Rajbir & ORS v. Municipal Corporation Gurgaon












 







 !"

"#$%$&'
"(!")*"+
,

!-

.
/

0*$+

!-"+% (("11 &!% 2"+%3%

3&$#$( 1
3&#$1.
3+4 &  "%(&5"&!


 !"#$%
&' ()%)(
*$+&',-%

+"%"&!'

+6&$%-
$!! 1.
56# !".

+
!-"
(("11 &!%

+%-7 &$
83) +
3+ .
56# !".

+
!-"
+"%(&5"&! 99999







































)(
*$+& (("11 &!:(1 $&!$%
+"
44+$"6"5

!-"
$)(34&"5
0354)"&! &5
5"#+""

!-"
;7"+
(("11 !"
3+!.
7-"+"*<
!-"
((" 1

!-" +"%(&5"&!
7 %
117"5
7-$1"
%"!!$&4: %$5"
!-"
0354)"&!
&5
5"#+""

!-" !+$ 1
3+!.
7-"+"*<
!-"
%3$!
- 5
*""&
5"#+""5

+6&$%-
$!! 1.
1" +&"5
#3&%"1
+
!-"
(("11 &!:(1 $&!$% %3*)$!%
!- !

!-"
(1 $&!$%
- 5
$1"5

%3$!
+
("+) &"&!
$&03&#!$&
4 $&%! !-"
5""&5 &!%
&
!-"
(+")$%"
!- !
!-"<
+"
("+) &"&!
+"%$5"&!%

2$11 4"  ) %(3+
&5
7&"+
$&
(%%"%%$&

!-"
&#"%!+ 1
+"%$5"&!$ 1
-3%" 1&47$!-
*3&5 +<
7 11
%$!3 !"5
7$!-$&
!-"
* 5$
5"-

6$11 4"
 ) %(3+ &5
- 6"
(" #"311<
"&0$&"5
!-"
%3$!
(+("+!<
+)
!-"
!$)"

!-"$+ &#"%!+%
&5
+ $%"5
#&%!+3#!$&
6"+
!-"
% )"
-"
5""&5 &!%
7 &!"5
! $&!"+"+"
$&!
(%%"%%$&
%
!-"
 +( &#-
!-+" !"&"5
!
!" #-

1"%%&
!
!-" (1 $&!$%
&
&"
(+"!"=!
+
!-"
!-"+
-"
+ )
&#- < !
%"+6"5

1"4 1



&!$#"
5 !"5
>/
3&5"+
"#!$&
 

!-"
 +< &
&#- < !$
#!.
>>
&
!-"
(1 $&!$%
-"<.
&
>/.
((" +"5
*"+"
!-"  +( &#-

+ )
&#- < !
+"4 +5$&4
!-"
*6"% $5
&!$#"
&5
*+34-! $&!
-$%
?&71"54"
11
!-"
 #!%.
*3!
5$5
&!
<$"15
&<
+"%31!
&5.
!-"+"+". ## %$&
+%"
!
#- 11"&4"
!-"
+")"&!$&"5
&!$#".
%
7"11
!-"
 #!.
!- ! !-"+"
7 %

!-+" !

+#$*1"
5$%(%%"%%$& "
3+!-"+
%3*)$!%
!- !
!-"
("+%&.
7-
$%
3&5
!
*"
$&
1"4 1 &5
%"!!1"5
(%%"%%$&.
# &&!
*"
5$%(%%"%%"5
"=#"(!
$&
53"
#3+%"

1 7 "6"&
$
-"
$%
3&5
!
*"
$&
"=#"%%
+"
!- &
!-"
&"
7&"5
-"
+ )

&#- < !
- %
)"+4"5
$&!
!-"
3&$#$( 1
+(+ !$&
&5.
!-"+"+".
!-"< # &&!
"6"&
+"%+!
!
!-"
(+#""5$&4%
3&5"+
"#!$&
@

!-"
3&0 *
2$11 4"

))&
; &5%
#!
%
$!
$%
&!

%- )1 !.
*3!
* #- !
1 &5
-"
;7"+ (("11 !"
3+!
- %
#))$!!"5
$11"4 1$!<
&5
("+6"+%$!<
$&
%"!!$&4: %$5"
!-" 7"11
+" %&"5
0354)"&!
&5
5"#+""

!-"
!+$ 1
3+!
&
!-"
(+")$%"
!- !
!-" (("11 &!:(1 $&!$%
+"
$&
##3( !$&

"=#"%%
+" 
&
 #!.
!-"<
+"
7&"+% 
&1<

%A< +5%
&5
!-"
!! 1
+"
$&
(%%"%%$&

!-"
(("11 &!: (1 $&!$%
$%

%A< +5%
&5.
!-3%.
3+4"%
!-$%
3+!
+
%"!!$&4: %$5"

!-" $&5$&4%

!-"
;7"+
(("11 !"
3+!

"+:#&!+ #!.
+%-7 &$
83) +
3+ .
1" +&"5
#3&%"1
+
!-" +"%(&5"&!
%3*)$!%
!- !
&
$&03&#!$&
4 $&%!
!-"
7&"+
$%
) $&! $& *1" &#"
!-"
(+("+!<
6"%!"5
$&
!-"
3&$#$( 1
+(+ !$&.
!-"<
- 6"
"6"+< +$4-!
!
) $&! $&
!-"
% )".
)3#-
1"%%
%""?
(%%"%%$&

!-"
(+("+!<  ) * &5$
= 
(1 #"5
&
+"#+5
%-7%
!- !
8- %+
>>B
:.
4 $+ )3)?$&.
+"#+5"5
!
*"
7&"5
&5
(%%"%%"5
*<
!-"
(1 $&!$%.
7-"+" %
?% $0+
= ,
%-7%
!- !
!-"
% $5
?- %+
&3)*"+
$%
$&
!-"
)" %3+")"&!

 ? + )
>>
""!
&5
&
# 1#31 !$&
$!
7 %
3&5
!- !
!-"
(1 $&!$%
+"
7&"+%

.


&1<

%A< +5%
%
("+
!-"
%$!"
(1 &
= .
!-"
(1 $&!$%
+"
$& ##3( !$&

)+"
+" .
%
$&5$# !"5
*6"
-$%
 #!
$%
"6$5"&!
+)
!-" +"(+!

!-"
;# 1
))$%%$&"+
= 
&5
+$4-!1<
%.
!-"
$&03&#!$&
% %34-!
+
- %
*""&
5"#1$&"5
*<
%"!!$&4: %$5"
!-"
0354)"&!
&5
5"#+""

!-" !+$ 1
3+!

- 6"
-" +5
!-"
1" +&"5
#3&%"1
+
!-"
( +!$"%
&5
((+ $%"5 !-"
( ("+
*? -"
A3"%!$&.
7-$#-
- %
+$%"&
*"+"
!-$%
3+!
!
5035$# !" !-"
#&!+6"+%<.
$%



!-"
 #!
!- !
!-"
(("11 &!:(1 $&!$%
+"
$& (%%"%%$&

)+"
+"
!- &
!-"
&"
!-"<
7&.
*3!
7-"!-"+
!-"<
# &
*" 5$%(%%"%%"5

"=#"(!
$&
53"
#3+%"

1 7
-"
&%7"+
$%
!- !
!-"<
# &&! *".
+.

("+%&
7-
$%
$&
1&4
&5
%"!!1"5
(%%"%%$&
# &&!
*" 5$%(%%"%%"5
"=#"(!
$&
53"
#3+%"

1 7
$&
6$"7

!-"
+ !$
5"#$5"&5$ #311"5
3!
*<
!-"
&C*1"
3(+")"
3+!
$&

/- , 12$
3 4334 5 , 12$
3

67+  89: -"
$&5$&4%
+"&5"+"5
*<
!-"
;7"+
(("11 !"
3+!
1" 5
!
& $++"%$%!$*1"
#&#13%$&
!- !
!-"
(("11 &!:(1 $&!$%
+"
$&
(%%"%%$&

 %A< +5%
$&%!" 5


%A< +5%
#!3 11<
7&"5
*<
!-")
&5
!-$%
 #!
$%
1% #&$+)"5
!-+34-
!-"
+"(+!

!-"
;# 1
))$%%$&"+
= 
-"

3&$#$( 1
+(+ !$&.
7$!-
7-)
!-"
(+("+!<
$&
5$%(3!"
- %
6"%!"5.
$% 7"11
7$!-$&
$!%
+$4-!
!
! ?"
(%%"%%$&
$&
##+5 &#"
7$!-
1 7.
*3!
&! +#$*1<.
!-3%.
$&
)<
6$"7.
!-"
;7"+
(("11 !"
3+!
34-!
&!
!
- 6" 6 # !"5
!-"
$&03&#!$&
+5"+
4+ &!"5
*<
!-"
!+$ 1
3+! 
53*!.
!-$%
3+!.
&
" +1$"+
## %$&%
- 5
*""&
+ )$&4
!-" %3*%! &!$ 1
A3"%!$&%

1 7
7-$1"
5"#$5$&4
!-"
((" 1%
*3!
$&
6$"7

!-"
+ !$ 5"#$5"&5$
#311"5
3!
*<
$6"
1" +&"5
354"%

!-"
&C*1"
3(+")"
3+!
$&







            

  
7-"+"$&
!-"
(+(%$!$&
+%"
%
!
7-"!-"+
$&
6$"7

!-" (+6$%$&%

"#!$&
>@ 
 .
(+6$%$&%

"#!$&


!-"
3&0 *
3+!% #!.
>
7315
((1<
+
!-"
((" 1
$"

7315
*"
$1"5
3&5"+
"#!$&
 
5"

$6$1
+#"53+".
%
!-"+"
$%
&""5
!
+ )"
!-"
%3*%! &!$ 1
A3"%!$&% 
1 7
+
&!
-"
&%!$!3!$& 1
"&#-

&C*1"
3(+")"
3+!
-"15
!- ! !-"
5"#$%$&
$&
!"# !     $ "

 %



&'

    

(

  
&
((1$# *$1$!<

"#!$&
>@ 

 
$% &!

#++"#!
1 7.
$&
"%%"&#".
!-"
(+6$%$&%

"#!$&


!-"
3&0 *
3+!% #!.
>
- 5
*""&
+"%!+"5
* #?
+
!-"
% ?"

*+"6$!<.
!-"
+"1"6 &!
(+!$& 
!-"
0354)"&!

$6"
1" +&"5
354"%

!-"
&C*1"
3(+")"
3+!
$&

&? 0 ?%-$
C%
# %"
%3(+ 
+" 5%
!-3%':

D 

 

  

   

 


    

  !!

 


   
"      
   
 
 #$  % & 

 $) * +,-
./ , 0 -
 

    

  
'( )*+),-.

D)* /       )0  &      




 &   

  

 



 & 

 , 1    2    

        
      3                &     4
    4 
   3  


 1! 5    4


 ,    
    $   4
  
             5   4


 ,60 

 ),)  4  

  &     4
   
  

;

6,0 
 5   4


 ,60    & 

  
        4

      &     4
    6*)7 8 &     4
 "      )0  &     4

             
 3        

 
    6*) &     4
 4      6*)7 8   
           



   3         9  
  
      

 ,*7 8     &
    &   
7
 8

 ,*:     



  & 

 
        .
-"+"+".

5
&!
$&!"&5
!
+ )"
!-"
%3*%! &!$ 1
A3"%!$&%
 1 7
7-$1"
5"#$5$&4
!-"
((" 1.
+")"&!$&"5
##+5$&41<.
!-"
0354)"&! &5
5"#+""

!-"
;7"+
(("11 !"
3+!
$%
%"!: %$5"
&5
!- !

!-"
!+$ 1 3+!
$%
+"%!+"5 ((" 1
%! &5%
117"5 6/1.67+9  )(
*$

/37 &',-% *7673<5 =3

 >3=

*767
 61 >3=