High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/22658/2025disposed of

M/S Kahlon Stone Crusher v. State Of Punjab And Others

2025-12-11Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor19 pages

!"#$%

, %#&'('$)*++,

!"#$% , %#&'('$)*++,

!"#$% , , %#&'('$)*++,

!"#$% - .

, %#&'('$)*++,

/ /

!"#$% , , , %#&'('$)*++,

!"#$%

, , %#&'('$)*++,

, ,

.,7 , 1

70 ,

5-6

7 (

07- (

07 (

0.7

-. ,.1

- - ,.1

5.6

- ,.1

-,7

- .

, 1

--0-

0 ,.1

. , 1

5 6

-7

--- , 1

-07

- 0

-70

- 0

576

--..

-.-

-..,

- -

-,.

--0

----

-----

----

---7

---77

---0

506

-- -

-- 7

--0,

--0 , 1

--0,

--0

5,6

--0-

--00

-.-. +

-.-.-

-.-.

-.-.7

-.- ,

-.7

-..

-.7

-.0 /

-.0

-.0,-

- -

- ,

- --

- - (

- , 1

- . , 1

9#(#)"* 9+!)(:9;'89+4<$&!"#='"> 9+ !'?>!< !9@84<$&!"#8!)4

5-6 9+ !9')4#9>'A!)84<$&!"#8 9+ !9')4#9!;')@>'">#=!;84<$&!"#8 9+ !9(> !(: :B"!84<$&!"#8 9+!:9!<>!"'!84<$&!"#8 9+!9"!C')@>>!D:984<$&!"#8%$9">#B#"'"'$)#91(3+ 9+!A!)4##B')@>!)4>#9844;+ 8:)C!?+ EEE + ;;">#B#"'"'$)(9!'(#&$AA$)F:#("'$)($%;!=!)4%!&"(!)4 >!<#?##)>#!94"$@#">#9+>#G!9#">:(8?#')@4'(B$(#4$%?G">'(&$AA$) C:4@A#)"='">">#&$)(#)"$%;#!9)#4&$:)(#;%$9">#B!9"'#(+$9">#(!D#$% ?9#<'"G8 %!&"( !9# ?#')@ #H"9!&"#4 %9$A

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

4 )$"'&#1(3 '((:#4 "$ ">#A ?G "># '("9'&" ')')@ %%'&#9 $% "># &$)&#9)#4 4'("9'&"1(3>$;4')@">#A;'!?;#"$B!G(B#&'%'#4(:A(%$9!;;#@#4<'$;!"'$)$% "># B9$<'('$)( $% "># :)C!? 9:(>#9 $;'&G8 ,- 1%$9 (>$9" K"># $;'&G8 ,-3$9">#:)C!?')$9')#9!;(:;#(8,-1%$9(>$9"K">#:;#(8,-3+ + $"'&#(!9#'((:#4"$">#B#"'"'$)#9(:)4#9">#$;'&G8,-%$9 (:?A'""')@ ')&$99#&" 9#":9)( $9 ') $9A KJ $% "># :;#(8 ,- %$9 ';;#@!

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

"#$

"&$ '

"#$

"($% %

)

"#$

"($ * '%

, %

5 6

"&$ -

".$

$&$

/ %

"0$

"3$

4 (

% %

"&$

6 1

% %

8 .+ :;# 8!%$9#(!'48=$:;4&;#!9;G')4'&!"#">#A!))#9')=>'&> !((#((A#)"$%9$G!;"G'("$?#A!4#')4'%%#9#)"&'9&:A("!)&#(+)&!(#=>#9# "># A')')@ '( ?#')@ :)4#9"!D#) ?G "># A')')@ ;'&#)(##8 9#":9)( !9# "$ ?# %:9)'(>#4')$9AKJ!)4!((#((A#)"$94#9(!9#"$?#B!((#4')$9AK J+ :;#($%,-8%:9">#9B9$<'4#%$9">#B9$&#4:9#"$?#%$;;$=#4%$9B!((')@ "># $94#9 $% !((#((A#)"+ :?

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

'#=#4 %9$A ?$"> "># !(B#&"(8 =# %')4 ">!" "># 'AB:@)#4 4#A!)4)$"'&#(9!'(#4?G">#"!"#$%:)C!?&!))$"?#!;;$=#4"$("!)4')'"( &:99#)"%$9A')!(A:&>!()$)#$%">#B#"'"'$)#9(>!<#?##)A!4#!=!9#$% ">#)!":9#$%4#A!)49!'(#4!@!')("">#A')!&&$94!)&#='">">#!BB;'&!?;# B9$&#4:9# )$9 !)G $BB$9":)'"G $% &$)"#(" >!( ?##) @'<#) "$ ">#A+ ) (:&> &'9&:A("!)&#(8$)">'((>$9"B$')"!;$)#8">#@9'#<!)&#$%">#B#"'"'$)#9('( %$:)4 "$ >!<# (:?("!)&# !)4 "># =9'" B#"'"'$)( &$)(#F:#)";G !9# ;'!?;# "$ (:&&##4+ +

#A!G!;($)$"#">!"')">#:;#(8,-8">#9#'(!9#A#4G$% !BB#!;?#%$9#">#"!"# #$;$@'("+:9')@">#B#)4#)&G$%">#=9'"B#"'"'$)(8 :;#7>!(?##)!A#)4#4!)4">#B$=#9$%!BB#;;!"#!:">$9'"G'(4#;#@!"#4 "$:B#9')"#)4')@ )@')##9+>#!BB#;;!"#$94#9(B!((#4!@!')("($A#$%">#

56 B#"'"'$)#9(!9#!;($!((!';#4')">#9#(B#&"'<#=9'"B#"'"'$)(+>#!BB#!;(>!<# ?##) 4'(A'((#4 ?G "># :B#9')"#)4')@ )@')##9+ " "># "'A# =>#) (:&> $94#9( =#9# B!((#4 ') !BB#!;8 "># :B#9')"#)4')@ )@')##9 =!( )$" "># !BB9$B9'!"# !BB#;;!"# !:">$9'"G :)4#9 :;# 7 $% "># :;#(8 ,-+ <#) $">#9='(#8=#%')4">!"">#(#$94#9(B!((#4')!BB#!;?G">#:B#9')"#)4')@

)@')##9!(!BB#;;!"#!:">$9'"G8&!))$"?#(:("!')#4$)&#'"'(%$:)4">!""># ;'!?';'"G $% "># B#"'"'$)#9( >!( )$" ?##) 4#"#9A')#4 ') !&&$94!)&# ='"> "># B9$&#4:9# B9#(&9'?#4 ?G B!((')@ !BB9$B9'!"# $94#9( $% !((#((A#)" !)4 ">'( !(B#&">!(&$AB;#"#;G?##)@;$((#4$<#9+ 0+ $9&$A')@"$">#&$)&;:('$)">!"!BB9$B9'!"#B9$&#4:9#>!()$" ?##)%$;;$=#4?#%$9#4#A!)4)$"'&#(=#9#'((:#4"$">#B#"'"'$)#9(8=#%')4 (:BB$9"%9$A">#$?(#9<!"'$)(A!4#?G! $$94')!"##)&>$%">'( $:9"') ">#&!(#$%

"#$% &'( )* +& #%8

, .

,,84#&'4#4$),+,+,,+>#'<'('$)#)&>>!(>#;4">!"&$AB;'!)&# ='">#&"'$) 1 3$%">#:)C!?')#(!)4')#9!;(:;#(8,-8'(#((#)"'!; ?#%$9#!4#A!)4$%9$G!;"G&$:;4?#9!'(#4+>#$?(#9<!"'$)(A!4#?G"># '<'('$)#)&>')B!9!($+!)40!9#9#B9$4:&#4>#9#')!%"#9* 619

9 % !

"3$% ": #

;

"3$

% ,

) =% '>'> ,

( $

506

( $

8 ,+ )<'#=$%">#!);G('(!)44'(&:(('$)(8!%$9#(!'48=#!;;$=!;; ">#=9'"B#"'"'$)(!)4&$)(#F:#)";G">#4#A!)4)$"'&#(!(=#;;!(">#$94#9( B!((#4 ') !BB#!;(8 =>'&> !9# 'AB:@)#4 ') 9#(B#&"'<# =9'" B#"'"'$)(8 !9# F:!(>#4+>#"!"#$%:)C!?(>!;;8>$=#<#98?#!";'?#9"G"$B9$&##4!@!')(" "># B#"'"'$)#9( ?G (&9:B:;$:(;G %$;;$=')@ "># B9$&#4:9# ;!'4 4$=) %$9 4#"#9A')!"'$)$%9$G!;"G#'">#9%$9<'$;!"'$)$%:;#(8,-$9 9:(>#9$;'&G8 ,-8?GB!((')@!BB9$B9'!"#$94#9($%!((#((A#)"')!&&$94!)&#='">;!=+ $9(:&>B:9B$(#(8">#"!"#$%:)C!?(>!;;!;($?#!";'?#9"G"$'((:#)$"'&#( (B#&'%G')@ "># )!":9# $% <'$;!"'$) !""9'?:"#4 "$ #!&> $% "># B#"'"'$)#9(8 ') "#9A( $% "># 9:;#(B$;'&G8 =>#9#<#9 !BB;'&!?;#8 @'<')@ "># B#"'"'$)#9( ! 9#!($)!?;#$BB$9":)'"G$%>#!

9')@8')">#A!""#9+ + ># =9'" B#"'"'$)( !9# &$)(#F:#)";G !;;$=#4+ $ $94#9( !9# B!((#4!("$&$("(+ + ;;B#)4')@A'(&+!BB;'&!"'$)1(38'%!)G8!;($("!)44'(B$(#4$%+ ,- ,- ++, 9!C#(> + >#">#9(B#!D')@9#!($)#4L * #($ + >#">#99#B$9"!?