High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5560/2016dismissed

Ved Prakash Gupta v. Pritam Nath Gupta

2022-12-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"#$%

%%&&

$ '("#$%

) " *+

$"#$%*+ "%%&&

( " %

,,,,

# !

- " '"%%&*"' &&.&/0/&1&/0/ &1"% %%&

! !$ "%

2 &/*" "%& ' (" #$% " 3 $1" $ 1 !"

#$%*!45$' ""5$' *&& - 3!1 % '4$ 1" ' 1"%$&%"/&% "%& '%1"'&&1&&/ 3&/ '" % % /'% ( "%&*$ " 1" $ 1"%/"$*"$ %1 " %& &&1&&/ 3&/* " " +$&/ ' /4$3%+$ "%&1"

% " + " %&* " . %% % /3 1%&(

'$ 1 6$ / $7-8$ &9*"8."" +$ +&&1 .& " 4%$ *:"& - 3;

4<% 5"5$&&4 /5" 5$&* 0 4%$ *&""%$ "% % / 3 1%&(

'$ 1 6$ / $78$ &9" ." +$+&&1 .&

" 4%$ *:"& - 3 ' =7-< 7'+&

>0$&/ 1 ."" 1 *&""+1$'( ?0

>0;

"%&"" '&/' (""%$ "" % % / '4<% 5"5$&6$&" +& $&/@$ 1 .""$31 *

0 2&&31 "3 1$'( ?

?;" " %& &6$"""&" +$ "%&6$" $% % /+ &6$"'$&/@$ 1 .""1 *&"3 1$'( >0

;"%&'&/ '$8$ 1'<""'%&/ +*."$! " %& 3$ . 1 3 " % % / 6$ 3 !%"&!"1'3"+ ."" +"%& % % 1$' ."'& 1&/" +"%& " '""%&" .!)$&/* ;

""%&+"% % /6$*" &1 '%& * - 3 0 > .&& $3'1'%&& 0 *- 3*" 3.""-8( >A > $ A*A* A> *AA>* * 28B. 1 1( ;" "%&"%%& $& 1 1"% % /6$3 "B":.& *

B-* - 3* ."" . $ + '' (

B-=B:= = >

% ""%&*" .$ & %&3 1(

27-8$ & "8"88* - 3;" " 1% &&$

A .""" %"/&%" %&%"%& '"% % /6$* 1+1 $"%&&"% $

*( 0%% 3$"/ &/. '*$"" . $! + 0 > $36$&/"/3 '" B$ % 1@%

8". ' &3"& ( * " " % &' / 34 ." 1 '3&/"$*&$"%&3 1" $1""%&"%% ""B$ ." &" ' *$""%&' %"$% % /; " &&11"$ "% @ %$/"% %&. "$% &&1&&/ "% % /.%3/" ' ";" '"" 3$ / .&&.".1*$ /1$ '"&&& "3&$. %"% % / 6$"% %&" $1""&&$.

" "&&%&&1"-8 8$ " $3'" '" . %"% % /6$ 8 31*" 6$%&31%" $ % % / 1 " .

% / '&"$

"%&1"% *&&.1$. '

# $

% &

:"% & +$%% " %+ &'

" 1"& $& "% *" & B$ $( +$ "%&1" *$( .1" +$ "%&*$( 0.+$ " %& 1 " * $ ( A > .

% 3/"$& %% 1$ 1"$ 1$'". % 1&/ $&&/*" $"%&. . ' 1 " %$& % " %& ' %1 " %& &&1&&/ 3&/ ' " $ % % /+4$1' > A

-&111 +3/"4$1' *" ( C !"#$%"&%%&"B$ )$1* - 3* ."" . 1 & & )$1*- 3*."+4$1' > '"%%&

21.""4$1' % 3/"B$ 3&.*"( "&"% 1$& %%&3 "B$ *."".$" %%& %% " $1" $& &&/ D.+ * " . % "3"& *'& "%/

8"+" & $& "%%&&3 11" $1""

D 3""B$ $'$ 1 %& 31&1&%"%&6$*."""& % 1" 1 "%&(

2&' 3/"%% 1* 1 9@ $3/

B-*" &B$ "3 +"" $ &%& (

2"7-8$ & *"8"88*- 3

'& &/"&/$%&7-9@ *" ' %& (

2 :" %% " " %& " 3 " .!%"$% % /&&1&&/ 3&/3/'!1$'$&%. :"$" &/& (

$"%&(

2" :"&1@$ 3/3 1( ?> ?

." 1 & (

2 $%"'/+&$3& 1"." 1 %&(

:"( !" &' "+ %$ "%&(

2'$ 1 A 0>6$ / ' ""5$' ?

:"' "1"%&& $&+1$3/"%&@ %&(

2&'3/".$3" 7- - / *"% +% "4$1'3/ " &B$ 31 % $$ '

#( ) *

# +,

,!-.

/0)

0 * ,!-

1 +, 2 * 3

# , * 0 . 4 5 2 6 7

(

89&* * #

$9)

# *

0 * 0 )

7 & )$1* - 3 ."& " 1"%%&$"'&1 '.""3 + 3/" &B$ ." 1 %&31%%& 6$" 1 "'" 3&+$ ( *."" &%& (

2*.""@" 7-&."3/

" &B$ &' :" *"%&. 1"&/$& % '4$% /

2""4$1' 6$& .&& % $&% % %% &%% + % &. :" &&1&/ '/" ($3&6$&. " %%&

-1 ' " %%&* " ' ' 1&/

" ' %%& '* " '&&$%%& */*% 1&/

$% 2 4 &'()'(**(+,-.(/0,1(+23.4 (,0- &'()'(**(1-*)+56( (,0-