High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4192/2015dismissed

Bakhtawar Singh v. Gurdev Singh

2015-09-02Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!"# $#%&'&(

!)*"!+!,&(-* ..#//!(" 0#,'1' 1,$#0&(-* #'.($#(" 23456 7*#"*#,#.,"#,' 5%!/#+'.!.#,'8!9:#!//+#$" '##"*#;1$-8#("<

:#,# #,,#$""*##.,"#,',("< =7*#"*#,"*#;1$-8#("'*1/$:#,#.,"#$&("*#&-#'"< ,#'#("2,!8&"!1"!8>$0%!"# ,"*#!..#//!(" *&'&'!(!..#!/$&,#%"#$:9$# #($!("?!..#//!("!-!&('""*# ;1$-8#(" !($ $#%,## $!"#$ @

.!''#$ :9 *,& !($##. &(-* !;+!>$$&"&(!/&'",&%"1$-#>51$*&!(!0&$#+*&%*"*#!..#!/.,# #,,#$ :9"*#$# #($!("!-!&('""*#;1$-8#("!($$#%,##$!"#$

=+!'

$&'8&''#$

,&# !%"' "*#.,#'#("%!'#!,#"*!""*#./!&("&

&'+(#,

"*#'*.&($&'.1"#!($'!8#+!'-&0#("$# #($!("(,#("#(!(%9+!'

,!/(#!($%1./#$+&"*$#/&0#,9 .''#''&((&"&!/,!"# ,#("+!'

&A#$!''

?3.#,8("*#A%/1$&(-"*##/#%",&%&"9!($"*#,%*!,-#'

*#,#!

"#,>"*#,!"# ,#("+!' &A#$!"'

?3.#,8("*!($"*#( , '

?3.#,8("* *#$# #($!("(":#&(--$"#(!("+!'*&-*/9 &,,#-1/!,&(.!9&(-,#("!($'"..#$.!98#(" ,"*#/!'""+9#!,'#'&$#'

"*&'>'*.&(B1#'"&(!/',#B1&,#'1,-#(",#.!&,!($'!8#&'!/',#B1&,#$ :9"*#./!&("&

,*&'.#,'(!/1'#!($%%1.!"&((!//"*#'#!%%1("'> "*#./!&("&

"#,8&(!"#$ "*#"#(!(%9 "*#$# #($!("0&$#("&%# $!"#$

#'.&"# ("&%#> $# #($!(" !&/#$ " 0!%!"# "*# $#8&'#$ .,#8&'#'#(%#"*&''1&" = .(("&%#>$# #($!("!..#!,#$!($ &/#$+,&""#('"!"#8#("

"!)&(-.,#/&8&(!,9:;#%"&('!'"8!&("!&(!:&/&"9 "*#'1&"&("*#.,#'#("

,8!($%*!//#(-#$"*#/%1''"!($& "*#./!&("&

1,"*#,:;#%"&('!'

""*#("&%#-&0#(:9"*#./!&("&

*!':##(,!&'#$:9"*#$# #($!("!'"*# '!8#:#&(-&//#-!/!($8!/!3 &$#!($&(0!/&$:;#%"&(',#-!,$&(-0!/1#

"*#%1," ##!($(%!1'# !%"&(*!0#!/':##("!)#((8#,&"'>"*# $# #($!("$#(&#$"*#,!0#,8#("'!($.,!9#$ ,$&'8&''!/ "*#'1&" #./&%!"&(+!'(" &/#$,8"*#./#!$&(- "*#.!,"&#'

//+&(-&''1#'+#,# ,!8#$23

= *#.!,"&#'*!0#/#$"*#&,,#'.#%"&0##0&$#(%#("*#! ,#'!&$ &''1#'*#",&!/1,"!

"#,!..,!&'!/ "*##0&$#(%#0&$#;1$-8#("!($ $#%,##$!"#$

=>$#%,##$"*#'1&" "*#./!&("&

C ##/&(-!--,&#0#$>"*#$# #($!(".,# #,,#$&,'"!..#!/*# /#!,(#$$$&"&(!/&'",&%"1$-#>51$*&!(!0&$# ;1$-8#("!($$#%,## $!"#$ @

$&'8&''#$"*#!..#!/ "*#$# #($!(" D

##/&(-$&''!"&'

&#$+&"*"*#!

,#'!&$;1$-8#("'!($$#%,##'

$!"#$

= !($ @

>"*#.,#'#(",#-1/!,'#%($!..#!/*!'

:##($&,#%"#$:9"*#$# #($!("?!..#//!(" @ *#!..#//!("&(.!,!-,!.* C "*#-,1($' !..#!/>*!'

8#("&(#$"*!" //+&(-'1:'"!("&!/B1#'"&(' /!+*!0#!,&'#(&("*# .,#'#(",#-1/!,'#%($!..#!/23 "

# $%

% 7*#"*#,"*#;1$-8#("'!($$#%,##' "*#5$1,"' :#/+!,#((3'.#!)&(-<

$ 7*#"*#,;1$-8#("'!($$#%,##' "*#%1,"':#/+!,# .#,0#,'#!($/&!:/#":#,#0#,'#$<

# 7*#"*#,"*#5$1,"':#/+*!0#8&',#!$!($ 8&'&("#,.,#"#$"*##0&$#(%#(,#%,$<

7*#"*#,"*#("&%#1($#,#%"&( C "*#,!('

#, ,.#,"9%"&'0!/&$&("*##9#' /!+<

- 7*#"*#,"*#,#'.($#("%!(8!&("!&("*#'1&" , .''#''&((%#*#*!' !&/#$".,0#*&'+(#,'*&. 0#,"*#'1&".,.#,"9<

* 7*#"*#,"*#5$$$/&'",&%"1$-#*!'-,''/9#,,#$&( $&'8&''&(-"*#!../&%!"&(1($#,,$#, ,1/# D

+&"*1"!''&-(&(-!(90!/&$,#!'(<

& 7*#"*#,"*#,#'.($#("*!'%(%#!/#$"*#8!"#,&!/

!%"'<

*!0#*#!,$/#!,(#$%1('#/ ,"*#!..#//!("!($*!0#-(# "*,1-*"*#%!'# &/#+&"**#,!:/#!''&'"!(%#

5#!,(#$%1('#/ ,"*#!..#//!("*!'%*!//#(-#$"*#;1$-8#("' !($$#%,##' :"*"*#1,"':#/+("+-,1($' &,'"/9"*!"("&%# 1($#,#%"&( C "*#,!('

#, ,.#,"9%"&'$# #%"&0#!($"*#"*#, -,1($"!)#(:9"*#$# #($!("?!..#//!("&'"*!"./!&("&

*!' !&/#$".,0# *&'+(#,'*&.1('#/ ,"*#!..#//!("*!',#/&#$1.(!1"*,&"9

!" *!0#%('&$#,#$"*#'!&$'1:8&''&(:1"$(" &($!(9 ,%# &("*!"'1:8&''&(

$# #%" &( ("&%# 1($#, #%"&( C "*# ,!('

,.#,"9%"*!':##(.&("#$1"#A%#.""*!"&"&' ,(#8("*+*#,#!'

"*#("&%#'*1/$*!0#:##( ,!.#,&$ & "##($!9'*#&("#("&(

"*#!,/&!8#("&(#(!%"&(-#%"&( C "*#,!('

#, ,.#,"9%"+!'

"-&0#("&%# !"3/#!'" & "##($!9' ,0!%!"&(-"*#.,#8&'#'"&%# , /(-#,.#,&$&#(#8("*%!((":#'!&$":#&(0!/&$ = !,!'!1"*,&"9

# $ % &'%(%#,(#$"*#'!&$ !1"*,&"9,#/!"#'"%%88$!"&((",/%"> C "*#,+&'# !/'>&("*!"%!'##0&%"&(,$#,+!'1.*#/$1($#,#%"&(

* "*# %%88$!"&( (",/ %"> C > "*!" !1"*,&"9 &'

$&'"&(-1&'*!:/#""*# !%"' "*#.,#'#("%!'#

*#,#/!"&('*&. /!($/,$!($"#(!("*!':##(!$8&""#$&("*# +,&""#('"!"#8#("*#+(#,'*&.*!'(":##($#(&#$&(.!,! "*# +,&""#('"!"#8#(""&''#""/#$/!+"*!""#(!("&':1($"'1,,#($#,"*# .''#''&( "*#/!($/,$!

"#,"#,8&(!"&( "*#%(",!%">*!0#( *#'&"!"&(&(*/$&(-"*!"('1:'"!("&!/B1#'"&( /!+*!'!,&'#(&("*# .,#'#("!..#!/('#B1#("/9>"*#!..#!/&'+&"*1"!(98#,&"!($"*#'!8# '"!($'$&'8&''#$+#0#,>"*#!..#//!("'*!//0!%!"#"*#.,#8&'#'+&"*&( '&A8("*'(.!98#(" 8#'(#., &"'""*##A"#(" '

?3.#, 8("*(%!'# $# !1/" .!98#(" "+%('#%1"&0#8#'(#., &"'>"*# /!($/,$'*!//:#!"/&:#,"9"-#""*#$#%,###A#%1"#$#0#(.,&,"'&A 8("*'!/(-+&"*!,,#!,' ,#(" %.9 "*&';1$-8#(":#'#("""*#",&!/1," , '",&%"

%8./&!(%#

&'(

)