3!(4 !"&($#0+!+ &(,+!($(#10$!0'+!(&(,+4!' C' "B0#'-#%"&/#.8 +#$# #($!("#:!3&(#$(.8$# #($!("( 421.6&($#02!104 !' C -(!--0!&'!. "+##/&$#(%#4"+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,#%!3#" "+# %(%.1'&( "+!" !' -#0 "+# $%13#("!08 #/&$#(%#4 &( "+# 03

D*!3!7!($&'D 0#%0$' 0&,+"4&"6!'-0/#$"+!""+#-.!&("&

!($"+# #($!("'6#0#%9'+!0#0'&("+#'1&".!($71"6&"+"+#-.!&("&

("'+6( "7#&(#:%.1'&/#-''#''&(/#0!(8-!0" &"+#'1&".!($6!'!.'("

1($"+!/#7##(-!0"&"&(#$!($"+#-.!&("&

+&3'#.

+!$'.$'-#%& &% 5+!'0!(137#0'1" "+##("&0#5+#6!""!$&

#0#("-#0'(4!'0# .#%"#$&( "+#D*!3!7!($&D 0"+#8#!0

B9 #(%#4&"6!' +#.$"+!"+#&(!(8%!'#%1.$ ("'##5 !( &(*1(%"&( !,!&('" "+#$# #($!("' 03!.&#(!"&(, !(8-!0" "+#*&("

+.$&(,4!'+#+!$+&3'#.

!.&#(!"#$!-!0" &" +&'6!'+#.$#/#(6+&.#7'#0/&(,"+!"#/#08%9'+!0#0+!'! 0&,+""#/#08&(%+ !*&("5+#6!"71"& !%9'+!0#0'.$A!.&#(!"#$!(8 -!0" "+#*&("+.$&(,4#/#(78'-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#0'4"+#0&,+" "+#0 %9'+!0#0'&'("!

#%"#$!($61.$7#;'17*#%""-!0"&"&( "+#*&("

+.$&(,< #" 10"+#04!'0#,!0$'"+#-.!&("&

D'-0!8#0 0&(*1(%"&(#/#( 6&"+0#,!0$""+##.#%"0&%%((#%"&("01(!3"0 @+0'#-6#04 6+&%+%((#%"&(6!'&("+#(!3#

+&3'#.

4&"6!'+#.$"+!"

"+1,+"+#'!&$ !%"6!'-0/#$ 03"+#-!''75#"%4+6#/#04+#+!$ ("#/#(3#("&(#$"+#!%%1("(137#0&("+#-.!&("!($"+#0# 0#4"+# #/&$#(%#.#$6!'7#8($-.#!$&(,'(!(8%!'#4#/#(& &"6!'!''13#$"+!"

"+##.#%"0&%3"0&('"!..#$&(+&'(!3#4&"7#&(,&('"!..#$&(*&(".8+#.$ .!($4&"6!'!-!0" "+#*&("-0-#0"8("+&'0#,!0$4!*1$,3#(" 1-0#3#10"&(

6!'%&"#$78"+#.#!0(#$&/&. 1$,# @ +# !%"13 "+# +1'# "+# -.!&("&

+!/&(, 7##( %('"01%"#$6!' 1($"7#-0/#$#/#(786!8 :

>46+&%+6!'!

'"!"#3#("3!$#78"+#'#%($$# #($!("&(!(#!0.&#0.&"&,!"&(7#"6##("+# -!0"&#'%3-03&'#$##$4: @4!00&/#$!"&("+!".&"&,!"&(46!'!.'

1($"+!/#7##(-0/#$4&(6+&%+"+#%('"01%"&( "+#+1'#6!'

!,!&(!$3&""#$ ? ("+#!

0#'!&$ &($&(,'"+#'1&"

6!'-!0".8 $#%0##$40#'"0!&(&(,"+#$# #($!("' 03&..#,!..8!($ 0%&7.8&("#0 #0&(,&( "+#-#!%# 1.-''#''&(

!'0#,!0$'"+#+1'#471""+#-0!8#0

0&(*1(%"&(=1!"+#"+#0'1&"-0-#0"8&(%.1$&(,"+##.#%"0&%&"83"0 %((#%"&(46!'0#*#%"#$!($"+#'1&"""+!"#:"#("6!'$&'3&''#$ > '!"&'

&#$6&"+"+#$#%0##&(, "+#'1&"&(-!0"4"+#-.!&("&

&.#$!(!--#!.1($#0#%"&(> "+# 46+&%+6!'+#!0$78"+# .#!0(#$$$&"&(!. &'"0&%" 1$,#4 !"&!.!46+4!

"#0("&%&(,"+#-.#!$&(,'

!($ !--0!&'&(, "+# #/&$#(%#4 %!3# " "+# %(%.1'&( "+!" "+# &($&(,'

0#%0$#$78"+#.#!0(#$"0&!.10"(&''1#( 4&#"+#-0&(%&-!.&''1#4 0#=1&0#$3$& &%!"&(""+##

#%""+!""+#-.!&("&

%1.$("7#+#.$"7# &(#:%.1'&/#-''#''&( !(85+!'0!(137#04"+#0#7#&(,(0# .#%"&(

'1%+ '-#%& &% -''#''&( &( "+# 0#/#(1# 0#%0$4 !' "+#0# +!$ 7##( ( -!0"&"&( "+#'1&"-0-#0"8783#"#'!($71($' +# &($&(, "+#&/&. 1$,# 6&"+ 0#,!0$ " "+##.#%"0&% %((#%"&(7#&(,&('"!..#$(*&(".!($4#/#(6&"+"+#%((#%"&('"!($&(, &("+#(!3#

46!'1-+#.$78"+#.6#0!--#..!"#10"4 10"+#0 +.$&(,"+!"6&"+"+#$# #($!("'("+!/&(,&('"!..#$!(8"+#0"17#6#.. 0 &00&,!"&(,"+#&0.!($4"+#8%1.$("7#0#'"0!&(#$ 031'&(,"+#6!"#0 %((#%"&( 03"+##.#%"0&%&"83"0&('"!..#$&("+#(!3#

"6!' 10"+#0+#.$78"+# &0'"!--#..!"#10""+!"#/#("+1,+ "+#-.!&("&

+!$%('"01%"#$+&'+1'#/#0'3#-!0" "+#.!($48#"4"+# #($!("'+!$(0&,+""%+!(,#"+##("&0#(!"10# "+#.!($471"6&"+

"+#0#+!/&(,7##(("+0#!" 03"+#3-0/#$4"+#-0!8#0 0&(*1(%"&(&( "+!" 0#,!0$ 6!' -0#93!"10#4 6&"+ "+# -.!&("&

!" .&7#0"8 " '##5 '1%+ &(*1(%"&(& "+#0#6!'!(8&33&(#(""+0#!"""+#%+!(,# "+#(!"10#

"+#.!($

!/&(,+#.$&("+#!7/#3!((#04"+#.6#0!--#..!"#10" '"&..6#("("+.$"+!""+#&/&. 1$,#+!$#00#$&(0# 1'&(,"&(*1(%""+# #($!("' 03!.&#(!"&(,!(8'-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#04"+#.!($'"&..7#&(, *&(".8+#.$ #(%#4("+#!

0#'!&$0#!'(&(,4"+#!--#!.

6!'-!0".8!..6#$!($"+#*1$,3#("!($$#%0## "+#.6#0%10"6!'

3$& &#$4 78 10"+#0 ,0!("&(, !( &(*1(%"&( !,!&('" "+# $# #($!("'4 0#'"0!&(&(,"+#3 03!.&#(!"&(,!(8'-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#0' "+#'1&"

.!($4-0&0"&"'-!0"&"&(

+#-.!&("&

'"&..("'!"&'

&#$4+!'(6 &.#$"+&' ($!--#!. '!3!""#0 !%"4&("+#6!5# "+#!

0#'!&$*1$,3#("!($ $#%0##4"+#'!3#("+!/&(,7##(%+!..#(,#$78"+#$# #($!("'4"+&'10"

+!$#:-0#''#$'10-0&'#!""+#'#%($!--#!.+!/&(,7##( &.#$6#/#04 .#!0(#$%1('#. 0"+#!--#..!("9-.!&("&

'173&""#$"+!""+#3!&(,0&#/!(%#

&'&(0#'-#%" "+##.#%"0&%%((#%"&(!($"+#3"07#&(, 01(6&"+&"

B 0+&($#0213!0+!'/#+#3#(".8"0&#$"%(/&(%#"+&' 10""+!"'&(%#"+#0#&'!"17#6#..%((#%"&(&("+##:%.1'&/#(!3# !--#..!("&('"!..#$("+#'1&".!($46+&%+!$3&""#$.8+!'("7##( 03!..8 -!0"&"&(#$4!($"+#0#6!'!(!$3&''&( 0#'-($#("9$# #($!("( ""+# #

#%" "+!" "+# !--#..!(" 6!' &( !%"1!. -''#''&( '-#%& &% 5+!'0!

@ (137#0'4"+#.#!0(#$10"'7#.6+!/#6+..8#00#$&(+.$&(,"+!""+# "17#6#..%((#%"&(&'!.'&('"!..#$(*&(".!($!($'&3-.87#%!1'#&" '"!($'&("+#(!3# "+#!--#..!("9-.!&("&

4&"%!(("7#'!&$"+!"+#6!'

"+##:%.1'&/#6(#0 "+#'!3#

!/&(,%('&$#0#$"+!"!0,13#("4%!(("!,0##6&"+&"4!'"+# .!($&"'#.

+!'7##($#'%0&7#$!'D (&("+#*!3!7!($& 0"+#8#!0

>46&"+"+#'10%# &00&,!"&('+6("7#"+!" "+#'!3#"17#6#..

'0#,!0$'"+#!$3&''&( 0#'-($#("9$# #($!("( 6&"+ 0#,!0$""+#!--#..!("7#&(,&(#:%.1'&/#-''#''&( '-#%& &%5+!'0!

(137#0'4"+!"61.$("+#.-"+#!--#..!("#&"+#04&(/&#6 "+# !%""+!"&

+# &' &( #:%.1'&/# -''#''&( '-#%& &% 5+!'0! (137#0'4 "+!" 61.$ 7/&1'.8 &3-.8 "+!" "+# 0#'-($#("'9$# #($!("' !0# !.' !%"1!..8 &( #:%.1'&/#-''#''&( '-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#0'46+&%+&'("$#(&#$78 .#!0(#$%1('#.10"+#04&"&'(7$8'D%!'#"+!""+#8!0#&(-''#''&(&( #:%#'' "+#&00#'-#%"&/#'+!0#' +!"7#&(,'4"+#(.8!--0#+#('&(6&"+"+#!--#..!("%1.$ 7#"+!""+#0#'-($#("'9$# #($!("''+1.$("'#..

!(8.!($7#8($"+#&0 '+!0#!($'+1.$("&("#0 #0#&(+&'-''#''&(/#0"+#'1&".!($ +!"&(*1(%"&(&(!(8%!'#+!'7##(,0!("#$"+&378"+# .#!0(#$ .6#0 !--#..!"#10" #(%#4 6&"+ "+#.#!0(#$ 10"' 7#.6 ,0!("&(,.&7#0"846+&%+&(!(8%!'#%1.$("+!/#7##($#(&#$4""+#-!0"&#' ",#""+#'1&".!($-!0"&"&(#$!($"+#0#78",#"'-#%& &%5+!'0!(137#0'

!..""#$""+#3!' !..""+#&00#'-#%"&/#'+!0#'4$("'##!(8,01($" &("#0 #0#6&"+"+#&3-1,(#$*1$,3#("'!($$#%0##'

('#=1#(".84 &($&(,(3#0&"&("+&'!--#!.4&"&'$&'3&''#$

471"6&"+(0$#0!'"%'"'

? (/&#6 "+# !%""+!""+#!--#!.+!'7##($&'3&''#$(3#0&"'4 "+#&''1# %($(!"&( !$#.!8 B$!8'&( &.&(,"+#!--#!.&'

0#($#0#$!%!$#3&%!($&'(",(#&("

-5A$!/&($#0