High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4168/2015dismissed

State Of Punjab & ORS v. Mohinder Singh

2016-01-19Mrs Justice Sabina3 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* ")+",- ./

")+",- ./

+)0"1#"#$")%#2$,( 33$44")#( 5$,(+( 2')%$,')62 $(3)%$)# * * * * 78 78 78 78

,$($)#*

,$($)#* ,9 '%2+/%%4 +)0"1 :::::

:::::

/ $(3)%$)#2"% '4$% (+'# , %$&4","#')#2"#2$ ;"($)#'#4$%#3"-<(&"4$ = >< ;$

..#'44 #2$%"#$ 2'((+3$,"))+"#') 2$&"($ #2$,$(3)%$)#/')1,'$ /;"(#2"#2$ 2"%0')$%#2$ $3",#?$)# )%+(#,'$( ??$,&$/ +)0"1 ) .@@"($&2)'&'")")%;"(4"#$,"%0+(#$%"6"')(# A"&")# 3(# +)', $&2)'&"4 (('(#")# A'%$ ,%$, %"#$%

.. $(3)%$)# ,$#',$% ,? #2$ ("'% 3(# ) "##"')')6#2$"6$ (+3$,"))+"#'))> .4#2+62/ #2$(&"4$ +)',$&2)'&"4(('(#")#;"(= >< 1+##2$ ,$(3)%$)#;"(3"'%("4",-')#2$3"-<(&"4$ ;$

.. $)&$/ #2$ (+'# ;"( '4$% 1- #2$ ,$(3)%$)#&4"'?')6#2$",,$",( 3"- $ $)%")#( ') #2$', ($3","#$ ;,'##$) (#"#$?$)#( "A$,,$%#2"##2$,$(3)%$)#2"%1$$)"33')#$%"(B'44$% 3$,"#, ) .@@ ) "% 2& 1"('( ")% ;"( 4"#$,

,$6+4",'($% ;$ .

$(3)%$)# ;"( %$&4",$% (+,34+(")%;"("%0+(#$%"6"')(#3(# B'44$%3$,"#,') #2$3"-<(&"4$ '))%+(#,'"4 $A$43?$)#<&+?< C+"4'#-",B$#')6$)#,$)6')$$,')6/6"')2'(;)3"-< (&"4$)#2$1"('( 2'(3#')%"#$% .. #;"( ,%$,$% #2"# #2$ 3"- #2$ ,$(3)%$)# 1$ %,";) "6"')(# A"&")#3(# +)',$&2)'&"4(('(#")#$(3)%$)#)$A$, ;,B$% "( +)', $&2)'&"4 (('(#")# ")% ,$#',$% "( B'44$% 3$,"#, ) "##"')')6 #2$ "6$ (+3$,"))+"#') ) > . ) #2$ 34$"%')6( #2$ 3",#'$(/ 44;')6 '((+$( ;$,$ ,"?$%1-#2$#,'"4+,#*< D E2$#2$,#2$34"')#'

'($)#'#4$% ,%$&4","#') "(3,"-$% ,F

E2$#2$, 34"')#'

'( $)#'#4$% , ?")%"#,- ')0+)&#')"(3,"-$% ,F

> E2$#2$,3,$($)#(+'#'()#?"')#"')"14$F

E2$#2$,)&"+($ "&#')",($') "A+,

34"')#'

E2$#2$, 3,3$, &+,# $$ 2"( )# 1$$) 3"'%F

$4'$ G

",#'$( 4$% #2$', $A'%$)&$ ') (+33,# #2$', ,$(3$&#'A$34$"( ,'"4+,#A'%$0+%6?$)#H%$&,$$%"#$%> > %'(?'(($%#2$(+'# #2$,$(3)%$)#<34"')#'

)")"33$"4

'4$% 1- #2$ ,$(3)%$)#<34"')#'

"6"')(# #2$ ("'% 0+%6?$)#H%$&,$$3"(($%1-#2$#,'"4+,#/#2$ ',(#33$44"#$ +,# A'%$ 0+%6?$)#H%$&,$$ %"#$% > %$&,$$% #2$

> (+'#$)&$/#2$3,$($)#"33$"41-#2$"33$44")#(<%$ $)%")#( 2"A$2$",%4$",)$%#"#$&+)($4")%2"A$6)$ #2,+62#2$,$&,%"A"'4"14$)#2$ '4$&",$ +44- ) #2$ 3,$($)# &"($/ "%?'##$%4-/ ,$(3)%$)# 2"% 0')$%#2$ $3",#?$)# )%+(#,'$(")%??$,&$/ +)0"1) .@@2$3(# ,$(3)%$)#;"(%$&4",$%(+,34+(")% 2$;"("%0+(#$%"6"')(##2$3(# +)',$&2)'&"4(('(#")# A'%$,%$,%"#$% ..$(3)%$)#,$#',$%)"##"')')6 #2$ "6$ (+3$,"))+"#') ) > . %?'##$%4-/ ,$(3)%$)#;"("%0+(#$%"6"')(##2$3(# +)',$&2)'&"4 (('(#")#;$

..")%&)#')+$%)#2$("'%3(##'44 #2$%"#$ 2'(,$#',$?$)#/'$> .")%2'(("4",-;"( "4(%,";)"6"')(##2$("'%3(#)#2$($&',&+?(#")&$(/#2$ 4$",)$% ',(#33$44"#$+,#,'62#4-2$4%#2"##2$,$(3)%$)# ;"( 4'"14$ # 1$ 3"'% #2$ ("4",- "( "%?'(('14$ # +)', $&2)'&"4(('(#")#$)&$/#2$,$(3)%$)#;"(4'"14$#1$ 3"'%#2$("4",-')#2$(&"4$ = >< "%?'(('14$# +)', $&2)'&"4(('(#")#')(#$"% ("4",-')#2$6,"%$

(+1(#")#'"4I+$(#') 4";",'($(')#2'(&"($ ;",,")#')6')#$, $,$)&$1-#2'(+,# '(?'(($%

")+",- ./

")+",- ./ ?"2"A',