High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23555/2024disposed of

Union Of India And Others v. Ic 44551 Col Sanjay Kumar Verma And Another

2024-11-18Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

!" #$%$!&'()((

!"#$%&'

()( ")#$

*' +,* --

- .

+,* - -- - * , +-./ ( 0

10 10 2 0 3

34 1* $5 ( *0 6032+7800 + ( 110 902+7804 ( 07+* ,12+7804 ::::

- .

#1 ,11

0 6 * 21* $5

4 +02 * 0.

4 1 , 0 + 4 1

+0+ "

;

$2 0 *0

+ -. 1 30

+ 9+ # - 8

+261 183094 4 1, 4 + 0-3.*

60 0336+

#0 1 #234!0&5 < + 9. = >?@ 04 0 41031 ,18

41 7821

+1+ 0-3.4

* - 0 +60 + ,+4 9 78

>194+ ,21 + 0-3.60

+AB 34-.1(+803C0 + #1+ 0-3.39 830941 60 <8+ -. 1 9* 1 .2 1 1 , + 10 1

+ 0-3 6 1 0 - 0-3 - , 0,, 070+ -.

4930 78 43+ 4

0**03 +0+ D67 21 0960 <8+-.1**330997+

+0+ @ #1 04 21 ,1 43+ + 0**03+0+> 2- 1 0910 03 - - 8

+ + -.1**3309920 60 43+04 030* 49 10

;9 1 3 ,0,, 7+2 43+2-4 1 30

+ 9+ # - 03 8

+2 61 1 80 0 81033 ,104 0+ <8 $#1 0+2-809 0336+7+ +0+ #1* 07*0 41 0+ ; 08+1 04

&'() *()

(+ +( ,(,(

+( +, ,(+-

= 3 ,0,, 7+4 9104 0+ *0

+ *

0$2-.130

+ 9+ # - 038

+21 *

4 +010 43+1 0,0

0 6 *

-4 1 &" 4 &# %!"7$%!04 @ C4 * 8+ ,90E0 44870+< +80 *

1* 6 * 2 0 4 30

0 84 + 9 ,611

1-40339 40 .+ 7 F7 .99- 41+4 *

32- * 1 - ,

33+ 10 9.2+ *01 03

0,2 * 1 -89 , 3 +20 099- 4189-00 +4 8 0-3 19 2 1 09 90 , +8+2.1 0** * 21 * 3 9 1 8- ,8

0-3- 1 8 , 03 - ,8

0-3-890,, 070+ - 0 - 0-3930 7821 08G +24 921* 8*3 1 1< +,9 +-.1D H-3*; 2 80 3+

! 2 * + "#$% #& #1 370 *0 0, 0*1 4 1 0+ 7 +8 0 ; 08+ 1 04 ,.

" "

0 1 #$ 2

" "

" 3

,() "

4 5 / +.7,8 / 93:: #5

+;*$

#$/

<5 ' =5 +-#$> #$ ? #

#5 .$ #"$:

<5 +-#$> #"$:

" @

" " @

<+-#$> #"$:

" A B

<+-#$>C #"$:

A B

3::

8D A #A 6 $,((,E84 1D

6 8

;7 .

? 8 7 0+ ,"

$410-7; 08+* 8*3 1 ,1* +3.+830 21061 0+ 0-3.-89 03+ *

.99- 4189-00 +4 8 0-3 19 20 +6181 1 ; 4 B 7 2 1 * 2 1 ,1 0 81 + 0-3+ 99- +- 703++ 4 91 9.2- . 1

+-0

, +1- 44+ 0-3.*

> 13

210

, 9 4+ 0-3.*

0 .

99- 4189-00 +4 8 0-3 19 261-89 03+ 61 0 + 0-3. 0 G 0 9 4 B 9 2 - 9* 073.

0 +830 0 4 9 1 (+803 C0 +2 80 ++3.

8 ,101 0+00 ++ 0-3.- ,0 - 0-3

-89 ,0,, 070+-.930 78#1 0++830 0 -89

< +-.14 5 6 / +.7,8 / 93::#5

+;*$

9 21 ,11

0* 9*

, + "3G3"1 +*1.

8030 +9 03103140 .99- 41 +4 8 0-3 19 8

+2 *8033.61 01 0,41

-89 ,

33+21 +0- 1 -89 ,- 610 .+ ( 7 21 ,11

03 04

9* 2 10 61 0 . + 0 1 2 1 88

- G 3.2 1 1 0+ 10** , 4 + 0 $

40 .+ 2 -* 9+-0 G 341

, 78 0 0 99- 4 1 +4 8 0-3 19 9* 073.21

4 * 7 ,1 +69 G 0- 4

0$"3G3"18

+2- + 19*3. 20 +

21 0+

+ ,+21 * 2183090 -89 3+ 87+ 0-3.*

( 7 20331408

+ 8 8 9 0 0 +0 1 4 78 -. 1 8

+20 -83 3. I+21 4 +830 ,611

40 .+ 7 F7 18

+2 0 G 3G 0

4 930 78 0 +5 1 09 - , 0,, 070+ -. - 0 - 0-3930 78

C100 90.21

-89 03 4 104

8*3"

$10.1 80 -+ 034+ 0-3.*

1 8

+2- 3. * / 0$194088*0 8418

+ 930 .

782 9 -89 , ++-.1(+803 C0 + 7 07 1 - , - 61 0 + 6181 167 2-89 8 83 ++-. ,19

4-89 3 + -$ . 4 + 0 1 4 2 90. 03

- G 3.-898 83 ++-.1(+803C0 +2

0 4 9 4 930 . 78 - 0 - 0-3930 782 1 09- ,0 8 , 03+

2419+803* 13+ 101+ 8 3+

107- +8+ 9+803;09 0 418

+- 90+21 * 1 -89 , 3 + 7821 *

09633 -+9+1070 + , 782.

0 "

0$21(+803C0 + + 01

8 83 + ,

( 7 2 03 +830 + 0210 90 +0 .

1(+803C0 +43361, +3 30++6 10*

41JK +(+803"(30 .

$2LJ) 39 / K 03 8*3 J

#1 4 210 - 6+ 9 +611 4 10-7* 8*3 2611 0194 3 9 41*

1 9.21 04 0* 39 .9+803;09 0

- ,90+ "33" 103121 0 -809 ++0-

9+ - ,190 +5 611 9 -8090** ++ 101 0++ 60 0+ 0,( 7 2 03

+-+ 9 +24 91408 010 +2611 03 ;

1 * 41+ 20 +5 1

4 2 1 *

21 * 1

339 41*

0E , *3082 "33" 1 087

-. 19 4 930 78261 21 90.8 83 +101

4 1+ - 60 0 G 341 , 78 1 9.

+0 8160 0 - 0-3 -8090,, 070+-.1 930 78

0++ 2 03 +-,01 +4 91

+ 2611 1(+803C0 +2++ 033.* 8+90E0 +03+ 8 70 8+ 03818E2*0 8 30 3.0** 0 ,1 0+7 41+ 21 ,19*3.9 404 9+803 81 G 2 1 73 , 1 -38E 810 , 8 8

8 61 4 9 2 1+ -809 8+( 7 241 0+ 9*3.9 403 30 3.21 90.-898 83 ++G 0 *

421 - G 10** 3 9 0E *3082 60 8 , 03- 6+ , 4 930 78- + - ,0 - 0-3 -89 ,0,, 070+

-.* 84930 78 3.241 09*3.+ 81 G 01 0,40** 3 9 0E ,*30821 -.1 (+803C0 +8

+230+ 08 2101 0

+ 8+ 40 .+ 2- .1 0++ + 1- ,1 3 9 40 .*

3 10 9.2 07. 0

8 30 3.1 - G 087+8 5 * 4 + ,18

4 4930 782- 6 3+ 0 033.

30+06338 -.1(+803C0 +210 087 *

- -809 8+ 4 9 0 4487 80 03 , 8 8

61 6 3+-+ 034+ 0-3.*

= D67 2 6 1 0+ +07 21 + -; 08 ,18 41* 20 -809 ++-.1 30 (+803C0 + '( '

')*+,-, ./'

30 +

+ 5+ 0-3 81 3,803 488

02 0

3 !!

01 3"4 $

52 3 "4 $

4 , 613

7 , . 0 E0+ 0 E 08 02 8 8++ 0

1 0 - 0-3 0,, 070+-.

930 78 0 * 0 0 4 10* 4K(H (3

?09 ++

@ 0+ ,41 + 703 1001941 90 .

D.*

$ 0** 3 9 0E ,*308 -80990+

41* 8*3 "

0$+830 +-.1D H-3*; 80 3+0

! "2 $-.1(+803 C0 +210 9+ 6181167 2++ 4 -+1*

2-89 3 + 1 9.2++90E * 39 .

4 2 1 +830 0 4 306 < +,9 "

0$ 10

0* 9* 101

,41 0++ 0 G 34 4 782 +-407 0-3.

+6+7 07 1 #1 ,1 1 0+ * 9*

- 0-3- 1

30+7+ 8 - 1 0+* 9*

-809 80 * 1 * D67 2 1 0+ 80 7+ 0++ 8 ,+ , ,

7 07 1 2 4 8, 3.

- ,1 0+* 9* 2- 0 033.03 ++80 0

+ .03 * 1(+803C0 +2 ,0, 34 1 +07 4

1 ,2 1 ,1 9*3.9 4 1 0 4 -38E 810

, 8 80 03 8

8 81 G "

$2 61 90. -809

073+101

,41+ 10 9.*

32 -809 8+4 90 8+ 03, 84093.1 .( 7 60 03 +- 0+ 19+803* 210 1+ - 4 06334 9+ 60 08 , 03+ +-809 1 0,, 070+-. -8090 - 0-3930 .

? D67 20 0+ ,4* "

0$2+ 83 1010

- ++ 0 .*+4 90 +

107- ++ 1 ; "

0$ 0+3.2 8 7+ 8 - 1 9* "

0$10 - 3+-.1* 21 21 8

0 +,7 6,10,1* 419+803-0 +2 ; 08+ "

*8 3.2 1 8 + 8 80 -

, +1 033 9+ 2- + 1

41+ 80

- 0+-0 G 340 8+ 03, 8 4093.1 . 3.2 +-+830 +0 4 9

4930 78 0++ 2 +-+830 +

-0 - 0-3 -89 ,0,, 070+-. 4930 78 -.1*

> ( 7 21 ,1 0+1

101+ "

$ 88

+613 78-809* 9+-.1+4 8*

0*080 02- 81 ;*

90 +0

370 , 30

2618190E 1

41+ "

$ *080 02 -,04 G 3100 812H

0 4 91 4930 78 -8090,, 070+ -. 41930 78 8

G 821308E41 0+ ;*

90 +0 1 , 30

2 + 8

0 1 8 83 +2107 41

41 0++ "

$ * 1 88

+ 0*080 021 -.21 0+

0 - +830 + -89 0,, 070+ -. - 0 - 0-3 4930 78 2 8 41< +,9 +-.1 *; 2 80 3+0 6

'%&7 61

20+830 0 90+1 ; 2101- 44 + ,442 10 -89 +6+ 18

+ 30 3.03 1

+40 -3 ,1 -809 7 + 1 * 4 1 E , G 0 1 0** + 44- ,90+ 1 407 )7 1 6 8 1 +830 0 4 306 90+

7 +8"

0$90E 1 0++830 0 -0 ;* 30 4306 921 21;* 30 4306 920 90+ 7 +8 0$03 90E 11

8 4

+- 4 7 07 1 +4 8 *

3 8

+2 2 2 03 3 1

+21 00 .9 E1, ,41 +69

90+1

20 +102 14 33 89*39 20 *3

2- +

*8741-0 240 .24+30.0 +3081 #1 4 2 1 , , 4 1 - 4 4 1 0**

+ 442 417 +8"

0$ +-.1# - 8

+203 + 44 4 90 .33,03.0 + +- *13+

$& 1 45 4!"7$%!04 04 90121 4 + 9 16 *

+61- 70

0-721 09 + 9

+ #19* , + 20 *0

+-.130

+# - 8

+2 90 0 +0 +044 9+ +403 ,61033* + ,0**380 $240 . -

- .

- - * ()((

11 *0E ,5 + / & 5 11 * 0-3 / & 5