Gurdial Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS




   
 

!"#$#%&'&()* +,$&!-&(./ 011#--!(" 2#,'+' "!"# +(3!4!($"/#,' 0 #'1($#("' 

)  56  
76


,#'#(") , !38+9!,8!::!,;$<%!"#,"/#!11#--!(" ===
  

 >? "/ "/# +,"' 4#-@ $&'9&''#$ "/# '+&" &-#$ 4A "/# !11#--!("B1-!&("&@/#,#&(1,!A#,@!',!$#%-!,!"&("/!"/#@!'@(#,&( 1''#''&(-!($9#!'+,&(.C:!(!-'%91,&'#$8/!',! * CD ; !$4!'"  '&"+!"#$ &( <&--!.# !'&,! 8/&-%/&; #/'&- !($ &'",&%"

#,E#1+,; 4#'&$#'; , 1#,9!(#(" &(3+(%"&( , ,#'",!&(&(. $##($!("'B ,#'1($#(" ' !($  ,9 #F#%+"&(. !($ &91-#9#("&(. ,$#, $!"#$  C1!''#$4A"/##1+"A99&''&(#,; #,E#1+,#F#,%&'&(."/# 1@#,'  "/# 99&''&(#, +($#, "/# +(3!4 +4-&% ,#9&'#' !($ 6!($

<&%"&( !($ #(" #%<#,A  %"; G*H @&"/ %('#I+#("&!- ,#-&#  1#,9!(#("&(3+(%"&(,#'",!&(&(."/#$##($!("'B,#'1($#("',9&("#,#,&(. &("/#1#!%#+-1''#''&("/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("<#,"/#'+&"-!($!($ ,9$&'1''#''&(."/#1-!&("&B!11#--!(",9"/#'+&"-!($ >? /# %!'# !' '#" +1 4A "/# !11#--!(" 4#,# "/# -#!,(#$ ,&!- +,"@!'"/!"/&'!"/#,@!'&(1''#''&("/#'+&"-!($@/&%/@!'@(#$

 4A"/# ,<&(%&!-<#,(9#("'&(%#!(+94#,A#!,'!($!"#,/&'$#!"/; "/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("/!$%9#&("1''#''&(&#!-9'"*A#!,'1,&," "/# &-&(.  "/# '+&" !($ "/!" $##($!("B,#'1($#("  /!$ &-#$ !( !11-&%!"&(+($#,#%"&('C!($"/#!,#9#("&(#$%",#<&%"&( "/#1-!&("&4+""/#'!9#@!'$&'9&''#$4A"/#--#%",<&$#,$#,$!"#$ * F DC   @#<#,; "/# #1+"A 99&''&(#,; #,E#1+, #F#,%&'&(."/#1@#,'"/#99&''&(#,; #,E#1+,!--@#$"/#!11#!- &-#$4A"/#"!"#<&$#,$#,F $!"#$ C >H? ,$#, F  ; ,#%,$#$ "/!" "/# 1-!&("&B!11#--!(" @!' (" $&'1+"&(."/#@(#,'/&1"/#"!"#<#,(9#("!($@!'1,#1!,#$""!:# "/# 1,1#,"A &( I+#'"&( ( -#!'# ( '+%/ "#,9' !($ %($&"&(' !' @#,# $##9#$!11,1,&!"

#4A"/#"!"#<#,(9#("
"@!'+,"/#,4'#,<#$"/!" %(",-  "/# 1,1#,"A &( I+#'"&( @!' @&"/ "/#
,,&.!"&( #1!,"9#("; <#,(9#(" +(3!4!($"/!""/#!11#--!("/!$&-#$"/#%&<&-'+&"4!'#$( !$<#,'#1''#''&( >C? /#%&<&-'+&"@!'$&'9&''#$4A"/#-#!,(#$",&!-+,"4A("/# .,+($ "/!" "/# "!"# <#,(9#(" /!$ '+./" #<&%"&(  "/# 1-!&("&B!11#--!(",9"/#1,1#,"A&(I+#'"&(&("/#A#!,C;"/#,#,#; &"%+-$("4#'!&$"/!""/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("@!'&(!+"/,&E#$1''#''&( "/#'!&$1,1#,"A!($(#&"/#,%+-$1''#''&(4#",#!"#$!'+(&("#,,+1"#$; "/!"!-"/+./;"/#,$#,1!''#$4A"/#--#%", F C @!'&(!<+,"/# !11#--!("; A#" "/# '!9# @!'

#,E#1+, #F#,%&'&(. "/# 1@#,'  "/# 99&''&(#, <&$# ,$#, $!"#$  C !($ "/# !11#--!("B1-!&("& @!' ,$#,#$ " 4# #<&%"#$ ,9 "/# 1,1#,"A&(I+#'"&(/#-#!,(#$,&!-+,"!-',#-&#$+1("/#%,''D #F!9&(!"&("/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("!($4'#,<#$"/!""/#-!($&(I+#'"&( /!$ (#<#, 4##( !--""#$ " /&9 , /&' 1,#$#%#'', 4A "/# 1,<&(%&!-

 <#,(9#("/#-#!,(#$,&!-+,"4'#,<#$"/!""/#9#,#!%""/!""/# (!9#"/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("@!',#%,$#$&("/#%-+9(%+-"&<!"&(&( "/#!9!4!($&@+-$("&(&"'#-%(#,!,&./"("/#1-!&("&B!11#--!("" '##:,#-&#$#%-!,!"&(("/#.,+($!$<#,'#1''#''&(!'"/#1-#! !$<#,'#1''#''&(%+-$4#"!:#((-A&($##(%#!($,#-&#$#%-!,!"&( ( "/# 4!'&'  !$<#,'# 1''#''&( %+-$ (" 4# .,!("#$ &( "#,9'  ,"&%-# "/#6&9&"!"&(%" #-&!(%#@!'1-!%#$("/#$#%&'&("/&' +,"&(  &(%!'#"&"-#$!'

  ! 

!'@#--!'  "

#$%% & '&( %!'#"&"-#$!'() ## ! 

"

*#! 

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

,(#$%+('#-,"/#!11#--!("/!'("4##(!4-#"%+("#, "/#&($&(."/#+,"'4#-@4!'#$(,"&%-# "/#%""/!""/#1-#!  !$<#,'# 1''#''&( %+-$ 4# ,!&'#$ (-A 4A @!A  $##(%# !($ ,#-&# %+-$("4#'+./"("/#4!'&'!$<#,'#1''#''&(4A&-&(.!%&<&-'+&" ,!$#%-!,!"

+ >*?
( "/# %&,%+9'"!(%#';
 !9  "/# <&#@ "/!" "/# &($&(.' ,#%,$#$4A"/#+,"'4#-@$("@!,,!("!(A&("#,#,#(%#4A"/&'+," !' ( '+4'"!("&!- I+#'"&(  -!@ &' &(<-<#$  /#,# &' ( 9#,&" &( "/# !11#!-%%,$&(.-A;"/#'!9#&'$&'9&''#$&(-&9&(#  7!-&!  +$.# * !9&" 
7/#"/#,'1#!:&(.B,#!'(#$ ) #'B 
7/#"/#,,#1,"!4-# ) #'B